GTA III Definitive Edition Analysis & Comparisons Topic

[BS_BlackScout]

19 minutes ago, Mktz1 said:

why are you talking like you already know how the game is?

_

i don't know if i want to ruin the good childhood memories with some halfass good looking product that possibly sucks ass.

You just did the same thing.

Edited October 29, 2021 by BS_BlackScout

[OREOBOREALIS]

4 minutes ago, BS_BlackScout said:

You just did the same thing.

He talks like he already knows its good for sure. I said POSSIBLY suck ass. How is that doing the same thing?

Is speculating and criticism no more allowed in this forum?

 

Spoiler

Attitude of some people in this topic smh

 

Edited October 29, 2021 by Mktz1

[MrGTAmodsgerman]

I noticed something is different with the traffic and made an comparsion. Look at the brake lights and how smooth they brake now. Looks like a different traffic system. Not sure which one is better but the brake light improvements make it now really better.

Also take a look at the road itself. Seems to be have little more detail like that bump, but i could be wrong because i didn't had the zoom in my footage.

GTA 3

Spoiler

GTA 3 Definitive Edition

Spoiler

https://imgur.com/gallery/ZKB83XR

Edited October 29, 2021 by MrGTAmodsgerman

[MonoChrome213]

9 minutes ago, MrGTAmodsgerman said:

I noticed something is different with the traffic and made an comparsion. Look at the brake lights and how smooth they brake now. Looks like a different traffic system. Not sure which one is better but the brake light improvements make it now really better.

Also take a look at the road itself. Seems to be have little more detail like that bump, but i could be wrong because i didn't had the zoom in my footage.

GTA 3

  Hide contents

GTA 3 Definitive Edition

  Hide contents

https://imgur.com/gallery/ZKB83XR

i think it's because traffic and vehicles handling are more like those of san andreas

[SquoniX]

1 hour ago, Mktz1 said:

why are you talking like you already know how the game is?

Its almost like you are part of the team that was making this remaster and need to defend it..

That picture looks really good, but how are you so sure we will like the atmosphere? Just because it looks better does not automatically mean the whole product is better.

The atmosphere in the original trilogy is very specific and has grown on us who played these games when they first were released.

i don't know if i want to ruin the good childhood memories with some halfass good looking product that possibly sucks ass.

At least the new character models are just bad and disappointment.

 

Brother, I am talking about it in the context of the trailer. 

 

Now, yes, it could be ass in the sense that you launch the game and it crashes instantly. 

 

Or maybe I am a Rockstar employee. 

[BS_BlackScout]

1 hour ago, MrGTAmodsgerman said:

I noticed something is different with the traffic and made an comparsion. Look at the brake lights and how smooth they brake now. Looks like a different traffic system. Not sure which one is better but the brake light improvements make it now really better.

Also take a look at the road itself. Seems to be have little more detail like that bump, but i could be wrong because i didn't had the zoom in my footage.

GTA 3

  Reveal hidden contents

GTA 3 Definitive Edition

  Reveal hidden contents

https://imgur.com/gallery/ZKB83XR

Better yet, look at the light being reflected on the sign!!
Pretty sure it's SA code if it isn't redone.

Edited October 29, 2021 by BS_BlackScout

[SquoniX]

1 minute ago, BS_BlackScout said:

Better yet, look at the light being reflected on the sign!!
Pretty sure it's SA code if it isn't redone.

 

Hopefully, that means angry drivers as well.

[BS_BlackScout]

2 hours ago, Mktz1 said:

Is speculating and criticism no more allowed in this forum?

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Attitude of some people in this topic smh

 

 

2 hours ago, Mktz1 said:

why are you talking like you already know how the game is?

You tell me

[OREOBOREALIS]

lol theres some bully problem starting in this forum lately with 3 same users in these 3 different trilogy topics.

Can't anymore even comment things normally about this definitive edition if its even little critical, without some arrogant ass holes coming with some "you are wrong. This definitive edition is 100% perfect. How dare you say anything bad about it!!!" type of crap.

..and its the same 3 users every time with their mighty entitled opinions.

Not happening only to me, but to everybody who says something negative about this remaster.

I have always been big fan of games made by R*, but not that level that Im completely gullible enough to gobble down any turd they produce just because its made by R*.

I like lots of the things Ive seen in the trailer, but theres also lots of things idon't like. Im not going to be yes men for things i dont like.

 

 

On 10/29/2021 at 12:01 PM, BS_BlackScout said:

 

You tell me

you don't even make any sense anymore

[boomboom5950]

2 hours ago, BS_BlackScout said:

Better yet, look at the light being reflected on the sign!!
Pretty sure it's SA code if it isn't redone.

san andreas traffic sucks!! why is this a good thing people want? have you ever been on any highway in san andreas? pure chaos. Try standing in the middle of the highway and watch as a semi truck speeds at you going 100kmph and instantly stops in front of you while every car behind the truck crashes into it creating chaos

[MrGTAmodsgerman]

2 hours ago, BS_BlackScout said:

Better yet, look at the light being reflected on the sign!!
Pretty sure it's SA code if it isn't redone.

I am not sure if you serious with this one, but the reflection is just because Unreal Engine light rendering and its specular map on the sign.

