Quantcast
Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
    1. Welcome to GTAForums!

    1. GTANet.com

    1. GTA Online

      1. The Cayo Perico Heist
      2. Find Lobbies & Players
      3. Guides & Strategies
      4. Vehicles
      5. Content Creator
      6. Help & Support
    2. Red Dead Online

      1. Frontier Pursuits
      2. Find Lobbies & Outlaws
      3. Help & Support
    3. Crews

    1. Red Dead Redemption 2

      1. PC
      2. Help & Support
    2. Red Dead Redemption

    1. Grand Theft Auto Series

    2. GTA VI

      1. St. Andrews Cathedral
    3. GTA V

      1. Guides & Strategies
      2. Help & Support
    4. GTA IV

      1. The Lost and Damned
      2. The Ballad of Gay Tony
      3. Guides & Strategies
      4. Help & Support
    5. GTA San Andreas

      1. Guides & Strategies
      2. Help & Support
    6. GTA Vice City

      1. Guides & Strategies
      2. Help & Support
    7. GTA III

      1. Guides & Strategies
      2. Help & Support
    8. Portable Games

      1. GTA Chinatown Wars
      2. GTA Vice City Stories
      3. GTA Liberty City Stories
    9. Top-Down Games

      1. GTA Advance
      2. GTA 2
      3. GTA
    1. GTA Mods

      1. GTA V
      2. GTA IV
      3. GTA III, VC & SA
      4. Tutorials
    2. Red Dead Mods

      1. Documentation
    3. Mod Showroom

      1. Scripts & Plugins
      2. Maps
      3. Total Conversions
      4. Vehicles
      5. Textures
      6. Characters
      7. Tools
      8. Other
      9. Workshop
    4. Featured Mods

      1. Design Your Own Mission
      2. OpenIV
      3. GTA: Underground
      4. GTA: Liberty City
      5. GTA: State of Liberty
    1. Rockstar Games

    2. Rockstar Collectors

    1. Off-Topic

      1. General Chat
      2. Gaming
      3. Technology
      4. Movies & TV
      5. Music
      6. Sports
      7. Vehicles
    2. Expression

      1. Graphics / Visual Arts
      2. GFX Requests & Tutorials
      3. Writers' Discussion
      4. Debates & Discussion
    3. Gangs

    1. Announcements

    2. Support

    3. Suggestions

GTA Protagonists ranked from worst to best


Ahmedmfroezspeed

Recommended Posts

Niobium

i think CJ has more character development than franklin, even if he isn't well-written at times.

  • Like 6
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
Prasdana21

Just my own opinion.

 

1. Claude

2. Tommy Vercetti

3. Carl Johnson

4. Niko Bellic

5. Johnny Klebitz

6. Victor Vance

7. Toni Cipriani

8. Michael De Santa

9. Franklin Clinton

10. Luis Lopez

11. Trevor Phillips

 

Maybe I'd edit this to explain my reasons why.

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
Ahmedmfroezspeed
On 4/26/2020 at 10:21 AM, Prasdana21 said:

Just my own opinion.

 

1. Claude

2. Tommy Vercetti

3. Carl Johnson

4. Niko Bellic

5. Johnny Klebitz

6. Victor Vance

7. Toni Cipriani

8. Michael De Santa

9. Franklin Clinton

10. Luis Lopez

11. Trevor Phillips

 

Maybe I'd edit this to explain my reasons why.

finally someone who has Claude as #1

someone who kinda has the same mind as mine, finally

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
MyNameIsNotImportantBro

If a San Andreas fanboy saw Cj is lower than Toni he will be like.

