RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 - "Chronological" Mission Order

July 20, 2024

19 hours ago, Tkayyy1018 said:

You can’t even walk passed him before Americans at rest or you won’t get the dialogue after AAR, just tested it last night. I do AAR at rest first and when I went passed the stables and downes (tried interacting and not interacting) after the fight he’s not there. I reloaded a save from camp and went the other way passed gun store and went straight to AAR and he was there after the fight. Seems like they changed so you can only get one or the other

There were two Downes interactions, one before AAR and one after AAR. I have more than 4100 hours on this game. From 2018-2024. Two year break from 2022-2024. Just started playing again 2024. Somewhere in my break from playing, R* patched the 2nd Downes Interaction after AAR with one of RD Online Updates. I have Standard Disc version and the digital Ultimate Edition. I cannot get the 2nd Downes Interaction after AAR.

July 21, 2024

16 hours ago, Psycho18 said:

There were two Downes interactions, one before AAR and one after AAR. I have more than 4100 hours on this game. From 2018-2024. Two year break from 2022-2024. Just started playing again 2024. Somewhere in my break from playing, R* patched the 2nd Downes Interaction after AAR with one of RD Online Updates. I have Standard Disc version and the digital Ultimate Edition. I cannot get the 2nd Downes Interaction after AAR.

Brother, that’s great and all but I’m literally playing the game right now and just got the second interaction…you can only get one or the other, not both. If you want the second one you can’t walk past Downes before Americans at rest. Experimented with it just today. I also have thousands of hours over 4-5 playthroughs. Just started this recent one to do 100% completion.

I feel like I remember being able to get both my first second or maybe 3rd but this time around I’ve only been able to get one of the other

Edited July 21, 2024 by Tkayyy1018

July 21, 2024

56 minutes ago, Tkayyy1018 said:

Brother, that’s great and all but I’m literally playing the game right now and just got the second interaction…you can only get one or the other, not both. If you want the second one you can’t walk past Downes before Americans at rest. Experimented with it just today. I also have thousands of hours over 4-5 playthroughs. Just started this recent one to do 100% completion

July 21, 2024

On 7/19/2024 at 1:46 AM, Psycho18 said:

Polite Society before American at Rest, Arthur have to chase Jimmy Brooks before Jimmy Brooks goes to Blackwater to tell the Pinkertons. Dutch and Hosea said keep the noises clean and stay out of trouble. The Dutch Boys suppose to be in hiding in low profile. This is better for storytelling.

Polite Society after American at Rest, The Law saw Arthur beat up Tommy, Arthur killed Odriscolls at Six Point Cabin, Arthur killed Bounty Hunters saving Sean, Arthur Killed Law in Strawberry with Micah. Pinkertons knows the Dutch Boys is close to Valentine. In Polite Society, there is no reason to chase Jimmy Brooks before he rides to Blackwater. Chasing Jimmy Brooks is programed into the mission.

Jimmy Brooks recognises Arthur and is a possible snitch, so there is every reason to chase him down and talk to him/kill him regardless of whether Arthur has committed crimes or not. In fact it is what an outlaw like Arthur would do.

July 21, 2024

5 hours ago, Dan_1983 said:

Jimmy Brooks recognises Arthur and is a possible snitch, so there is every reason to chase him down and talk to him/kill him regardless of whether Arthur has committed crimes or not. In fact it is what an outlaw like Arthur would do.

Talking about him, who the hell recognizes a criminal and shouts to his face that he saw him doing something? I kill him just for being a idiot.

July 21, 2024

I'm currently working on something which might interest everyone here when I get time or I'm bored ha - a video of all of the unique dialogue responses that gang members have to Arthur completing missions in each Chapter.

For example after completing Americans At Rest, when talking to Bill, Arthur says "Bruises don't look so bad". He has unique dialogues with most characters which are triggered after completing certain missions so thought it would be interesting to compile them all. I've got all of the chapter 1 dialogues so far.

July 21, 2024

7 hours ago, Agent Edward said:

Talking about him, who the hell recognizes a criminal and shouts to his face that he saw him doing something? I kill him just for being a idiot.

People with a holier than thou attitude. I have killed him a few times in playthroughs and always thought it might be better as you lose a lot of honour for it and it makes Arthur's redemption a little better going from bad honour to good.

7 hours ago, jimmyoneshot said:

I'm currently working on something which might interest everyone here when I get time or I'm bored ha - a video of all of the unique dialogue responses that gang members have to Arthur completing missions in each Chapter.

For example after completing Americans At Rest, when talking to Bill, Arthur says "Bruises don't look so bad". He has unique dialogues with most characters which are triggered after completing certain missions so thought it would be interesting to compile them all. I've got all of the chapter 1 dialogues so far.

Sounds good mate.

My game has glitched in the past where I've had Chapter 1 post mission dialogue in Chapter 2 haha.

Edited July 21, 2024 by Dan_1983

July 22, 2024

9 minutes ago, Dan_1983 said:

People with a holier than thou attitude. I have killed him a few times in playthroughs and always thought it might be better as you lose a lot of honour for it and it makes Arthur's redemption a little better going from bad honour to good.

Sounds good mate.

My game has glitched in the past where I've had Chapter 1 post mission dialogue in Chapter 2 haha.

That happened to me recently did you reload a save in chapter 1 ? I thought might’ve been the issue. I wasn’t that far into ch2 so I just started a new game, made sure to talk to everyone between missions in chapter 1 and it stopped

July 22, 2024

On 7/18/2024 at 7:46 PM, Psycho18 said:

Polite Society before American at Rest, Arthur have to chase Jimmy Brooks before Jimmy Brooks goes to Blackwater to tell the Pinkertons. Dutch and Hosea said keep the noises clean and stay out of trouble. The Dutch Boys suppose to be in hiding in low profile. This is better for storytelling.

Polite Society after American at Rest, The Law saw Arthur beat up Tommy, Arthur killed Odriscolls at Six Point Cabin, Arthur killed Bounty Hunters saving Sean, Arthur Killed Law in Strawberry with Micah. Pinkertons knows the Dutch Boys is close to Valentine. In Polite Society, there is no reason to chase Jimmy Brooks before he rides to Blackwater. Chasing Jimmy Brooks is programed into the mission.

I'm starting to think polite society should be before Americans at Rest.

Gah I hate my ocd

July 23, 2024

3 hours ago, propanecocaine71 said:

I'm starting to think polite society should be before Americans at Rest.

Gah I hate my ocd

I feel like first time playing its a good first or second mission. Going back thru though it does fit well somewhere in the middle. Both of the leads that come from them going to town don’t happen until late chapter 2 and even into chapter 3. The lip sync at the beginning has me stuck as well. Definitely reasonable I think to do a day or 2 after Sean’s party

July 23, 2024

On 7/22/2024 at 7:33 PM, Tkayyy1018 said:

I feel like first time playing its a good first or second mission. Going back thru though it does fit well somewhere in the middle. Both of the leads that come from them going to town don’t happen until late chapter 2 and even into chapter 3. The lip sync at the beginning has me stuck as well. Definitely reasonable I think to do a day or 2 after Sean’s party

I prefer it as a first mission for chapter 2 but yeah after Sean's party is also a good fit.

Edited July 26, 2024 by propanecocaine71

July 23, 2024

3 hours ago, Tkayyy1018 said:

I feel like first time playing its a good first or second mission. Going back thru though it does fit well somewhere in the middle. Both of the leads that come from them going to town don’t happen until late chapter 2 and even into chapter 3. The lip sync at the beginning has me stuck as well. Definitely reasonable I think to do a day or 2 after Sean’s party

I think it works well as the first mission in Valentine or after Sean's party. Sometimes I do it after arriving back at camp with Hosea after Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego which is the mission I always do after Sean's party. I don't leave it too late in the chapter as Mary-Beth's dialogue about being cooped up for two weeks won't make much sense.

If I do it as the first mission in Valentine, I always follow up with Americans at Rest to kill two birds with one stone. I leave the bounty hunting mission for later on.

My main Chapter 2 starting mission is Who is Not Without Sin as it's a pain in the backside to put anywhere else and it's convenient as it's near camp.

Edited July 23, 2024 by Dan_1983

July 23, 2024

On 7/22/2024 at 1:08 AM, Tkayyy1018 said:

That happened to me recently did you reload a save in chapter 1 ? I thought might’ve been the issue. I wasn’t that far into ch2 so I just started a new game, made sure to talk to everyone between missions in chapter 1 and it stopped

Yes it happened after reloading a save. Updates have f*cked this game up.

July 23, 2024

On 7/22/2024 at 11:24 PM, Dan_1983 said:

I think it works well as the first mission in Valentine or after Sean's party. Sometimes I do it after arriving back at camp with Hosea after Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego which is the mission I always do after Sean's party. I don't leave it too late in the chapter as Mary-Beth's dialogue about being cooped up for two weeks won't make much sense.

If I do it as the first mission in Valentine, I always follow up with Americans at Rest to kill two birds with one stone. I leave the bounty hunting mission for later on.

My main Chapter 2 starting mission is Who is Not Without Sin as it's a pain in the backside to put anywhere else and it's convenient as it's near camp.

I like to do without sin first then after I drop off Swanson in camp immediately follow with polite society, flows nicely into Americans at Rest and serves as a nice intro to Valentine.

Edited July 26, 2024 by propanecocaine71

July 27, 2024

On 7/23/2024 at 6:55 AM, propanecocaine71 said:

I like to do without sin first then after I drop off Swanson in camp immediately follow with polite society, flows nicely into Americans at Rest and serves as a nice intro to Valentine.

Really? I stay in camp and do those two the next day.

July 27, 2024

8 hours ago, Dan_1983 said:

Really? I stay in camp and do those two the next day.

I find it has a nice flow to it. Although it is a bit much for arthur in one day.

July 28, 2024

On 7/21/2024 at 8:45 PM, Dan_1983 said:

People with a holier than thou attitude. I have killed him a few times in playthroughs and always thought it might be better as you lose a lot of honour for it and it makes Arthur's redemption a little better going from bad honour to good.

I also like the description in Strange Man's cabin better when Arthur kills him.

Regarding Arthur turning from dishonorable to honorable, I don't think this should happen only when he finds out that he has tuberculosis and is going to die, becoming good just because you know you will die is just a lame excuse to redeem yourself and get a better ending.

In my opinion Arthur should start becoming honorable right after the mission "Blessed are the Peacemakers", as he goes through a near death experience but he still don't know that he will die later, and also because I like the reference to John's gravestone in 1911.

July 28, 2024

13 hours ago, propanecocaine71 said:

I find it has a nice flow to it. Although it is a bit much for arthur in one day.

Two missions is my limit a day.

5 hours ago, Agent Edward said:

I also like the description in Strange Man's cabin better when Arthur kills him.

Regarding Arthur turning from dishonorable to honorable, I don't think this should happen only when he finds out that he has tuberculosis and is going to die, becoming good just because you know you will die is just a lame excuse to redeem yourself and get a better ending.

