Red Dead Redemption Issues Thread

[Kust]

Isen't horses dying randomly an actual feature instead of a bug?

[Abbanon]

1 hour ago, neonwinch83 said:

On the topic of an actual bug, this one is original RDR jank, but they should really do something about horses dying randomly, aside from being a total inconvenience, it does ruin the Spurred to Victory achievement. Had it happen to me twice, would post a clip of it if I could.

Speaking of... I had this happen yesterday:

 

Edited October 31 by Abbanon

[CurtisG2000]

During the mission "Empty Promises" the cutscene where the rebels get executed, the audio mixing sounds off on PC compared to PS4.

 

 

 

Edited November 1 by CurtisG2000

[kubon352]

Duster coat flickers way too fast when having fps locked to 60 or more. Just pointing out, that's something a patch can only fix, I'm afraid.

[RecklessGlue540]

9 hours ago, kubon352 said:

Duster coat flickers way too fast when having fps locked to 60 or more. Just pointing out, that's something a patch can only fix, I'm afraid.

Ahh the infamous RAGE cloth physics issues. Hopefully they patch it.

 

Something from me again too:

 

I've always noticed this on emulation, thought it was an issue related to that, but apparently it happens here too. Probably a vanilla issue.

It stabilizes as you get closer, i'm not sure but it could be an issue with the sasquatch's model or the shaders it uses.

[Kust]

PC

 

Spoiler

In the mission where you get tricked into the church in mexico I had the gentlemen outfit and after I got capture and bound I had John's regular clothes

 

[44Orca]

Doesn't seem to be mentioned, but I think this might be a bug on PC if it wasn't in the original. I placed my horse way too close to the safehouse of Chuparosa (Nuevo Paraíso) and then I couldn't whistle or could find the horse anywhere, reloading the save file fixed it though same as when Bonnie stopped moving in an early mission.

That's really the only 2 bugs I came across playing. A good port overall though.

Edited November 2 by 44Orca

[neonwinch83]

3 hours ago, Kust said:

PC

 

  Hide contents

In the mission where you get tricked into the church in mexico I had the gentlemen outfit and after I got capture and bound I had John's regular clothes

 

This was in all versions. It's an intended outfit swap.

[Abbanon]

Found a spooky floating triangle in McFarlane's Ranch, which can only be seen from above. Would anyone be able to verify if this is a leftover PS3/360 issue?
https://i.imgur.com/HitVnYg.mp4

 

Edit: Some images if there are difficulties with the footage.

Edited November 3 by Abbanon

[Abbanon]

Found a very strange area with player shadows in Las Hermanas.

Footage: https://i.imgur.com/XSoNxa2.mp4

 

Screenshots:

[RecklessGlue540]

49 minutes ago, Abbanon said:

Found a very strange area with player shadows in Las Hermanas.

Footage: https://i.imgur.com/XSoNxa2.mp4

 

Screenshots:

As far as I've seen this happens a lot in this game and ever since the 360 era.

 

These issues are caused due to rockstar giving shadow flags to fake light sources like these erroneously.

Generally shadows should only be enabled on lights where they make sense and here they obviously don't, so it looks very bad.

 

Probably very much fixable, but as far as I've seen light sources and their placements / data are located in town sector info files (.wsi), which I'm not sure if they include the town models themselves, so that makes it significantly harder to tweak light placement or find which lights are which, for example.

But we need more advancements for the tools, in any case..

Edited November 4 by RecklessGlue540

[CurtisG2000]

On 11/3/2024 at 5:51 AM, Abbanon said:

Found a spooky floating triangle in McFarlane's Ranch, which can only be seen from above. Would anyone be able to verify if this is a leftover PS3/360 issue?
https://i.imgur.com/HitVnYg.mp4

 

Edit: Some images if there are difficulties with the footage.

This is also on X360, just a misplaced texture.

[Abbanon]

Floating gather plant in Mexico:

[Claude_Lib]

I guess these are procedurally generated and can't really be fixed.

[Abbanon]

40 minutes ago, Claude_Lib said:

I guess these are procedurally generated and can't really be fixed.

I thought the plants you can harvest are fixed in location? Could've sworn they were...

 

[Abbanon]

Some floating small rocks:

 

[neonwinch83]

2 hours ago, Abbanon said:

I thought the plants you can harvest are fixed in location? Could've sworn they were...

 

I don't think they are. They seem to generate randomly depending on your zone. I was doing Survivalist Rank 9, and I had the survivalist map on, there was a flower in the Great Plains on the map, and I went towards it, but as soon as my zone changed from Tall Trees to Great Plains, it disappeared, and the placement for those flowers entirely changed.

[CurtisG2000]

Rain puddles are visible underwater on PC, which doesn't happen on X360. This bug is also present on PS4 and Switch ports.