"Wait, That's illegal"

  • KEKW 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
Prasdana21
On 4/30/2020 at 7:52 AM, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

finally someone who has Claude as #1

someone who kinda has the same mind as mine, finally

 

Haha thank you. He was the first GTA protagonist that I played as xD

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...
Limefong

 

 

12) Vic Vance

 

11) Toni Cipriani 

 

10) Huang Lee

 

9) Michael De Santa

 

8) Jonny Klebitz

 

7) Claude

 

6) Luis Lopez

 

5) Trevor

 

4) Tommy Vercetti

 

3) Franklin

 

2) CJ

 

1) Niko 

Edited by Limefong
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Ahmedmfroezspeed

alright, i had to renew my list again

this is the new version of my list you are going to see

some spots have changed,and the rest remained the same,

the Craiterias are the same, with the addition of 4 more Craitrias

the new Craiterias

1- how good his voice actor is

2- how much effort Rockstar put in the character, like Stunt performing,etc

3- how cool his outfits are

and 4 which is a big one that plays like 65% of a role in my ranking and i forgot to mention it

4- how much times he gets laid, the less,the higher he becomes

and the two at #13 and #12 are thw worst of all

and the ones at #11 and #10 are in the middle

and from #9 to #6 are protagonists i like

and from #5 to #1,these are protagonists that are my favorite

and both the ones at the top keep changing continuously

when i look at the one at the #1 spot, i say this is my favorite

and when i look at the other one, i say,no, this is my favorite

and they just keep changing

good ? alright

now let's move on to the ranking

#13- and yes, this one didn't change

#13- Luis Lopez- GTA The Ballad of Gay Tony

now you understand my hate for him,right ?

don't try to convince me that he's not a douchebag that does anything for sex

no,i'm immune to convenience,my mind never changes

instead of trying to correct me,however,

try to tell me about his moments of psychopathy

this might make me put him higher than CJ

both Luis and CJ are the protagonists with the least moments of psychopathy

that's why they're very low on this list

In other words, he's an a**hole

But not in the fun Trevor Phillips way

I'd rate him 0/5 stars

#12- C.J.- GTA San Andreas

i f*cking HATE this asshole

he's overrated, and he's a f*cking pussy/coward

he has a few moments of psychopathy,that's why he's a bit higher than Luis

but not way higher

they don't even deserve that kind of love...

I'm not Racist, he is just less "badass"ic than the other protagonists we got used to like Claude and Tommy, and one of the problems with this guy is that he feels renorse... like all the time

He doesn't even have rampages

Another problem with this guy is that he's another kind of douche bag that would say ABSOLUTELY anything to get his d*ck wet

Like "spit it out, filthy worm", oh man I hate this guy

Even if he did deliver one idiotic line that ended up making me laugh

"EHHAHAHAHAAA, man those are pretty strong drawers...",

But compared to Luis, CJ is way better if you ask me, at least he has a psychopathic side like when he killed the construction site workers and buried an engineer alive in concrete,  plus he could have killed Tenpenny and his officers from the beginning, plus he could have killed them when he met them in las Venturaas, I mean dude you have weapons already, and you've unlocked all the islands why don't you just shoot them in the head and escape?  This is the GTA dimension,  not real life you idiot...

egh, what do I know...?

For me, I rate him 0.5/5 stars

#11- Huang Lee- GTA Chinatown Wars

What makes him better than CJ here is that he has les capability of remorse, and he's pretty psychopathic if you ask me

I'd give him 1.5/5 stars

Edit: how is he still living in China after that Corona Virus... ?

#10- Mike- GTA Advance

What makes him pretty high on this list is that he is very loyal,  and probably the most Loyal protagonist in this series, hell he's even more Loyal than Cipriani, and what proves that is that if his mission Boss got killed, he would do everything in his power to know the killer and kill him as revenge for his boss' death

Pretty loyal if you ask me

he's the kind of person you'd really want to have as a friend...

He's not bad at all

I give him 2.5/5 stars, not bad...

_________________________________________________________________

#9- Franklin Clinton- GTA V

this is the new and enhanced CJ

Franklin is just better than CJ...Much Better...