In my opinion Arthur should start becoming honorable right after the mission "Blessed are the Peacemakers", as he goes through a near death experience but he still don't know that he will die later, and also because I like the reference to John's gravestone in 1911.

By the time he's diagnosed, he has high in honour in my game. Jimmy Brooks is killed in Chapter 2, Arthur's diagnosis is Chapter 5. Chapter 6 is when I usually stop outlaw activities outside of missions such as robbery and when I start helping people more.

Edited July 28, 2024 by Dan_1983

July 31, 2024

On 7/28/2024 at 4:25 AM, Dan_1983 said:

Two missions is my limit a day.

By the time he's diagnosed, he has high in honour in my game. Jimmy Brooks is killed in Chapter 2, Arthur's diagnosis is Chapter 5. Chapter 6 is when I usually stop outlaw activities outside of missions such as robbery and when I start helping people more.

I usually do outlaw activities up to "Blessed are the Peacemakers", like robbing trains, stagecoaches, etc. But I only kill those who fight back, I may be dishonorable until this point, but I'm not a complete asshole either.

August 1, 2024

21 hours ago, Agent Edward said:

I usually do outlaw activities up to "Blessed are the Peacemakers", like robbing trains, stagecoaches, etc. But I only kill those who fight back, I may be dishonorable until this point, but I'm not a complete asshole either.

I kill those who fight back, those who start shooting or ambush me, or witnesses that never listen. I don't kill innocent people if I can help it. I hate killing horses in ambushes or bounty hunter dogs but it has to be done.

August 1, 2024

5 minutes ago, Dan_1983 said:

I kill those who fight back, those who start shooting or ambush me, or witnesses that never listen. I don't kill innocent people if I can help it. I hate killing horses in ambushes or bounty hunter dogs but it has to be done.

This is basically what I do myself, I always help people in random events too, most of the time we earn something for it.

August 5, 2024

Chapter 5

Dutch (Welcome to the New World)

(Arthur Coughs)

-----------------------------------------------------

Day 1.

Stranger (Savagery Unleashed)
(Arthur Poisoned)
(Arthur Captured)
(Arthur wakes in the night)

Spoiler

Went hunting before Stranger mission.

Study, Hunt, Track (Blue and Yellow Macaw)

Study, Hunt, Track (Scarlet Macaw)
Study, Hunt, Track (Great Green Macaw)
Study, Hunt, Track (Red Footed Booby)
NW path from camp to find snakes. Save. On Map, Arroyo De La.

Study, Hunt, Track ( Rainbow Boa Snake)
Study, Hunt, Track ( Red Boa Snake)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2.

Dutch (A Kind and Benevolent Desent)

(Dutch killed a lady underground)
Dialogue (Helped the Workers)
Dialogue (Go back Saint Denis)
(Arthur is Coughing)
Dialogue (Dutch- Somebody made a plan, to make the gang cause trouble in the past couple weeks)
Dialogue (Arthur, Are you strangled me next, Dutch, I am doing the best as I can)
(Arthur's red eyes)

Dutch (Hell Hath No Fury)
Kill all. Walk.
(Arthur Cough)

Bill (Paradise Mercifully Departed)
Kill all.

Spoiler

Went hunting before meet Dutch.

Study, Hunt, Track (Sunglow Boa Snake)
Study, Hunt, Track ( Fer De Lance Snake)- Sugar cane Fields.

Follow river NW. Find House and goat/pig pen. Climb up on roof.
Guards wont see you. Drop down. Crouch move behind goat pen and guards. Hide in bushes on beach.

Study, track (Green Turtle)

Camp- eat, drink, save.

78. Random Encounter (Soldiers pursued two Escapees)
79. Random Encounter (Guarma Soldiers Trap)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 3-5

Sea Travel

(Arthur Coughs)

Dutch (Dear, Uncle Tacitus)

(Van Horn)
Steal Horse.

(Shady Belle)
Find Letter. Kill all.
Escape.

(Lakay)
Dutch ( Fleeting Joy)

(Bill got followed)
Kill bunch of Pinkertons.
(Arthur Coughs)
Dialogue (Sadie- Meet me in Saint Denis saloon)

---------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6.

(Saint Denis)

Arthur (A Fork in the Road)
(Arthur Coughs)
(Arthur-Passes out)
(Doctor- TB)

Barber- Hair cut- 1-10 length
Face Hair- 2/10 Length.
Save. Arthur's horse disappeared. Stable- get horse. Only time, I retrieve the horse.

Stranger (Of Men and Angels 1-2)

(Arthur got a adrenaline shot from the Doctor)
Dialogue (Arthur- Tells the Sister he is fine)
(Arthur needs time to confess to the sister)
Give Money.
Save.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7

Sadie (Icarus and Friends)
6am
Hot Air Balloon. Fly over prison. Help Sadie escape. Kill All.
Crash- Kill all.
Dialogue (Colm Odrisscoll-captured by government)
Dialogue (Dutch- would not help with Marston)
Dialogue (Sadie-Meet me in Copperhead Landing)
(We need to find a place for the camp)

(Lakay)
Save. 7pm.
(Sadie not in Copperhead Landing yet)

Dutch (That's Murfee Country)

Dialogue (Dutch-Arthur-Charles find a place up NE)
Dialogue (Arthur- agrees to take Charles)
Dialogue (Dutch-Micah and I)
Dialogue (Arthur-wants to save lives)
(Take the Boat)
(Arthur sees skulls on sticks- acting like 1st time been in Lakay)( Been Lakay in Freeroam)
Dialogue (Arthur- Not sure what Dutch wants anymore-Thanks to the bump on head, Death of Hosea, and Micah)

(Butcher Creek)
( Been here in Freeroam)
Dialogue (Arthur-Who are they?- Charles-Locals. Arthur- They don't look friendly.)
(Arthur- acting like the 1st time heard about the Murfees)
(Arthur met the Murfees already-in freeroam)

(Beaver Hollow)
Take Machete. Kill All. Free Lady.

(Annesburg)
Take lady home- Decline money.

(Mrs. Downes)

(Beaver Hollow)
(Molly)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Chapter 6-Beaver Hollow)
Day 1

(Roanoke Ridge)
(Arthur- Acted like he never been here. I been here in Freeroam).

Save.

Travel South.

Stranger (The Wisdom of the Elders)
Dialogue (Arthur-Where?- Old man-Butchers Creek)

Copperhead Landing)
Save.

Sadie (Visting Hours)
(Arthur-went to save John- Dutch don't care anymore).

(Prison)
Kill all. Escape.

(Beaver Hollow)

Spoiler

(Beaver Hollow Cave)
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
336. Locked Box.

(Butcher Creek)
341. Locked Box.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2

(Annesburg)
Save.

Micah (Just a Social Call)

Dialogue (Micah-thinks there is a rat)(Guess who?)
Dialogue (Micah is Dutch's ear in the cutscene)
(Dutch is very messed up)
Dialogue (Dutch-Cornwall is the reason for Hosea's Death and people of Guarma are slaves)
Dialogue (Arthur-went after John, he didn't want him hanged- Dutch, I didn't either)
(Dutch- never thought about rescuing John)
Dialogue (Railroad Contract with Army)

(Death of Cornwall)- Kill all and Escape.

Spoiler

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (5. Artists- Preston T. Stephenson)- on Office desk.
(I don't want John to get the card later- I am here already)

(Deer Cottage)
80. Random Encounter (Feral Man-Wolfman)- Chase him back to cave. Kill wolves.

Save. Cheat code-top drawer. Eat, drink sleep.
Take stuff.

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
6. Rock Carving- NE of Deer Cottage. On map, near N=Roanoke

------------------------------------------------------

Day 3.

Stranger (Widow of Willard's Rest 1)
Take lady home.
Hunt. Save.

Spoiler

(Annesburg)
Item ( Rusted Double Bit Hatchet)

NE Path from Annesburg.

Places of Interest (Old World Scripts)
Item (Shark Tooth Trinket)- Ship Wreckage.

81. Random Encounter (Corpse Hanging-Murfee Ambush)

(Manito Glade)
Stranger (Hermit) -Kill
Item (Rare Shotgun)
Take all.
Item (Torn Treasure Map)
Save.

(Reed Cottage)
Treasure Hunt (Reed Cottage Treasure 1)
Save. Take all.

( Big Lake-River-Willard's Rest)
Fishing- Perch- Bread.
Muskie-Lake Lure.

(Deer Cottage)

Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 4

Spoiler

Legendary Fish Map.
7. Steelhead Trout- Special River Lure. Willard Rest big pool of water.

Save.

(Post office)
Send Mail.

(Annesburg)
Random Encounter (Consequence)
Gunshop: Buy free- Evans Repeater.

(Willard's Rest)
Save.

Legendary Animal Map.
9. Moose- Willard's Rest. Springfield Rifle.

Stranger (Poor Joe in Tree)

Challenge (Herbalist 6- Pick 15 different species of herb)- Finished.

(Elysian Pool Trapper)
Sell Pelt
Buy All: The Stalker Trapper Outfit.
Save. Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 5

Spoiler

Places of Interest (Trail Trees 1-4)- North of Elysian Pool Trapper.

(Elysian Pool)
Save.
Reeds Cottage Treasure. -On Map, R=Kamassa River. On top of waterfall. Find tree with X. 20 steps north-5 steps east. Under small-behind a big rock.

Legendary Fish Map
8. Perch. -Special Lake Lure.

Stranger (Gavin's Friend)- Hogtie him take letter.

(Post Office)
Send/Recieve Mail.
Save.

(Elysian Pool)
Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
7. Rock Carving- Elysian Pool NE ledge.

(Deer Cottage)
Save. West of River and Deer Cottage.

Places of Interest (Old Mine)
Item (Viking Helmet)
Item (Ancient Viking Comb)
Item (Viking Hachet)

Places of Interest (Old Abandoned Trading Post)-Near Train track-west of Brandywine Drop.

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (2. Gems of Beauty- Isabella Barlow)

Take All stuff. Hidden Stash under floor board.

Places of Interest (Meteorite Hole)- SW train tracks and Old Trade post.
Item:( Meteorite 1)

Places of Interest (Meteorite House)- SE train tracks and Old Trade post.
Take all.
Item: (Meteorite 2)

Cigarette Card (3. Gems of Beauty-Hattie Langtry)

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6

(Beaver Hollow)

Save. Talk. Shave-2/10 Length.

Read Letter
Penelope (The Course of True Love 4)

Swanson ( A Rage Unleashed)
Dialogue (Swanson-gave up Morphine)
Dialogue (Dutch- New York)
Dialogue (Dutch- One Final Score-Whole lot of smoke/Commotion)
(Eagle Flies)
Dialogue (Colonel Favours)

(Van Horn Shores)
(Ship)
Kill all.

(Van Horn)
Hotel- Eat, drink, sleep save

Spoiler

(Annesburg)
Save. Find escape Ladder. Into the Mine. Under G=Annesburg on map.
Cigarette Card (4. Gems of Beauty-Isabella Standish)- Large chamber of Mine on table.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7.

