Buddy Hightower 812 Posted January 11 Share Posted January 11 Perhaps some day in RDO we will catch up to current time of story-mode and get to see it, but regardless it is still hidden in Blackwater. I believe it is hidden in Dutch's mother's grave, and he never had a chance to go back and get it. Link to post Share on other sites
Mysterious hero 345 Posted January 12 Share Posted January 12 Micah and Dutch recovered the money from Blackwater. After the shootout, John and Sadie took it. 5 Link to post Share on other sites
darkdayz 627 Posted January 12 Share Posted January 12 (edited) 13 hours ago, Buddy Hightower said: Perhaps some day in RDO we will catch up to current time of story-mode and get to see it, but regardless it is still hidden in Blackwater. I believe it is hidden in Dutch's mother's grave, and he never had a chance to go back and get it. 10.58 Sorry to burst your bubble dude. You retrieve the Blackwater money at the end of the game. Edited January 12 by darkdayz Link to post Share on other sites
Buddy Hightower 812 Posted January 12 Author Share Posted January 12 55 minutes ago, darkdayz said: 10.58 Sorry to burst your bubble dude. You retrieve the Blackwater money at the end of the game. lol, nope - that was Dutch's chest that you contributed to throughout the whole game, plus any money that Micah and Dutch made since. The Blackwater money was over 200K - read the papers. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
Buddy Hightower 812 Posted January 12 Author Share Posted January 12 7 hours ago, Mysterious hero said: Micah and Dutch recovered the money from Blackwater. After the shootout, John and Sadie took it. wrong - blackwater money was over 200k Link to post Share on other sites
darkdayz 627 Posted January 12 Share Posted January 12 (edited) 3 hours ago, Buddy Hightower said: lol, nope - that was Dutch's chest that you contributed to throughout the whole game, plus any money that Micah and Dutch made since. The Blackwater money was over 200K - read the papers. Are you dense? Sadie literally says it's blackwater money in that video. Micah literally also says they retrieved the blackwater money in that mission also. The blackwater money is 150k, gang funds 40k. Sadie, John and Charles each take a split and John pays off his debts. So it's not just Dutch's chest money because the split of the three characters after American Venom is almost twice as much as what is in Dutch's chest in Chapter 6. So it's not just his chest money clearly. We have no idea how much of the remainder was spent in the 8 years leading up to the Epilogue. We also have no idea if Dutch took any with him as he left, it would be incredibly stupid of him to leave with nothing. Edited January 12 by darkdayz 2 Link to post Share on other sites
Buddy Hightower 812 Posted January 12 Author Share Posted January 12 Sadie says blackwater but how would she know? Micah said "we have money. we have dreams, join us" There was 42,000 in there. John and Charles split the money and Sadie took zero. If you go back for the cash as Arthur, guess what, there is 42,000 in there. Link to post Share on other sites
GroveStGTAV 1,292 Posted January 12 Share Posted January 12 (edited) Blackwater money is 150.000 Micah said "we got money from blackwater. Well, MOST OF IT ANYWAY" So lets say Blackwater money is now 80.000 chest money is 42.000 so we have 122.000 Marston 20.000 marston debts 1.500 sadie 20.000 charles 20.000 uncle 20.000 jack for his future 20.000 Dutch took remaining for himself Edited January 12 by GroveStGTAV Link to post Share on other sites
darkdayz 627 Posted January 13 Share Posted January 13 (edited) 15 hours ago, Buddy Hightower said: Sadie says blackwater but how would she know? Micah said "we have money. we have dreams, join us" There was 42,000 in there. John and Charles split the money and Sadie took zero. If you go back for the cash as Arthur, guess what, there is 42,000 in there. You're making things up to justify your point. Micah say's they have the money from blackwater, then say's 'most of it' whilst laughing. Suggesting they spent a good chunk of it already. Why would John and Charle's split the cash and Sadie not take any? You are literally just bending what happened in the game to try and fit it into the 42k chest narrative you're making. And yes there is 42k, but the split between the three would equal more than that, including John's debt on top. So it's clearly more than Dutch's chest money. Further to that, the gap between Chapter 6 and American Venom in the Epilogue is almost a decade, you really think Dutch and those guys wouldn't have touched any of the money in his chest during that time? But yeah, continue to bend the facts of the game to prove the point you're trying to make. Would advise on making threads again if you aren't up for any kind of deliberation or unwilling to accept what is literally in the game. Edited January 13 by darkdayz 1 Link to post Share on other sites