What makes Clinton better than Johnson here is that he's a badass

A Sociopath, he might feel remorse

From time to time, and I don't blame him for that, but not ALL THE TIME like CJ

Plus, he has rampages

Definitely better than CJ here

Rating: 2.75/5

#8- Michael De Santa- GTA V

originally,Michael wa at #7. but i had to re position the V protagonists again

What makes him better than Franklin though is that he has an interesting backstory, he had an alcoholic father that abused him and later left him, his environment was rough, he got prisoned twice,

He suddenly had a family

Man, pretty dope

edit: it's no strange that a hypocrite can come out of this unhealthy environment...

Rating: 2.9/5 stars

 

#7- Trevor Phillips- GTA V

originally, Trevor was at #6, but i switched his place with Johnny

and now, i changed him to #7

for a reason, i asked myself 3 questions

ain't Johnny much more basassic than Trevor

Yea

ain't Johnny's gang better than Trevor

maybe

is Trevor reading my ranking of him ?

Hell Nah,brothers, that's why i changed them both

What makes him better than mikey and Frank that his backstory is even more interesting than Mikey

He has been abused in childhood, his father abandoned him, he wasn't accepted for working in flight, he had to kill his brother,  and etc, and he's even more interesting in GTA 5, he's enjoyable,  he's brutal and harsh as F*ck, his abilities, he kinda doesn't feel remorse, good job, Rockstar

I'd give him 2.95/5 stars

#6- Johnny Klebitz- GTA The Lost And Damned

just like Trevor, he was originally at #9

but i already told you the reason why i switched them both...

Klebitz is a psychopathic killer, a biker who cares about his family and friends, in other words, the biker version of Tommy Vercetti

only much more humanized

Rating:3/5 stars

________________________________________________________________

#5- -prepare your bullets,everybody-

#5- Niko Bellic- GTA IV

what made him 1 spot lower than original

is because when i read the lists of other users on this topic

i noticed that 99% of them have Niko Bellic as #1

which annoyed me..., and what annoyed me even more,is that

what's common between Niko Bellic's praising lists, all of them put Toni and Claude in the bottom

ik he's appealing, yes,but why this much of love for him ?

you just sh*t on the rest because the have no charm,charisma,or wit

f*ck Charm,f*ck Charisma,and f*ck Wit

and here's a little note: if i ever see anyone Putting Niko in the top and sh*tting on Toni Cipriani, Niko will be lower

ranking 3.25/5 stars

#4- Vic Vance- GTA Vice City Stories

originally,Vic was at #5,

but because of you all overrating Niko,

i swapped them both,happy now ?

What makes Vic better than Franklin here, and way better than CJ here is that he's a leader, he cares about everybody around him more than himself he's loyal and reliable, he has his own gang and drug empire,  he gets money everyday, man he's f*cking cool

He could have been on the #1 spot, but only if the protagonists in the 4th, 3rd, 2nd, and 1st spot didn't make it in this series,

ranking:3.5/5 stars

#3- Tommy Vercetti- GTA Vice City

another great protagonist here, just like Niko but what makes him better exactly ? Well he's more "badass"ic and psychopathic, he has his own organisation and gang, he had brutal kills, man he was just perfect,  Is he missing something? 

Yes, sadism,  he's psychopathic,  but not that psychopathic compared to Toni Cipriani, 

I mean he's not sadistic when you compare him to Toni,  and come to think of it, he never said that he likes seeing everyone around him suffer in pain, and he's not disloyal like Claude...,, nor a hypocrite like Michael...

he was great, but needed more psychopathy, that's why he's on my third spot And Toni on the second spot

Tommy is just a psychopathic schizophrenic with hunger and lust for power

Rating is 4/5 stars

#2- Claude- GTA 3

before,Claude was always my #1

until this moment came

i was like: nah, man, let's put Toni in the Top and switch their places

i actually like Claude, but his Coolness with Toni is a challenge

sometimes Claude wins,and Sometimes Toni wins

rating: 4.5/5 stars

so #2- Claude

#1- Toni Cipriani- GTA Liberty City Stories

the Best Protagonist in the series so far

this is the protagonist that personifies me the most, out of all the GTA Protagonists