Spoiler

Legendary Fish Map.
9. Muskie- Special River Lure.

(Post Office)
Send/Recieve Mail.

(Deer Cottage)
Save, Eat, Feed Horse.

Places of Interest (Fossilized Man)- Above Train Track- West of Old Abandoned Trading Post in Roanoke.
Places of Interest (The Loft)- NE Ambarino.

Take Items. Rest, sleep, Save.

(Arthur is Sick)
(Arthur is Helping Rains Fall/Eagle Flies)

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
1. Dreamcatcher- The Loft.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 8.

Rains Fall (Archeology For Beginners)
Dialogue (Arthur- I think I am Dying. Rains Fall- I hope you find peace)
Dialogue (Rains Fall- you went on a raid with my son)
Dialogue (Colonal Favours- mad about the raid)
Dialogue (Captain Monroe)
Dialogue (Mayor of Saint Denis-Oil Company-Drilling on Reservation)
Dialogue (Dutch)
Dialogue (Arthur's Son)
Dialogue (Arthur's Sickness)

(Burned Indian Camp)
(Army Camp)
Item (Owl Feather Trinket)

(Ocreagh's Run)
Save. 9am
Fishing-
Hamish ( The Veteran 1)

Spoiler

Travel West. Above the N-Ambarino.

(Witches Cauldron)
317. Locked Box. Don't drink the liquid.

(Ocreagh's Run)

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (8. Breeds of Horses-Turkoman) -Behind cabin in shed workbench.

3pm

(Indian Reservation)
Camp-Eat, Sleep, Save.
Fishing-Calumet Ravine.
Perch- Bread.

------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 9

Captain Monroe (Honor Amongst Theives)
Jump on back of wagon.

Spoiler

(Mysterious Hill House)
Pick Ram's Head, English Mace, Hummingbird Sage.

(SW path Fort Wallace)
339. Locked Box. Broken Wagon. (Last one for Arthur)

(Heartland Oil Fields)
Save.
Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (5. Gems of Beauty-Maud Engel) Last Card for Arthur.

(John will Finished Cigarette Card sets -Gunslingers, Artists,Vistas, Gems of Beauty, Flora, Stars of Stage, Amazing Inventions, Horses)
(Next couple cards from each set are in New Austin)

Challenge (Herbalist 6. Pick 15 Different Species of Herbs) -Finished.

(Deer Cottage)
Eat, Drink, Sleep Save.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 10.

Spoiler

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
2. Dreamcatcher- Near River-SW Deer cottage.
3. Dreamcatcher- On path- Between N-E= Annesburg on map.
4. Dreamcatcher- On path, Between U-R= Annesburg on map.
5. Dreamcatcher- Follow path- NE Elysian Pool.
6. Dreamcatcher- Elysian Pool- south shore.

Random Encounter (Murfees Camp Ambush- Man yell pox)

(Lakay)

Save.
Fishing: Lake Sturgeon- Lake Lure

Legendary Fish Map.

10. Longnose Gar-Special Swamp Lure.

(Saint Denis)
(Post Office)
Send Mail.
Saloon- eat, drink, Sleep, Save.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 11.

Sadie (Goodbye, Old Friend)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 12.

(Beaver Hollow)
3pm.
Save. Talk. Eat. Shave 2/10 Length. Sleep.
(Letter From Mary)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 13 .

Trelawny (The Fine Art of Conversation)

(Rains Fall)
(Meet with Army)
(Help Captain Monroe Escape)

(Emerald Ranch)

Dialogue (Arthur-Confess to Sister)
Dialogue (Do a loving act, Help folks)
Dialogue (Sister going to Mexico-RDR1)

Spoiler

(Emerald Ranch)
Fence- Sell $6.00- $300.00 Items.
Craft- Moose Antler Trinket.

(Mattock Pond, Lemoyne)
Save.

Legendary Animal Map
13. Fox.

(Saint Denis Trapper)
Sell pelt.

Buy- The Trophy Buck Trapper Outfit.

Hotel- Eat, Drink, sleep, save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 14.

Penelope Braithwaite (The Course of True Love 5)

Help Beau/Penelope, Kill all. Train. Don't take Brooch.
Dialogue (Mrs. Calhoon is dead-from chapter 3 rally)

(Riggs Station)
Save

(Stilt Shack)
Stranger (The Ties That Bind Us 5)

Camp- Eat, Drink, sleep, Save

Spoiler

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
8. Rock Carving- Flatneck Station.
9. Rock Carving-Mount Shann-Giant Remains.
10. Rock Carving- Owanjilla Lake.

(Post Office-Strawberry)
Send Mail.
Buy 3 Newspapers.

(Black Bone Forest)
Save.
Kill Cougar with Bow.
Challenge (Master Hunter 6- Kill 5 and skin 5 Cougars with Bow)- Finally Finished.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 15.

Path south of Wallace Station.
(Murder Scene 3)
Take note from head.

Stranger (Americans Dreams)-Lucky's Cabin-SW Valentine.
(Arthur gets knock down very quick- weak and sick)

(Valentine-Sheriff)-Night.
(Arthur saves the Sheriff)
(Arthur killed bunch of people in Chapters 2/3)
(This guy been killing folks for the past few years)

Camp- Eat, Sleep, Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 16.

(Post office- Valentine)
Dialogue ( Post master in Valentine- said to Arthur- Can you stop coughing in your sleep, I don't want to get sick, that's all).
Recieve mail.

(Strawberry)
Save.

Francis Sinclair (Geology for Beginners 2)
(Arthur seems to be a little confused- fits better when he is sick)

Spoiler

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

7. Dreamcatcher- Hani's Bethel- NE shack.
6. Dinosaur Bone- NE shack Hani's Bethel

8. Dreamcatcher- Heartland Overflow
9. Dreamcatcher- NW Bluewater Marsh.
10. Dreamcatcher- Across the river from Trapper's Cabin.
11. Dreamcatcher- NW Bluewater Marsh.
12. Dreamcatcher- SE Heartlands.
13. Dreamcatcher- Citadel Rock Train Tracks.
14. Dreamcatcher- on map train tracks- E=New
15. Dreamcatcher- Flatneck Station.
16. Dreamcatcher- Caliban's Seat Dakota River.
17. Dreamcatcher- south side Valentine. Lucky's Cabin.
18. Dreamcatcher -Cattail Pond.
19. Dreamcatcher- S Chez Porter.
20. Dreamcatcher- Cotorro Springs.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 17.

9am

Eagle Flies (Favored Sons)

Dialogue (Colm- Tying loose ends)
Dialogue (We have to save folks)

Camp, Save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 18.

6am.
Charles (King's Son)

(Fort Wallace) -Night

Kill all. Save Eagle Flies. Knives/Arrows.
Escape-use guns.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 19.

Micah (The Delights of Van Horn)
Save.

Charlotte (Widow of Willard's Rest 2)

Spoiler

Save. Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

7. Dinosaur Bone- Elysian Pool. below the top of mountain. On map, Between R-I= Kamassa River.

(Elysian Pool- Cave Waterfall- Reward DreamCatchers-painting)

Item (Ancient Arrowhead)-Follow Tunnel upward. Past the ledges going down to right. Don't go down ledges. Reach a open light cave area. Climb up ledges.

8. Dinosaur Bone- NW of Van Horn. South of Roadside Brothel.

(Van Horn Post Office)
Send Mail.

Use Stratgy Guide map/RDR2map.com
9. Dinosaur Bone -on map between O-A=Roanoke.

10. Dinosaur Bone - West border of Grizzlie East/Roanoke Ridge. On top of hill.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 20.

12am (Dover Hill)

Professor ( A Bright Bouncing Boy 2)

(After planting small poles, climbe ladder up tower. Pull right switch, left switch, middle switch)
(Professor-Flicked the switch. Robot started move, then fell over)
(Professor needs more time)
(It will take 7 years to get it right)
Eat, save.

Hamish (The Veteran 2)- OCreagh's Run.
Legendary Fish- Northern Pike.
Fishing: Northern pike- River Lure.

Spoiler

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
11.Dinosaur Bone- Path south of Fairwale Shanty in Ambarino NE.
12. Dinosaur Bone- Grizzlie East- West of Ocreagh's Run.
Save.

13. Dinosaur Bone- NE Donner Falls. Uphill. On map, Near I=Ambarino.
14. Dinosaur Bone- Bacchus station. On top of hill, sitting on flat rock.
15. Dinosaur Bone- South of Train tracks in Cotorro Spring.

(Last Dinosaur Bone for Arthur, John will get the last 15).

(Valentine)
(Post Office)
Pay bounty.
Send Mail.

83. Random Encounter (Town Robbery)- Hotel 1A-Fight-
Sleep, Save, eat.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 21.

Bacchus Station)
Save.

John (Bridge to Nowhere)

Dialogue (Dutch-Enjoys killing and revenge more than before)
Dialogue ( Dutch to Create more enemies, chaos, and noise)
Dialogue (John- take Jack and Abigail, leave soon)
Dialogue (Arthur-this is over. When time comes, run and don't look back)
Dialogue (Arthur don't believe in loyalty no more)
Dialogue ( Arthur needs a vacation. Dutch has all the money)
Dialogue (Abigail knows where the money is)

(Emerald Ranch)
Recieve mail.
Camp- eat, sleep, save.
(Read Arthur's Journal. Arthur is wishing everyone the best)

Spoiler

Legendary Animal Map
14. Elk- Cumberland Forest- SE of Fort Wallace.

(Elysian Pool Trapper)
Sell Pelt.
Last Trapper Outfit for Arthur- The Ghost Bison.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 22.

(Beaver Hollow)
Save, Shave 2/10 length.

( Cleet and Joe in camp)
(Arthur yells at Cleet, Joe, Micah, and Dutch)
Dialogue (Swanson leave the camp)
Dialogue (Arthur tells Abigail be ready)

Strauss (Money Lending and Other Sins 6)

(Money Lending and Other Sins- J John Weathers)-Help and don't take money.

Edith Downes (Do not Seek Absolution 1)- Part of Money Lending. Have to wait for the 2nd one.

(Money Lending and Other Sins-Arthur Londonderry) -Give money. Talk to the Foreman again.

Dialogue (Foreman- Arthur is dead. You cannot beat it out of him now, can you. Laughing.)

(Money Lending and Other Sins 7)- Kick Strauss out of Camp.

(Beaver Hollow)
Dialogue (Bill- Do you think Dutch lost is mind)
Dialogue (Bill-Micah said, Arthur talking bad about Dutch)
Dialogue (Dutch- why did you change on me, Arthur)
Dialogue (Dutch- I gave everything I had- to all of you)
Dialogue (Bill- who is the rat)
Dialogue (Bill- Why are you causing trouble , Arthur. Arthur said, Micah and Dutch).
Dialogue (Javier- Arthur is breaking Dutch's heart. Fool in Dutch's ear)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 23.

