Stolen Hats/Found Hats

[The Quartermaster]

Tried to edit my original post but it won't properly let me so making a new thread. 

 

Trying to put together a list of all the stolen hats and their locations. There is about 40 in total. Feel free to add any I have missed.

 

Remember these are Stolen Hats only so all come from npcs and will flash on the ground. These are not Found Hats. These hats will flash on the ground when they have been knocked off an npc. Simply pick the hat up and it will automatically save to your wardrobe under the 'Stolen Hats' section.

 

I have left the Nevada hat in because technically it can be stolen as well as found.

 

Happy Hunting!

 

1. Military officers Hat

Lemoyne Raiders

 

2. Military Forage Cap

Lemoyne Raiders

 

3. Moonshine Hat

Emerald Ranch infront of main house

 

4. Flop Hat

Emerald Ranch infront of main house

 

5. Western Homburg Hat

Annesburg Guards near the station/post office

 

 

6. Classic Raccoon Mountain Hat

Saloon in valentine  

 

7. Panama Fedora Hat

Rhodes post office 

 

8. Boater Hat

Post Office at Rhodes

 

9. Cattleman Hat

Pig farmer near Flat Neck Station

 

10. Sun Hat (Chapter 5) Missable

Guarma during main mission (missable) Can be farmed in the mission when you save the 3 men from being hung. Keep dying and reloading from check point until Hat drops and leave one guard alive until you pick it up so the cutscenes doesn't start.

 

11. Straw Hat

Fort Mercer

 

12. Military Mountie Hat

Fort Wallace during a main mission or use a lumber wagon to jump the fence if missed during main mission. You can also shoot up at the Fort until there's a number of soldiers lined up on the wall and then throw a stick of dynamite up at them which will blow all their hats off and should land on the ground outside of the Fort.

 

13. Rodeo Hat

Can be found at the Pig farmer near Flat Neck Station and the Cow Farm north of Rhodes and the small Ranch east of Butchers Creek.

 

14. Crown Bucket Hat

Annesburg npc that walks near station/post office

 

15. Conductor's Hat

Can be farmed on wagons outside of Valentine, stand at the first junction just outside of town that heads towards 6 point cabin. Also been seen at a random camp.

 

16. Bag Hat

Butchers Creek

 

17. Slouch Bucket Hat

Butchers Creek

 

18. Plantation Gambler's Hat

Braithwaite Manor. Can be done during or after mission.

 

19. Gaucho Hat

Strawberry wagon rider on outskirts and Rhodes train station 

 

 

20. Farmer's Hat

Strawberry npc in town. Has a blue top on and tanned pants. Sometimes rides a horse in town.

 

21. Homburg Hat

Strawberry wagon rider on outskirts on road that has Strawberry written on the map.

 

22. Worn Stovepipe Top Hat

Butchers Creek

 

23. Roanoke Hat

Butchers Creek

 

24. Wide Slouch Hat

Traveling npc around the Amberino area

 

25. Jipijapa Panama Hat

Rhodes Train Station

 

26. Pinned Flop Hat

Fort Mercer

Can easily farm these hats by leaving one npc alive which will spawn all the enemies in again when you go back.

 

27. Bolero Hat

Fort Mercer

 

28. High Hat

Van Horn

 

29. Gambler Hat

Armadillo Saloon

 

30. Cutter Hat 

Pig farmer near Flat Neck Station

 

31. Newsboy Cap (missable)

From Cornwalls men in the mission in Chapter 2 'The Sheep and the Goats' or in chapter 6 

 

32. Straw Boater Hat

St Denis

 

33. Military Cavalry Hat

Rhodes train station

 

34. Fisherman's Hat (Missable)

Last mission in the legendary fish chain.

 

35. Bucket Hat (Missable)

From a worker at the Lumberyard near Strawbery.

