RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 - "Chronological" Mission Order

[JB1982]

Charles says on the ride from Lakay that it was a tough few days after he regrouped with the gang at Shady Belle. It's unclear to me though if he's referring to them just packing up and moving to Lakay or the whole time Arthur and the others are missing though.

 

On the subject of beard length, at the start of Chapter 6, I have a level five beard which according to the guide takes 12 days to reach.

 

When riding to the hot air balloon in Icarus and Friends, Sadie says she's been hunting O'Driscoll's since "last week".

 

Shall update further as I progress. 

Edited February 24, 2024 by JB1982

[JB1982]

Going back to an earlier discussion, the second invitation from the Saint Denis mayor has the month of June on it. I believe that's the first reference I have seen in the game for a month other than May.

[I.v.or03]

Hey everyone, I'm trying to get this cutscene to trigger, but can't see how? Whenever you open the door, it's just gameplay? Maybe its a deleted cutscene, but many people have said that they'd gotten it before in the comments. (also, if there's another forum that is more in tune to this type of question, that'd be great). Cheers guys

 

[Jisoo]

17 hours ago, I.v.or03 said:

Hey everyone, I'm trying to get this cutscene to trigger, but can't see how? Whenever you open the door, it's just gameplay? Maybe its a deleted cutscene, but many people have said that they'd gotten it before in the comments. (also, if there's another forum that is more in tune to this type of question, that'd be great). Cheers guys

 

Ive had both myself. Im not sure what makes it skip the cutscene honestly. Maybe it depends on which door you enter or where you dismount your horse, but yea I know you can accidentally not start this cutscene. In the speedrun they light themself on fire by shooting a lantern while opening the door, so thats a guaranteed cutscene skip

Edited March 2, 2024 by Jisoo

[Psycho18]

I am playing RDR2 again soon. Just bought the RDR 2 Ultimate edition and RDR1 on sale. 

 

On the subject of Mr. Wrobel. During the camp cutscene, Arthur take a taste of the camp stew. Arthur throws the ladle back into stew pot.

 

Is it morning day old stew or late afternoon, after dinner stew? I usually visit Mr.Wrobel in the morning after Arthur get out jail. Arthur is  hung over. I might change the order.

 

[jimmyoneshot]

On 3/2/2024 at 4:09 AM, I.v.or03 said:

Hey everyone, I'm trying to get this cutscene to trigger, but can't see how? Whenever you open the door, it's just gameplay? Maybe its a deleted cutscene, but many people have said that they'd gotten it before in the comments. (also, if there's another forum that is more in tune to this type of question, that'd be great). Cheers guys

 

I believe this is triggered by restarting a checkpoint in the middle of the mission in which case sometimes a unique cutscene plays.

[jimmyoneshot]

On 3/17/2024 at 12:35 AM, Psycho18 said:

I am playing RDR2 again soon. Just bought the RDR 2 Ultimate edition and RDR1 on sale. 

 

On the subject of Mr. Wrobel. During the camp cutscene, Arthur take a taste of the camp stew. Arthur throws the ladle back into stew pot.

 

Is it morning day old stew or late afternoon, after dinner stew? I usually visit Mr.Wrobel in the morning after Arthur get out jail. Arthur is  hung over. I might change the order.

 

Usually the camp stew is ready around 5pm - 6pm at which point everyone eats however this is likely more for gameplay purposes than anything.

 

 

In this case though Arthur's reaction is pretty vague. He may be throwing the ladle back because the stew tastes bad which seems to be an in-joke in the game or it could be because it's too hot.

 

I think it fits multiple scenarios.

[Dan_1983]

Been months since I played the game. However, I always wondered if starting Strauss' debt missions and just visiting Wrobel fits in on the same day as Americans at Rest?

 

When you arrive at camp after Americans at Rest, Dutch will always approach Arthur about helping Strauss and both Charles and Javier have not long left Valentine with Trelawny to scout Blackwater.

 

[Psycho18]

I haven't play RDR2 in 4+ years. Is it just me or is this game more buggy than before. I am playing this game on PS5.

 

Thomas Downes and his family plays a big part in the story. Right now, I am having a hard time getting both Thomas Downes interactions in Valentine to appear.

 

 Does anybody else having problems? I don't get it, Thomas Downes shows up in Polite Society, then disappears in free roam. Thomas Downes shows up in American at Rest, then disappears in free roam.

 

1st mission order

Day 1:

Deer Hunt

Without Sin

--------------------------------

Day 2:

Polite Society- Thomas Downes in Valentine

Don't return horse after chasing Jimmy Brooks.  Tried to return the horse.

Camp- get Arthur's horse.

 

Return to Valentine.

Thomas Downes is gone.

Good Honest, Snake Oil.

Downes is still gone.

------------------------------------

Day 3:

Return to Valentine.

It is a hit or miss for Thomas Downes to appear.

 

American at Rest- Thomas Downes stops the fight.

Thomas Downes disappears from Valentine.

 

-------------------------------------------

2nd order

 

Day 1

Polite Society- Thomas Downes in Valentine

Don't return horse to Valentine.   Return the horse to Valentine.

Without Sin

---------------------------------------------

Day 2:

 

Return to Valentine

Thomas Downes is gone

Snake Oil

 

Hit or miss for Downes to appear

America at Rest- Downes stops the fight.

Downes disappears  again.

 

 

 

 

 

[Ballbreaker_]

It's not perfect, but I found the Piggyback's "official guide" mission order to be the most coherent of them all, from both gameplay and story perspective.

[Psycho18]

Here First two Chapters, Just started Chapter 3.

(Chapter 1: Colter)

 

(Micah Suggested the Blackwater Ferry Robbery)

 

Dutch: (Outlaws from the West)

(Micah Burned down the Adler's Ranch)

---------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2

 

(John not seen in a couple of days.

 

John (Enter Pursued by a Memory)

--------------------------------------------------------------

Day 3

Talk all

Dialogue (Dutch/Hosea Argument, Follow Dutch to small fire outside the boys shack)

 

Bill (Old Friends)

---------------------------------------------------------------

Day 4

Talk all- Make fun of John.

 

Pearson (Aftermath of Genosis)

Hunt deer.

Dialogue (2 deers is enough to feed all for a couple of days)

----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6.

(Few days later)

 

Dutch (Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall)

 

Dialogue (Micah wants to go back to Blackwater)

 

(On Train)

kill one guard with knife.

------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7

 

Dutch (Eastward Bound)

 

(Hosea gave Arthur some Yarrow/America Ginsing)

Spoiler

Challenge: ( Master Hunter 1- Skin 3 deers- 1/3)- Started.

Challenge (Weapon Expert 1- Kill 3 enemies with a knife- 1/3)- Started.

-------------------------------------------------------------------

 

(Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook)

(2 weeks Later)

Day 1:

 

Whitetail Deer Hunting- Started in Chapter 1.

Pick Yarrow- Outside around Horseshoe Camp.

 

Dialogue (Pearson's Trapper Info)

Dialogue (Mary-Beth-Arthur is worried)

Dialogue (Susan-Micah/Lenny went West)

Read Lenny's letter.

Read Bill's Letter.

Read Swanson Drug Book.

 

Swanson (Who is not without Sin) Clock stops at 5pm.

Play poker as long you want. Enough  time for Swanson to get chased by big man.

 

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Odriscoll Gang Encounter-Wilderness-Flatneck Station)

 

Dutch (Camp Request-Pipe)

Hosea (Camp Request-Book)

Mary-Beth (Camp request-Pen)

 

Challenge: (Master Hunter 1-Skin 3 deers)- Finished.

Challenge: (Herbalist 1- Pick 6 Yarrow)- Finished.

Challenge:(Gambler 1-Win 5 hands of poker)-Finished.

 

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2:

 

Uncle (Polite Society, Valentine Style)- 8am

 

Thomas Downes seen in Valentine. Cannot interact with him.

 

Dialogue (Mary-Beth- Cooped up for 2 weeks- They been in Horseshoe for 2 weeks)

Dialogue (Don't help Broken down wagon- Arthur has no energy for Charity)

Dialogue (Dutch wants all to keep a low profile, Arthur always follow orders).

Dialogue (Mary-Beth-Train Robbery)

Dialogue (Tilly/Anthony Foreman)

Dialogue (Karen-Bank Robbery)

 

(Arthur must chase Jimmy Brooks, before Jimmy Brooks rides to Blackwater. The Gang suppose to be in Low profile).

 

(Back to Horseshoe Camp)

Dialogue (Tell Dutch about the man from Blackwater).

 

Stranger:(Smoking and Other Hobbies)-Cigarette Cards- Find Cards when exploring. I don't count cards from packs.

Stranger (All that Glitters)

Pick/Eat- Raspberries- Outside Horseshoe camp.

Jack Hall Gang Treasure 2: Caliban's Seat.

 

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Snake Bite)

Random Encounter (Sharpshooter)

 

Challenge (Explorer 1- Acquired a Treasure Map)-Finished

Challenge (Sharpshooter  1-Shoot 3 Flying Birds)-Finished

Challenge ( Herbalists 2- Pick/Eat 4 species of berries)- Started.

Challenge (Explorer 2- Find a Treasure)-Finished.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 3:

(Valentine)

Buy Newspaper- Been in Valentine many times in chapter 2. This only time I can buy a newspaper. 

Thomas Downes not in Valentine. 

 

Sheriff( Good Honest, Snake Oil)-10am

 

Dialogue (Sheriff-Livestock Town- Similar to want Hosea said)

Dialogue (Arthur didn't start any trouble yet)

Dialogue (Sheriff knows Arthur is a sinner, not a saint)

 

Bounty (Benedict Allbright)

 

Stranger (Thomas Downes)-only time you can Interact with him.

 

Javier (American at Rest) 2pm

Dialogue (Dutch told Arthur to get cleaned, meet them in Blackwater when ready)

 

Thomas Downes is Gone from Valentine.

 

Stranger (Noblest of Men and a Women) Big saloon is closed.

Dialogue (Hotel Clerk- Polite Society)

Dialogue (General Store Clerk- Drunk Clergyman in Flatneck Station)

Stranger (Homeless Vet-Mickey)

 

Hotel: Bath-sleep overnight.

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/ RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (1. Gunslingers set- Frank Heck)- Valentine Cemetery gravestone. 

 

Random Encounter (Snake Bite-Consequence- Gun shop- buy Varmint Rifle for hunting.

Random Encounter (Odriscoll's Foot Robbery)

Random Encounter (Domestic Dispute-Town)

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 4-

6am

 

(Caster's Ridge- Father and Son's House Builders 1)

Travel South.

 

(Appleseed Timber CO 1)- Sell few food, Medicine, booze.

 

Javier (The First shall be Last)- 1pm.  Took a while to get down there.

 

River: use knife to kill left bounty hunter.

Escape: Ride north path cross river.

 

Sean's Party

Spoiler

( Pinkertons will be at small camp/main roads. Wanted Dead or Alive)

 

Challenge (Weapon Expert 1- kill 3 Enemies with a knife- 2/3)

 

Random Encounter( Odriscoll's Coach Robbery)

Random Encounter (Odriscoll's Bridge road Ambush)

Random Encounter (Lost Man)- Take him to Strawberry, don't enter.

Random Encounter (Gold Panner)- Hogtie/Loot when  he found gold-Dakota River/Bard's Crossing.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 5

12pm

 

Dialogue:(Dutch tell Arthur to help Strauss)

 

Money Lending (Mr. Wrobel)- 4pm

Pick/eat Blackberries- Painted Sky.

 

Spoiler

Dialogue (Sean's Camp request- Whiskey)- Give.

Dialogue (Charles Camp request-Moonshine)

 

Challege (Herbalist 2- Pick eat-4 species of berry- 2/4)

 

Usually I wait for Susan/Dutch tell Arthur to put money collection box. -$1.00 to $5.00 items only- Cash $5.00. Or as needed for Upgrading camp.

Place Wrobal's debt in Box.

Upgrade: Medicine wagon-Food Wagon. People need to eat and Medicine.

 

Random Encounter (Odriscoll gang encounter- Town night)

Random Encounter (Town Confrontation-Town)

Random Encounter (Peeping Toms- Town Night)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6.

8am

(Caster's Ridge-Father and Son's House Builders 2)- Shootout.

Stranger: (Blind man Cassidy)

 

Money Lending (Lily Milet)- Emerald Ranch

Money Lending (Chick Matthews- Gutherie Famrs

 

Took a long time get back to camp. Afternoon.

Place Debt in collection box.

 

Keiran (Paying a Social Call)- 4pm

Dialogue ( Bill- Odriscolls, Fight with Tommy)

Dialogue (Kieran- Been watching the gang for many weeks)

 

(Six Cabin point Cabin)- Clock stopped at 5pm

Man on log: Knife Kill.

 

Valentine Hotel Overnight.

Stranger (Jon in Saloon)- Take Racoon hat.

 

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Odriscolls Gang road Abush)- Dakota River Path.

Random Encounter ( Women trapped under horse)- Road to Emerald

 

Challenge (Weapons Expert 1- Kill 3 enemies with knife- 3/3)- Finished.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/ RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (2. Gunslingers set- Otis Miller Boys)- Six point Cabin outside area on blue wagon.

 

 Mary's Letter is blocking Arthur's Bed. Cannot sleep in  bed. Strauss will approach. I will not collect Thomas Downes debt at 10pm.

Behind Valentine-Sheriff/Doctors Office- See Deputy knock on metal door. Go check door- Odriscolls. Check window.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7.

(Horseshoe Camp)

8am

Dialogue (Susan- Mary Gillis)

Read Mary's Letter. Strauss Approached Arthur.

 

Money lending (Thomas Downes)- 10am.

 

Stranger : (A Test of Faith)- Dinosaur Bones.

 

(Horseshoe Camp)

Read Notes from Dutch's speech.