(Butcher Creek)

Obediah (The Wisdom of the Elders 2) -12am
Obediah (The Wisdom of the Elders 3) -Already in the area.
Obediah (The Wisdom of the Elders 4)

(Ocreagh's Run)
Save.
Hamish (The Veteran 3)- Last Visit.
Hunting- Clock fast forward to 8pm

(Beaver Hollow)

Save. Sleep.

Spoiler

(No more hunting, fishing, and collecting for Arthur)

(John will finish Challenges- Gambler 5/10, Herbalist 6/10, Horseman 5/10, Master Hunter 6/10, Sharpshooter 7/10, Survalist 5/10, Weapons Expert 5/10)

84. Random Encounter (Murfees attacked a wagon-on the path)-Free woman and take home.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 24.

Dialogue (Susan- very odd for Cleet/Joe here- Dutch is fine with it)

(Annesburg)
Edith Downes (Do not Seek Absolution 2)

(Willard's Rest)
Charlotte (Widow at Willard's Rest 3)

(Beaver Hollow)
Save. 12pm

Sadie (Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow 1)
Camp out overnight.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 25.

(Hanging Dog Ranch)

Sadie (Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow 2)
Weapon ( Litchfield Repeater)
Kill All.
(Cannot take trains after mission)

(Beaver Hollow)
Save.

Dutch (My Last Boy)

(Cornwall Kerosene & Tar)
(Micah, Joe, and Cleet not riding to help)
(Dutch want to rob the place)
(Dutch didn't help Arthur)

(Wap. Reservation)
(Death of Eagle Flies)
(Charles is staying)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 26.

Arthur coughing attack)
(German people from end of chapter 2)

(Annesburg)
Save.

(Beaver Hollow)
Save.

Dutch (Our Best Selves)

(Arthur- insists on letting Women, Jack and John leave).
(Train Robbery)
(John get shot and left behind)

Arthur (Red Dead Redemption)

(Van Horn)

Protect Sadie. Kill All.

(Kill Agent Milten)-Save Abigail.

Escape.

(Beaver Hollow)

(Arthur's Last Ride)

Escape cave. Help John. Kill All.

(Death of Arthur's Horse)

(Fight Micah).

Edited August 5, 2024 by Psycho18

August 6, 2024

On 7/21/2024 at 11:20 AM, jimmyoneshot said:

I'm currently working on something which might interest everyone here when I get time or I'm bored ha - a video of all of the unique dialogue responses that gang members have to Arthur completing missions in each Chapter.

For example after completing Americans At Rest, when talking to Bill, Arthur says "Bruises don't look so bad". He has unique dialogues with most characters which are triggered after completing certain missions so thought it would be interesting to compile them all. I've got all of the chapter 1 dialogues so far.

You know I'm interested. I love all of your videos so far.

September 24, 2024

On 11/3/2023 at 4:38 PM, jimmyoneshot said:

Maybe even set up a new thread at some point for an RDR1 chronological order considering there will probably be a few people playing it again now ha.

There's an open thread in the RDR1 section if you guys are interested. Like @AudaxTenebra said we figured out a rough mission order a while ago, but it's definitely not perfect, and lately we've been updating the list again. It'd be great to have more people involved, especially now with a PC release coming up.

September 25, 2024

It took a while to finish the Epilogue. I Got Bored. It was a Long Game.

I got Burnt out. I need a break. I Might play the game again in a couple years.

Epilogue

Some Years Later)1907

John (The Wheel)
(Strawberry)
Delivery.

(Pronghorn Ranch)
(Laramie Gang)

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2
6:30am
Tom Dickens (Simple Pleasures)
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 3.
David Geddes (Fatherhood for Beginners)

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 4
Tom Dickens (Farming for Beginners)
John (Old Habits)
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 5.
12am
David Geddes (Jim Milton, Rides Again?)
(Hanging Dog Ranch)
---------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6
Abigail (Fatherhood for Idiots)
(Strawberry)
(Post Office)

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7.
John (Motherhood)
(Telegram- Sadie Adler)(Valentine)
--------------------------------------------------------------------

(Few Months Later)
Talk Geddes.
-------------------------------------------------------------------

Spoiler

(Hunting) (8 Trapper Outfits-started)
(Cattail pond, Black Bone Forest, Owanjilla Lake, Diablo Ridge,Riggs Station, Dakota River)

Boars-5, Beavers-4, Rams-2, Wolf-1, Snakes-4, Rabbit-1, Foxes-2, Muskrat-2, Coyote-1, Pronghorn-2, Deer-1, Buck-1, Elk-1, Turkey-2, Eagles-4,

Study,Hunt,Track,(Seirra Nevada Bighorn Ram)
Study,Hunt,Track (Seirra Nevada Bighorn Sheep)

Random Encounter (Laramie Wagon Hold-up)
Random Encounter (Laramie Road Ambush)
Random Encounter (Laramie- Gang Encounter)

(Black Bone Forest/Riggs Station Trapper)

Sell Pelts.
Camp-Eat,Sleep, Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2-4

Continue Hunting.

Spoiler

Day 2-4

(Cumberland Forest-Six Point Cabin)

Save.
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Random Encounter (Young man skipping rocks- Dakota River)(Arthur ruined his life).

16. Dinosaur Bone.
17. Dinosaur Bone- NW from Valentine. On map, Under D= Dakota River. North shore.
18. Dinosaur Bone- NW from Valentine. South shore of Dakota River.
19. Dinosaur Bone- Dakota River Trail- SW of Downes Ranch.
20. Dinosaur Bone- Small cave- NW Wallace Station.
21. Dinosaur Bone- On map, Between W and E = West Elizabeth in Big Valley.
22. Dinosaur Bone- Big Valley- SE of Mount Shann.
(No more Bones in New Hanover and West Elizabeth)

(Blackwater)
(Post Office)

Send mail.
Save. Sleep for the night.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 5.

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (4. Artists- Aldous Bramley )- South side of Blackwater. On Front Porch of house.
Cigarette Card (6. Artists- Evelyn Miller)- NW side of Blackwater. House. clotheline on table.
Cigarette Card (3. Vistas- Blackwater)- NW of Blackwater. Behind theater.Climb ladder to roof.
Cigarette Card (6. Gems of Beauty- Sadie Russell)- Southside Blackwater. Barrel inside Chicken Coop.

709. Special Tonic/Aged Pirate Rum- SW Blackwater windmill.
Buy- Newspapers

Ansel Atherton (The Landowning Classes)
Ansel Atherton (Home of the Gentry)

(Beechers Hope)

(Blackwater)
(Uncle)

(Beechers Hope)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6.

(Armadillo)

Spoiler

Stranger (Sun Worshiper)- Hennigan's Stead. On map, above the A=Stead. Finally, found him. Always started raining.
Stranger (Tree House Man)- South from Sun Worshiper. On map, Under E=Stead.
Stranger (Armadillo Town Crier)(Cholera)

Random Encounter (Del Labo Gang Road Ambush)
Random Encounter (Del Labo Gang Jail Breakout)(The Sheriff is resigning)
Random Encounter (Fleeing Family- Armadillo)

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (7. Gunslingers-Landen Ricketts) SE side of town. On Barrel.
Cigarette Card (4. Vista-Armadillo)-NW Pig Pen on Barrel.
Cigarette Card (9. Horses-Hungarian Halfbred)- North side. Armadillo. Inside Blacksmith.

(Blackwater)
Save.

Cigarette Card (8. Gunslingers- Black Belle )- NE Pier on Barrel.

(Flatneck Station)
Save.

Random Encounter (Laramie Gang Hostage)- Lone Mule Stead.

Cigarette Card (5. Vistas- Rio Bravo )- Top of yellow windmill.

(Beechers Hope)
Camp- eat, sleep, save

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7

Dialogue (Sadie in Valentine)

(Lake Don Julio)
Save.

( Ventor's Place Shack)

Spoiler

Cigarette Card (6. Vistas-The Grizzlies)- Table inside shack.

(Tumbleweed)
Save.

Cigarette Card (9.Gunslingers-Bily Midnight)- Windmill. SE side.
Cigarette Card (8.Flora-Desert Fan Palm)- Front porch of House. West side.
Cigarette Card (3. Stars of the Stage-Jesse Raymond)- Inside burned out house. North side.

(Strawberry)
Save.

Random Encounter (Fake Doctor)

Cigarette Card (9.Flora-Coastal Redwood)- SE side. Back porch of house.

(Small Camp) Uphill.
South of Little Creek River.

Take All. Save.

349. Locked Box.

Pick- 30 Burdock Root- Little Creek River.

Camp-Eat, Sleep, Save.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 8

Spoiler

(Hanging Dog Ranch)
Kill All.

337. Locked Box- House 2nd floor bunk beds.

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (7. Gems of Beauty-Geraldine Emerson)- Barn upper floor.
Cigarette Card (4. Stars of the Stage-Augusta Tremlow)- Windmill
Cigarette Card (3. Amazing Invention-Electrical Execution Apparatus 1888-H.P Brown A. Kennelly)-Upper floor bunkbeds house.

745. Special Tonic/-Valerian Root-Upper Barn.

Kill- 1 Bull. Lasso and Knife.

(Black Bone Forest Trapper)
Sell Pelt.

(Blackwater)
Save.
Random Encounter (Skinners Road Ambush)

Cigarette Card (4. Amazing Inventions-Typewriter 1829- W.A. Burt)- Barrel at warehouse door.

(Downes Ranch)
Save.

Cigarette Card (10. Horses- Mustang)- Upper floor of Barn.

Kill Pig- Lasso/Knife.
Camp-Eat, Sleep, Save

----------------------------------------------------------

Day 9.

Spoiler

Mount Hagen)
Save.

(Shack- Millisani Claim Mine)
Take all.

739. Special Tonic/ Ginsing Elixer.
373. Locked Box

Cigarette Card (8. Gems of Beauty-Agnes Guyon)- Inside shack.

(Horseshoe Overlook)
Save.

Place of Interest (Brush Fire)
352. Locked Box.

Hunt- 1 Muskrat.

Pick 30 Yarrow- Horseshoe Overlook.

Camp-Eat,drink, sleep, Save.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 10.

Dialogue (Mary-Beth-Train Station)-Item/Book.

Sadie ( Gainful Employment)

Spoiler

Challenge (Survivalist 6- Kill an Animal scavenging 5 times)- Started.

(Valentine)
Save.

Strawberry)
Save.

(General Store)
Buy-Food, Horse, Meds, Booze.

Bounty ( Bart Cavanaugh)

Hotel- Eat, Sleep, Save.
Clothes- Equip/On Horse-Winter Cowboy, The Cowboy, The Homesteader.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 11.

Spoiler

Challenge (Horseman 6- Ride from Strawberry to Saint Denis in under 9 mins without touching water- Use Train Tracks)- Finished.

(Saint Denis)
Save.

Check Memorial House- NW side. Read Plaque-Arthur Morgan.
Show- NW side.

(Tilly not here yet in Saint Denis)

Exotics list 4- (30 Spoonbill Plumes, 5 Night Scented Orchids, 10 Rat tail Orchids, 5 Spider Orchids)

(Bayou NWA)

Random Encounter (Hanging Body-Night Folk Ambush)

Camp-Eat, Sleep, Save.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 12.