Loyal, and Trustworthy, but Very short tempered

he's in the best gang in the franchise, the Leones

he is the protagonist with the best outfits in the series by far

everything was cool about him

He's just Tommy Vercetti only with way more sadism and way less mercy, unlike Tommy, Toni is sadistic,  I mean think of it, whenever he slaughters anybody he always chooses the most painful.Cruel, sadistic, and yet brutal way to do it Look at giovanni casa for example That dude was killed by cipriani by a fire axe, his corpse got chopped up, the chops were put in the grinder, and the corpse meat was delivered to casa's delli, and the attack on fort staunton that killed over a hundred,  and probably over a thousand, 

That's why Toni's better than Tommy

rating: 5/5 stars ,perfecto

like my new list ?

Edited by Ahmedmfroezspeed
enhancements...
Link to post
Share on other sites
Yinepi

Many people say they like a talking protagonist, or that they prefer human qualities. I'm the opposite. I like the quiet and sophisticated appeal of Claude and the 2D era protagonists. You never knew what they were thinking, which added a sense of mystery to them. All you really know is that they're dangerous. Sure, Trevor is dangerous but the second he opens his mouth he feels less threatening than someone who simply never speaks, never yells. Only grunts when in pain.

If I were having a gun pointed at me by someone who is yelling at me or someone who looks at me with a blank stare, I'd be more inclined to give my money to the silent one.

Edited by Yinepi
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Algonquin Assassin
1 hour ago, Yinepi said:

Many people say they like a talking protagonist, or that they prefer human qualities. I'm the opposite. I like the quiet and sophisticated appeal of Claude and the 2D era protagonists. You never knew what they were thinking, which added a sense of mystery to them. All you really know is that they're dangerous. Sure, Trevor is dangerous but the second he opens his mouth he feels less threatening than someone who simply never speaks, never yells. Only grunts when in pain.

If I were having a gun pointed at me by someone who is yelling at me or someone who looks at me with a blank stare, I'd be more inclined to give my money to the silent one.

I agree it adds a sense of mystique, but it also limits the kind of stories that R* can tell. I remember some time back someone said in other another thread (can't remember who) that Vice City could've worked if Tommy never spoke, but I kind of just rolled my eyes.

 

I've been vocal about this before, but I feel R* made somewhat of a mistake trying to give Claude more of a backstory when he made a cameo in San Andreas. Of course he still doesn't speak and he lets his actions do the talking, but it doesn't make him as "mysterious" as GTA III. It's a bit like how Rob Zombie's Halloween movies try to give Michael Myers more of a backstory by explaining that he's evil because he had a tough upbringing yet in the original he's evil for the sake of being evil. No one knows why he is, but he is anyway which made him more terrifying IMO.

 

I even think giving Claude a name robs some of his mystique also. I don't know about anyone else, but I thought it was more bad arse when he was only known as "The GTA III guy" or "Fido". We didn't know who this guy was who or what his name was. All we knew was he'd wreck your sh*t up.

 

I think Claude's caught up in a bit of a strange limbo because the original idea behind him was to be an avatar and let the player inject any sort of personality they wanted hence why he was never referred to by name and there was even going to be the ability to let us make our own names for him, but it was removed before the game's release however when people started speculating that he might've been Claude Speed from GTA 2 R* tried making him more of a "character" if you get what I mean thus contradicting a large part of his original intention. 

 

@Ahmedmfroezspeed

 

So the only reason you have Niko lower is you don't like people favouring him over your favourite protagonists? Unless I'm missing something, but that's honestly stupid and well kind of childish.:/

 

People have already explained why they like Niko. I don't know where the mystery lies at all. Of course you don't have to like him (each to their own), but I would think someone would pick a genuine reason other than being annoyed he's liked by others.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
Ahmedmfroezspeed
On 5/19/2020 at 2:08 AM, Algonquin Assassin said:

@Ahmedmfroezspeed

 

So the only reason you have Niko lower is you don't like people favouring him over your favourite protagonists? Unless I'm missing something, but that's honestly stupid and well kind of childish.:/

 

People have already explained why they like Niko. I don't know where the mystery lies at all. Of course you don't have to like him (each to their own), but I would think someone would pick a genuine reason other than being annoyed he's liked by others.