 

Dutch (A Quiet Time)- 5pm

 

Dialogue ( Mich is in Jail)

Dialogue (Bonds-Hosea is handling it)

Dialogue (Here's hoping for Micah Hanging)

 

(Valentin, Saloon)- Clock stops at 7pm

Jail time.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 8.

9am.

 

Pick up hat from pig pen.

Murder Scene 1- Citadel Rock- Hunt Western Turkey Vulture- use Varmint Rifle.

 

(Horseshoe Camp)

Dialogue (Susan- slaps Arthur, make him wash)

 

Hosea (Exit Pursued of a Bruised)- 12pm

 

Dialogue (Be gone for a couple days)

Dialogue (Bonds-have few leads)

Dialogue( stay out of saloon)

Dialogue (John)

Dialogue (Micah)

 

(Stables)- Sell Black horse- Buy American Standardbred for now. Dutch WarmBlood to expensive.

(Orcreaghs Run)

Hunt Rabbit- use varmint rifle.  5pm

 

(Camp- intro-Craft intro) 8pm

----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 9

6am

Track Bear.

 

Hunt Bear- Split up. Save Hosea's life. Take  Legendary Animal Map.  8:45 am

Return to camp.  It doesn't take 15 mins travel.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 10

 

(Horseshoe Camp)

9am.

Save very quick.

Dialogue (Kieran saw Odriscolls riding around)

Dialogue (Susan Camp Request- Herbs).

Dialogue ( Susan- Hosea went to Emerald Ranch). 5:30pm. Very Glitchy- Maybe couple in game hours or couple in game days.

 

Spoiler

Watch Pearson. Stand by poker table.  10:30- 11:30am. Reload  if Swanson talks to Arthur 3 times or more.

 

Pearson (camp request-Rabbit) Give. Take Scout Jacket.

Hunt Rabbits. Use Varmint Rifle.

 

Challenge (Master Hunter 2- Collect 3 perfect quality Rabbit Pelts)- Finished.

Challenge (Horseman 1- Kill 5 Rabbits from Horseback)- Finished.

Challenge (Master Hunter 3- Track 10 different animal species use binoculars)- Started.

Challenge ( Horseman 2- Jump over 3 obstacles in 5 seconds)- Finshed

 

Random Encounter ( Outlaw Looting)

Random Encounter (Street Fight- Town)

 

 

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 11/12

 

Stranger (To the End of the Earth)

 

Hosea (A Spines of America)- 11am

 

Dialogue (Emerald Ranch- Gallivanting around here)

 

Day time- Con man Hosea work on the owners of Carmody Dell.

 

Return to camp.

 

(Valentine- Gunshop) Buy a Springfield Rifle/ Improve rifling for hunting.

(Valentine -Train Station- Hunting Request poster)

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Man cleans horse gets kicked in head)

Random Encounter ( Prison Transport)- get Info Robbery info.

Random Encounter (Lone prisoner)- shoot chains, get robbery info, hogtie him, take him to Valentine Sheriff.

Random Encounter (Duel Winner)

 

(Emerald Ranch Fence)- Didn't open. It took a while. Sell $6.00 to $25.00 items.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

 

Cigarette Card (1. Gems of Beauty set- Leila Stetson) Window Sill.

 

Camp Poker- (Pearson's Camp Request- Compass)

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 12 or 13

 

Charles Hunting-8am

Hunt Bison- Use Springfield Rifle.

Small Camp- Take Moonshine.

 

(Horseshoe Camp)

Donate Perfect Bison Pelt/meat to Camp

 

Dialogue(Karen- Stuff)

Dialogue ( Charles Camp Request-Moonshine)- Give

Craft camp fire( Small game arrows)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 13  or more- Days are fast when hunting.

 

Animal Hunting Around Horseshoe/ Dakota River/Caliban's Seat.

Spoiler

Hunting Request: 1 Rabbit and 1 Squirrel. Train Station send Mail.

 

Animal Hunting for Camp- Whitetail Buck, Muskrat, Squirrel, Pronghorn Doe/Buck- Carcass back to camp.

Arthur's Mountain Men Trapper Outfit- Whitetail Buck, Muskrat.

 

Random Encounter(Kidnapped)

 

Camp craft- Chuck Wagon- Pronghorn Skull.

Camp craft- Scout Campfire-Hanging Bones..

 

Charles(Camp Request-Oleander Sage)-Give

Javier (Camp Request-Oleander Sage)- Give

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 14 or more

 

(Caster's Ridge- Father and Son's House Builders 3) agree to find Lumber.

(Appleseed Timber CO 2-Tree fall on man)- buy lumber.

(Caster's Ridge 3)- return Lumber.

 

(Horseshoe Camp)

Lenny-Five Finger Fillet.

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Skipping Stones)- Give advice to boys 2x.

Random Encounter (Lost Drunk-Town night)

 

Camp Collection Box- $1.00 to $5.00 items, Cash $5.00

Camp Ledge: Medicine wagon/finish,Food Wagon, Ammo wagon.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 15

Travel Riggs Station

Stranger(Arcadia for Beginners)

 

(Owanjila Lake/Black Bone Forest)Trapper.

Stranger (Geology for Beginners)- Rock Carvings.

 

Use the Legendary Animal Map order- Hosea gave Arthur. First 3 are in New Austin.

4. Legendary Animal-Whitetail Buck- Black Bone Forest.  Sell to Trapper.

 

Pick/eat- Winterberry- Black Bone Forest.

 

(Venter's Echo Bear Cabin)- Hunt Grizzly Bear- Use Springfield Rifle- Sell Perfect Pelt to Trapper.

Take Dutch's Pipe.

 

Spoiler

7 days of Animal Hunting. Days are fast. Game very Glitchy.

 

Random Encounter (Man Trapped in Bear Trap)

Random Encounter (Animal Mauling)

Random Encounter (Drunk Wagon Driver)- wait for him to leave. Take Stuff.

Random Encounter (Safe Cracker)

Random Encounter (Bear trap Consequence)-General Store Strawberry-Buy :Cumberland most expensive outfit.

Random Encounter (Show gun off) Man shoot himself. Strawberry.

 

 

Hunt for Camp: 2 beavers,  2 snakes, 3 cougars, 6 Boars, Bull Moose, maybe.

Hunt for Mountain Man Trapper Outfit- 5 Beavers, 2 Elk.

 

Perfect Animal Pelts will disappear from Arthur's horse- Need to hunt more.

Animal Carcass will disappear in 3-4 days. Long wait for cougars to appear.

3 star animals won't die from headshots. Guns are clean, correct ammo and weapons.

 

(Odriscoll camp-Black Bone Forest)- kill all- Hogtie 3- throwing knives at heads- didn't die, even with knives sticking out of heads.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2 map.com

Cigarette Card (1. Fauna of America set- Black Widow Spider)- Desk.

 

Challenge (Herbalist 2-Pick/eat 4 species of Berries- 3/4)

 

 

 

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 22

Night- Bath- Sleep in hotel room.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 23

Micah (Blessed are the Meek)

 

(Pinkertons are in Strawberry-Wanted Dead or Alive)

(Bounty Hunters Black Bone Forest Trapper- other area West Elizabeth)

(Watson Cabin)- Enter. Steal Shotgun.  Tried to kill chickens with throw knives. Didn't die. No credit for Weapon expert 2 challenge.

 

Spoiler

2 days hunting trip.

Have to use the Riggs Station Trapper for now.

 

(Cattail Pond)

Legendary Animal Map Order

5. Big Horn Ram- Sell to Trapper.

 

Hunt for Mountain Man Trapper Outfit- 2 Big horn Rams/Sheep.

Hunt for Camp- Big Ram Carcass.

 

Random Encounter (Gang encounter- Bridge Ambush)

Random Encounter (Treasure Hunter)- Rob him

 

Challenge (Explorer 3- Find a treasure)- High Stakes Treasure 2- Cumberland Falls.

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 25

(Horseshow Camp)

Donate meat- Big horn Carcass.  All Pelts.

 

Dutch(Camp request-Pipe)- Give.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 26-27

 

Mary Linton (We Loved Once and True 2)

Mary Linton (We Love Once and True 3)

 

Spoiler

Camp Craft - Arthur's bed/Big Horn Ram Skull, John's Bed/ Boar Skin Rug, Main Fire/Moose Antlers, Scout Fire/Elk Antlers.

 

Challenge (Bandit 1-Rob 5 Townfolk)- Valentine Train Station Platform- Easy escape.

 

Valentine Stables- sell Begin Horse, and American Standardbred

Buy- Dutch Warmblood.

 

At Night- Chadwick Farms- lasso/knife kill- 4 sheep

 

(Odriscoll camp-Twin Stack Pass)- kill all, hogtie 3, throw knives at heads. Don't die with knives sticking out of heads.

 

Camp Collection Box-$1.00 to $5.00 Items/ Cash $5.00.

Ledger: Upgrade- Food Wagon/ Finished, Ammo wagon.  Refilled red wagons.

 

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 28

John(Pouring Forth Oil 1)- Talk John- Talk Dutch.

John (Pouring Forth Oil 2)

 

(Cornwall- Tar and Oil Refinery)

Shoot arrows at wagon near west gate. Steal wagon. Drive to Scarlet Meadows.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Central Union railroad 1)

Spoiler

Emerald Ranch fence- Sell- $6.00 to $25.00 Items

Craft: Buck antler Tricket.

 

Random Encounter (Bounty Hunter)- Take Prisoner to Valentine Sheriff.

 

Challenge (Bandit 2- Rob 2 wagons, Bring in to a Fence)- Finished.

 

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 28

 

(Horseshoe camp)

 

John (Pouring Forth Oil 3)

Dialogue (Tilly- Valentine Doctors Office Robbery).

Dialogue (Mrs. Downes Visits camp)

 

Valentine Night (Chadwick Farms)- Kill 2 Sheeps.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 29-30-31

 

(Caster's Ridge)(Father and Son's House Builder 4) Get money.

 

Javier (House Robbery- Chez Porter)

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (3. Gunslingers set-Jack hall Gang)- Chez Porter.

 

2-3 days Hunting/ collecting/ Trip.

Lake Isabella- Wolves, Western Moose, Elk.

 

Search Dormain Crest cabin- Snowfield shack. Official Strategy Guide Map.

 

Rock carving 1- Mount Hagen

Rock Carving- Whinyard Strait. Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2 map.com

 

High Stakes Treasure 3( Barrow Lagoon)

Challenge (Explorer 4-Find treasure)

 

Random Encounter (Horse Race)

 

Jack Hall Gang Treasure 3 ( Cotorra Springs)

Challenge (Explorer 5- Find treasure)

 

Sunny, clear day. Follow Flock of Birds to a Cave Entrance- Stranger - Giant not there to talk.

 

O'Creagh's Run- Jack Hall Gang Treasure- Small Treasure in middle of Lake.

Challenge (Explorer 6-Find Treasure)

 

Elysian Pool Trapper: sell all Pelts.

 

Emerald Ranch Fence: Sell Gold Bars, other $6.00 to $25.00 Items.

 

 

 

 

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 32

(Horseshoe Camp)

(Appleseed Timber CO 3)

 

Micah ( American Pastorial Scene)

Dialogue (Micah-Loose Ends)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Wallace Station)

Receive Mail.

 

Stranger (Arcadia For Beginners 2)

 

(Watson Cabin Robbery) Take All. Try again-Use throw Knives kill chickens. Cannot get Weapon expert 2 Challenge.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 33-34

 

Spoiler

Hunt -Cattail Pond

Rams, Big Horn Sheep, Elk, Deer, Bucks.

Random Encounter (Posse Breakout) Save Bill.

 

(Riggs Station Trapper)- Sell pelts

(Hanging Dog Ranch)

Hunt Wolves- Wolves Carcass back to Horseshoe Camp.

Donate -meat, wolf Carcass

Craft: Wolf Skull-Main Campfire.

 

Random Encounter (Self Defense-Night-Town) Working Girl killed a man.

Either help her or Take her to Sheriff. Two Sheriffs seated in the same seat.Take money from one Sheriff, the other Sheriff place a bounty on Arthur's head for the money from desk.  Trying throw knives at pursuing lawman will not kill them.  Knives  stuck in their heads.

Bounty poster is still on the wall.

 

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 34

(Horseshoe Camp)

Collection Box: $1.00 to $5.00 items- Cash $5.00

Ledger: Upgrade Ammo Wagon-Finished.

 

(Valentine-Gun shop)

Buy items, Volcanic pistol-Upgrades.

 

(Pinkertons saw the dead bodies, Bank wagon on Dakota River)

(Either Micah or Odrisscolls told the Pinkertons where to find the camp)

 

Abigail ( A Fisher of Men)  3pm

Jack (Camp request-Book)

 

Dialogue (Pinkertons meet Arthur)

Dialogue (Pinkertons offer Arthur, We know Micah was thinking about the offer

Dialogue (Either Micah or Odrisscols told the Pinkertons about the Cornwall Train Robbery

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Spoiler

Day 35-38

 

Hunting Request- Chipmunk, Rat, Northern Cardinal- Train station-send mail. Receive mail.

Birds Hunting.  Hunting- Badger, Fox, Elk, Deer.

Donate: Pelts, meats to camp.

 

Fishing: Dakota River. Different fish bites the wrong bait. Keep trying for fish I want.  It took a while.

Challenge : (Survivalist 1- Catch 3 Blue Gills)- Finished

Challenge :(Survivalists 2- Hand in 5 animals to the camp or trapper)-Finished.

 

 

Pick Organo- Horseshoe

Susan (Camp Request-Herbs)- Give

Abigail ( Camp Request- $5.00)-Give

Jack (Camp Request-Thimble)

Lenny (Camp Request-Watch) -Give a watch looted from bodies. Stay in camp for many nights. It took a while.