Spoiler

Exotics list 4
137. Study, Track, Hunt (Southern Copperhead Snake)

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

(Canebreak Manor)
Cigarette Card (10. Gunslingers-Emmit Granger)- inside on table. Take all.

(Fort Bennard)
Cigarette Card ( 7. Vistas- San Franciso)- SE tower windowsill.

(Van Horn Mansion)
Cigarette Card ( 7. Artists-Slick Hutton)- NE Balcony.

Pick (30 Golden Currants)

(Van Horn)
Save.

Challenge (Gambler 6- Beat the Blackjack Dealer in every Location)( Van Horn and Rhodes)

Cigarette Card ( 9. Gem of Beauty-Jennie Willetts)- Barrel in yard opposite of post office.

Legendary Animal Map
10. Beaver- Butcher's Creek. Springfield Rifle. 138-Compendium

(Elysian Pool Trapper)

Sell Pelts
Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Random Encounter (Murfees Camp Ambush)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 13.

Spoiler

(Annesburg)
Save.

Dialogue (Eagle Flies)- Train Station.
Stranger (Dr. Macintosh)
Buy- Newspaper.

Cigarette Card (5. Inventions-Revolver, 1836-Daniel Buck)- Terrace behind blacksmith.

(Willard's Rest)
Dialogue (Charlotte)- Take from house.
Save.
Cigarette Card (6. Inventions- Telegraph-1837- Samuel Morse)- On Bench on Abandoned Railway Platform.

(Saint Denis)
Save.

Cigarette Card (11. Gunslingers-Jim Boy Calloway)- Cementary, inside mausoleum with stained glass west of central dome.
Cigarette Card (8. Artists-Laurence Carson)- On Map, S=Denis. In NE Alley behind wooden wall.
Cigarette Card (10. Gems of Beauty-llga Ulmer)- On Map, Between E-N= Denis. Alley old desk.
Save.

Show- NW.

Cigarette Card (5. Stars of Stage-Mabel Potter)- West hall near Fireplace.
Cigarette Card (6. Stars of Stage-Robin Konisky)- On Stage, after see all shows.
Sleep, Save, eat, drink.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 14.

Spoiler

Exotics list 4.
(5 Night Scented Orchids)- Bolger Glade.

(Rhodes)
Save.

Dialogue (Pearson General Store)
Stranger (Joe Butler)
Buy-Newspaper.

Challenge (Gambler 6- Beat the Blackjack Dealer in every Location)( Van Horn and Rhodes)- Finished.
Cigarette Card (11. Horses-Thoroughbred)- Back of wagon of hay.

(Catfish Jackson)
Save. Finally. Nobody is home in chapters 4-6 with Arthur.
Robbery- Nate is Drunk. Take all.

Cigarette Card ( 12. Horses-Missouri Fox Trotter)- Boy's Bedroom.

(Rhodes)
Post Office- Send The Breed of Horses Cigarette Card set.

Save. eat. Drink, Sleep.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 15.

Spoiler

(Rhodes)
Post office : Recieve Mail.

Bounty: Robbie Laidlaw.

(Kamassa River- Near Bayall Edge)
Save.

Places of Interests (Painting in the Cabin)

Exotics List 4: (5 Spider Orchids, 30 Spoonbill plumes)

(Hill Haven Ranch)
Night Kill 2 Cows.

(Saint Denis Trapper)
Sell Pelts.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 16.

Spoiler

Exotics List 4 (30 Spoonbill Plumes)

Algernon Wasp (Duchesses and Other Animals 5)

Exotics List 5 ( 5 Clamshell Orchids, 5 Dragon Mouth Orchids, 5 Queen Orchids, 10 Sparrows Egg Orchids).

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 17.

Spoiler

Exotics List 5 (5 Clamshell Orchids)

(Caliga Hall)
Save.

Places of Interest (Grey's Secret)- Start SW corner. Stealth. Night.

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (7. Inventions- Manned Glider-1893- Charles Kinnear)- Barn workbench.
Cigarette Card (10. Flora-Horse Crippler Cactus)- Workbench under lean to.

Camp- Eat, Sleep, save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 18.

Spoiler

(Shady Belle)
Kill All.

Cigarette Card (8. Inventions-Dynamite-1866- Alfred Nobel)- back porch.

Save/Reload-Ghost Dialogue

(House Boat-Blue Water Marsh)

Cigarette Card (9. Artists- Miss Maud Delancey)
Place of Interest (Phonograph)

Save.

Exotic List 5 ( 5 Queens Orchids)- in Ground.
Save.

Legendary Animal Map.
11. Boar. (139. Compendium).

(Saint Denis Trapper)
Sell Pelt.
Save.

Find a Boat. Copperhead Landing.
(Prison)

Legendary Fish Map.
11. Bullhead Catfish- Special River Lure.

(Post office)

Send Mail.
Sleep, Save, Eat, Drink.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 19.

Spoiler

(Saint Denis)
Legendary Fish Map
12. Lake Sturgeon- Special River Lure.

(Post Office)
Send Mail.

(Ringneck Creek/Face Rock)
Legendary Animal Map.

12. Coyote. (140. Compendium)

(Old Greenbank Mill)

752. Special Tonic/Valerian Root.
343. Locked Box.

730. Special Tonic/Ginsing Elixer- SW of Face Rock. On Rail Tracks. Water Tower.

(Ringneck Creek)
Save.

342. Locked Box- Small stone wall. North of Graveyard.

(Eris Fields)
370. Locked Box- Small Shack on train tracks NE of Eris Field. On Map, M=Lemoyne.

(Mattock Pond)
347. Locked Box- Tree Stump east of Pond. Halfway up to Hill Haven Ranch.

(Maccombs End)
Save.
344. Locked Box- East Shack.

(Saint Denis Trapper)
Sell pelt.
Save. Eat, Drink, Sleep.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 20.

Spoiler

(Lagras)
Legendary Alligator. (141. Compendium)

(Elysian Pool Trapper)
Save.
Sell pelt.

(Elysian Pool)
Save.

348. Locked Box- Lone Chimney south of Elysian Pool.

(Van Horn)
Save.

Challenge (Gambler 7- Win Five Finger Fillet in Van Horn, Valentine and Strawberry).

(Roanoke Ridge-North of Annesburg)
Save.

Exotics List 5 (10 Sparrow Eggs Orchids)- On Ground.
Camp- Eat, Drink, sleep, save.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 21.

Spoiler

Fast travel to Lagras.
Save.

(Hunting Request)
142. Study, Hunt, Track (American Bullfrog)- Small Game Arrows.
143. Study, Hunt, Track (Western Toad)- Small Game Arrows.

(Dakota River-Horseshoe Overlook)
Save.

Hunt Songbird and Sparrows. Small Game Arrows.

(Riggs Station)(Black Bone Forest)

Hunt Skunk. Varmint Rifle. It took a long time to hunt. Alot of reloading.
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 22.

Hunting Request Continue.
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 23.

Hunting Request Continue.

Spoiler

Challenge (Master Hunter 7-Use Bait and kill predator and herbivore)- Finished.
Challenge (Survivalist 6- kill animal scavenging a corpse 5 times)- Finished.

(Strawberry)

(Post office)
Send Mail. Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 24.

Spoiler

Challenge (Gambler 7- Win Five Finger Fillet in Van Horn, Valentine and Strawberry).

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

(Flatneck Station)
Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (8. Vistas-Tall Trees)- Back of Station on Barrel.

Challenge (Master Hunter 8- Catch 3 Fish without Fishing Rod)- Finished.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Challenge (Herbalist 7- Craft and use 5 Special Miracle Tonic)- Finished.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 25.

Spoiler

Challenge (Survivalist 7- kill 8 small game with consecutive shots using small game arrows)-Finished.

(Riggs Station)

Challenge (Master Hunter 9- Kill a Opossum playing possum)- Finished.

Camp-Eat, drink, sleep, save.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 26.

Spoiler

Challenge (Survivalist 8- Craft Homing Tomahawk, Improved Tomahawk, Volatile Dynamite, Volatile Fire Bottle)- Finished.
Challenge (Horseman 7-Kill 7 enemies from horseback without dismount)- Finished.
Challenge (Horseman 8- Kill 9 predators from horseback)- Finished.

(Valentine)
Eat, drink, Sleep, save.

John's turn (Fight Jon in Saloon)- Take hat.

(Chadwick Farm)
Night- Kill 3 sheep.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 27.

Spoiler

Shave- 3/10 length.

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarete Card (9. Inventions-Cylinder Phonograph-1877-Thomas Edison)- In saloon, window sill.
Cigarette Card (7. Stars of the Stage-Isadore Reid)- by a tree, back of wagon.
Cigarette Card (9. Vistas-Valentine)- Train Station inside table.
Cigarette Card (11.Gems of Beauty-Fay Delaro)- Upper floor of barn.

(Chadwick Farms)
Cigarette Card (10. Artists-Charles Chatenay)- Front porch table.

(Valentine)
Save.

Dialogue (Sheriff-I said it for years- you don't send saints to catch sinners)
(Benedict Allbright still in jail, 8 years later)
(Arthur needs to catch Ms. Swann, makes more sense)

Bounty (Elle Anne Swann)
(Cumberland Falls)- Take all.

(Valentine)
Save.

Jail (Benedict Allbright gone)

(Twin Stack Pass)
355. Locked Box- Under wagon.
726. Special tonic/Ginsing Elixer.

(Heartland Overflow)
Hunt Bison

(Trapper)
Sell Pelts.
Buy-(Bounty Hunter Trapper outfit)

(Chadwick Farms)
Hunt Sheep.

(Valentine)
Challenge (Gambler 7- Win Five Finger Fillet in Valentine, Van Horn, Strawberry)- Finished.

Stranger (Mickey)

(Riggs Station Trapper)

Random Encounter (Rally Dispute)

Sell pelt.
Sleep, Save, Eat

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 28.

Beecher's Hope)
Save, Eat. Drink.

Uncle (Bare Knuckle Friendships)

(Saint Denis)
NE Saloon.
(Alley)

Bet all on Charles. Lone wolf.
Dialogue (Talk about Arthur)
Dialogue ( All the Trouble the gang had is Micah's Fault from Chapters 1-6)
Dialogue (John- If had to come back to Saint Denis, Remind me I hate Saint Denis).
(John, has to come back later- not finish collecting yet)
Escape.

(Beecher's Hope)
Save.

Spoiler

(Macfarlane's Ranch)
Save. Talk to people.

Challenge (Sharpshooter 8- Disarm 3 enemies without reloading or switching weapons)( Use Poison Arrows)- Finished.

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (9. Stars of the Stage-Irene Grubb)- Train station platform.

721. Special Tonic/ Aged pirate Rum- Blacksmith workshop.
365. Locked Box- Blacksmith workshop.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 29.

Uncle (Home Improvements for Beginners)
Save.