 

36. Liberty Hat (missable)

From the stranger mission 'A Fine Night for It' Do the mission up to when you clear the house, after that a second wave will attack. Kill everyone apart from one npc, if the hat hasn't dropped then let the npc kill you or kill yourself with dynamite and restart at the checkpoint. Took me about 10 times so good luck!!

Can also be found in the mission "An American pastoral scene"

 

37. Workman's Flat Cap

Worker in Annesburgh

 

38. Worn Flop Hat

Found near Emerald Ranch on a npc sometimes hearding sheep or from one of the poachers during the companion mission with Charles.

 

39. Derby Hat

On a passenger in a stagecoach outside of strawbery.

 

40. Johns Gambler Hat (Main Mission & missable)

Before the mission is over get in a fight with an npc so they knock your hat off. It should then be glowing when this happens so pick it up again and it will save. 

 

Nevada Hat

stolen from the Sheriff in valentine but also behind the waterfall 

 

****Found Hats****

 

Tricorn Hat

 

Civil War Hardee Hat

 

Morion Helmet

 

Scarecrow Derby Hat

 

Scarecrow Sombrero 

 

Scarecrow Hat

 

Scarecrow Top Hat

 

Viking Helmet

 

Miner's Hat

 

Chinese Skull Cap

Edited January 3, 2019 by Ring Dang Do

[Sneaky Queeky]

Nice list. Can these hats actually be stored in the wardrobe though?

[The Quartermaster]

Just now, SneakyDeaky said:

Nice list. Can these hats actually be stored in the wardrobe though?

Yes all of them can

[The4420]

How do you actually store them?

[The Quartermaster]

7 minutes ago, The4420 said:

How do you actually store them?

Just pick them up and they will automatically save to your wardrobe under the stolen hats section

[Haha365]

The hero we need,  but don't deserve... thank you!

[Striker_Blitz]

Dunno if they are already on the list but some scarecrows also have unique hats you can steal and are stored in your inventory 

[RedDadRedemption]

If i replay a guarma mission and pick up a sun hat will it save to my main game?

 

 

Also i got a "gambler hat" robbing someone in the armadillo saloon

Edited November 14, 2018 by RedDadRedemption

[Fugitive21]

what ever they call the police hats out St Denis. Picked one up while doing a shoot out there.

[The Quartermaster]

2 hours ago, Striker_Blitz said:

Dunno if they are already on the list but some scarecrows also have unique hats you can steal and are stored in your inventory 

Thanks but those are 'found hats' rather then 'stolen hats' so are saved under a different tab

31 minutes ago, Fugitive21 said:

what ever they call the police hats out St Denis. Picked one up while doing a shoot out there.

Did the police hat save to your wardrobe? I have picked up countless police hats but sadly none have saved.

[Cutter De Blanc]

Yeah those bobby hats  don't save I've picked up one before

[The Quartermaster]

2 hours ago, RedDadRedemption said:

If i replay a guarma mission and pick up a sun hat will it save to my main game?

 

 

Also i got a "gambler hat" robbing someone in the armadillo saloon

I don't think it will save as your always reverted back to your original game when you replay a mission. If it works though then let me know please

[Cutter De Blanc]

The Sun Hat is the one that slave driver is wearing? That thing is a bitch to try and get, you can only get it on the shootout at the beach, I think. I missed it, saw it glowing on the ground but the game switched to the next scene before I could grab it

[The Quartermaster]

So I think we have all 30 now as I just picked up 'Plantation Hat' from a npc at the pig farm at flat neck station and it's a different hat from 'Plantation Gamblers Hat'

 

I also stole the 'Nevada' hat from the sheriff in valentine but it saved as a 'found hat' rather than a 'stolen hat'

[RedDadRedemption]

I  replayed the fort wallace mission and got a special hat but it didnt save it to my main game could i still get one of i break in now post game?

[The Quartermaster]

18 minutes ago, RedDadRedemption said:

I  replayed the fort wallace mission and got a special hat but it didnt save it to my main game could i still get one of i break in now post game?