 

 

 

 

 

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 39

John (Pouring Forth Oil 4)

Dialogue (Micah)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 40

Emerald Ranch Fence: Sell $6.00 to $25.00 Items. Buy: Dynamite, Lock Breaker, Throw Knives,

Craft:  Ram Horn Tricket.

 

(Horseshoe Camp)

Spoiler

Challenge (Survivalist 3- Kill 5 animals using Varmint Rifle)-Finished.

Challenge (Survivalist 4- Craft-Dynamite, Fire, Improved, Poison, and Small Game Arrows)- Started.

 

Random Encounter (Odriscolls Train Robbery)

Random Encounter (Drunk Dueler-Town)

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 41

John ( The Sheep and the Goats) 12pm

Escape Law go west Cattail Pond. Pay Bounty.  Camp out.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 42

Dialogue (Micah Suggest Dewberry Creek-Wide open area-easy for attacks)

 

Dutch (Strange Kindness)

Dialogue (There no way Dutch will be hiding in  a cave somewhere, Foreshadowing)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[NikosUncle]

^^^ damn good job there!

[Psycho18]

Chapter 3: Clemson point

(A Few Days later)

 

Day 1

9am

 

Dutch ( A New South)

 

Dialogue (Dutch-Low profile in Rhodes)

Dialogue (Trelawny)

Dialogue (Sheriff Gray)

Dialogue (Arthur-Check out Caliga Hall)

Dialogue (Hosea- Brathewaite Manor)

 

Returned to camp

6:30pm

------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2

7am

 

Screaming all night. Mission starts automatically,if get close. 

Pearson (Further Question of Female Suffrage)

 

Dutch (American Distillation)

12:06 pm

 

(Clemson point)- 1:48pm

 

Dialogue (Hosea- Arthur go see the Gray Family)

Tilly- Dominos

 

(Rhodes)

Stranger- Joe Butler

Stranger- Gavin's Friend

Buy- 2 newspapers

 

Play Blackjack- Took all night/most of the morning.

Spoiler

Kieran (Camp Request-Burdock Root)

Sadie ( Camp Request- Harmonica)

Tilly (Camp Request-Necklace)

Hosea ( Camp Request- American Ginsing)- Give

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/ RDR2map.com

 

Cigarette Card (1. Prominent Americans set- President Fisher)- Outside of Clemson Point, Big Red Building, near train tracks.

Cigarette Card (1. Breeds of Horses set- American Pain)- Rhodes Cotton Mill on barrel.

 

Challenge (Gambler 2- In Blackjack, double down and win 5 times)- Finished.

 

Random Encounter ( Chain Gang)

Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raider's Saloon Encounter)- Fight

 

 

 

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 3

(Clemson Point)

1:30pm

 

Micah- Five Finger Fillet

Dialogue (Excuse me, If I slip and stab you in the Face)-

Dialogue (Karen/Bill- Bank Robbery in Valentine. Karen learned in Chapter 2)

 

Talk to Strauss- Money lending.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 4

6am

 

Lemoyne Raider Camp- outside Rhodes.

 

(Rhodes)

8am

 

Money lending: (Gwyn Hughes)- Use the Badge to block the cemetery entrance.

 

(Caliga Hall)

 

Grays (The Course of True Love 1)

Beau (The Course of True Love 2)

 

(Clemson point)

 

4:30pm

Spoiler

Challenge (Weapon Expert 2- Kill 3 Enemies in 10 seconds using only throw knives)- Finally, Poison throw knives worked on Lemoyne Raiders. Regular throw knives didn't work on chickens, Lawman, or Odriscolls in Chapter 2.

 

Random Encounter (Fleeing Trespassers- Caliga Hall)

Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raider Encounter- Town)

Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raider Wagon Robbery)

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

 

Cigarette Card (1. Vista, Scenery, & Cities of America Set- New York)- SE Caliga Hall. Front porch of 2nd shack.

Cigarette Card (1. Artists, Poets, and Writers set- Edith Corinne)- SE side of Brathwaite Manor under table near clothesline.

 

 

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 5.

6am

 

Read Journal, Newspapers/ 44-45 (Cornwall CO Expanding)

 

Javier (Fishing)

 

Molly ( A Honest Mistake)

1:15pm

 

Dialogue (Lawmen/Fishing)

(Bank Wagon- Cornwall)

(Barn/Abandoned Compson Stead)

Spoiler

Debt in Camp box

$1.00 to $5.00 items. Cash $5.00

 

Upgrade Chicken Coop.

 

(Hill Haven Ranch) 11:30pm

Hunt 3 star Cow- Lasso/Knife

 

Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raider- Rifle Practice)

 

Camp Craft: Lean to cow hide ground cover/main fire

 

 

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6

6am

 

Dialogue (Tilly)

Dialogue (Bank Wagon-Cornwall)

Dialogue (Dutch and Molly starts to Argue)

 

Sean (House Robbery- Lonnie's Shack)

 

Stranger (He's British of Course )- North of Pleasence - 11:30am

Stranger (He's British of Course 2) Larned Sod- 12:30pm

 

Pick/eat( Evergreen Huckleberry) - Kamassa River-NW Caliga Hall.

Pick Sage, Milkweed, Tobacco, Ginsing- Ringneck Creek, Old Greenback Mill-Scarlett Meadows.

 

Spoiler

Challenge (Herbalist 2- Pick/eat 4 Different Berries)- Finished

Challenge (Herbalist 3- Craft 7 Items using Sage-2/7)- Started

 

Random Encounter (Escort)- Take to Lagras.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (2. Prominent Americans- President Harden)- Lagras House near water with 2 broken wagon wheels.

Cigarette Card (3. Prominent Americans- Lillian Powell)- Pleasence, rightside of barn in bushes.

 

 

 

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7.

6am

 

Margaret ( He's British of Course 3) NW Caliga Hall

 

(Emerald Ranch)

12pm

Margaret (He's British of Course 4)

Stranger (Arcadia for Amateurs 3)-1:30pm

 

Central Union Railroad (Stage 2- Cornwall men) -Elysian Pool. 4:30pm

----------------------------------------------------

Day 8 -9

Margaret (He's British of Course 5)

 

Spoiler

Larned Sod- Hunt 4 goats-Lasso/knife

Hunt Coyotes

 

(Fence)

Sell $6.00 to $300.00 Items

Craft- Lion's Paw Trinket

 

Elysian pool trapper: Sell  2 goat pelts, coyote pelt.

 

(Butcher Creek-Elysian Pool) -I don't talk to people.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (4. Gunslingers set- The Butcher Brothers)- Barrel shack porch

Cigarette Card (1. World Champions set- Greco Roman Wrestler- Percy Wood) - Well  outside SE shack.

 

Kamassa River-McLean's Ranch

Hunt Black Bear

 

Trapper: Sell Bear pelt

Buy- The Night Wrangler Trapper Outfit

 

(Gutherie Farms)- Night

Hunt 3star OX- Lasso/Knife

 

(Southfield Flats- Robard Farm)

Dead bodies- Take all. Follow Blood trail outside. Loot body. Take Letter.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (1. Stars of Stage- Lawrence Dunn)- Mantel Piece. 

 

Random Encounter (Execution- Lemoyne Raiders- Night)

 

 

Donate: meat, pelts in camp.

 

------------------------------------------------------------

Day 9

9am

 

(Clemson Point)

 

Dialogue (Susan/Dutch- Molly)

 

Lenny ( Preaching Forgiveness as he Went)

 

Dialogue (Dutch and Hosea got Arthur hunting Hillbilly gold- not done yet)

Dialogue ( Met Lemoyne Raiders on a supply run with Sadie)

(Arthur forget to mention, Lemoyne Raiders buying Monshine from Brathwaites, Dutch, Bill, Arthur with the Deputy)

 

Follow Lenny- Bolger Glade/Abandoned Church

 

(Shady Belle)

Dialogue (Hosea/the Ladies put on Acting show, not Lenny).

Dialogue ( Sean's- Train Robbery, House Robbery)

 

(Clemson Point)

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 10

6am

 

Kieran (Fishing)

Dialogue (Kieran doesn't want to leave the camp, Afraid the Odriscolls might get him)

Dialogue (Legendary Fish)

 

Stranger (Fisher of Fish 1) Gill's Landing

Legendary Fish map.

10am

 

Plant Pick- Burdock Root

 

(Lagras)

Spoiler

Bait Shop- Buy worms, crickets, all Special Lures for Legendary Fish

 

Random Encounter (Naked Swimmer)

Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raider- Prison Wagon)

Random Encounter (Lemoyne- Snake Bite)

Random Encounter (Drunk Camp- Night)- Dialogue (Fort Riggs)

 

(Gutherie Farms)- Night- Hunt  Ox

 

Donate Camp- Meat- Fish, Pelt

Craft- Arthur's Lodging- Ox Hide Rug

$1.00 to $5.00 Items- Cash  $300.00- For Camp Updgrading

Ledger- Dutch's Tent

 

Kieran (Camp Request- Burdock Root)- Give

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 11

7am

 

( Rhodes)

(Give the Rally time to gather)

(Gave time to Beau's cousins to hear about the Rally)

(Forbidden Love)

 

Beau Gray ( The Course of True Love 3)-2pm

 

Dialogue (Brathewaite got a daughter, nobody seen her in years)

Dialogue (Yankee Gold, nothing but a story)

 

(Bolger Glade)

 

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Cigarette Card (5. Gunslingers- Flaco Hernandez)- Bank roof.

 

Lemoyne Raider Camp

Random Encounter ( Hostage Rescue)- lawman

Random Encounter ( Safe Crack- Lemoyne)

Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raider- Road Ambush)

 

Places of Interest (Abandoned Church)

Cigarette Card (1. Amazing Inventions-Steam Locomotive 1814-George Stephenson)- Birds nest.

 

Places of Interest (Bolger Glade)

Cigarette Card ( 2. Fauna of America-Bloodhound)- Ruined fire place.

 

Camp overnight

Hunt Panther- Springfield rifle/poison Arrows

Hunt Deers

 

Camp- Donate meat, pelts

 

Craft: Scout Fire/Ground Cover

Molly (Camp request- Mirror)

 

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------

Day 12

11am

 

Dialogue (Abigail- John need to talk)

Abigail (Advertising the New American Art 1)

 

Change outfit: Ruffian

 

Hosea (Advertising the New American Art 2) - 2:30pm

 

(Arthur's Badge gone from shirt)

Dialogue (Hosea- Finally sold the Cornwall Bonds from Chapter 1)

Dialogue (Hosea- Bloodbath in Valentine)

 

(Brathwaite Manor-Rhodes) Clock stopped at 2:57pm in Rhodes.

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Clemson Point)

9pm

Change outfit: Innocent

 

Arthur's horse disappeared from camp , it took a while to whistle the horse back.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 13

 

Hosea (The Fine Joys of Tobacco)-- 12-2am

 

(Caliga Hall Barn) 3-5am

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 13

(Clemson Point)

 

Change outfit.

 

(Rhodes)

 

Stranger (No Good Deeds)

Stranger ( The Iniquities of History)

 

(Compson Stead)

Stranger (The Iniquities of History 2)

 

(Central Union Railroad) Stage 3.

 

Spoiler

Hunt panthers- Springfield Rifle/ poison arrows- SE Brathwaite Manor path.

 

Random Encounter (Snake Bite-Consequence)- Rhodes General Store- Buy- The Gambler most expensive outfit.

Random Encounter (Poisoned)

 

 

(Hill Haven Ranch)- Night

Hunt Cow

 

(Elysian pool Trapper)

Sell Pelts

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 14

 

(Clemson Point) - 8am

 

Spoiler

Donate meat

$1.00 to $5.00 items- Cash $200.00 For Upgrading

 

Ledger: Mining Tools, Restock Red Wagons

 

Craft: Tonic, Ingredients, Kit Satchels

Arthur's Bed- Cougar covered chest, Boar skin table cover

 

Camp Table- Pronghorn table top

Main Camp fire- Snake Banjo cover

 

Jack (Camp Request-Thimble)- Give.

 

(SE Path Brathwaite Manor)

Hunt Deer, Badger, Panther

Pick American Ginsing

 

Challenge (Weapon Expert 3- Kill 3 Birds with Tomahawk)- Finished

 

Camp:

Had to wait, Couldn't give Jack the Thimble.

Donate meat, Deer Pelt.

 

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 15

 

(Liked to wait for couple of days to head back to Caliga Hall, after burning the Tobacco Fields)

 

John ( Horse Flesh for Dinner)

10am

 

Dialogue (That was you Burning the Fields)

Dialogue (Sean was a pig in sh*t)

Dialogue (Tavish Gray- Gold)

---------------------------------------------------------

Day 16

(Clemson Point)

8am

 

Dialogue (Gray Family)

Dutch (Magician of Sport)- 3pm

 

Spoiler

9am

Hunting Deer, Panther, Coyote,

Pick Sage.

 

Murder Scene 2- SE Brathwaite Manor path- Take note from head.

 Challenge (Herbalist 3- Craft  7 items with sage- 3/7)

 

Random Encounter ( Moonshiners)

 

Camp Fishing: Steelhead Trout-Worms

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 17

12pm

 

Dialogue (Dutch/John- I will never leave you son- lair)

Dialogue (Dutch/John- Jack)

Dialogue ( Charles threw Micah to ground)

Dialogue( Dutch/Susan tells Arthur, why he in camp all the time)( Arthur needs a break)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 18

 

10am

Bill (Sodom? Back to Gomorrah)

Ride to Valentine

 

Dialogue (Valentine)

Dialogue (Karen/Lenny came along)

Dialogue (Cornwall)

Dialogue ( How you feel, Lenny)

Dialogue (Drunken Harlot)

 

(Downes Ranch)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 19

(Clemson Point)

 

Trewlawny (Friends in Low Places)- 12:30pm

 

Spoiler

Hunting- SE path Brathwaite Manor- 9am

 

 Random Encounter (Lemoyne Raiders-Train Robbery)

Random Encounter (Rally Ceremony-Night)

 

Challenge (Master Hunter 4- Call an Animals and get 5 clean kills)- Finished.