 

yeah,it's so annoying to see your favorite protagonists being sh*tted on just because they have no charm,Charima,or wit

well, f*ck these 3 characteristics, i'm only interested in how high their psychopathy'o' meter is and how low their getting laid'o'meter is,not their charisma or charm

Edited by Ahmedmfroezspeed
Link to post
Share on other sites
Algonquin Assassin
3 minutes ago, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

yeah,it's so annoying to see your favorite protagonists being sh*tted on just because they have no charm,Charima,or wit

well, f*ck these 3 characteristics, i'm only interested in their psychopathy level,not their charisma or charm

I have to ask because who's even doing that? I've looked over this thread several times and I don't see anyone "taking a sh*t" on Claude or Toni for lacking charm, charisma or wit nor have I in other similar threads. Even if that were true that's still a pretty poor reason to relegate Niko on the basis people have him as their favourite as it gives the impression you can't handle opposing opinions.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Ahmedmfroezspeed
23 minutes ago, Algonquin Assassin said:

I have to ask because who's even doing that? I've looked over this thread several times and I don't see anyone "taking a sh*t" on Claude or Toni for lacking charm, charisma or wit nor have I in other similar threads. Even if that were true that's still a pretty poor reason to relegate Niko on the basis people have him as their favourite as it gives the impression you can't handle opposing opinions.

 

 

it's been 12 f*cking years since the release of GTA IV

and since then, almost all the Lists had Niko Bellic as #1

and still, we've seen nothing new about a protagonist as #1

whenever there's a ranking protagonists list

there is a 99% chance that Niko would be #1

and 99% chance to see Claude and Toni taken a sh*t from that list

edit: it's almost like people are racist towards these two

my point is, Niko Bellic's praising lists are so so so mega annoying

Edited by Ahmedmfroezspeed
Link to post
Share on other sites
Algonquin Assassin
Just now, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

it's been 12 f*cking years since the release of GTA IV

and since then, almost all the Lists had Niko Bellic as #1

and still, we've seen nothing new about a protagonist as #1

whenever there's a ranking protagonists list

there is a 99% chance that Niko would be #1

and 99% chance to see Claude and Toni taken a sh*t from that list

my point is, Niko Bellic's praising lists are so so so mega annoying

Ever think there's a good reason for that? Sorry, but all you're doing is proving my exact point.

 

Maybe some people just don't like Claude and Toni? I mean Claude as I said is basically just an avatar and I get how this may not be appealing to some people who are more interested in characters with actual depth and personality and I don't know, but Toni just seemed uninspired to me. I liked him more as a side character in GTA III, but there's nothing that stands out about him in LCS so I can understand how for others that might feel the same way too.

 

But if you love them then go nuts as far as I'm concerned, but being annoyed because Niko's so popular (and for good reason I might add) surely isn't the best way to go about things

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
Ahmedmfroezspeed
On 5/19/2020 at 2:08 AM, Algonquin Assassin said:

It's a bit like how Rob Zombie's Halloween movies try to give Michael Myers more of a backstory by explaining that he's evil because he had a tough upbringing yet in the original he's evil for the sake of being evil. No one knows why he is, but he is anyway which made him more terrifying IMO.

Rob Zombie was an imbecile...who loved the Halloween remake anyway ?

Link to post
Share on other sites
Americana

This is my preference. 