[Helegad]

10 hours ago, suicidehummer said:

Not nitpicking, I'm very happy with what we've seen so far, but if I were in charge of the project, I would have made more of an effort to stick to the original with situations like the above pic, where you see they've removed a lot of the fog, which was initially probably there just to mask draw distance limitations, but ended up being part of the game's character IMO. I think you could split the difference and maybe halve the amount of fog. Similarly, I see they removed the yellow entrance markers in SA. While they did look cheesy and would look even worse in contrast with the remaster, there has to be some way you could just update them to look better. The wanted star in the above pic makes me wonder how they handled those.

 

 

What fog?

[suicidehummer]

6 hours ago, Helegad said:

 

 

What fog?

 

Uhhh...

[MonoChrome213]

8 hours ago, Helegad said:

 

 

What fog?

damn that’s a beatiful skyline

[BS_BlackScout]

12 hours ago, Zerdical said:

san andreas traffic sucks!! why is this a good thing people want?

I didn't say that's what I want though.

[DoubleDutch]

On 10/29/2021 at 6:21 AM, suicidehummer said:

Not nitpicking, I'm very happy with what we've seen so far, but if I were in charge of the project, I would have made more of an effort to stick to the original with situations like the above pic, where you see they've removed a lot of the fog, which was initially probably there just to mask draw distance limitations, but ended up being part of the game's character IMO. I think you could split the difference and maybe halve the amount of fog. Similarly, I see they removed the yellow entrance markers in SA. While they did look cheesy and would look even worse in contrast with the remaster, there has to be some way you could just update them to look better. The wanted star in the above pic makes me wonder how they handled those.

I think they probably just switched the entrance markers off for the trailer/screenshots

Edited October 30, 2021 by DoubleDutch

[CynicalMexican]

7 hours ago, DoubleDutch said:

I think they probably just switched the entrance markers off for the trailer/screenshots

 

I think the opposite. They've probably implemented the HD era of entering universes, which was already quite similar in Vice City anyway.

 

This would be a huge fix, would make San Andreas feel more connected.

[MonoChrome213]

9 hours ago, CynicalMexican said:

 

I think the opposite. They've probably implemented the HD era of entering universes, which was already quite similar in Vice City anyway.

 

This would be a huge fix, would make San Andreas feel more connected.

i think almost all interiors don’t match their exteriors, so either all interiors have been reworked, or it’s the same as it was. i’m curious tho, why they removed the yellow cone from binco in the trailer, if it’s just for the trailer, then why they didn’t bother removing health and wanted star pickups in other shots

[boomboom5950]

3 hours ago, MonoChrome213 said:

i think almost all interiors don’t match their exteriors, so either all interiors have been reworked, or it’s the same as it was. i’m curious tho, why they removed the yellow cone from binco in the trailer, if it’s just for the trailer, then why they didn’t bother removing health and wanted star pickups in other shots

they probably removed each pickup manually, the yellow arrow was obvious so they got rid of it, the health and adrenaline pickups were probably not noticed

[SquoniX]

2 minutes ago, Zerdical said:

they probably removed each pickup manually, the yellow arrow was obvious so they got rid of it, the health and adrenaline pickups were probably not noticed

 

Then what about gang wars in SA? Health pickups are essential there.

 

Horseshoes, snapshots, oysters, etc. in SA too.

Edited October 31, 2021 by SquoniX

[boomboom5950]

2 minutes ago, SquoniX said:

 

Then what about gang wars in SA? Health pickups are essential there.

 

Horseshoes, snapshots, oysters, etc. in SA too.

just for the trailer, in game they will for sure be there. It also makes me think that there will be no photo mode, since rockstar manually got rid of some pickups and left a few in theres no photo mode that would do that anyway

Edited October 31, 2021 by Zerdical

[The-Ghost]

On 10/25/2021 at 8:18 PM, Lioshenka said:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Full interior in the building on the right? Damn, did they actually make every building enterable?

Nah, it's not a full interior, it's a fake effect that gives the illusion that there's an interior inside, the Spiderman game has this and it's very cool, gives more details and life to the game world.

 

 

This is a screenshot from the PS4 version I think, you can see the fake interiors in here, I think they're using the same technique.

Edited October 31, 2021 by The_Ghost

[Stahli]

I hope all buildings will have this fake interiors and not just a few. The Buildings look a lot better. I am curious how the skyscrapers will look like.

[Americana]

Well, I'm not sure about that. Only part of the building has 3D windows.

Edited November 1, 2021 by Americana

[Stahli]

Yes unfortunely. I see it also at this scene in the trailer.

This is sad, but it is better to have some buildings with fake interiors as only Buildings with textures.

 

 

 

[Jenci]

wont thta car hit the train and crash into an accident? wrong timing RIP XD 

[Stahli]

No, car and train go in the same direction. You can see it in the Trailer. 

[Jenci]

ok thx

[The-Ghost]

3 hours ago, Jenci said:

wont thta car hit the train and crash into an accident? wrong timing RIP XD 

Wouldn't be the first time this happens, check the very last few shots from this trailer of GTA VCS, knowing that area, you can tell the cars are going to crash into the wall off-screen.

 

 

[Masny]

3 hours ago, Stahli said:

Yes unfortunely. I see it also at this scene in the trailer.

This is sad, but it is better to have some buildings with fake interiors as only Buildings with textures.

 

 

 

Look how detalied underbody of car is