 

(Hill Haven Ranch)- Night- Hunt Cows.

 

(Elysian Pool trapper)

Sell all pelts

Buy- Panther Trail saddle

 

(Emerald ranch)

Sell $6.00 to $300.00 items

Pay all bounties

 

(Stables)

Equip- Panther trail Saddles

 

 

 

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 20

(Clemson Point)

 

Sean (Coach robbery)- 9am

 

Alden (Coach Robbery 1)-Rhodes

------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 21

Bill (Coach Robbery)-  Had to Wait.

 

Alden (Coach Robbery 2)

Spoiler

Camp Box- $1.00 to $5.00 Items.  Cash $300.00 For Upgrading

Ledger: Arthur's Bed, Restock Red Wagons

 

Bill (Camp Request- Hair Pomade)- Give

 

--------------------------------------------------------------

Day 22

 

Alden (Coach Robbery 3) -12:30pm

Spoiler

6am

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
(Dinosaur Bone 1 -SE Heartlands- north of train tracks/Gill Landing)

(Place of Interest: Trading Post)-Nw of Gill Landing. Look at ceiling for cheat code. Take Stuff.

(Dinosaur Bone 2)- NE from Trading post-SE Heartlands.

(Dinosaur Bone 3)- SE Heartlands- Oil Derrick.

(Place of Interest: Oil Derrick SE Heartlands) Take Items.

 

SE Heartlands- Bottle Tree-Gold Nugget.
(Odriscolls Camp-SE Heartlands)- Kill/Loot Take all.

 

(Dinosaur Bone 4)- Dewberry Creek- North of Old Greenback Mill.
(Dinosaur Bone 5)- Dewberry Creek- South from last bone.

 

(Places of Interest- Warped Tree)- Larned Sod
(Places of Interest- Register Rock)- NW Larned Sod.

 

(Emerald Ranch)- Send Mail.

 

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 23/24

Spoiler

(Clemson Point)
Cross Lake to Small Island. West of Clemson Point.
  Hunt (3star Green Iguana)- Varmint Rifle

 Hunt other Animals

(Ship Wreck)
Item (Tricorn Hat)
Camp; Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save
 

Random Encounter (Rally Setup).

Random Encounter ( Rhodes Town Burial)

Random Encounter (Arms Deal)

 

(Clemson point)

 

Donate Iguana, meat.
Craft: Material Satchel
Pick Bulrush.
 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 25/26

 

(Peacemakers is only main mission left on map)
(Micah can sit in the chair for a long time, I don't care)
(Micah can't yell at anybody in camp now)

 

Going Hunting/ Collecting/ Fishing out West/NW/ North/NE

 

Gunslingers (Emmit Granger)

Sadie ( Camp request- Harmonica)

 

Spoiler

Hunting Request ( Chipmunk, Opossum, Robin, Oriole)- It took a while to a Robin.  Dakota River/Upper Montana.

Picked plants.

Camp Craft:

Challenge ( Herbalist 3- Craft 7 items use Sage- 4/7)

 

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 26
Continue Hunting.
(Strawberry)

8pm
Room, Eat, Drink, Sleep Save.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 27

(Strawberry)

6am

 

Dialogue( General Store Clerk- At least the jail fixed now)

 

Hector (Coach Robbery 1)

Stranger (Mayor)

Five Finger Fillet.

Bounty (Joshua Brown)-Arthur better at Duel, than John.

 

 

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (2. Artists Set-Elsie Rose)2nd Floor Hotel .

 

Challenge ( Gambler 3- Win  Games of Five Finger Fillet)- Finished

 

Day 28-31

Hunting Owanjilla Lake, Black Bone Forest.

Spoiler

Second try getting Beavers. Beavers pelts disappeared from Arthur's Horse in Chapter 2.

 

(Trapper)

Buy Outfits- Mountain Man and The Wrangler.

 

Challenge (Master Hunter 5- Skin 3 Black/Grizzly Bears)- Started.

 

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 32

 

Hector (Coach Robbery 2)

 

Spoiler

(Appleseed Timber CO)

(Micah's Little Camp)

 

Take Blackwater robbery clipping, Dutch's Wanted poster, other stuff.

 

(Pinkertons or Odriscolls gave Micah Dutch's Wanted poster)

(Micah Wanted to go to Blackwater from Strawberry)

(Pinkerton's likely offer to Micah, Micah Refuses for now)

 

(Lenora View Cabin)

Talk to man looking over edge. Go down. Loot body. Photo.

Back to cabin. Take letter.

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 33

 

Hector (Coach Robbery 3)

Stranger (Mad Preacher- River)

Money Lending (Winton Holmes)

 

Spoiler

Owanjilla Lake)
Save.
Places of Interest (Faces in Trees)
Places of Interest (Whale Bones)
Places of Interest (Pagan Ritual)
Places of Interest (Obelisk)

Treasure Hunt- (Landmarks of Riches 1)- Started.

Trapper: Sell only Wolf/ Bear/ Cougar Pelts.
Camp: Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 34

Spoiler

Legendary Fish Map- First 3 is in New Austin.
4. Legendary Fish (Smallmouth Bass)- Special Lake Lure. -Owanjilla Lake.

(Strawberry)

Post Office- send mail.

 

(Mount Shann)
Places of Interest (Giant Skeleton Remains)

(Little Creek River)
Save.

 

Places of Interest (Devil's Cave)
Talk Hermit.

 

Places of Interest (Crashed Airship)

Places of Interest (Stilt Shack)
Take stuff, Sleep if want. Save. Eat, Drink.

 

Places of Interest/Stranger ( Hermit Woman)
Talk, Kill/Loot, Kill Dogs. Take Stuff.
Item- Torn Treasure Map

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 35

Spoiler

(Mount Hagen)
Places of Interest (Frozen Settler)
Item: Morion Helmet.

 

(Lake Isabella)
Save
Hunt Moose
(Trapper)
Sell Pelt.

(Lake Isabella)
Save.
Legendary Animal Map:
6. Legendary White Bison. Use Springfield Rifle

(Trapper)
Sell Pelt.

(Lake Isabella)

Camp: Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

Day 36

Spoiler

Hunt Coyotes
(Trapper)
Sell Coyote pelts.
Buy: All Night Wrangler Outfit.

 

(Cairn Lake)
Save.
Gunslinger (Flaco Hernandez)
Talk, Duel, Take Photo, Take Gun.
Take Items.
Treasure Hunt (Poisonous Trail 1)- Started.
Special Tonic/ Ginsing Elixer.

 

(Lake Isabella)
Save.
Legendary Fish Map
5. Legendary Fish (Sockeye Salmon)- Special Lake Lure.

 

(Train Station) (Wallace)
Send Mail- Collect mail.
(General Store)

Dialogue (Some Gang cleaned out the bank in Valentine)
Buy Food, Booze, Meds, Horse.
Save.

 

Travel north of Cattail pond.
(Clawson's Rest Shack)
Take Stuff.
Jack (Camp request-Otis Miller and the Arabian Prince)

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (2. The World Champions set-Billards-Edwin A.Rowe)- Window sill.

 

(Window Rock)
Save.
Places of Interest (Strange Statues Painting)

(Cabin)(Dobb's Bluff)
Item (Hunter Hunchet)
Take All. Gold Nugget. Dead Bodies.
Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 37

Spoiler

(Cumberland Forest)
Use RDR2map.com/Official Strategy Guide map
Rock Carving 3- NW C-Cumberland Forest near Edge.

 

(Valentine)
(General Store)
Dialogue (Blood bath Valentine-Cornwall should handle his own mess)

Buy Food, Booze, Horse, Meds.
Save.

Use RDR2map.com/ Official Strategy Guide map.
Cigarette Card ( 4. Prominent Americans- Leviticus Cornwall)- House Front Porch- I =Valentine.

 

(Whinyard Strait)
Behind Waterfall.
Item (Nevada Hat-Letter)
Fish will fall from waterfall. Take Fish.
Save.

(Cotorro Springs)
Legendary Animal Map
7. Legendary Animal (Wolf)- Springfield.

 

(NE Trapper-Elysian Pool)
Sell Wolf pelt.

 

(Bacchus Station)
Camp-Eat,drink, sleep, save

 

 

Day 38

Spoiler

(Bacchus station)
Follow path between Fort Wallace and Bacchus Station. Go up hill.  See two trees. Follow path between 2 trees.
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com- Save.
Rock Carving 4

 

Follow rocky path from rock carving. Jump over and down.
Treasure Hunt (High Stakes Treasure)
Challenge (Explorer 7-Find a Treasure)-Finished

 

(O'creaghs Run)
Save. Legendary Animal Map.
8. Legendary Bear- Use Springfield rifle.
Challenge (Master Hunter 5- Skin 3 Black or Grizzly Bears)- Finished.

 

(NE Trapper-Elysian Pool)
Sell Bear pelt.
Save.

 

(South of Moonstone Pond)
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2 map.com
Rock Carving 5- Rock plateau.

 

(Martha's Swain Cabin) Three Sisters
Take letter, Stuff.
Molly (Camp Request-Pocket Mirror)
Item (Rusted Hunter Hachet)

 

(Osman Grove Cabin)- East of Emerald Ranch.
Dead bodies.
Mary-Beth ( Camp Request-Pen)
Item (Otis Miller and the Black Hearted Lady).
Take Stuff.

 

(Emerald Ranch)
Fence- Sell- $6.00 to $500.00 items.
Craft: Wolf Heart tricket

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (3. World Champions set-Pugilist-Theobaud Getzin)- Emerald Ranch Saloon Front Porch.

 

(Dakota River-Horseshoe)
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, save

 

Day 39

Spoiler

Legendary Fish Map.
6. Legendary Fish (Chain Pickeral)- Special River Lure.

 

(Wallace Station)
Send mail-Recieve Mail.

 

(Watson Cabin)
Check on old lady. Take stuff.

 

(Black Bone Forest)
Hunt Cougers- Use Bow.
Challenge (Master Hunter 6- Kill 5 Cougars with bow and skin them)-Started.

 

(Trapper)
Sell cougar pelt.
(Cattail Pond)

Hunt Elk.

 

(Clemson Point)
Eat,Talk, Drink, Sleep save. Shave 1/10 length.

Donate Elk pelt, Racoon, Beavers. meat
Craft: Kit Satchel, Provisions Satchel, Valuables Satchel, Legend of the west satchel.
Craft: Campfire Seat Cover

 

Jack (Camp Request-Comic Book)- Give
Mary-Beth (Camp Request- Pen)- Give
Molly (Camp Request-Mirror)-Give
Sadie(Camp Request- Harmonica)-Give

Debt money in box
$1.00 to $5.00 items- Cash $300.00, for upgrading

Upgrade: Lodgings for all. Restock red wagons.

 

 

Day 40

 

(Clemson Point)
Save.
Micah (Blessed are the Peacemakers)- 12:30pm
Dialogue (Micah's Plan)
(Pinkerton's Offer to Colm Odriscoll)
(Arthur gets captured-Odrisscols)

 

(Lone Mule Stead)
(Arthur Coughs- maybe- injured, TB, Dust/Dirt, Smoking)

 

 

Spoiler

(Rhodes)
Post Office- Recieve mail.
Buy Newspaper

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/ RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (5. Prominent Americans set- J.D. Mcknight)- Gazebo in frontyard of house with white pillers. Across from Saloon.

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 54

(A Few Weeks Later)

 

7:30am
Save, Talk, eat, drink. Shave 1/10 length.

 Change Outfit: Brawler- didn't want to use Arthur's summer outfit. Big shootout in Rhodes soon.
Outfit- Winter-on horse, Gunslinger-on horse.

 

(Arthur will antagonize, Micah alot more now)

 

Bill (A Short Walk in a Pretty Town)- 9am
(Rhodes)
Dialogue (Security)
Dialogue (Steal Horses for Them)
Dialogue ( Keep on deal with them, until we find this gold)

 

Kill all. Death of Sean. Save Bill. Kill Sheriff Gray.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Save-
(Clemson Point)
6pm
Outfit- Brawler.

 

Dutch ( Bloods Feuds Ancient and Modern)
Jack Taken.
Dialogue (No Gold)

(Brathwaite Manor)
Kill All.

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 55
9am
Dutch (Battle for Shady Belle)

 

(Clemson Point)

(Pinkertons showed up)

 

(Shady Belle)
Kill all.
(Saint Denis) 5pm
Follow Dutch.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[jimmyoneshot]

First time commenting here in months. I hope all my old friends from here are all good.

 

I found 2 what I think are new and pretty obscure pieces of dialogue near the start of Chapter 2. Basically right at the start of the Chapter you can speak to Dutch a couple of times. He usually either asks you to get a pipe for him which triggers the Pipe Item Request OR he speaks about how the gang now have money and food and that everyone "needs to keep it coming" OR he talks about how it's nice to be "warm and dry with nobody shooting at me".

 

What i didn't realize is that if you stand there near him after he responds to the 2 last above mentioned dialogues he has further responses to them. In one he tells Arthur to "get out there son" and in the other he says "You should go check on those boys in town. They've been gone a while.". I've made a video of each of them:-
 

 

 

Edited June 13, 2024 by jimmyoneshot

[Dan_1983]

Getting that second response and then going into town with Uncle and the girls might be a great way to start Chapter 2. You can do Americans at Rest straight after Polite Society.

[jimmyoneshot]

On 6/14/2024 at 7:36 PM, Dan_1983 said:

Getting that second response and then going into town with Uncle and the girls might be a great way to start Chapter 2. You can do Americans at Rest straight after Polite Society.

Ye possibly if you like that. Usually I prefer to do Exit Pursued before Polite Society so that there is a horse for Arthur to get back with and I also like to be able to buy a decent horse during Exit so I like to do Social Call before that.