 

11. The Worst: Trevor

10. Franklin

9. Carl 

8. Toni 

7. Victor

6. Luis

5. Claude

4. Michael

3. Tommy

2. Johnny

1. The Best: Niko

 


 

 

 

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
Limefong

I have decided to rewrite my list

 

Worst character

 

Mike: 0.25/10

 

OK characters

 

Toni Cipriani: 2.25/10

Huang Lee: 2.75/10

Michael De Santa: 3.25/10

 

Good characters

Claude: 4.5/10

Luis Lopez: 5/10

 

Great characters

Trevor Phillips: 6.25/10

Vic Vance: 6.75/10 (I have played most missions of VCs and he wasn't that bad at all)

Johnny Klebitz: 7.5/10

 

Best characters

Franklin: 8.25/10

CJ: 9/10

Tommy Vercetti: 9.5/10

Niko Bellic: 10/10, Please don't be mad over me putting him on the top :)

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
Ahmedmfroezspeed
3 hours ago, Limefong said:

I have decided to rewrite my list

 

Worst character

 

Mike: 0.25/10

wait, he's an extremely loyal guy

and would seek revenge for you if you got killed

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
Schachmatt777

I only played four games myself, because I never had and don't intend to obtain any console. Though I watched all remaining but the 2D games as walkthroughs on Youtube, and maybe one day I will even do a GTA III run myself, as it's the only GTA PC game I haven't played as of yet. But watching someone/something is entirely different than playing it myself, so I won't judge these characters. The remaining 8 characters, from best to worst IMO:

 

1. Michael de Santa

2. Carl Johnson

3. Trevor Phillips

4. Johnny Klebitz

5. Thommy Vercetti

6. Franklin Clinton

7. Louis Lopez

8. Niko Bellic

 

I don't hate (or worship ;)) any of these characters btw and would play any of these characters at any day, I think that all of them have their strenghts and weaknesses, as all of them has their unique charm.

 

I can relate to Michael more than to the other characters, and can't warm up to Niko the same way due to certain reasons. But at the end of the day, I enjoyed and still enjoyplaying each of them.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Yinepi

I tend to not like Niko because I find him annoying. His accent it is all over the place in an very irritating manner. He has a way of speaking that is like nails on chalkboard. One minute he is speaking in a very forced way that makes him sound unnatural, then after 10 missions he starts to speak like a native English speaker. Which are you? A foreigner with little English, or an American?

Edited by Yinepi
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Cheatz/Trickz
16 hours ago, Yinepi said:

I tend to not like Niko because I find him annoying. His accent it is all over the place in an very irritating manner. He has a way of speaking that is like nails on chalkboard. One minute he is speaking in a very forced way that makes him sound unnatural, then after 10 missions he starts to speak like a native English speaker. Which are you? A foreigner with little English, or an American?


I mean I don’t agree with your point at all (your criticisms are not related to his character or actions i.e. I can’t stand Franklin’s ghetto speak but I wouldn’t criticize him for it) but I gotta agree with the language thing. Niko’s English is superb, yet he constantly says it’s bad.
 

His accent is consistent though, he never once sounds American at all. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Ryo256
1 hour ago, Cheatz/Trickz said:

Niko’s English is superb, yet he constantly says it’s bad.

In his conversation with Bruice (first friend hang out if I'm right) where he is talking something about the "beast inside him", Niko does ask him to repeat because his "English is not so good". 

Unless he was using that as an excuse to tell Bruice to stop speaking nonsense, I think Niko has difficulty understanding when English words are used more figuratively. But as a means of communication, I agree, his English is superb.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
Cheatz/Trickz
1 hour ago, Ryo256 said:

In his conversation with Bruice (first friend hang out if I'm right) where he is talking something about the "beast inside him", Niko does ask him to repeat because his "English is not so good". 

Unless he was using that as an excuse to tell Bruice to stop speaking nonsense, I think Niko has difficulty understanding when English words are used more figuratively. But as a means of communication, I agree, his English is superb.


Lol, during Harbouring A Grudge when he and Packie go to the fish market, Packie is talking about the dodgy dealings going on there and says something smells fishy about the whole thing. Niko responds with a bemused “the fish market smells fishy?” 

  • Like 2
  • KEKW 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Algonquin Assassin
10 hours ago, Cheatz/Trickz said:


I mean I don’t agree with your point at all (your criticisms are not related to his character or actions i.e. I can’t stand Franklin’s ghetto speak but I wouldn’t criticize him for it) but I gotta agree with the language thing. Niko’s English is superb, yet he constantly says it’s bad.
 

