Best Antagonist? [POSSIBLE SPOILERS!]

[The Blast]

Micah is a son of a bitch but Dutch is straight unforgivable, so I go with Dutch. I hate Dutch more than anyone in any game. How could he betray the best cowboy of all time? Still boils my blood.

[Dan_1983]

10 hours ago, The Blast said:

Micah is a son of a bitch but Dutch is straight unforgivable, so I go with Dutch. I hate Dutch more than anyone in any game. How could he betray the best cowboy of all time? Still boils my blood.

Indeed, betrayed two men who have been with him 20 and 15 years.

 

Hosea was more of a father to both Arthur and John.

[Mokrie Dela]

1 hour ago, Dan_1983 said:

Indeed, betrayed two men who have been with him 20 and 15 years.

 

Hosea was more of a father to both Arthur and John.

But until then they were family. I actually forgot that Dutch 'goes mad' and ultimately becomes the enemy while playing rdr2. Then when he does it hurts harder. Micah is always a prick but Dutch? His change hit all the more hard. Plus I saw conflict in him a lot. He wasnt 100% a bad guy. He had doubts and obvious insecurities (you can hear it in his voice when Arthur returns to camp after saving Abigail at the end). 

[jaylen pizarro]

dutch

[Old Man With No Name]

Angelo Bronte is underrated

[Middle Class Roadman]

Thing with Dutch is even after all the shenanigans he pulled and questionable things he done, I still very much liked him. For me he is simply one of Rockstars best ever character creations. 

 

I personally voted for Bronte, he was a real slime ball.

Edited April 3, 2020 by Dark Rosewood Varnish

[VenusianDream]

Definitely Micah, I hated him from the very beginning and I knew he'd be the bad guy. He ratted out the gang, killed Jack's dog, and he manipulated Dutch into becoming an antagonist of his own. His voice and personality irks me. Despite all that, he's also pretty badass and he's skilled at shooting (he sucks at fighting though). He seems to be the polar opposite of Arthur; he kills for the simple sake of killing, and his white hat and red shirt contrasts Arthur's blue shirt and black hat. R* is pretty good at writing antagonists, but I think Micah is the best one so far.

Edited April 12, 2020 by VenusianDream
Forgot that the bank robbery was Hosea's idea, not Micah's

[Edward RDRIII]

7 hours ago, VenusianDream said:

Definitely Micah, I hated him from the very beginning and I knew he'd be the bad guy. He ratted out the gang, killed Jack's dog, got Hosea and Lenny killed (The Lemoyne bank heist was his idea) and he manipulated Dutch into becoming an antagonist of his own. His voice and personality irks me. Despite all that, he's also pretty badass and he's skilled at shooting (he sucks at fighting though). He seems to be the polar opposite of Arthur; he kills for the simple sake of killing, and his white hat and red shirt contrasts Arthur's blue shirt and black hat. R* is pretty good at writing antagonists, but I think Micah is the best one so far.

The Lemoyne National Bank robbery was Hosea's idea, not Micah's or Dutch's.

Edited April 12, 2020 by Dudu RDRII

[Buddy Hightower]

Micha and Dutch are not antagonists. If so, then so is Arthur from another point of view.

It's agent Milton, no one else fits the bill.