This game needs some changes

[Nolan2018]

 

 

1.Save after entering cheats

 

2.Let John be able to swim 

 

3.fast travel needs a go to waypoint option and allow camp fires for fast travel also and also I see a lot of random houses throughout the world that have beds. We should be able to use those as fast travel 

 

4.Allow upgrades to John’s house like animal skin rugs, Head skulls, bring animals in for the ranch, etc

 

5.has to be a way to carry more than one large pelt at a time

 

6.need more trapper and fence locations 

 

7.wanted system needs to be toned down. I should get wanted for accidentally bumping someone or running someone over with these touchy controls

 

 

 

[Fugitive21]

As for #5 you can bring 2 horses out to hunt. Just have to make sure both are close and able to be called to whistle.

[tre288]

You'll probably get buried for suggesting most of these things

[RileyRock]

Just imagine how many random events you’d missed by fast travel.f*ck John, he is dump cant herd cant swim

Edited November 19, 2018 by RileyRock

[MagicNarcosis]

 

 

Man up and eat this gristly mutton, ya bum.

Edited November 19, 2018 by MagicNarcosis

[Fugitive21]

I think i used fast travel once. 

[AmyStone]

1 hour ago, tre288 said:

You'll probably get buried for suggesting most of these things

Well number 1 was enough for me to realise he's not a serious gamer so his opinions don't matter.

[tre288]

7 minutes ago, AmyStone said:

Well number 1 was enough for me to realise he's not a serious gamer so his opinions don't matter.

Seems like you're trying too hard with that "serious gamer" business

Edited November 19, 2018 by tre288

[Nutduster]

1 hour ago, Nolan2018 said:

 

1.Save after entering cheats

 

2.Let John be able to swim 

 

3.fast travel needs a go to waypoint option and allow camp fires for fast travel also and also I see a lot of random houses throughout the world that have beds. We should be able to use those as fast travel 

 

5.has to be a way to carry more than one large pelt at a time

 

 

No thanks on all of those. #5 will be less irritating if they added another couple trapper locations.

 

 

1 hour ago, Nolan2018 said:

4.Allow upgrades to John’s house like animal skin rugs, Head skulls, bring animals in for the ranch, etc

 

6.need more trapper and fence locations 

 

7.wanted system needs to be toned down. I should get wanted for accidentally bumping someone or running someone over with these touchy controls

 

 

These are good.

 

My most wanted change would be to make Arthur a little more responsive and nimble on foot, and to add a fast walk option of some kind like we already have in camp.  The most logical thing I think would be to just increase his walk speed by like 50% but you can push the stick less to have him walk slower if you want.  Or add a button option other than A.  I just feel like walking in towns is too slow, but sprinting is both dumb-looking and dangerous.

[AmyStone]

5 minutes ago, tre288 said:

Seems like you're trying too hard with that "serious gamer" business

What does that mean?

[tre288]

1 minute ago, AmyStone said:

What does that mean?

It means you're trying way too hard to make yourself feel better about the title of "serious gamer" because cheats lol

 

One of the most fun things about SA was printing off the lists and just having mindless fun with the game. What does using cheats here have to do with being a "serious gamer"..

 

 

[Ziggy_Ivanhoe]

More Trappers and Fences I can agree with. Maybe one more horse fence too or at least let me get a little bit more for the horses I tame and  bring to the stables. I brought one in and got a whole dollar for him. Seriously, a dollar for a damn horse!

[Ziggy_Ivanhoe]

8 minutes ago, tre288 said:

It means you're trying way too hard to make yourself feel better about the title of "serious gamer" because cheats lol

 

One of the most fun things about SA was printing off the lists and just having mindless fun with the game. What does using cheats here have to do with being a "serious gamer"..

 

 

With respect to AmyStone's comments, I think the issue is that they want to use cheats AND then be able to save the game afterwards. Defeats the purpose of Achievements if you are into those and many gamers are hell bent on 100%ing every game. Cheating to get there would be a slap in the face to the people who did it legit. 