His accent is consistent though, he never once sounds American at all. 

Yeah. I don't see how he sounds American either.

 

It's obvious though as the more time that passes Hollick got more and more comfortable speaking with an accent, but it's really difficult to tell he's American and from Brooklyn specifically. At the start I think Niko just has difficulty understanding certain terminology/slang and this is what he means by his English not being so good. A bit like how some Americans probably wouldn't get Australian terminology/slang and vice versa. Niko's ability to speak in English is fine, but since he's not accustomed to American culture it takes him some time to get familiar with it. Lets also remember that GTA IV's only a video game that lasts on average 40 hours. In real life it would probably take someone months or years even, but I guess they had to fast track it somewhat because it's a video game.

 

Anyway atleast it feels believable and he probably wouldn't get it when someone says "something smells fishy". Another example from the same mission is when Packie says "meds" and Niko's not sure what he means.

  • Like 5
Link to post
Share on other sites
Cheatz/Trickz
22 minutes ago, Algonquin Assassin said:

Yeah. I don't see how he sounds American either.

 

It's obvious though as the more time that passes Hollick got more and more comfortable speaking with an accent, but it's really difficult to tell he's American and from Brooklyn specifically. At the start I think Niko just has difficulty understanding certain terminology/slang and this is what he means by his English not being so good. A bit like how some Americans probably wouldn't get Australian terminology/slang and vice versa. Niko's ability to speak in English is fine, but since he's not accustomed to American culture it takes him some time to get familiar with it. Lets also remember that GTA IV's only a video game that lasts on average 40 hours. In real life it would probably take someone months or years even, but I guess they had to fast track it somewhat because it's a video game.

 

Anyway atleast it feels believable and he probably wouldn't get it when someone says "something smells fishy". Another example from the same mission is when Packie says "meds" and Niko's not sure what he means.


I’ve heard it suggested that he gradually becomes more fluent as the missions go on, as if he’s picking up the language more.

 

I like that he doesn’t understand those kinds of abbreviations. I’m trying to recall some others because i’m sure there are other occasions. I know early on with Vlad, he doesn’t understand when Vlad says he’ll let him “take the sh*t, mickey about”. Another one I remember is when you cancel a date he says “We will have to check the rain” lol

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
Algonquin Assassin
28 minutes ago, Cheatz/Trickz said:

I like that he doesn’t understand those kinds of abbreviations. I’m trying to recall some others because i’m sure there are other occasions. I know early on with Vlad, he doesn’t understand when Vlad says he’ll let him “take the sh*t, mickey about”. Another one I remember is when you cancel a date he says “We will have to check the rain” lol

How about when PBX tries to describe Marlon in "Photo Shoot"?:p

 

Actually even I struggle to understand ghetto/street talk so I can understand how this would be confusing for Niko and of course the infamous scene when Badman's talking and Niko literally has the "WTF are you even saying?" on his face lol. Considering the amount of people he encounters from a range of different backgrounds/cultures etc more than the average person would it's probably no wonder he has difficultly understanding certain things people say whilst he's developing his own grasp of the English language.

  • Like 4
Link to post
Share on other sites
billiejoearmstrong8
On 5/31/2020 at 2:45 AM, Algonquin Assassin said:

How about when PBX tries to describe Marlon in "Photo Shoot"?:p

 

Actually even I struggle to understand ghetto/street talk so I can understand how this would be confusing for Niko and of course the infamous scene when Badman's talking and Niko literally has the "WTF are you even saying?" on his face lol. Considering the amount of people he encounters from a range of different backgrounds/cultures etc more than the average person would it's probably no wonder he has difficultly understanding certain things people say whilst he's developing his own grasp of the English language.