Random Encounter (Skinners-Road Ambush)

(Blackwater)
Sadie (An Honest Day's Labors)
Dialogue (Dutch and Micah)

(Blackwater)
Save. Eat, Sleep.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 30.

Albert Cakes (The Tool Box)

Kill Skinner Brothers.

(Manzanita Post)
(Beecher Hope)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 31-66

Uncle (A New Jerusalem)
(House Building)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Days 67-68
(John's Beard/hair is long again)

Save.

Uncle (A Quick Favor for a Old Friend)
(Blackwater)(Painted Sky)(Rhodes)
Dialogue (John says he met the Tumbleweed Sheriff before, I never did) (Need to go to Tumbleweed before this)
(Rhodes jail cell wall get blown up)(I am glad, I did the bounties early)

(Dewberry Creek)
(Beechers Hope)
Save, Eat, Sleep.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 69.

Spoiler

(Beechers Hope)
Fast travel Strawberry.
Save.

(Vetter's Cabin)
Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (11. Flora-Blazing Star) Front porch railing.

(Hanging Dog Ranch)
Save.
Cigarette Card (12. Gunslingers-Bart Love)- Inside house 1st floor couch.

Hunt Cows

(Valentine)
Save.
Saloon- Eat, Drink, Shave 3/10 length, Hair cut- 4/7 length.

(Post office)
Pay Bounty.
Send Cigarette Card Set-Famous Gunslingers/Outlaws

(Chadwick Farms)
Hunt Sheep.

Cigarette Cards (9. Stars of the Stage-Nettie Palmer)- show tent.
See Show.

(Bacchus Station)
Save.

Cigarette Card (12. Gems of Beauty- Pauline Henderson)- Platform north end.

(Emerald Ranch)
Save.

(Post Office)
Send Cigarette Card Set- Gems of Beauty.
Recieve Mail.
Cigarette Card (10. Vistas-Chicago)- Windmill.

Random Encounter (Lost Dog) -under the windmill or wagon.

(Elysian Pool Trapper)
Save.
Sell Pelts.

(Gutherie Farms)
Hunt Ox.
Save.
Cigarette Card (11. Artists-George Dixie)- inside house. Bed.

(Elysian Pool Trapper)
Save.
Sell Pelts.
Buy- (The Bronco Buster Trapper Outfit)

Camp- Eat, drink, sleep, save.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 70.

Spoiler

(Emerald Ranch-Post Office)
Receive Mail.

(Fence)
Sell - Jewelry Bags, Gold nuggets.
Craft- Beaver Tooth Trinket, Coyote Fang Trinket, Elk Antler Trinket, Fox Claw Trinket, Alligator Tooth Trinket, Boar Tusk Talisman,

(Compson Stead)
Save.
Cigarette Card (10. Stars of the Stage- Jim Cobb)- Front porch.

(Larned Sod)
Save. Hogtie man.
Hunt 2 goats.

(House)
Take all.
Cigarette Card (11. Stars of the Stage-Mittie Cornstock )- Barrel near door.
744. Special Tonic/Valerian Root.

(Gutherie Farms)
Hunt Ox.
Save.

(Elysian Pool Trapper)
Save. Sell pelts.

(Rhodes)
Save. Eat, Drink.

Blackjack. Save win/Reload lose 5x- See face cards, leave table and sit down.
Challenge (Gambler 8- Win 3 hands of Blackjack with 3 hits or more)- Finished.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 71.

(At this point of my playthrough. I got bored. Stop playing for a while).

Spoiler

Day 71.
Took all night to play Blackjack.
Save.

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (12. Stars of the Stage-Robert Elliot Patchen)- Yellow hut crate N of Rhodes Caravan. Fence.

(Rhodes Post Office)
Send Cigarette Card Set- Stars of the Stage.

(North of Rhodes Sheriff Office)
(House)
Item: Abalone Shell Fragment.

(Rhodes)
Save.

Cigarette Card (11. Vistas-Rhodes)- Gravestone Cemetary.

Talk to Pearson.

(Bolger Glade)
Save.

Challenge (Master Hunter 10- Find and Kill the Legendary Panther Giaguaro)- 144-Compendium.

Cross water to big island.
Kill 3 Iguana.
Camp-eat, drink, Sleep, save.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 72.

Spoiler

(Saint Denis Trapper)
Sell Pelts.

(Fence)
Craft- Bison Horn Talisman.
Craft- Panther Eye Trinket.

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.
Send Cigarette Card Set- Artists.
Save.

Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (12. Artists-Richard McCullough)- North Saint Denis, on table SE Gazebo.

Cigarette Card (10. Inventions-Player Piano, 1829-Edward Leveaux)- NW Saloon. On Piano.

Dialogue (Tilly) - Between Saint and Denis.

Bounty (Anthony Foreman)
Save.

(Van Horn)
Save.

Challenge (Sharpshooter 9- Shoot 3 people's hats off with the same dead eye)- Finished.

(Annesburg)
Save.

(Post Office)
Recieve mail.
Send Cigarette Card Set- Vistas.

Cigarette Card (12. Vistas-Annesburg)- Mine car Tracks crates.

(Reed Cottage)
eat, drink, Sleep, save

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 73.

Spoiler

Dover Hill)
Check Professor. Take All.
Cigarette Card (11. Amazing Inventions-Electric Light Bulb, 1878-Thomas Edison)- Crates outside back door.

(Railway Tracks South of the Loft NE Arbarino)

749. Special Tonic/Valerian Root- Wooden shack on crate.

(O'Creagh's Run)

Random Encounter (Road Ambush)

Save.

Hamish (The Veteran 4)
Take Saddle off Rachel, place Saddle Buell. Take Hat.

(Stable) (Van Horn)

Take Buell. Leave Rachel.

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

(Grizzlie East)
Save.

374. Locked Box- Small ledge beneath peak. On map, Above 1st I = Grizzlies East.
767. Special Tonic/Aged Pirate Rum.

(Bird's Nest Gems) -On map, Between 1st I and 1st Z= Grizzlies East.
Item- Ammolite and Flourite Gems. Set up camp near nest.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 74.

Spoiler

Point of Interest (Meditating Monk) -On Map, Between G and R =Grizzlies East.
Save.

Exotics List (5 Dragon Mouth Orchids) -Grizzlies East. On Ground.

Save.

Points of Interest (Face in Cliff)- North of Moonstone Pond.

345. Locked Box- Face in Cliff.

(Moonstone Pond)
Save.

Item - (Hewing Hatchet)

356. Locked Box.

Camp-eat, drink, save sleep

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 75.

Spoiler

Hanis Brothel)
346. Locked Box.

(Small Shack)
NE Emerald Ranch.

354. Locked Box.

(Elysian Pool)
Save. Cave. Run in and out of the cave.

145. Study, Track, Hunt (Little Brown Bat)

Hunting Request (Bat, Blue Jay, Crow, Beaver, Cedar Waxwing Bird)

(Riggs Station, Upper Montana, Owanjila Lake, Dakota River, Fort Riggs)

Camp-eat, drink, sleep.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 76.

Spoiler

Save.
(Post Office)
Send Mail.

(Saint Denis)
Save.

Algernon Wasp (Duchesses and Other Animals 6)
Take gun, hat.

(Emerald Ranch)
Save. Make sure only one player.
If pick 5 or more tiles from table. Exit game and play again.
This took forever- John is lucky he didn't die, from playing dominos.
Play high tiles 1st. Use Doubles 1st.

Challenge (Gambler 9- Win 3 games of Dominos in a row)- Finished.

(Ringneck Creek, Kamassa River)
Pick Oleander Sage.

(Pleasance)
Cigarette Card (12. Inventions-Fountain Pen; 1884-Lewis Waterman)- inside derelect schoolhouse.

(Post Office)
Save.
Send and Recieve Mail.

(Radleys Pasture)
Save.

Legendary Fish Map.
13. Blue Gill- Special Lake Lure.

(Post Office)
Send/Recieve Mail.

Camp:

Challenge (Herbalist 8- Use Oleander to craft 8 poison weapons)- Finished.

(Fence)
Sell items.
Buy- Snake oil, Gun oil, Dynamite.

Save.

Challenge (Herbalist 9- Pick one of each species of herb-43 count)
1. Radley's Pasture- Indian Tobacco, Wild Carrot, Burdock Root, Common Bulrush,
2. Radley's House - Yarrow, Oregano, Huckleberry.
3. Bolger Glade- Night Scented Orchid, American Ginsing, Hummingbird Sage, Chantelle Mushrooms,
4. Shady Belle- Ghost Orchid, Clamshell Orchid, Oleander Sage, Wild Mint, Milkweed,
5. Caliga Hall- Lady of the Night Orchid.

Camp- Eat, Sleep, Save.
Craft- Dynamite Volatile.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 77.

Spoiler

6. Bayou NWA- Vanilla Flower, Rat Tail Orchid, Cigar Orchid, Queen's Orchid, Acuna's Star Orchid, Spider Orchid.
7. Fort Brennard- Golden Current, Moccasin Flower Orchid,
8. Annesburg- Sparrow's Egg Orchid,
9. Roanoke Valley- Ram's Head, Voilet Snowdrop, Wintergreen Berry,
10. Grizzlies East- English Mace, Parsol Mushrooms, Dragon's Mouth Orchid,
11. Citadel Rock- Raspberry, Thyme,

(Valentine)
Save. Buy Horse Medicine.

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

Save, Sleep, Eat, Drink.
Barber- shave-3/10 Length, Hair Length- 3/7

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 78.

Spoiler

(Painted Sky)
12. Painted Sky- Blackberry

353. Locked Box- west side of house under garden shelves.

13. Path north of Dakota River- South of Downes Ranch - Bay Bolete Mushrooms.

(Flatneck Station)
Save.

Challenge (Gambler 10- Win 3 pokers hands in a row) -Finished. Go all in on every hand.

(Caliban's Seat)
Find very high point.

Challege (Sharpshooter 10- Kill 3 flying birds with 3 consecutive shots)- Finished Use Rare Rolling Block rifle.

(Emerald Ranch)
146. Study, Hunt, Pluck ( Chinese Ringed Necked Pheasent)
Hunt Hawk, Eagle.

Night.

147. Study, Hunt,Pluck ( Great Horn Owl)

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Challege (Survivalist 8- Craft Homing Tomahawk, Improved Tomahawk, Volatile Dynamite, Volatile Fire bottle)- Finished.

(Owanjilla Lake)
Hunt Eagles and Hawks.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 79.

Spoiler

Kamassa River-NW Lagras)
Used Special Swamp Lure-Night.
Save.

Challenge (Survivalist 9- Catch a fish that weigh at least 19lbs-Catfish) -Finished.

Stranger (A Fine Night for it)

Camp Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.
Random Encounter (Woman in White Trap- Bayou-Night Folk).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 80.

Spoiler

Challenge (Survivalist 10- Catch one of each type of Fish)-Finished.