[tre288]

17 minutes ago, Marcinguy said:

With respect to AmyStone's comments, I think the issue is that they want to use cheats AND then be able to save the game afterwards. Defeats the purpose of Achievements if you are into those and many gamers are hell bent on 100%ing every game. Cheating to get there would be a slap in the face to the people who did it legit. 

Achievements are turned off once cheats are on anyway.

 

You could save the game in RDR with cheats enabled. You'd just never be able to unlock achievements on that save file again. I don't see the difference.

Edited November 19, 2018 by tre288

[Ziggy_Ivanhoe]

3 minutes ago, tre288 said:

Achievements are turned off once cheats are on anyway.

 

You could save the game in RDR with cheats enabled. You'd just never be able to unlock achievements on that save file again. I don't see the difference.

Never used cheats so I guess I didn't know that it turns off the achievements.  Maybe they are not allowed to turn off achievements completely due to some restriction Sony has imposed. There has to be a reason they prevent you from saving, but honestly I personally could not care less. Just was curious as to the reasoning behind it.

[tre288]

7 minutes ago, Marcinguy said:

Never used cheats so I guess I didn't know that it turns off the achievements.  Maybe they are not allowed to turn off achievements completely due to some restriction Sony has imposed. There has to be a reason they prevent you from saving, but honestly I personally could not care less. Just was curious as to the reasoning behind it.

When you just want to turn it on and half a half hour of mindless fun it's the way to go

[DentureDynamite]

Players should be able to:

 

* Sell back at a loss, or at least permanently ditch, any weapons or equipment we don't want (other than "critical" default items, like the bandanna).

* Save the configuration of our weapon wheel.

* Be able to swim underwater for a limited amount of time (no rebreathers in the game; but breathable reeds could be added at a later point).

 

How these three things got left out amidst all the attention to minutia in this game is pure Rockstar logic.

Edited November 19, 2018 by DentureDynamite

[jje1000]

Given Rockstar's habit of presenting their single-player games as a take-it-or-leave it affair, I guess we'll be waiting until the PC version comes out so modders can fix these things themselves.

[iddqdvie]

they wont change anything anymore. only online from now on.

 

 

my wish:   being able to consume a food/drink item alternativly to picking it up. 

[DentureDynamite]

^^ Judging by their handling of GTA Online, that's (sadly) a pretty accurate statement.

 

Once the Rockstar 'maintenance team' takes over ongoing development, it's pretty much "meh" in regards to hopes of continuation of what's made the game so good at release.

[MaddenedGhost]

4 minutes ago, jje1000 said:

Given Rockstar's habit of presenting their single-player games as a take-it-or-leave it affair, I guess we'll be waiting until the PC version comes out so modders can fix these things themselves.

I know right? it's all about that take-it-or-leave it affair .. it's not like they've introduced the Director Mode into GTAV's single player on consoles a year after their initial release.

 

freakin Rockstar man.

[Ziggy_Ivanhoe]

2 minutes ago, DentureDynamite said:

^^ Judging by their handling of GTA Online, that's (sadly) a pretty accurate statement.

 

Once the Rockstar 'maintenance team' takes over ongoing development, it's pretty much "meh" in regards to hopes of continuation of what's made the game so good at release.

It's funny though because they added in the gun locker at some piont in GTAO which let you finally customize your weapon wheel. It got out of freaking control after a few years trying to sift through all the guns so that was a godsend. It's curious that this is not a feature ind RDR2 though. They could just have a gun locker at the camp. Make it an upgrade or something.

[wagszilla]

I got a f*cking wanted level for "Animal Cruelty" the other day.

 

Are you kidding me with this sh*t?

 

I killed a Turkey with a bow and then another turkey walked directly in front of me as I walked on it.

 

Am I playing a video game or am I playing PETA Simulator 2018? 

[Nolan2018]

I already beat the game, I’m going around collecting everything. It’s just frustrating how long it takes to get to certain places. Original red dead you can set a waypoint from your campfire and go wherever you want.

 

the cheat codes i like to use on another play through and just have fun beating it again

 

 

[Mach1bud]

I honestly don't want any of the things OP suggests other than the house customization deal. But idk cause I'm not at that point in the game yet, I may not even want that either.