My favourite slight language issue is when he says "I know how to go on the line"

 

And then there's Little Jacob who Niko can understand perfectly simply because they vibe together so well lol

 

I agree they did the whole not being totally familiar with English thing well, considering the restraints of a video game setting. Falling back into Serbian when talking to Roman quite often when he first arrives and a little bit of getting more accustomed to English. And just the subtle unfamiliarities with certain turns of phrase. And even though I'm aware the accent isn't really that accurate I think it still sounds very consistent and pleasant to listen to, it might not be authentically Serbian sounding but it certainly never sounds American and to my non expert ears I never don't buy that he's from Eastern Europe. Not to mention the high quality of the voice acting in general besides just the accent, he put across such a range of emotion and a compelling performance.

Edited by billiejoearmstrong8
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 7 months later...
DR:BUSTA
On 3/13/2020 at 11:14 AM, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

problems with this guy is that he feels renorse... like all the time

He doesn't even have rampages

Because he already has gangwars which are literally rampages but with waves

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Vic

2. Niko

3. CJ

4. Tommy

5. Huang

6. Michael

7. Johnny

8. Trevor

9. Luis

10. Claude

11. Franklin

12. Toni

Edited by OH76
Forgot to add Huang...
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
FanEu7

1. Niko Bellic

2. Tommy Vercetti

3. Michael De Santa

4. CJ

5. Trevor Phillips

6. Johnny Klebitz

7. Franklin Clinton

8. Luis Lopez

9. Victor Vance

10. Toni Cipriani

11. Claude

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
DR:BUSTA

1- CJ

How can someone look at this face and not say "This Is Art"

6e4018bd536d50709c9508d5cdedc2f8.jpg

Seriously I like him because he's different and more relatable he's not a badass but he has his moments and he received the most character development (except if you chose sparing Darko and deal for Niko this way you feel like he's really trying to change) and CJ  is also funny and I like how he pays respect to everyone and makes the right connections and this is the only absent trip where the protagonist doesn't have most of the things offered to him which makes it more interesting

2- Niko bellic

I don't think this needs to be explained 

Niko is badass and a bit human at the same time which makes him unique 

Also a lot of people try to deny this because ah Niko is always a good guy but the greatest thing about Niko is how he turned into the thing he was fighting against an even became worse without noticing  reminds me of batman when he admits that he's physcotic criminal and loses it

3-Tommy Vercetti

Hands down the biggest badass in the series the only one who does everything for himself and doesn't take sh*t from others and everytime I play the game I feel like the world is mine

4- Vic Vance

Vic is a mix of all of the three above but I see him as CJ if he was more badass and had charisma or a perfect mix between Niko and CJ I like how rockstar managed to pull a fully badass guy and fully human at the same time and his anger issues makes him more relatable unlike Tommy who was smart most the time Victor is always angry I mean compare their similar scenes together like meeting Umberto Tommy made one of the greatest and smartest lines in the series when Umberto made fun of him meanwhile Vic pulled a gun and was about to blow his f*cking face

5- Luis Lopez

He's a bit bland because there is no reason for him to be involved in all of this but when I play the game I think that he developed a father/son relationship with Tony prince and that's why he won't leave his back but I like how cool he's and how I get engaged playing as him even though I don't like commiting too much crimes playing as him and prefer to live the night life

6- Michael

I like Michael and his chemistry with his family . He wanted to provide them a better life but it turned them into assholes and he's an asshole they call him that I feel bad for him but he's an asshole and deserves to be hated by them but they're also assholes it's a who created who thing

7- Johnny Klebtez

Well this guy's place changed a lot for me and the reason is the guy under hum right now but I used to hate Trevor and like Johnny  then the opposite and it kept changing until both became very low on my list

8- Trevor

I like his idea and the Comic relief funny protagonist

He gets on my nerves  sometimes but I can handle it

9- Claude

He does his role pretty well making me feel like a thug but not interesting except if I made him interesting

10- Franklin

He's CJ just lonely and more pacifist 

11- Toni

Hey I will do random favors for half of liberty city for no real reason

Edit: oops I forgot Huang just put him somewhere with Johnny and Trevor 

Edited by DR:BUSTA
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • 1 User Currently Viewing
    0 members, 0 Anonymous, 1 Guest

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.