PC

 

X360

Edited November 5 by CurtisG2000

[CurtisG2000]

Black Arrow on the compass is slightly highlighted on X360.

PC

 

X360

Edited November 5 by CurtisG2000

[RecklessGlue540]

5 hours ago, CurtisG2000 said:

Black Arrow on the compass is slightly highlighted on X360.

PC

 

X360

This one is probably a texture thing.

They changed them for PC and they lost details here and there...

[Abbanon]

The mission "Mexican Caesar" has a LOT of subtitle issues when you get on the wagon with the dude. I missed my chances to take many screenshots, but:
- Two sentences of John's are missing punctuation at the end
- One sentence of John's is missing the word "the" despite being spoken
The other dude's dialogue subtitles also had some punctuation issues, such as missing spaces after commas. Probably something else, too.

I tried failing and replaying the mission several times to take screenshots, but the dialogue was different each time, and after a certain point no more dialogue played at all during the wagon trip.

Each one of these dialogue variations after the retries featured at least one issue. I managed to take exactly one screenshot in time, here (Where it says "victory,we" there is no space):

 

Edit: There are more subtitles issues later on in the mission as well. Generally the whole thing is rather poorly handled as far as QA. I know for a fact these issues are carried over from PS3/360.

Edited November 5 by Abbanon

[Kust]

In beecher hope if you shoot the chandelier the chandelier rotates but the flame does not.

 

 

Dosen't the picture frame shadow looks wierd?

 

The camera can clip through the roof

 

 

Edited November 5 by Kust
Addding more pictures

[Nebula666]

Looks like I am the only, only, ONLY person to experience this issue?
 

I am completely unable to sell any of the plants gathered from Mexico. Woolly Blue Curls, Butterfly Weed, and Prickly Pear do not show up in my 'Sell' menu when interacting with any vendors at all. I have tried selling one, two, and up to thirty of each plant.
 

Simply no luck, I can see it displaying in my Provisions tab but cannot sell it anywhere in New Austin or Nuevo Paraiso, I am hoping getting to West Elizabeth and picking some Golden Currant or Violet Snowdrop might somehow fix the issue. I have even tried to use a save editor to fix the problem and just can't seem to resolve things at all.

[neonwinch83]

1 hour ago, Nebula666 said:

Looks like I am the only, only, ONLY person to experience this issue?
 

I am completely unable to sell any of the plants gathered from Mexico. Woolly Blue Curls, Butterfly Weed, and Prickly Pear do not show up in my 'Sell' menu when interacting with any vendors at all. I have tried selling one, two, and up to thirty of each plant.
 

Simply no luck, I can see it displaying in my Provisions tab but cannot sell it anywhere in New Austin or Nuevo Paraiso, I am hoping getting to West Elizabeth and picking some Golden Currant or Violet Snowdrop might somehow fix the issue. I have even tried to use a save editor to fix the problem and just can't seem to resolve things at all.

That's weird, first time I hear of this bug at all, and I've done 100% in the main game. Maybe if you get the Treasure Hunter's satchel from Treasure Hunter Rank 10, it might somehow fix things due to it messing with the inventory?

[Nebula666]

13 minutes ago, neonwinch83 said:

That's weird, first time I hear of this bug at all, and I've done 100% in the main game. Maybe if you get the Treasure Hunter's satchel from Treasure Hunter Rank 10, it might somehow fix things due to it messing with the inventory?

Damn man I really hope so, planning to get the Treasure Hunter's satchel last to try avoid the bug with Vittles. I just made it to West Elizabeth last night. I tried to fix this initially with a save editor too and I think I may have just ended up f*cking my save maybe... Fuuurk I may have to just bite the bullet and start another Hardcore playthrough...

[CurtisG2000]

A few PC specific issues pointed out by Digital Foundry.

 

 

Edited November 8 by CurtisG2000

[neonwinch83]

Undead Nightmare truly is freaky and supernatural, they got a ghost hammer in the game now.

Not even sure what caused this, lmao.

 

[RecklessGlue540]

56 minutes ago, neonwinch83 said:

Undead Nightmare truly is freaky and supernatural, they got a ghost hammer in the game now.

Not even sure what caused this, lmao.

 

I think this could have happened all the way back in the original? I swear I've noticed it a few times.

 

 

[neonwinch83]

5 minutes ago, RecklessGlue540 said:

I think this could have happened all the way back in the original? I swear I've noticed it a few times.

 

 

Probably so, I think any or all bugs we see might be 99% jank from the original RDR. Ironically enough, in the same mission, I got some really odd looking puddles, that white coloring went away after a bit.

[RecklessGlue540]

Bruh they really messed up a lot of the rain in this port

 

Bit sad to see tbh, as I've seen they had done other things with better care...