 

I recently have been liking doing Without Sin on the first day too strangely enough as it feels a bit hectic for Arthur having 2 fights in one day ha.

 

For those reasons I've recently been doing Social Call pretty early in Chapter 2. Like this:-

Without Sin

-------------------------

Americans At Rest

-------------------------

Paying A Social Call

First Shall Be Last

(Sean's Party)

-------------------------

Exit Pursued

-------------------------

Polite Society

etc

 

My reasoning is that Exit Pursued is obviously the horse and hunting intro and Polite Society is the Honor and Shop intro so they should be done relatively soon but I like to have a horse for Polite Society and I like to have money for a decent horse.

 

Social Call actually feels pretty good the day after Americans At Rest because at the end of Americans At Rest Dutch sends just Charles and Javier to Blackwater and Bill says "what about me?" to which Dutch responds "Well exactly, what about you?" like he has something planned for Bill. Then the next day during Social Call we see that he has planned the Social Call O'Driscoll camp attack with Bill giving him throwing knives to give to Arthur etc. It also makes sene that Dutch would send just John and Bill too as they would be the only men left in camp at that point with Charles and Javier gone.

Edited June 15, 2024 by jimmyoneshot

[Dan_1983]

On 6/15/2024 at 11:43 PM, jimmyoneshot said:

Ye possibly if you like that. Usually I prefer to do Exit Pursued before Polite Society so that there is a horse for Arthur to get back with and I also like to be able to buy a decent horse during Exit so I like to do Social Call before that.

 

I recently have been liking doing Without Sin on the first day too strangely enough as it feels a bit hectic for Arthur having 2 fights in one day ha.

 

For those reasons I've recently been doing Social Call pretty early in Chapter 2. Like this:-

Without Sin

-------------------------

Americans At Rest

-------------------------

Paying A Social Call

First Shall Be Last

(Sean's Party)

-------------------------

Exit Pursued

-------------------------

Polite Society

etc

 

My reasoning is that Exit Pursued is obviously the horse and hunting intro and Polite Society is the Honor and Shop intro so they should be done relatively soon but I like to have a horse for Polite Society and I like to have money for a decent horse.

 

Social Call actually feels pretty good the day after Americans At Rest because at the end of Americans At Rest Dutch sends just Charles and Javier to Blackwater and Bill says "what about me?" to which Dutch responds "Well exactly, what about you?" like he has something planned for Bill. Then the next day during Social Call we see that he has planned the Social Call O'Driscoll camp attack with Bill giving him throwing knives to give to Arthur etc. It also makes sene that Dutch would send just John and Bill too as they would be the only men left in camp at that point with Charles and Javier gone.

The order I suggested isn't a way I would normally start Chapter 2. Just an idea. I haven't played the game in almost a year, so talking about it might get me installing it again and playing haha.

 

Who is Not Without Sin is usually the first mission I do in Chapter 2 as I think checking out what Swanson is doing would be top of Arthur's priorities because he's an addict. Plus it gives me a few hours to hunt near camp for food and collect a few other things nearby too.

 

I agree that Polite Society is better after Exit as the stables are open and you can collect your horse from there post mission. This is when I'll usually do Good Honest Snake Oil. With Exit, I do not need horse funds as I have both the Thoroughbred or the War Horse. I head canon that Arthur agreed a swap plus cash for the large shire horse haha.

 

Paying a Social Call straight after Americans at Rest might be good. However I believe Arthur's top priority would be to head to Blackwater and meet up with Javier and Charles as soon as he can get there. However if I arrive at camp after Americans at Rest and it's still around 3 or 4 pm, I usually start the debt collecting missions and just go and get Wrobel's debt and ride out towards Blackwater in the morning.

 

[Tkayyy1018]

So I’ve recently come across this thread. Played thru a few years back just now doing my first 100% run. After reading thru this thread and looking into this is what I came up. 
 

day 1- talk to Dutch for pipe request,

Limphany gold bar/hunting/rob prospector

go up the hill on the other side rob the treasure map fella

who is without sin

Back at camp I sit by the fire and Grimshaw asks what it’s like. Arthur will say there’s food to eat and fools to rob(relevant to hunting and all that glitters)

hang around camp a bit maybe more hunting and dinosaur bones

 

Day 2-coffee and chores, hunting, Pearson trapper dialogue, treasure map

 

day 3-4 - i do exit pursued, I looted literally everyone and everything beforehand so I have just enough for the standardbred. For me hunting the bear is neither here nor there

 

day 5- I do polite society, steal the horse, return the horse. Again either works for Arthur’s character. Americans at rest. Bath and rent a room then good honest snake oil(sheriff likely saw you beat the brakes off Tommy and you don’t hire a saint to catch a sinner)

 

day 6- I go over to the other saloon, talk to Levin for gunslingers, order some food and head out for first shall be last. 
 

this is as far as I’ve gotten so far if there’s any plot holes or suggestions I’d be happy to hear them!

edit: if you still don’t have enough after looting/jack hall 1/ and selling the shire horse I GUESS you could break immersion a bit and slide to Rhodes and sell the gold bar. Not my favorite thing to do but it is an option

 

Edited June 24, 2024 by Tkayyy1018

[Tkayyy1018]

On 1/13/2024 at 11:02 AM, JB1982 said:

Got a few thoughts on Pouring Forth Oil that may need considering when deciding where to fit this into a playthrough:

• Ahead of the robbery Arthur tells Sean that he might as well take Micah along.
• Arthur says that the law has already found him near camp after the robbery when they discuss how quickly the law showed up at the train.

This suggests to me that An American Pastoral Scene needs to be completed so that Micah is back in camp as it wouldn't make sense for Arthur to say this if Micah is still in jail in Strawberry or in his self imposed exile directly after as he would be unavailable (even though I personally don't think Arthur would choose to take Micah anywhere!). It also suggests that Arthur has taken Jack fishing in A Fisher of Men and encountered the Pinkerton's. Depending on how you play, you may need to do things before starting this one or splitting it up (one of the advantages of it having four stages).

I tried doing pastoral scene somewhat early in chapter 2 and then in chapter 3 Dutch approaches mocha and says “so you’re back” and they talk ab the strawberry incident leading me to believe Dutch hasn’t had the chance to really speak to Micah yet. I thought it would be weird Micah was in horseshoe for days and Dutch doesn’t speak to him until chapter 3

[Dan_1983]

12 hours ago, Tkayyy1018 said:

So I’ve recently come across this thread. Played thru a few years back just now doing my first 100% run. After reading thru this thread and looking into this is what I came up. 
 

day 1- talk to Dutch for pipe request,

Limphany gold bar/hunting/rob prospector

go up the hill on the other side rob the treasure map fella

who is without sin

Back at camp I sit by the fire and Grimshaw asks what it’s like. Arthur will say there’s food to eat and fools to rob(relevant to hunting and all that glitters)

hang around camp a bit maybe more hunting and dinosaur bones

 

Day 2-coffee and chores, hunting, Pearson trapper dialogue, treasure map

 

day 3-4 - i do exit pursued, I looted literally everyone and everything beforehand so I have just enough for the standardbred. For me hunting the bear is neither here nor there

 

day 5- I do polite society, steal the horse, return the horse. Again either works for Arthur’s character. Americans at rest. Bath and rent a room then good honest snake oil(sheriff likely saw you beat the brakes off Tommy and you don’t hire a saint to catch a sinner)

 

day 6- I go over to the other saloon, talk to Levin for gunslingers, order some food and head out for first shall be last. 
 

this is as far as I’ve gotten so far if there’s any plot holes or suggestions I’d be happy to hear them!

edit: if you still don’t have enough after looting/jack hall 1/ and selling the shire horse I GUESS you could break immersion a bit and slide to Rhodes and sell the gold bar. Not my favorite thing to do but it is an option

 

If I visit a fence early, it's the one in Van Horn as it doesn't break immersion and it's located in the same state. Plus robbing the Van Horn mansion is a good way to make some easy money early.

 

I avoid Rhodes until it's introduced in Chapter 3 and the same goes for Saint Denis in Chapter 4.

Edited June 25, 2024 by Dan_1983

[Tkayyy1018]

3 hours ago, Dan_1983 said:

If I visit a fence early, it's the one in Van Horn as it doesn't break immersion and it's located in the same state. Plus robbing the Van Horn mansion is a good way to make some easy money early.

 

I avoid Rhodes until it's introduced in Chapter 3 and the same goes for Saint Denis in Chapter 4.

NICE, never thought ab that I really hated going to Rhodes that early. Like I’d go there and literally not stop for anything or anyone bc I like to save it for ch 3-4. 

[Tkayyy1018]

Has anyone tried doing all the gangs missions in chapter 3 before the fued missions? With the exception of like new south and AD..Gang missions as in honest mistake forgiveness, sodom, and peacemakers. just feel like the break after peace makers is too long until a short walk.. bill mentions doing security work in his coach robbery. Said robbery isn’t available after peacemakers.. so then it’s 2-3 weeks until he follows thru with it??

 

so maybe fitting peacemakers somewhere in the middle of the chapter rather than the end? Just a thought gimme some feedback @Psycho18 you ever try a playthrough this way ? 

Edited July 4, 2024 by Tkayyy1018

[Psycho18]

I been Busy. Here is Chapter 4.

 

I didn't see  many new Random Encounters. Saw many repeated ones.

 

(Chapter 4- Saint Denis)
Save
Day 1
(Shady Belle) 5pm

 

(Saint Denis)

Stranger (Fundraiser)- 6:30pm

 

(Shady Belle)

Dialogue (Swanson-Ghost in Swamp)

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Hostage Rescue)- Crayfish Willies

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 2.

 

(Shady Belle)

 

(Gave Dutch sometime to look around)

(Dutch been in the Bastille Saloon)

(Clock Fast forward to morning)

 

Angelo Bronte ( The Joy of Civilization) 7am

 

Dialogue (Dutch, will get John. Arthur has time to spare)

(Next mission, best start at 9pm)

 

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Piss Pot-Town)

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (3. Fauna of North America set- Blue Bird)- Tree Platform- Watchtower/ Clingman Cabin. On map- south of (V)= Hanover.

 

(Saint Denis)
Save. 3pm.
Cigarette Card (6. Prominent Americans set-Luther Covington)- SW Saint Denis on Pier.
Cigarette Card ( 7. Prominent Americans set- Harvey Griggs)- SW Saint Denis, Trainyard red Building under stairs.
Cigarette Card (2. Breeds of Horses set-Appaloosa)- S side Pier of Sant Denis.

Cigarette Card (2. Vistas of America set-Saint Denis)- Saint Denis Post Office, Baggage cart.
Cigarette Card set -Vistas of America-. Next 3 in New Austin. John will finish)

 

Cigarette Card (2. Amazing Inventions set- Camera-1814-Joseph Nicephone Niepce)- NE Saint Denis Photo Studio Backyard Balcony.
Cigarette Card (8. Prominent Americans set-Henrietta Beatrice Woods)- NE Saint Denis, North of Cemetery, Front porch of red wooden house.
Cigarette Card (4. Fauna of North America set- Catfish)- NW Saint Denis Sitting Pier.

(Saint Denis)

9pm

Dutch ( Angelo Bronte, Man of Honor)- Clock fast forward to 9pm and stops.
Follow Dutch. (Arthur is coughing a little)

 

(Shady Belle)

Party.

Dialogue (Dutch-Tahiti)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 3.

 

Mary Linton (Fatherhood and other Dreams 1)
Read Letter.

(Saint Denis)
Stranger (Gavin's Friend)

 

Mary Linton (Fatherhood and Other Dreams 2)
Dialogue ( Arthur-Intimidate the kid, similiar to Jimmy Brooks)
Follow Daddy. Chase Coach.

(Lakay)
(Saint Denis)
Show.
Dialogue ( Arthur- Got some people to take care of first. Wonder who? Maybe, John,Abigail and Jack)

 

Spoiler

Box: Cash-$500.00

Camp Upgrading: Boat- Last One.

 

Random Encounter (Police Chase- Saint Denis)

Random Encounter (Begger-Saint Denis)

 

Hotel- Sleep overnight.

Stranger (Lillian Powell)

 

Buy -Newspaper.

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 4.

Stranger (The Mercies of Knowledge 1)

 

(Shady Belle)

Dialogue (Swanson-Brother Dorkins)

 

Spoiler

(Lakay)

Random Encounter (Injured Rider)- Lakay- Take to doctor in Saint Denis.- Foreshadow of Arthur.

 

Take stuff.
Item: Cat Skull Mask
Item: Skrunken Head in jar.

Use Official Startegy Guide map/ RDR2map.com

 

Cigarette Card (5. Fauna of North America- Coral Snake)- Largest Building.
Cigarette Card (1. Flora of North America- Golden Current)- Shack on shelf.

 

Places of Interest-Tiny Church- NE of Lakay.

Treasure Hunt (Landmarks of Riches 2)
Challenge (Explorer 8-Find a Treasure)

 

Save- Eat, Drink, Brush/ Feed horse.

(Largas)
Use Official Startegy Guide map/ RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (6. Fauna of North America- Grouper)- Wooden Fishing boat.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 5.

Mary-Beth (No,No,and Thrice No)

(Very Similiar to Bounty Hunting)
Dialogue (That Mary girl)
Dialogue (Saw one of the Foreman Brothers, Hasseling Tilly in Valentine)

 

(Radley's House)

 

(Stables-Dewberry Creek)
Save.
Keep Leopard Appaloosa. Rename

Buy- Missouri Fox Trotter- either in Chapter 3 or 4.  Forgot to write it down in Chapter 3 mission order.

 

Spoiler

(Face Rock-Ring neck Creek)

Treasure Hunt (Poisonous Trail 2) -Inside hollow tree.
Challenge (Explorer 9-Find treasure)- Finished.

