Which things you wish were part of RDR2 but didn't make it into the game?

[Edward RDRIII]

Before anything, this isn't a topic to blame Rockstar Games and/or Red Dead Redemption 2 for what it's missing, we know it's impossible to add every single animal, fish and other things to a videogame at the moment, there are literally millions species of them out there! But discussing this topic we can at least help Rockstar to make even more realistic worlds for their upcoming games on the next years.

 

I'll start saying that I wish RDR2 had falcons on it, we have eagles and hawks on it already so it would be cool if we also had falcons, especially the Peregrine Falcon and the Prairie Falcon, the first one is the fastest animal in the world and probably the deadliest bird as well, the other one is also a really cool bird, not as heavy, fast or deadly (considering the amount of species they hunt) but it's about the same size of its brother and just as pretty.

 

Peregrine Falcon (All five states):

 

 

Prairie Falcon (New Austin, Ambarino and West Elizabeth):

 

Edited November 3, 2022 by Edward RDRIII

[unfairlane]

 Wish we could choose to have a cat in the camp instead of those stupd noisy dogs 

[Edward RDRIII]

3 hours ago, unfairlane said:

 Wish we could choose to have a cat in the camp instead of those stupd noisy dogs 

I still wonder why we can't pet cats and why there's only one kind of cat, meanwhile there are so many kinds of dogs lol.

[subvod]

The Eastern and Shiras moose. There are already three coats of moose in game, but for some reason they're all labelled as Western. Be nice with a little variety instead of running across either a gray cow or orange bull at almost every single spawn point.

 

Tree frogs. We already have woodpeckers which spawn pecking the sides of trees. Why not scale down the model of the bullfrog, change the pattern and texture, and add spawnpoints like on the sides of tree trunks?

 

Fox squirrels. They're kind of in between red and gray. We have gray foxes in game with similar patterns to real life fox squirrels...

 

Flying squirrels. They've terrified me a number of times while just walking in the woods at night. See a flash and enormous shadow outline from my spotlight only to realize it was a tiny flying squirrel. The world terrain and tree geometry might have made animating them flying from tree to tree difficult.

 

Screech and barn owls. Maybe even pygmy owls in the saguaros of New Austin.

[Edward RDRIII]

The Buffalo Rifle, it was one of my favorite weapons in RDR1 and it would increase RDR2's weapons variety even more, Arthur has two of them with bayonets on his wagon but they're old, rusty and don't look like they fire anymore, needless to say they're unusable.

 

 

I also wish we had a sawed-off version of the Repeater Shotgun, but I don't think Arthur would be able to use it with a single hand and dual wield it unless he used it like the Terminator does lol.

 

Edited November 3, 2022 by Edward RDRIII

[JumpingKentFlash]

An obtainable Raven Black Shire horse (as John).

One thing I always liked in GTA3 was the import/export cars. When you did all the lists, you could always go to that harbor garage and retrieve one. Almost all cars in the game. Should be like this with horses in RDR2.

[Jutland]

A really old motor car, the sort that rumbles along at 10 mph with a bulb hooter and looks like it might fall to pieces if you look at it wrong. Surely wealthy people in Saint Denis in 1907 would have had one or two

[GrandTheftPots]

Same as above world first car and bike flying machine "even if they almost kill you" could have been locked to final misson / 100% so you can't speed run the game 

[Lemoyne outlaw]

On 11/3/2022 at 12:17 AM, Edward RDRIII said:

The Buffalo Rifle, it was one of my favorite weapons in RDR1 and it would increase RDR2's weapons variety even more, Arthur has two of them with bayonets on his wagon but they're old, rusty and don't look like they fire anymore, needless to say they're unusable.

 

 

I also wish we had a sawed-off version of the Repeater Shotgun, but I don't think Arthur would be able to use it with a single hand and dual wield it unless he used it like the Terminator does lol.

 

yes i do wish we could have the buffalo rifle. they already made a hud image for it. that they teased a few years ago. and while we are talking about the repeater shotgun. i wish it had its own unique firing sound. because it's the exact same as the semi auto shotgun sound.