(I got fishes in wrong places-wrong bait)

Lagras- Lake Sturgeon, Catfish.
Lakay- Longnose Gar.
Siska Island - Bullhead Catfish, Blue Gill,
Ringneck Creek- Smallmouth Bass, Chain Pickeral,
O'Creagh's Run- Perch, Rock Bass, Sockeye Salmon, Muskie.
Bard's Crossing- Redfin Pickeral, Largemouth Bass, Steelhead Trout.
Cattail's Pond- Northern Pike.

Camp-Eat, Sleep, Save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 81.

Day 81
(Continue Fishing)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 82.
(Continue Fishing)
It is taking a long time to fish. Take a Break.

(Lake Isabella)
Save. Camp, Eat, Sleep

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 83.

Spoiler

Hunt Moose.

(Black Bone Forest Trapper)
Sell Pelt.

(Bard's Crossing)
Save.

Continue Fishing.

(Lemoyne)
Random Encounter (Rally- Night)

(Lemoyne Raider Camp)

Challenge (Weapons Expert 6-Kill 4 Enemies at the same time with a single stick dynamite) -Finished.

Chellenge (Weapons Expert 7- Kill 4 Consecutive Enemies by throwing and Retrieving the same Tomahawk)-Finished.

Use the Ancient Tomahawk. I pick one rider only on path near Old Henry Fen. Antagonize first. I don't have a rifle out. After throw Tomahawk, John automatic takes out rifle. Don't put the rifle away, it resets the challenge.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 84.

Spoiler

(Rhodes Gunsmith)
Buy long barrel for side arm. Other Accessories.

(Lemoyne Camps or Hideouts)
Challenge (Weapons Expert 8- Kill 15 enemies using long barreled sidearm)- Finished.

Save/Reload - Shot 20 arrows at back of unware heads-The counter very messed up- Buy more arrows.

Challenge (Weapons Expert 9- Kill 9 Unaware Enemies with Bow from behind)- Finished.

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 85-86

Spoiler

(Continue with Challenges)
Challenge (Weapons Expert 10- Kill a Grizzly Bear without take damage using only throw knives)- Finished.

(Van Horn)
Save.

Challenge (Horseman 9- Ride from Van Horn to Blackwater in under 17 minutes without touch water)- Finished.

(Blackwater)
Save.

Bounty (Elias Green)

755. Special Tonic/Valerian Root-Large Tree on cliff overlook Beecher's Hope.
13. Beecher's Hope- Prairie Poppy.

(Manzanita Post)
Save.

729. Special Tonic/Ginsing Elixer- On Table hung animals.
148. Study-Siberian Huskie.
Places of Interest (Circus Wagons)

(Bear Claw Shack)
Save. Take All.
324. Locked Box- Old Cabin in well.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 87/88
(Beecher's Hope)
Uncle (Uncle's Bad Day)
(Drink All day/Night)

---------------------------------------------------------------------

(Couple of Weeks Later)

Day 102.

John ( The Best of Woman)
149. Study (Rufus Dog)

Spoiler

(Aurora Basin)
(Tanner Reach) -Take All
(Swadbass Point) -Take All

Save.

Legendary Fish Map.
3. Rock Bass-Special Lake Lure.

(Strawberry Post Office)
Send Mail.
Save.

Ms. L. Hobbs (A Better World, A New Friend 1)

Stranger (The American Inferno, Burnt Out)

(NE Fort Riggs)
(Small Camp-Place we saved Sean in Chapter 2)

751. Special Tonic/Valerian Root- Shack east of water tower.

(Blackwater)
Easter Eggs (6 Mysterious Aztec Writing)
Shave- Facial-2/10 Length.

Places of Interest (Broken Tree)- On Map, Near B=Blackwater.

Save.

Bounty ( Herman Zizendorf) -Night.
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 103.

Spoiler

(Stillwater Creek)
Save.

(Stillwater Cabin)

719. Special Tonic/ Aged Pirate Rum- on table inside cabin.

Legendary Fish Map
2. Redfin Pickeral-Special River Lure.

(Post Office)
Send Mail.

(Thieves Landing)
Save.
(Del Lobos Hideout)
Kill-take all.

(Travel SE from Thieves Landing)

(Old Bacchus Place)
Take Fertility Statue.
Save.

(Travel NW Manteca Falls)

Legendary Animal Map.
3. Tananka Bison. (150. Compendium)

(Riggs Station Trapper)
Sell Pelt
Buy- (Dreamcatcher Trapper Outfit)
Buy (Sharpshooter Equipment)
Buy (Weapons Expert Equipment)
Buy (Gambler Equipment)
Buy (Master Hunter Equipment)
Buy (Survivalist Equipment)

Camp Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 104.

Spoiler

Day 104
Evelyn Miller (The American Inferno, Burnt out 2)

(Beecher's Hope)
Save.

Do some Ranch Chores.

(Hennigan's Stead)
Save.

23. Dinosaur Bone- Pike's Basin.

(Travel South)
On Map- I=Austin.
13. Hennigan's Stead - Wild Feverfew.

(Green Luis River)
(Green Hollow)

Save. Camp- Eat, drink, Sleep.
24. Dinosaur Bone-

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 105.

Spoiler

360. Locked Box- On path Broken Wagon, North Lake Don Julio.

(Venter's Place)

(Lake Don Julio House)
Save.
Item (True Tales of Frank Heck, 102)

(Travel South)
(Rio Del Lobo Rock House)
Save.
366. Locked Box.

25. Dinosaur Bone- Rio Del Lobo Rock.

(West Rio Del Lobo Rock)
Save.
14. Rio Del Lobo Rock - Red Sage

Legendary Animal Map.
2. Pronghorn. (151. Compendium)

( South East of Jorge's Gap)
Save.
358. Locked Box- Abandoned Wagon.

(Two Crows)
319. Locked Box- Farm ruins.
Places of Interest (Donkey Lady)

(Armadillo)
Save.

Item (Chinese Skullcap)
762. Special Tonic/Valerian Root - Campsite- On map, Above 2nd L=Armadillo.
359. Locked Box.

152. Study, Hunt, Track (Desert Iguana)
153. Study, Hunt, Track (Blacktailed Rattlesnake)
154. Study, Hunt, Track (Sonoran Pronghorn Doe)
155. Study, Hunt, Track (Sonoran Pronghorn Buck)
156. Study, Hunt,Track (Nine Banded Armadillo)
157. Study, Hunt, Track ( Banded Gila Monster)
158. Study, Hunt, Track (Collared Peccary Pig)
159. Study, Hunt, Track (Baja California Pronghorn Buck)
160. Study, Hunt, Track (Baja California Pronghorn Doe)
161. Study, Hunt, Track (Desert Bighorn Sheep)
162 Study, Hunt, Track (Desert Bighorn Ram)

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

------------------------------------------------------

Day 106-108

Spoiler

(Armadillo- Benedict Point)
(Continue Hunting) - After kill one animal, it takes 4-5 in game days to get another. Save/reload a bunch. Just want Armadillo,Piccary Pig, Gila Monster.. Taking forever.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 109.

Spoiler

(Riggs Station)
Send Mail.

(Riggs Station Trapper)
Sell Pelts

Buy (The Huntsman Outfit)
Buy (The Death Roll Outfit)
Buy (The Rattler Outfit)
Buy (The Desperado Outfit)

Evelyn Miller (The American Inferno, Burnt Out 3)
Evelyn Miller (The American Inferno, Burnt Out 4)- Leave Food.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, save

------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 110.

(Beechers Hope)
Abigail (Really Big Bastard)

Jack (Trying Again)

Save.

Spoiler

(Blackwater)
Save.

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

(Beechers Hope)
Save.
Ranch Chores.

(Fort Mercer)
753. Special Tonic/Valerian Root - On crate NW section of Fort.

(Mercer Station)
703. Special Tonic/Aged Pirate Rum- Shack inside Window.
Locked Box.

361. Locked Box- White Wagon in 5 wagon circle. NW Mercer Station.
728. Special Tonic/Ginsing Elixer.

26. Dinosaur Bone- Rio Bravo= B. On Map.

15. Benedict Pass- Blackcurrent.
Places of Interest (Sperm Whale Bones)

(Jorge's Gap)
Save.
27. Dinosaur Bone- High point.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 111.

Spoiler

Places of Interest (Flying Machine)- On Map, Between S-P= Springs.

(Pleasance House)
Save.

(Otis Miller's Treasure) -North of Flying Machine.
Item- (Otis Miller Gun)

28. Dinosaur Bone- North Cholla Springs and Flying Machine.

(Alchemists Burned down house) -On Map, C=Cholla. House Exploded.
362. Locked Box.
Save.

(Rathskeller Fork)
Save.
Item- Ram Skull Mask.

(Silent Stead Shack)
368. Locked Box- West of Rathskeller Fork.
Save.

(Abandoned Mission)- South Silent Stead.
364. Locked Box.

(Tumbleweed)
Save.
Stranger (Sheriff)
29. Dinosaur Bone. - Tumbleweed-On map, Between L-1st E.
30. Dinosaur Bone- Gaptooth Ridge- On map, between D-G= Ridge.

Cigarette Card (12. Flora- Carolina Lupine)- Roof of Sheriff Office.
(Last Cigarette Card)

(Travel South)
(On Map, New Austin- on path between N-E=New)

363. Locked Box.
763. Special Tonic/Valerian Root.

(Travel South- Benedict Point)
Save.
(Soloman's Folly)
(Destoryed Cabin) -Take all.

706. Special Tonic/Aged Pirate Rum.

Camp-eat, drink, sleep,save

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 112.

Spoiler

(Scratching Post)
Item (Ancient Necklace)

16. Scratching Post- Desert Sage.

(Go SW, Sea of Coronado)
Shoot the hanging Corpse. Save.

Treasure Map (The Elemental Trail 1)

Places of Interest (Jessuit Missionary)

(Mining Camp-On map, G-A= Gaptooth)
Item (Turtle Shell Trinket)
Money- upstairs room.

Save.

Legendary Animal Map.
1. Cougar (163. Compendium) -on map, T=Gaptooth.

(Greenhollow)
Save.

Treasure Map (The Elemental Trail 2)

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 113.

Spoiler

Legendary Fish Map
1. Largemouth Bass- Special River Lure.

(Benedict Point Post Office)
Send Mail.
Send Cigarette Card Set Flora. -
Stranger (Smoking and Other Hobbies)- Finished.
(Cigarette Cards Compendium)- Finished.

Treasue Map (The Elemental Trail 3)

367. Locked Box- Last one. - Under Bed Benedict Point.

(Armadillo)
Save.

(Coot's Chapel)
731. Special Tonic/ Ginsing Elixer.-Barrel eastside of church.
Treasure Map (The Elemental Trail Treasure)- By grave near tree.

Item (Crow Beak Trinket)

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------

Day 114.

Spoiler

Riggs Station Trapper)
Sell Pelt
Buy ( The Beasts of Prey Outfit)- Last One.

(Plants Compendium)- Finished.
(Animals Compendium)- Not Finished.
(Equipment Compendium) Not Finished.
(Gangs Compendium)- Not Finished
(Weapons Compendium)- Not Finished.