 

(Gill's Landing)
Save, Eat, Drink, Brush Horse, Feed.
Pick Burdock Root.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (7. Fauna of America- Largemouth Bass)- under couch.

(Rhodes)
Camp, Sleep, Save. Eat, Drink, Feed/Brush Horse.

Challenge (Herbalist 3- Craft 7 items using Sage)- Finally- Finished

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 6.

 

Gunslinger (Billy Midnight)
 

 

(Rhodes)
Save, Pay Bounty.
Bounty (Mark Johnson)

 

Save- 1:21pm
Stranger (The Ties That Bind Us)
Stranger (The Ties That Bind Us 2)

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Spoiler

Challenge ( Sharpshooter 3- Kill 5 Flying Birds from a moving train)- Finished.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 7.

Professor (The Mericies of Knowledge 2)
Alden- Rhodes

Professor (The Mericies of Knowledge 3)

( Bluewater Marsh)
Steal the Wagon.

 

(Saint Denis)
Professor (The Mericies of Knowledge 4)

Police Station.
Stranger (Timothy Donahue)
Save.

Professor (The Mericies of Knowledge 5)

Bounty (Lindsey Woffard)
(Fort Bernnard/Mossy Flats-SW Van Horn)
Kill all. Hogtie.

 

(Saint Denis)
Dialogue (Shady Belle)
Dialogue (Night Folk)

(Police Station)

Room-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save

Stranger (The Artist's Way)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 8.

 

Collecting Day

 

(Van Horn)

(Saloon)

 

Stranger (Smells Liked Grease Paint)
Talk, Fight, Exit.
Save.

 

(House Robbery-Van Horn Mansion)
Kill/Loot. Take All.

 

 

 

Spoiler

Elysian Pool)
Random Encounter (Taunting-Kids- Saint Denis)

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Locked Box 1.- East shore of Elysian pool, under bridge.
Locked Box 2. -Under Wagon SW of  Butcher Creek.
Locked Box 3. -South of Huron Glen-Abandoned wagon.

 

Cigarette Card (2. Flora of America-Hummingbird Sage)- Lying on a small table on western side of shack. SE side Butcher Creek.

Cigarette Card (2. Stars of the Stage-Louis Durand)- Abandoned house west of Van Horn. East porch.
(Last one for Arthur, Next Card of Stars of the Stage set in Tumbleweed- John get the rest)

Places of Interest (Manmade Mutant)

(Fence)
Sell $6.00 to $300.00 Items
Craft: Bear Claw Talisman.

 

Take Missing Person Poster.

 

Travel NW from Van Horn Mansion.

Places of Interest (Serpent Mound)
Treasure Hunt (Poisonous Trail 3) - Steep Hill, Stones pile.
Challenge (Explorer 10-Find Treasure)

 

(Mossy Flats-Fort Bernnard)
Item- Civil War Knife.
Item- Civil War Hardee

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (8. Fauna of America set- Panther )- Inside a hut.

 

Locked Box 4-SE Corner.

 

 

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 9.

Magnifico (The Smell of the Grease Paint 2)

 

Collecting Day.

Gunslinger (Black Belle)

House Robbery (Aberdeen Pig Farm)

 

Spoiler

Locked Box 5- Kamassa River east shore. South Mossy Flats.

Save.

Locked Box 6- Bluewater Marsh- Near Train Tracks- On map, above the R.

Save.
Locked Box 7- Bayou NWA- Stables. NE Saint Denis.
Locked Box 8- Bluewater Marsh. West side of Bridge. Near water. N Pleasance.

 

(Macombs End)
Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (9. Fauna of America- Parrot)- On Pier.

Take All. Eat.

(Pig Farm)
Night: Go Back to House. Find Money behind painting in Kitchen.  Kill Man. Hogtie Women. Bring her to ditch with corpse.
Locked Box 9- South side of house. Small Room .

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 10

Collecting day

(Saint Denis)

 

Charles Chatenay (The Artist Way II)
Talk Trelawny.

Stranger (Sonny)  Kill the man.

 

(Clingman)
Stranger (Captain Russell)

 

(Saint Denis)

Stranger (Anders Helgerson)- NW Park.

 

 

 

Spoiler

Cigarette Card (3. Flora of America-Oleander Sage)- Saint Denis Trelis Railing near vines.Above E-N/ Denis.

Bayou NWA- South of N. (Sonny's House)
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (4. Flora of America-Yarrow)- Inside Window sill
Cigarette Card (5. Flora of America-Tobacco)- Outside on Crate.

 

(Canebreak Manor)
 Cigeratte Card (4. World Champions-Oarsman/H.T. Slocum)- Under Shack on Crate.

 

(Maccleans House)
Cigarette Card(5.World Champions-Cyclist-R.S. Harradon)- Front Porch.

Kill All. Take Stuff.

 

(Clingman)

Cigarette Card (10. Fauna of America- Pheasant)- Up tree Platform.

 

(Emerald Ranch)
Cigarette Card (6. Flora of America- Black Mangrove )- Lying under bench Train Station.

 

(Dewberry Creek-Burned out building)
Cigarette Card (6. World Champions- Walker-E.D. Ewing) -Basement.

 

(Saint Denis)
Cigarette Card (7. World Champions- Lawn Tennis-Patsey Hill)- Back porch of shack

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 11.

(Shady Belle)

Tilly (Camp Request-Necklace)- Give.
Box- $1.00 to $5.00 Items -Cash $100.00

Ledger- Restock Red Wagons.
Dialogue (Susan- I know you been killing innocents folk)( Not me, I was up north

 

(Rhodes)

Bounty (Camille De Millemont)

 

(Saint Denis)

Brother Dorkins (Help a Brother Out)
Stranger (Gavin's Friend)

 

(Pawn Shop)
Enter back door. Go Straight to Book Shelf. Down stairs. Release Prisoner. Go upstairs. Take From Cash Register. Give to Prisoner. Exit. Return to Brother.

 

(Saint Denis- Gunshop Robbery)
Save.
Check backdoor. Mask on. Aim gun at Store clerk. Open door. Knock out clerk. Hogtie 1st guard. Go upstairs.
Hogtie guards. Threaten rest. Open Safe take money and take money from table. Gold Nugget on desk.

 

Spoiler

Random Encounter (Rat Infestation-Saint Denis NE saloon) -Use Small Game Arrows.

 

 

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 12-13

 

Spoiler

6am
Challenge (Bandit 3- Rob the Cash Register in any 4 shops in one day) -Pay bounty after all four.
Saint Denis-General Store, Rhodes-General Store, Valentine-General Store, Wallace Station-General Store.

 

(Strawberry)
Save.
Look in basement window of General Store. Make clerk to open trap door.
(General Store Robbery)

 

(Hunting)(Owanjilla Lake/Black Bone Forest)
2 Wolves/Camp,
Rabbit 6- Trapper.

Pick Parasol and Bay Bolette Mushroom.

Challenge (Master Hunter 6-Kill and skin 5 Cougars with poison arrows and bow)
Challenge (Herbalist 4- Pick 5 Mushrooms and feed them to horse)2/5

 

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep,Save.

(Barrow Lagoon)
Save.
310. Locked Box- South shore. Tree stump.

(Lake Isabella)
312. Locked Box- On cart under large overhang rock.

(Painted Sky)

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (3. Breeds of Horses- Adalusian )- In stable, on shelf.

 

(Firewood Rise)
Cigarette Card (11. Fauna of North America- Snapping Turtle  )- Inside House.
Take Stuff.

(Cotorro Springs)
Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 14

Stranger (To The End of the Earth)

Spoiler

South of train tracks of Cotorro Springs.
(Yellow Train Car)- Save.
Climb up Ledge near Yellow Train.Jump Inside.
Take Gold Bars.

Use Official Startegy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
314. Locked Box- Inside Yellow Train Car.

 

(Donner Falls)(Bacchus Bridge)
Save.
Places of Interest (Barrel Rider)
Fishing-

(Indian Reservation)
350. Locked Box

 

(Calumet Ravine)
Weapon: Ancient Tomahawk

 

(East of Donner Falls)
Save.
Places of Interest (Mysterious Hill Home)
351. Locked Box.

Treasure Hunt (Landmark of Riches 3)

 

(Cave Notrh of Mysterious House)

Entrance to cave is SE of I=Ambarino.
Places of Interest (Strange Statues)
(Puzzle)
Go back to painting on the rock of window Rock. Look at bird painting.
Push bush of statues with numbers of fingers. 2,3,5,7. 7 has missing arm.
Take 3 gold Bars.
2=Statue its back to cave Entrance. 6= right of 2. 7= right of 6. 3=right of 7. 8=right 3. 5=right of 8. 4=right of 5 and 4=left of 2.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 15.

Spoiler

NE Ambarino=shack above o)
(Fairwale Shanty)
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
372. Locked Box.

Cigarette Card (6. Gunslingers set- Slink Grant)
(Last one for Arthur- Next Card for Gunslinger set is in New Austin- Rest for John)

 

(Cornwall Kerosene &Tar)
Cigarette Card (9. Prominent Americans- General Quincy Harris ) Base of Oil Rig.
Cigarette Card (8. World Champions- WeightLifter-William Sleicher )- North end of shack on table on porch.

 

(Valentine)
Save before, reload when lose.
Challenge (Gambler 4- Bust out a oppenent out in each location-Flatneck Station, Saint Denis, Valentine)-1/3- Started.

68. Random Encounter (Rowdy Drunks-Saloon)

 

Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.
Ride around Valentine at Night.

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 16.

(Valentine)

Stranger (Oh Brother)

 

Doctor's Offiice Robbery)
Take money/Gun.
Escape. Pay Bounty.
Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Spoiler

(Flatneck Station)

Save. Poker. Reload if lose.
Challenge (Gambler 4- Bust out a oppenent out in each location-Flatneck Station, Saint Denis, Valentine)-2/3- Started.

 

(New Hanover-Emerald Ranch)

(Larned Sod)

Hunting- Bison- Goats.

 

 

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 17.

 

(NE Elysian Pool Trapper)
Sell-Bison, Goat Pelt

 

Spoiler

(Hani's Brothel-Heartland Overflow)

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (3. Artist- W.G. Hoyt)- Inside school on desk.
(Artists Cigarette Card set- Next one in Blackwater- John will finish)

 

(Emerald Ranch)
Save.
Challenge (Bandit 4- Rob 3 Coaches or Return any 3 to Fence in Day) - Finish. Steal one coach, Loot lock box, Take to Fence. Loot other coach lock box.
Challenge (Bandit 5- Amass $250 bounty in one State)- Finished. Emerald Ranch windmill.
Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 18.

Dewberry Creek)
Stranger (The Ties That Bind Us 3)
Stranger (The Ties That Bind Us 4)

Spoiler

Odriscoll Camp)- Old Trail Rise.

Get on Train.
Challenge (Bandit 7-Rob $50 worth of items from Townsfolk and Travelers)- Finished. Use Train.

Night- Hill Haven Ranch
Save.  Study, Hunt ( Angus Bull-3 star) -Lasso Knife.

 

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save
 Random Encounter ( Camp Attack-Mufrees)

 

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 19.

Spoiler

(Elysian pool Trapper)
Sell- Bull Pelt.
Buy all- Bear Hunter Trapper Outfit.

 

(Emerald Ranch)
Pay Bounty.
Challenge (Bandit 8- Steal 7 Wagons and sell them to the Fence in Emerald Ranch)- Finished.
Camp-Eat, Drink, sleep, Save.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 20.

Spoiler

Save.
Challenge (Bandit 9- Hogtie someone and leave them on railroad 3 times)- Finished.
Challenge (Bandit 10-Complete 5 train robberies without of dying or getting caught)- Finished. -Buy Emerald Ranch-to Riggs train ticket. Mask on, go to Back Frieght Car- Open chest. Take. Jump off. Mask off. Buy other ticket. Riggs to Wallece station. Repeat.
Camp-eat, drink, sleep, save.
Challenge (Survivalist 4- Craft Dynamite, Fire, Improved, Poison, Small Game Arrows )- Finished.

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 21.

(Saint Denis)

Save- Pay Bounty.

Charles Chatenay (The Artist's Way 3)

(Shady Belle)
Eat,Drink,Sleep, save, Shve 1/10 legnth.

 

Spoiler

(Valentine)
Save.
Challenge (Horseman 3- Ride from Valentine to Rhodes in less than five Minutes) -Finished.
(Rhodes)
Save
(Rhodes Gun shop Robbery)
Look in Basement window. Make the clerk open door. Talk kid. Take stuff.

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 22.

Donate meat, wolf pelts.
Craft- Campfire log seat cover.
Dialogue (Mary-Beth)

 

Charles (Rhodes Bank Robbery)

 

 

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy Guide map.RDR2 map.com
311. Locked box Shady Belle- Mausoleum.

Pick Sage-Bullrush. Chantelle Mushroom.
Challenge (Herbalist 4-Pick 5 Mushrooms and feed them to your horse)-3/5

 

Tilly (Camp request-Necklace)-Give.

Fishing: Largemouth Bass- Use Crayfish

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 23.

Save.
(Saint Denis)
Pay bounty
Stranger (Eugenics Proponent) -Take pamphlet. Chase and beat up.
Stranger (A Bright Bouncing Boy)

Save.

Brother Dorkins (Brothers and Sisters, One and All)
Dialogue (Mrs. Downes)
(Arthur- coughs little bit or clearing his throat. Maybe from running or TB)

Pay Bounty- from running from law. Thanks to Mrs. Downes.

 

Save. Show SE Saint Denis. Show NW. (Smell of Grease paint show)
Talk clerk. Take money.

Sleep, Save, Eat, Drink.
Ride around Saint Denis at night.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 24.