Buddy Hightower 812 Posted January 13 Author Share Posted January 13 1 hour ago, darkdayz said: You're making things up to justify your point. Micah say's they have the money from blackwater, then say's 'most of it' whilst laughing. Suggesting they spent a good chunk of it already. Why would John and Charle's split the cash and Sadie not take any? You are literally just bending what happened in the game to try and fit it into the 42k chest narrative you're making. And yes there is 42k, but the split between the three would equal more than that, including John's debt on top. So it's clearly more than Dutch's chest money. Further to that, the gap between Chapter 6 and American Venom in the Epilogue is almost a decade, you really think Dutch and those guys wouldn't have touched any of the money in his chest during that time? But yeah, continue to bend the facts of the game to prove the point you're trying to make. Would advise on making threads again if you aren't up for any kind of deliberation or unwilling to accept what is literally in the game. 1. Not really, sadie said before the mission that she didn't want anything but revenge. 2. When do you think Dutch and Micah hooked back up? Sounded like Dutch showed up the same day as John. Micah said "all kinds of people visiting today" - then Dutch comes out. 3. If they had 150K plus, why are they still hiding in the snow and not in Tahiti? 4. Did you trust anything Micah said during the game? Why start now? There was about 42k in the chest, hell you can almost count it while he looks at it. Link to post Share on other sites
darkdayz 627 Posted January 13 Share Posted January 13 1 hour ago, Buddy Hightower said: 1. Not really, sadie said before the mission that she didn't want anything but revenge. 2. When do you think Dutch and Micah hooked back up? Sounded like Dutch showed up the same day as John. Micah said "all kinds of people visiting today" - then Dutch comes out. 3. If they had 150K plus, why are they still hiding in the snow and not in Tahiti? 4. Did you trust anything Micah said during the game? Why start now? There was about 42k in the chest, hell you can almost count it while he looks at it. Jesus Christ dude. 1. Neither did John and Charles, nobody went up there knowing the money was stashed. That does not mean Sadie didn't take a cut, she quite clearly did. 2. It makes no difference to what I'm saying if Dutch only turned up the same day as John. Dutch is in the main building of Micah's camp, so it's doubtful he randomly turns up in that scene. I think it's pretty clear they have been together for some time when Micah say's they retrieved the Blackwater money. 3. I have no idea why they haven't left. Probably the same reason they never left during the first 6 chapters, because Dutch is deluded. $400 of money back then is worth 11k now. More than enough to get 4 people out of America. Don't know why you think that's only possible if they had surplus 100k. 4. You are right I don't trust him. But he wasn't lying. If he said that and there was no money at the end, then yeah fair enough. But you retrieve the money which is quite clearly more than Dutch had 8 years prior. Link to post Share on other sites
Buddy Hightower 812 Posted January 13 Author Share Posted January 13 19 minutes ago, darkdayz said: Jesus Christ dude. 1. Neither did John and Charles, nobody went up there knowing the money was stashed. That does not mean Sadie didn't take a cut, she quite clearly did. 2. It makes no difference to what I'm saying if Dutch only turned up the same day as John. Dutch is in the main building of Micah's camp, so it's doubtful he randomly turns up in that scene. I think it's pretty clear they have been together for some time when Micah say's they retrieved the Blackwater money. 3. I have no idea why they haven't left. Probably the same reason they never left during the first 6 chapters, because Dutch is deluded. $400 of money back then is worth 11k now. More than enough to get 4 people out of America. Don't know why you think that's only possible if they had surplus 100k. 4. You are right I don't trust him. But he wasn't lying. If he said that and there was no money at the end, then yeah fair enough. But you retrieve the money which is quite clearly more than Dutch had 8 years prior. 1. If she didn't know any money was there, then why did she say blackwater? I think it was more of a question, like: There's money in the cabin, could it be the blackwater money? Also the amount of money in chest is part of that great rockstar logic.. lol Just like when you leave Arthur's money at the pig farm and john gets it 8 years later and none of it was ever spent. I'll just agree to disagree with you. Link to post Share on other sites
GroveStGTAV 1,292 Posted January 13 Share Posted January 13 (edited) There was a newspaper about Micah seen in Blackwater. This confirms Ferry money is taken by Micah. Maybe they wasted most of that money by hiring gunmens for Micah's gang to earn more scores Edited January 13 by GroveStGTAV Link to post Share on other sites
Cutter De Blanc 15,165 Posted January 14 Share Posted January 14 13 hours ago, Buddy Hightower said: Also the amount of money in chest is part of that great rockstar logic.. lol Just like when you leave Arthur's money at the pig farm and john gets it 8 years later and none of it was ever spent. I'll just agree to disagree with you. I dont have a dog in this fight, but I just have to say you cant compare an exploit in which the player has to do some metagaming with a plot point in the story, its comparing apples to oranges The money isnt spent at the pig farm because you wouldn't expect the player to wait until the Epilouge to try and get Arthurs cash back unless the player is metagaming Link to post Share on other sites