Top 3 characters of the Red Dead series!

[O.Z 2,138]

Now that the dust has settled its time to list your top 3 all time favourite Red Dead characters.

 

In order:

 

1. John Marston

2. Arthur Morgan

3. Dutch Van Der Linde

[JC_HUMBLE 407]

Dude that's my top 3 as well but in diferent order:

 

3. John Marston - The face of the Redemption series the two games evolve around him, with a tragic sacrifice... the man deserved better.

 

2. Dutch Van Der Linde - I just can't hate this guy, heartbroken by his actions yes... the most interesting non playable character I had most care about. 

 

1. Arthur Morgan - No words to describe my affection towards him, definitely my favorite R* character so far.

 

Honorable Mentions: Bonnie McFarlane (even though the second game delivered us great female characters like Sadie, Bonnie stills on my top) & Micah Bell (damn you Micah! Thanks to the incredible performance of Peter Blomquist Micah became a character that I love to hate).

Edited February 14 by Shinola Gamer

[JPFL 258]

1.Arthur Morgan

2.Dutch Van Der Linde

3.John Marston

 

[TheSantader25 4,945]

1.Arthur Morgan

2.Hosea Mathews

3.Irish/Leigh Johnson

[HeyThereFriend 171]

1. John Marston - Not only my favorite RDR character but my all time favorite video game character. The most iconic voice in gaming for me and a total badass.

 

2. Arthur Morgan - Didn't expect to like him as much as I do. The trailers really built him up as a scumbag, most of his lines in the trailer are from the Money Lending missions. However he surprised me and I think he's a great Boah!

 

3. Abigail Marston - In the first game I didn't care for her much, was more of a Bonnie fan but in this game they got her right, just completely right.

 

Honorable Mention - Jack Swift

[Dark Rosewood Varnish 129]

1. Arthur Morgan

2. Arthur Morgan

3. Arthur Morgan 

Edited February 14 by Dark Rosewood Varnish

[Deadman2112 1,032]

John and Arthur for obvious reasons.

 

The Strange Man simply because outside of the two listed above...

No one character has generated more buzz and theories than him.

 

Edited February 14 by Deadman2112

[DoctorMike 1,364]

John Marston

Dutch van der Linde

Irish

[ShayD 215]

1. Arthur Morgan - best rockstar protagonist by a country mile. Has a story of true redemption and is a much deeper character with more development that eclipses John in every way. 

 

2. Hosea Matthews - Probably the most father like figure in the camp, always showing concern for his family. Learning about his past shows how hes been through hard times, and seeing how he interacts with people in the camp shows his good nature and he was clearly loved by everyone.

 

3. Micah Bell - I hate to admit it but I loved Micahs part in RDR2. Such a well written character and made the perfect one for us to love to hate. I would argue he makes a better villain than Dutch given how sneaky he was in his manipulation of the camp members.

 

Honorable mentions - Charles Smith, apart from the 3 above he was the best side character of both games.

Marshall Johnson, professional bad ass.

Edited February 14 by ShayD
I can't spell lol

[confederatestatesgta 1,471]

micah bell. he is my favorite character. i know i will get hate but i have always loved the villains more. micah is so cool. he is one of the best shots in the gang. if not the best.

 

arthur morgan. another amazing character. he is definitely the best protagonist of the series for me.

 

landon ricketts. one of the best gunslingers of the wild west. and i really liked his missions. he also helps john a lot. its a shame he wasent in rdr 2. it was nice that he was mentioned. and he had a cigarette card.

[Cutter De Blanc 13,108]

Top 3  important characters:

Dutch Van Der Linde

Arthur Morgan

Jack Marston

 

My favorite 3:

Dutch Van Der Linde

Arthur Morgan

The Strange Man

[coach_wargo 1,954]

I really like John. Arthur is awesome, but I feel at home playing as John. My top 3 are people that I wish we could just hangout with more or do more missions with.

 

1. Landon Rickets

2. Charles Smith

3. Marshal Leigh Johnson

 

 

 

[ThroatSlasher2 2,068]

1a - Arthur Morgan

1b - John Marston

2 - Dutch Van der Linde

3 - Micah Bell

[Jason 16,191]

1) Arthur 2) John 3) I'll put out a name I haven't seen anyone say yet: Uncle

[ghostsoap01 786]

1. Arthur Morgan

2. Landon Ricketts

3. Jack Marston

[JC Hammer 3,440]

The main story is just sooo bad that I'd have to go with a few of the Strangers in RDR2....

 

3. Margaret

2. Algernon Wasp

1. Hamish Sinclair

[O.Z 2,138]

11 hours ago, JC Hammer said:

The main story is just sooo bad that I'd have to go with a few of the Strangers in RDR2....

 

3. Margaret

2. Algernon Wasp

1. Hamish Sinclair

I wouldn’t call it bad, I would give it 7/10. So just above average.

[Dark Rosewood Varnish 129]

On 2/14/2019 at 10:02 PM, coach_wargo said:

 

3. Marshal Leigh Johnson

 

 

 

 

This is the one character I wish made an appearance or would be at least referenced in RDR2. One of my favourite characters of RDR1.