Charles Chatenay (The Artist Way 4)
(Arthur enters the Trolley Station)

 

(Shady Belle)
Eat, Drink, Talk, Shave 1/10 length, Sleep, Save.
Pearson (Hunting) -Crayfish- Gator's Eggs

 

 

Spoiler

Poker- Saint Denis.
Challenge (Gambler 4-Bust out one player from Saint Denis, Flatneck Station, Valentine)- 3/3-Finished.
Save. If lose Reload. Leave and come back.

Dominos- Saint Denis.

Challenge (Gambler 5- Win 3 rounds at Dominoes without drawing any tiles against 2 or fewer players)- Finished.
(John will finish Gambler Challenges)

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 25.

110. Study, track, hunt (3star American Alligator)- Springfield Rifle.
111. Study, track, hunt (3star American Alligator- Small)-Repeater or Bow.

 

Craft- Arthur's bed- Alligator Skull.
Camp Crafting- Finished.
Camp Upgrades- Finished.

 

Lenny (Coach Robbery)
Save. Pay Bounty.

______________________________________________________________________________________________-

Day 26.

Uncle (Rustling)- 12-3am

 

(Shady Belle)
Eat, Drink, Sleep until noon, Save.

 

Hosea ( Gilded Cage) 2pm
(Mayor's House)
Talk to people. Help choking man. Talk man on right-take tickets.Pour drinks to ladies on right. Ladies in hat near band. Find Mayor. Follow Servant. Take Letter.
Dialogue (Trolley Station)
Dialogue (Indians)
Dialogue (Mayor)
Dialogue (Cornwall)
Dialogue (Algernon Wasp)
Dialogue (Poker Game)
Dialogue (Bank)

 

(Shady Belle)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 27.

Save, eat, drink, talk.

(Saint Denis)
Algernon Wasp (Duchesses and Other Animal)

Spoiler

(Hagen Orchards)
Take stuff.
Hosea (Camp Request-Shrew in the Fog Book)

 

Exotic List 1 (15 Lady of the Night Orchid)
112. Study, Hunt, pluck (3star Roseate Spoonbill Bird)

 

(Bayall Edge Cabin)
Take Stuff.
Camp, Eat, Drink, sleep, Save.

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 28.

Spoiler

Exotic List 1: (15 Lady of the Night Orchid)
Exotic List 1: ( 5 Little Egret, 5 Reddish Egret, 5 Snowy Egret)- Use Varmint Rifle.

113. Study, Hunt, Pluck (3 star Tricolored Heron)
114. Study, Hunt, Pluck (3 star Little Egret)
115. Study, Hunt, Pluck (3 star Snowy Egret)
116. Study, Hunt, pluck (3 star Great Blue Heron)
117. Study, hunt, pluck (3 star American White Pelican)
118. Study, hunt, pluck (3 star Brown Pelican)
119. Study, hunt, pluck (3star Whooping Crane)

Camp, Eat, drink, sleep,save.

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 29/31.

Takes a long time.

Spoiler

Exotic List 1: ( 5 Little Egret, 5 Reddish Egret, 5 Snowy Egret)- Use Varmint Rifle.
120. Study, hunt, pluck (3 star Reddish Egret)
121. Study, hunt, pluck (3 star Sandhill Crane)
Camp, Eat, drink, sleep, save.

Return to Algernon Wasp.
Save.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 32.

Algernon Wasp (Duchesses and Other Animal 2)

Take a long time to collect.

Spoiler

Exotic List 2: (20 Heron Plumes, 7 Lady's Slipper Orchid, 10 Moccasin Flower Orchid)

 

(Hill Haven Ranch)
Save-Night.
Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (10.Prominent Americans-General Cornelius Palmer)- Cow Pen.

 

122. Study, Hunt, Lasso, Knife (3 star Devon Bull)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 33.

Spoiler

(Elysian Pool)Trapper.
Sell Bull Pelt.
Hunt 2 Boars 3 stars.

 

Treasure Hunt (Poisonous Trail Treasure)- Secret Cave behind Waterfall. Follow path. 1st ledge drop. Follow steep path right. Go through small circle cave entrance. Go right path at fork. Run and Jump off Go down in Water.. Find Boulder.

369. Locked Box.

Exotic List 2 (10 Moccasin Flower Orchid)
Eat and Brush/Feed Horse.

Save.
70. Random Encounters (Murfees Boat Affairs)- Loot corpses drop bodies in Boat.
313. Locked Box- SW Elysian Pool. Shelter. Skeletons.

 

71. Random Encounters (Murfees Road Ambush)
Challenge (Herbalist 4-Pick 5Mushrooms and feed to horse)- Finished.

 

(Van Horn)
Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (12. Fauna of America-Turkey)
(Cigarette Card Set-Fauna of America)- Completed .

 

(Post office)
Recieve Mail.
Send Cigarette Card set-Fauna of America.

 

(Fence)
Sell $6.00-$500.00 Items.

(Pleasance)
Camp, Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.
Challenge (Herbalist 5- Craft 9 Items using Indian Tobacco as an Ingredient)- Started -8/9

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 34/35

Albert Mason (Arcadia for Amateurs 4)

Spoiler

Exotic List 2 (20 Heron Plumes) Save/Reload.
(Lonnie's Shack)
Take All
Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card ( 11. Prominent Americans-Senator Thaddeus Waxman)- Mantle Piece/Fireplace.

Camp: Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Challenge (Survivalist 4- Craft Dynamite, Fire, Inproved, Poison, Small Game Arrows)- Finished.
Challenge (Horseman 4- Drag victim for 3300 feet using lasso from horseback)-Finished.
Challenge (Sharpshooter 4- Kill an Enemy at least 80 feet away with a Tomahawk)- Finished.

Exotic List 2 (20 Heron Plumes) Save/Reload.

Challenge (Horseman 5- Trample 5 Animals while on horseback)- Finished.

 

(Saint Denis trapper)
Sell Boar Pelts.
Buy All: Marauder Outfit.

 

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

 

(Shady Belle)
Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save, Shave 1/10 Length.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 36.

Hosea (Camp Request-Book)- Give.

(Saint Denis)

Native Americans (American Fathers)
Dialogue (Meet Eagle Flies in Citadel Rock in a couple of days)
Dialogue (The Mayor thinks Arthur Robbed him)
(It is time to meet the mayor next Tomorrow Night)

 

Spoiler

(Crawdad Willies)
Take Stuff.
325. Locked Box- Dead Tree, SE Island. Fish Hanging.

71. Random Encounter (Prisoner encounter chained to rock)

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (12. Prominent Americas- President Alfred Macalister)

 

(Post office)
Send Cigarette Card set- Prominent Americans.

(Rhodes)
South of Train tracks.
Item: Gold Bar- 3 rocks near tree.

 

(Abandoned Factory)
Near Train Track-SW Saint Denis.

2nd floor.
Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

 

Places of Interest (Withered Arm)- SE of Abandoned Factory.
East of Abandoned Factory.
Item (Pirate Sword)

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 37.

(Saint Denis)
Save.
Josiah Trelawny (A Fine Night of Debachery)- 3pm
Barber- Shave Length 1/10, Hair cut. Length 2/7- for now.
Tailor-  Suit
Follow.
(Casino Boat)
Play Poker. Don't use Strauss help. Go upstairs. Rob Safe. Escape.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 38.

Save.
(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.

Stranger (Dorathea)

 

(Shady Belle)
Restock Red Wagons -Save

Micah (Coach Robbery) -2pm

(Micah went to the source)
(Micah- you can keep your friend in Rhodes)
Dialogue (Odriscolls this time)
Dialogue (Micah is complaining about the people who don't work and the ladies in camp)
Dialogue (Grab the loot, why, Micah got the lead, and Williamson is a halfwit)

 

(Saint Denis)
Eat, Drink Save
Ride around at Night.
Henri Lemieux (Idealism and Pragmatism for Beginners I)-9pm

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 39.

(Shady Belle)
Dialogue (Mary-Beth ask about Kieran)
Dialogue (Bill- I met this guy in the Swamp, who knows Arthur very well)(Sonny is dead).
Dialogue (Hosea- Bank)
Dialogue (Hosea-Pearson: Talking Tahiti)

 

(In Chapter 3, Kieran says he doesn't want to leave the camp, He is afraid the Odriscolls pick him up)
(Why leave camp in chapter 4?)

 

Sadie (Horseman Apocalypses)
(Micah not in camp after coach robbery)
(No, Bill, Lenny, Javier)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 40.

9am

Save. Eat, Drink, Talk
Shave 1/10 length.

 

(Saint Denis)
Dutch (Urban Pleasures)
(Robbery the Trolley Station)
(Dutch hits his head)
(Tahiti)

 

(Valentine)
Save.
Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.
Ride Around Valentine at night.
Pay Bounty.

 

Jim Boy Calloway (The Noblest of Men and an Woman 2)
Buy Newspaper .

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 41.

Stranger (Oh Brother 2)

Spoiler

Use Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
315. Locked Box- Path south of Wallace Station.

Pick Indian tobacco.
Challenge (Herbalist 5- Craft 9 Items using Indian Tobacco as an Ingredient)- Finished -9/9
Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 41-42.

Spoiler

Hunt Cougars with Bow.
Challenge (Master Hunter 6-Kill and skin 5 Cougars with poison arrows and bow)

 

(Black Bone Forest)
Exotic List 2: ( 7 Lady's Slipper Orchid)

(Owanjilla Lake)
Challenge (Sharpshooter 5-Kill 6 animals without switching or reloading weapon)-Finished.

318.Locked Box. Wreckage Riverbank.
323. Locked Box. Crates on broken wagon south path of Dam.

Item: Stone Hatchet- Burial Site.

(Black Bone Forest Mine)

Item: Wide Blade Knife.
Item: Miner's Hat
Loot: Gold Nuggets .

(Hanging Dog Ranch)
Challenge (Sharpshooter 6-Kill someone a least 660 Feet with a long scope rifle)- Finished.

 

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 43.

Spoiler

(Mount Shann- V-Big Valley)
Use Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
712. Special Tonic/Aged Pirate Rum

Save.
(Post Office)
Recieve Mail.
Ride around Valentine at night.

72. Random Encounter ( Odrisscolls-Rowdy Drunks-Valentine)

Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save. Shave 1/10- Length.

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 44/45

Albert Mason (Arcadia for Amateurs V)

 

Save.
Eagle Flies (American Fathers 2)
Get in Wagon. Exit. Crouch walk in bottom east door. Hide behind stuff on 1st floor. Don't get spotted. Go west on 1st floor. Go up west stairs.
(2nd flr)
Crouch walk along walkway to SE. Enter door.
(Office)
Threaten/Beat up. Search papers. Escape. Kill All.
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

Spoiler

320. Locked Box- SE path of Oil Derrick. Abandoned Wagon.

Use Strategy Guide Map.

 

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
326. Locked Box- Lone Mule Stead, SW of Bard's Crossing.
327. Locked Box- Cumberland Forest, small dead tree atop of rock cliff. Next to Dead man.
Item- Tomahawk- Cumberland Forest on wagon.

 

(Adler Ranch)
329. Locked Box.
Item- Panoramic Map- 2 frozen bodies.

 

(Burned out Settlement-Horseshoe Overlook)

330. Locked Box- Burned out Settlement

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, save.

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 46.

Cumberland Falls)
Save.

Stranger (Oh Brother 3)

 

Moonstone Pond)
Professor (The Mercies of Knowledge 6)
Bounty (Wilson J. McDanials)

 

(Saint Denis)
Save.
Algernon Wasp (Duchesses and Other Animals 3)
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

Spoiler

Use Official strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

331. Locked Box- north cliff of Twin Stack Pass.

 

(Clingman)
332. Locked Box- Under stairs of fire tower.
 

(Flatneck Station)

 

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 47.

Spoiler

(Braithwaite Manor)
Save.
Places of Interests ( Braithwaite Secret- Women locked in outhouse)

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

333. Locked Box- Face dead body. Go left corner.
Item: Brooch- Mrs. Braithwaite body.

Pearson (Camp Request-Compass)

 

(Saint Denis)
Save.
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

 

Jim Boy Calloway (The Noblest of Men and a Woman 3)

 

72. Random Encounter ( Bronte Patrol)

321. Locked Box- NE Saint Denis. Oblong shape shack. Under Floor board. Take Stuff.

 

(Copperhead Landing)
357. Locked Box.

Exotics 3 (25x Gator Eggs, 3x Acuna's Star Orchid, 7x Cigar Orchid, 5x Ghost Orchid)-Has I Travel.
Challenge (Herbalist 6- Pick 15 different species of herb)- Started-1/15

 

(Trapper Cabin-Bluewater Marsh)

73. Random Encounter (Murfees-Inbred Kidnap-Wagon)

Stranger (Ghost of Agnes Dowd)

Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save
Craft- Exploding Shotgun Shells.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 48

(Annesberg)

 

(Arthur needs money)
Jim Boy Calloway (The Noblest of Men and a Woman 4)

Gunslinger (Slink Grant)

 

(Bradywine Drop)
Gunslinger (Jim Boy Calloway) -Take Gun.

 

 

 

 

Spoiler

Exotics 3 (25x Gator Eggs, 3x Acuna's Star Orchid, 7x Cigar Orchid, 5x Ghost Orchid)-Has I Travel.
Challenge (Herbalist 6- Pick 15 different species of herb)- Started

 

(Annesburg)
Save.
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com

Secret ladder of mine. On map. under G-Annesburg.

Cigarette Card (7.Flora of America- Longleaf Pine)- Up 1st ladder.
Cigarette Card (9.World Champions- Pigeon Shooting/Edwin Singerly)- Coal Mining Facility tower.
Cigarette Card (1. Marvels of Travel- Packet Ship)- on Pier.

74. Random Encounter (Domestic Murder)

 

(Bradywine Drop)
702. Special Tonic/ Aged Pirate Rum. -Behind Waterfall.
371. Locked Box.

(Van Horn)
Hotel- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 49

(Saint Denis)
Save.