Not too sure about that. There's always one guard standing on the wall at the front gate, maybe there's a chance you could kill him and his body might fall over the wall?

[The Queenslayer]

I wore defeated NPC's hats for fun and thought nothing of it but only yesterday, for the first time, the game notified me that I picked up some special hat from a bounty hunter.  Couldn't tell you what it is yet as I haven't checked.

[Oldsport]

i got a newsboy hat off someone in valentine. it looks exactly like one of the patchy hats u can buy

[L1337]

At the same ranch you can find the Cattleman hat by Flatneck Station you can get the Cutter hat

[Cheddarhead7]

I can't remember the name of it so it might be already listed in the OP but a guy at *potential map spoilers*

Spoiler

Rathskeller's Fork

 

has a wide-brimmed farmer-type hat that can be saved.

[RedDadRedemption]

17 hours ago, Ring Dang Do said:

Not too sure about that. There's always one guard standing on the wall at the front gate, maybe there's a chance you could kill him and his body might fall over the wall?

Hoped over the fence killed a bunch of guards until i found it and escaped

[The Quartermaster]

9 hours ago, L1337 said:

At the same ranch you can find the Cattleman hat by Flatneck Station you can get the Cutter hat

Thanks for the update! So that's now Rodeo Hat, Cutter Hat, Cattleman Hat and Plantation Hat all from that one farm!

3 hours ago, RedDadRedemption said:

Hoped over the fence killed a bunch of guards until i found it and escaped

Need a wagon to get over or is it easy enough?

[RedDadRedemption]

7 minutes ago, Ring Dang Do said:

Thanks for the update! So that's now Rodeo Hat, Cutter Hat, Cattleman Hat and Plantation Hat all from that one farm!

Need a wagon to get over or is it easy enough?

I had to use a tree log wagon i found at the lumber yard near by all other type of wagons wouldnt let me climb on top of them 

[Cutter De Blanc]

I don't know what these hats look like,  and don't want to have to punch everybody in the face just to find out, we need pictures 

[RedDadRedemption]

Are there any special hats in saint denis? Ive been spearing random people looking for hats 

[RedDadRedemption]

What does the farmers hat in strawberry look like and where?

[The Quartermaster]

1 hour ago, RedDadRedemption said:

What does the farmers hat in strawberry look like and where?

Most of the hats in Strawberry are from people riding the wagons on the outskirts but the Farmers Hat is from an npc actually walking about the town. Sometimes standing infront of the building that's under construction. 

 

I usually make a manuel save then hogtie the person and pick them up then drop them so their hat falls off. If it's not the right one I can just reload. 

Edited November 16, 2018 by Ring Dang Do

[The Quartermaster]

20 hours ago, The Queenslayer said:

I wore defeated NPC's hats for fun and thought nothing of it but only yesterday, for the first time, the game notified me that I picked up some special hat from a bounty hunter.  Couldn't tell you what it is yet as I haven't checked.

Was that bounty hunters during a mission or just random bounty hunters?

 

one of the missions with Micah when you rob a stagecoach with uncle the bounty hunters there drop a hat but I'm not sure which one.

[The Queenslayer]

2 hours ago, Ring Dang Do said:

Was that bounty hunters during a mission or just random bounty hunters?

 

one of the missions with Micah when you rob a stagecoach with uncle the bounty hunters there drop a hat but I'm not sure which one.

 

It was random bounty hunters.  Cannot remember what the bounty was but it was a lot.

[The Quartermaster]

On 11/16/2018 at 3:24 PM, MatthewIRL said:

 

I could be wrong, but if you killed the original owner of the hat before picking the hat up, it doesn't count as "stolen". Hence, I have only like one stolen hat because the people I take hats from tend to already be dead.

I have stolen and saved hats from people I have killed and people I havnt killed.