17. Monto's Rest -Lady Slipper Orchid.

Challenge (Herbalist 9- Pick one of each species of herb-43 count)-Finished.
(Had to travel around, find the plants the game says was missing 3)

Challenge ( Herbalist 10- Season and cook all 11 types of meat)- Finished.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Day 115-117.

Spoiler

Challenge (Horseman 10- Break every wild horse)-Finished.
Save.

Horses (Compendium)- Not Finished.

Equip- Legends of the East Outfit.

(Tumbleweed)

Bounty ( Joaquin Arroyo)

Eat, Drink, Save. Sleep.

(Benedict Point Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 118.

Spoiler

(Gunshop)
Buy Repeating Shotgun.
Buy Saw Shotgun.

(Saloon)
Play Poker.

164. Study, Hunt, Pluck (California Condor)

Bounty (Esteban Cortez)

(Manzanita Post)
Camp- Save. Eat, Drink, Sleep.

---------------------------------------------------------------

Day 119.

Spoiler

Evelyn Miller (The American Inferno,Burnt Out 4)

(Blackwater)
Save.

Bounty (Otis Skinner)

(Barber)
Trim Face- 3/10 length.
Hair- 3/7 length

(Beechers Hope)
Save.
Ranch Chores.

Camp-eat, drink, sleep,

-----------------------------------------------------------

Day 120.

Abigail (A New Future Imagined)

------------------------------------------------------------

Day 121.

Spoiler

Save.
(Colter)
Visit Campsite.
Grave: 1: Jenny Kirk.
Grave 2: Davy Callender.

Place of Interest (Robot)

(Horseshoe Overlook)
Save-Listen.

(Cumberland Forest)
Debrah MacGiuness (A Test of Faith 2)
Item (Jawbone Knife)

Grave 3: Eagle Flies
Grave 4: Arthur Morgan.

(Clemson Point)
Save, Listen.
Grave 5: Sean MacGuire.

(Shady Belle)
Kill-Save, Listen.
Grave 6: Kieran Duffy.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 122.

Spoiler

Takes a long time to travel.

(Lakey)
Save, Listen.

Grave 7. Hosea Matthews.
Grave 8: Lenny Summers.

(Beaver Hollow)
Kill, Save Listen.

Grave 9: Susan Grimshaw.

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

--------------------------------------------------------------

Day 123.

Spoiler

----------------------------------------------------------
Day 123

Jeremy Gill (A Fisher of Fish 2)
Take Photo: of Jeremy Gill legs sticking out of water.
Fish (Conpendium)- Finished.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 124.

(Beecher Hope)
Save.
Ranch Chores.

Abigail (American Venom)
Dialogue (Beechers Hope won't be around, Thank you to Arthur and Sadie)
Dialogue (Get Micah for the people who fell)

(Strawberry)
(Mount Hagen) -Kill Micah.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 125- 131

Spoiler

(Beechers Hope)
Save.
Ranch Chores.

Place Squirrel on Mantle.

(A Better World, A New Friend 2)
Find Squirrel Statues: Place on Mantle again.

1. John's Bed-In Chest.
2. John's Bed- In fireplace.
3. Kitchen-Loft.
4. Sheep Pen
5. Upper level of Barn.
6. Mount Shann-

(Mount Hagen)
Save.

Take Micah's Guns
Photo Body
757. Special Tonic/
768. Special Tonic/

(Beechers Hope)
Save. Place Squirrel Statue on Fireplace.
Ranch Chores/Family Dinner.

Evelyn Miller (The American Inferno,Burnt Out) Go back to finish.

Uncle ( Ranch Request)
Charles (Ranch Request) - Maybe.

September 28, 2024

Regarding Chapter 6 and the conundrum of Delights of Van Horn, I believe it's meant to be placed much earlier in the chapter. In fact as the next Main Story mission after Just a Social Call.

Dutch's plan involving the Army, Dynamite, Railroads and the Oil Refinery begins to take shape even before A Rage Unleashed, as evidenced by the ending cutscene in Just a Social Call, where Dutch reads Cornwall's papers (that were retrieved by Micah, while Dutch and Arthur confronted Cornwall at the docks), and learns about Cornwall's connection to the army:

Dutch: "We just need a distraction. Buy us some time. It looks like Mr. Cornwall's company has signed a railroad contract with the army and they're also moving dynamite down from, well, the Annesburg mines to Saint Denis to resell. And there's bonds at his oil factory. Maybe there's a way to get them off our back and get the money that we need."

Dutch then proceeds to charge Micah and Bill with procuring the dynamite, and for Arthur to help them when he can, but first he asks Micah to speak in private about their plan.

Next time we see Micah (during Delights of Van Horn) he knows Dutch's plan from the conversation he had with Dutch after the ending of Just a Social Call.

At no point during Delights of Van Horn does Micah or Bill mention indians, because at this point in time, the indians aren't part of Dutch's plan, as they haven't been introduced yet.

This is what Micah has to say about the plan, during Delights of Van Horn:

Micah: "Dutch says we is to go on with plans to create a diversion. We gotta get some explosives to blow up the bridge. Keep the army out of here a few days." ... "We gotta confuse them one last time... then he and I will head to Blackwater, collect the money and help everyone leave."

As you can see, all of Micah's details about the plan are based on the information from Cornwall's papers from Just a Social Call. I do believe Micah would have mentioned the Indians, if he'd known about them, which he would have, if the Indian storyline or even just A Rage Unleashed would have been completed at this point.

At the start of A Rage Unleashed Dutch shares the first details of his plan (Make a distraction, get cash, go to New York, then Fiji / Taihiti / New Guinea) with Arthur. Then by good fortune Charles and Eagle Flies arrive, and Dutch's final missing piece falls into place.

During A Rage Unleashed Dutch has dialogue with Arthur, where he explains this:

Dutch: "That dynamite, the railroad contract with the army, it was all in those papers Micah found. I have a plan. You just have to trust me."

At the end of Delights of Van Horn Micah sends John off with the dynamite to blow up the bridge. I've also struggled with placing The Bridge to Nowhere because of this, but I believe it fits narratively and thematically best towards the end of the chapter, right after Favored Sons (as that seems to be Arthur's breaking point, when he loses faith in Dutch completely), before The King's Son.

That leaves John sitting around at Bacchus Bridge with the dynamite for quite a lot of time, but I can excuse this by imagining that he was spent the time hiding the dynamite (which makes sense, given as Dutch manages to procure some of it between Favored Sons and Bridge to Nowhere), and being informed by Abigail that she may have found Dutch's money stash (Dutch only informs Arthur, that he has procured it from the old Shady Belle camp during A Rage Unleashed).

So therefore I believe the chronological mission order for Chapter 6 should go a little something like this:

Visiting Hours

Just a Social Call

Time off for side activities

Delights of Van Horn

Time off for side activities

The Course of True Love IV

A Rage Unleashed

Archaeology for Beginners

Time off for side activities

Honor, Among Thieves

Of Men and Angels

Goodbye, Dear Friend

The Fine Art of Conversation

The Course of True Love V

Favored Sons

The Bridge to Nowhere

The King's Son

Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow

October 20, 2024

On 7/21/2024 at 3:05 AM, Tkayyy1018 said:

Just wanted to note that I have also gotten both Thomas Downes interactions at the charity table in Valentine in the past. In fact, it was Psycho who taught me how to get both in two different ways. So if it is not possible now, then something has changed in the game. I can verify this because I keep my own 'expanded' Arthur journal and I have documented this as I played through.

October 26, 2024

So this topic is mostly dead I think but I have been sick a long time and dealing with a wife with cancer so I never got to really dive in the way I wanted to with doing a chronological gameplay. But now I have some time and I'm very OCD so I'm trying to put together a document from this thread and other sources with an estimated mission order and an estimated timeline.

I've really found that I think one of the most interesting things that gets missed in a "timeline" sense is when Arthur says in "A Fisher of Men" that the gang was up in the snow for a "few weeks" (which I'm going to count as "two"). If we go with Hosea saying his bit about the weather in "May" in the opening dialogue, and the Blackwater robbery clipping being in a newspaper dated May that says it was "yesterday" - I think we end up with the gang not actually getting to Horseshoe Overlook until at least around May 14th. Pretty much every timeline I've seen puts the gang at Colter at the Overlook at least a week earlier, which doesn't go with Arthur's dialogue. Then "Polite Society", whenever you do that, would then have to be around May 28th at the earliest as the girls clearly say they've been cooped up at Overlook for "two weeks". Regardless, the gang seems to definitely not have left Overlook until sometime in June.

Of course, we have the Mayor's letters later on with one of them dated in May but I think we just have to ignore that and retcon it as the Mayor being an idiot or something because it makes NO sense to the earlier dialogues. The date on the second letter as "June" can be worked around.

Anyway, here is the document I'm working on, with commentary, for anyone who might want to add comments or contributions or alternate mission orders or timeline thoughts. Probably no one will because y'all have long moved on, but just in case. Still a work in much progress of course.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qIraRoSl5sI14G5y6lJ-L5jrY2Nemt5M1AY8k_G1MmA/edit?usp=sharing

Edited October 27, 2024 by EpiceneBlue

October 26, 2024

1 hour ago, EpiceneBlue said:

I think we end up with the gang not actually getting to Horseshoe Overlook until at least around May 14th. Pretty much every timeline I've seen puts the gang at Colter at the Overlook at least a week earlier, which doesn't go with Arthur's dialogue. Then "Polite Society", whenever you do that, would then have to be around May 28th at the earliest as the girls clearly say they've been cooped up at Overlook for "two weeks".

You may be aware of it but during "Eastward Bound", the game states its been "a couple of weeks" during the fade-out where it says "chapter 2 - horseshoe overlook" on the screen, backing up the girls saying "two weeks" during Polite Society

Also, f*ck cancer. Hope everything is going alright

October 26, 2024

1 hour ago, Jisoo said:

You may be aware of it but during "Eastward Bound", the game states its been "a couple of weeks" during the fade-out where it says "chapter 2 - horseshoe overlook" on the screen, backing up the girls saying "two weeks" during Polite Society

Also, f*ck cancer. Hope everything is going alright

Yep, but always good to have that backup notation thank you. it also reinforced doing Polite Society soon after arriving at Horseshoe in order for the Eastern Bound note and the dialogue from the girls to match up. And yep, F cancer.

RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 - "Chronological" Mission Order

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

Spydr Webz

SpaceBeagle

BrandyNova

Recommended Posts

Psycho18

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Tkayyy1018

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Tkayyy1018

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Agent Edward

Link to comment

Share on other sites

jimmyoneshot

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Tkayyy1018

Link to comment

Share on other sites

propanecocaine71

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Tkayyy1018

Link to comment

Share on other sites

propanecocaine71

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

propanecocaine71

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

propanecocaine71

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Agent Edward

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Agent Edward

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Dan_1983

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Agent Edward

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Psycho18

Link to comment

Share on other sites

KKs_Grandma

Link to comment

Share on other sites

luckycanadian95

15 Users Currently Viewing

0 members, 0 Anonymous, 15 Guests