Professor (The Mercies of Knowledge 7)
(Mayor Lemieux is seen in cutscene)

Train to Valentine.

(Valentine)
Save.

 

Spoiler

334. Locked Box- North of Van Horn. Roadside Brothel.
(Van Horn)

 Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (2. Marvels of Travel- Schooner )- House Boat.

 

Save. (Lannahechee River) (Copperhead Landing)
(Fishing)
(Swamp Fishing-Lakay)

 

(Barrow Lagoon)
Save. Cabin- Take items.
Places of Interest (Defaced Grave)

 

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (10.World Champions-Skater/Felix Hawley)

 

(Clawson Rest)
Save.
Cigarette Card (11.World Champions-Hammer Thrower/Capt. Jack Page)

 

(Cattail Pond)
Fishing- Northern Pike- River Lure.
Camp- Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 50/51

(Saint Denis)

Save.
Algernon Wasp (Duchesses and other Animals 4) - Last visit for Arthur.

 

(Shady Belle)
Eat,Talk, Drink, Save, Shave 1/10 Length.

Pearson (Camp Request-Compass)- Give
Dialogue (Charles-Rains Fall and Son)
Dialogue (Susan- Somebody was running around the country shooting)- 2nd time
(It Wasn't Arthur- it been a long time since seen Random Encounters)
(Arthur was in Van Horn, Annesburg, Valentine, Bayou, Strawberry, Saint Denis)

 

(Saint Denis)
Save. 8pm
Ride Around at night.
Henri Lemieux (Idealism and Pragmatism For Beginners 2)

 

Spoiler

340. Locked Box- Dakota River. NE Diablo Ridge. Wagon under Bridge.

(Black Bone Forest-Trapper)
Kill Cougar.
Buy- All Bandit and Explorer Equipment.

 

354. Special Tonic/- Valerian Root- Rock islet in SW Dakota River-West of Painted Sky.
338. Special Tonic/Ginsing Elixer -Bushes dead tree on islet north Dakota River- NW Valentine.

 

(Rhodes)
Save.
Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (3. Marvels of Travel-Camal Caravan )- Blue House near Saloon. on table and laundry.

 

(Bolger Glade)
Camp-Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.

 

316. Locked Box- Abandoned Church.

 

(Flat Iron Lake)
322. Locked Box- Flatiron Lake big island. Ship Wreck.
716. Special Tonic/ Aged Pirate Rum.

 

(Bolger Glade)
328. Locked Box- Two Wagon wheel, east of Battlefield.
Save.

(Shady Belle)
Exotics 3 ( 5x Ghost Orchid)

 

(Saint Denis)

Use Official Strategy Guide map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (12. World Champions-Club Swinger/Axel McCormack)-  Back courtyard of Bastille Saloon.

 

Post Office)
Recieve Mail.
Send- World Champions Cigarette Card Set.

 

 

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 52.

6am
(Saint Denis)
Save.
Vampire Clues
1. NE Saint Denis. Cross street from Saloon. On Map-Above N-Denis.
2. Gated courtyard right of fence/Trapper. Between I-S in Denis.
General Store- Buy Gun oil. Food, Drink, Horse Treats and Meds. Clean Guns.
3. Behind Butcher/General Store. SE Saint Denis. On outside wall.
4. SE Saint Denis. Alley Soda pop sign-Between Theater/Gunshop. Right courtyard.
5. SE Saint Denis. Alley- Soda pop sign-Look up. Between Theater/Gunshop. Go Straight. Behind Gunshop.

 

NW Show- Free Ticket.
Save.
Henri Lemieux (Idealism and Pragmatism for Beginners 3)
Go to Jean Marc house, Knock him out, Go back to Mayor house. Spare Jean Marc.

Save.

 

Spoiler

(Saint Denis)
Save.
Fishing from Train Tracks. Fishing from boats.
Boat NW Saint Denis Pier.
Challenge (Survalist 5- Catch a fish while boating in the Bayou and while standing on Railroad Track)-Finished.

 

Random Encounter (Random Couple gets Robbed)-Night.

Random Encounter (Bronte Goons)

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 53

Vampire: 12am- Saint Denis Gunshop. Alley east of Church and Gun shop.
Item: Ornate Dagger.

 

Hotel-sleep, save. Eat, Drink.
Fence- Sell $6.00 to $500.00 Items
Buy- High Roller Revolver,

(Post Office)
Recieve Mail

 

(Shady Belle)
Save.
Shave 1/10 Length.
Dialogue (Molly- driving herself crazy on the docks)
Cash Box- $8,000 to 10,000. Don't have much to give this time.

 

Dutch (Country Pursuits) 12pm
Dialogue (Tahiti)
8pm
(Lagras) -Been there before in Freeroam. 1st time in the story.

Dialogue (Dutch-Believe in Micah, more than anybody in camp)
Dialogue (Dutch- Micah has more common sense, than anybody in camp)
Dialogue (Night Folk)
( Huge monster Alligator)
Dialogue (Dutch shoot something, pretend you care)
Dialogue (Thanks, to old uncle Dutch)
(Sounds like Arthur, losing faith in Dutch, already)

----------------------------------------------------------------

Day 54.

Fast Forward)
7am

(Saint Denis)
(Shady Belle)

Eat, Drink, save.

 

Strauss (Money Lending and Other Sins 5)
Dialogue (Tahiti)
(Arthur Coughs)

 

Money Lending (Algie Davidson) -Find him on the beach, West of house.

(Catfish Jacksons)
Don't kill. Take Debt.

Spoiler

Use Official Strategy Guide Map/RDR2map.com
Cigarette Card (4. Breeds of Horses-American Standardbred)- Boy's Room Table-left card.

 

(Small Island- West of Braithwaite Manor)
Item- (Cats eye Tricket in locked Box).

 

(Rhodes)
Save.
Cigarette Card (5. Breeds of Horses-Nokota)- Stable workbench.

 

(Strawberry)
Save.
Cigarette Card (4. Marvels of Travel-Elephant Carriage)- Trackers Hotel wood stairs.

 

(Wallace Station)
Save.
Cigarette Card (6. Breed of Horses-Ardennes)- Train Platform shelf.

 

(Downes Ranch)
Save. Take stuff.
Cigarette Card (7. Breeds of Horse-Dutch Warmblood) House on Fireplace.

 

(Emerald Ranch)
Save.
Cigarette Card (5. Marvels of Travel- Goat Carriage) Stables Back left on bench.

(Saint Denis)

Eat, Drink, Sleep, Save.
77. Random Encounter (Saint Denis Night Alley foot robbery)

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day  55.

Spoiler

Cigarette Card (6. Marvels of Travel-Hot Air Balloon ) NE Saint Denis Saloon on shelf.

 

(Braithwaite Manor)
Save.
Cigarette Card (7. Marvels of Travel-US Frigate)- Boathouse Wooden Table.

 

(Saint Denis)
Save.
Cigarette Card (8. Marvels of Travel-ShowBoat)- SE Dock-Harbor's House. Near Fish on Table.
Cigarette Card (9. Marvels of Travel-Balener Whaling Vessel)- SE Dock-Counter of Ticket Booth.

 

(Riggs Station)
Save.
Cigarette Card (10.Marvels of Travel-Stagecoach)- On Benches at station.

(Clemson Point)
Cigarette Card (11. Marvels of Travel-Steam Locomotive) -North of Clemson Point. Ruins wall of Building.

 

(Saint Denis)
Save.
Cigarette Card (12. Marvels of Travel-Velocipede)- NW Saint Denis. 3rd house East of 2nd E-Lemoyne.

(Post Office)

Send- Cigarette Card Set-Marvels of Travel
Camp- eat,drink, Sleep, Save.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 56.

Save. Take All
(Catfish Jackson-House Robbery) -No body is home. Come back later.
Mask on. Hogtie Father or Kill him.
Take Stash.
(Outside Crawlspace)

Spoiler

(Outside Crawlspace)
713. Special Tonic/Aged Pirate Rum.
335. Locked Box.

 

(Shady Belle)
338. Locked Box- Small shack SE of Belle.
Save. Eat, Drink,

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 57

(Saint Denis)

(Post Office)

Receive Mail .

 

(Lagras) 9pm.

 

Dutch (Reverge is a Dish Best Eaten)

(Death of Angelo Bronte)

(Arthur/John Losing Faith)

 

Spoiler

Challenge (Sharpshooter 7- Get 7 Headshots in a row)-Finished.

Challenge (Weapons Expert 4- Kill 10 Enemies with a shotgun using crafted ammo)

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Day 58.

(House Robbery- Catfish Jacksons)- Maybe.

 

Dutch (Banking , The Old American Art)

(Death of Lenny and Hosea)

(Micah, is wearing white suit-Lair, Rat, and Traitor)

 

 

 

Spoiler

Challenge (Weapons Expert 5- Kill 5 Mounted enemies with Throwing Knives)- Finished.

 

 

Edited July 3, 2024 by Psycho18

[jimmyoneshot]

@Psycho18 That's very in detail mate  Great stuff.

[propanecocaine71]

I've started a new playthrough recently and currently on chapter 2. I feel like without sin would be on the first day but I'm undecided which is directly after that, polite society or Americans at rest. 

[AudaxTenebra]

13 hours ago, propanecocaine71 said:

I've started a new playthrough recently and currently on chapter 2. I feel like without sin would be on the first day but I'm undecided which is directly after that, polite society or Americans at rest. 

Thx to @jimmyoneshot I can never play Polite Society before Americans at Rest again. Bro made me hyperfixate on small details since then lmao. I won't tell you why so I dont ruin it for you too

[propanecocaine71]

On 7/16/2024 at 9:43 AM, AudaxTenebra said:

Thx to @jimmyoneshot I can never play Polite Society before Americans at Rest again. Bro made me hyperfixate on small details since then lmao. I won't tell you why so I dont ruin it for you too

Yeah I feel like it makes sense to play americans at rest before polite society, the dialogue flows alot better ( Arthurs remark "real civilized" works much better than "okay then let's go", the lip synch, the store owner mentioning the bar fight, not mention hosea telling you the boys are in valentine right at the beginning of chapter 2. 

 

.....I've just realized I focus and over analyze the tiniest details way too much lol.

[Psycho18]

1 hour ago, propanecocaine71 said:

Yeah I feel like it makes sense to play americans at rest before polite society, the dialogue flows alot better ( Arthurs remark "real civilized" works much better than "okay then let's go", the lip synch, the store owner mentioning the bar fight, not mention hosea telling you the boys are in valentine right at the beginning of chapter 2. 

 

.....I've just realized I focus and over analyze the tiniest details way too much lol.

Polite Society before American at Rest, Arthur have to chase Jimmy Brooks before Jimmy Brooks goes to Blackwater to tell the Pinkertons.  Dutch and Hosea said keep the noises clean and stay  out of trouble. The Dutch Boys suppose to be in hiding in low profile.  This is better for storytelling.

 

Polite Society after American at Rest, The Law saw Arthur beat up Tommy, Arthur killed Odriscolls at Six Point Cabin, Arthur killed Bounty Hunters saving Sean, Arthur Killed Law in Strawberry with Micah. Pinkertons knows the Dutch Boys is close to Valentine. In Polite Society, there is no reason to chase Jimmy Brooks before he rides to Blackwater.  Chasing Jimmy Brooks is programed into  the mission.

 

 

Edited July 19, 2024 by Psycho18

[Tkayyy1018]

On 4/5/2024 at 6:24 PM, Psycho18 said:

I haven't play RDR2 in 4+ years. Is it just me or is this game more buggy than before. I am playing this game on PS5.

 

Thomas Downes and his family plays a big part in the story. Right now, I am having a hard time getting both Thomas Downes interactions in Valentine to appear.

 

 Does anybody else having problems? I don't get it, Thomas Downes shows up in Polite Society, then disappears in free roam. Thomas Downes shows up in American at Rest, then disappears in free roam.

 

1st mission order

Day 1:

Deer Hunt

Without Sin

--------------------------------

Day 2:

Polite Society- Thomas Downes in Valentine

Don't return horse after chasing Jimmy Brooks.  Tried to return the horse.

Camp- get Arthur's horse.

 

Return to Valentine.

Thomas Downes is gone.

Good Honest, Snake Oil.

Downes is still gone.

------------------------------------

Day 3:

Return to Valentine.

It is a hit or miss for Thomas Downes to appear.

 

American at Rest- Thomas Downes stops the fight.

Thomas Downes disappears from Valentine.

 

-------------------------------------------

2nd order

 

Day 1

Polite Society- Thomas Downes in Valentine

Don't return horse to Valentine.   Return the horse to Valentine.

Without Sin

---------------------------------------------

Day 2:

 

Return to Valentine

Thomas Downes is gone

Snake Oil

 

Hit or miss for Downes to appear

America at Rest- Downes stops the fight.

Downes disappears  again.

 

 

 

 

 

You can’t even walk passed him before Americans at rest or you won’t get the dialogue after AAR, just tested it last night. I do AAR at rest first and when I went passed the stables and downes (tried interacting and not interacting) after the fight he’s not there. I reloaded a save from camp and went the other way passed gun store and went straight to AAR and he was there after the fight. Seems like they changed so you can only get one or the other

[Tkayyy1018]

Day 1- hunt, all that glitters, rob maximo,

grimshaw dialogue ab food and fools to rob

day 2-hunt,chores, Dutch dialogues about seeing the boys in town

-hoses didn’t specify which saloon so stop in kearnes and run into Levin

-noblest of men and women
-Americans at rest in late afternoon/evening

downes dialogue after fight 

Bathe/sleep until noon at hotel

 

day3

return to camp and prepare food, craft bullets. Roleplay walking ledge with binoculars to map a route to blackwater.

-find Swensons bible

-without sin

bring Swanson back and get Dutch dialogue about meeting up with javier.

 

flows pretty well so far

 

swanson***

 

 

Edited July 19, 2024 by Tkayyy1018