SPOILERS Did you start the story again ?

[vadimukr22]

After Arthur died and all , and you kill Micah at the end , did you restart the story to play as Arthur again or nah ? 

[Rykjeklut]

I started a new game after the epilogue, yes.

[Johan]

Yes and no, I already had plenty of backup saves from chapter 3 to 5. 

 

I'll either load them or start a new game eventually after getting the 70 gold medals for the trophy.

[HockeyMike24]

I'm on my second playthrough at the start of chapter 2. I have only done up to Hosea's hunting mission so I unlock the stables. I already found some treasure, unlocked second holster (Not Micah's), a double action revolver, the Lancaster repeater and completed level 10 of hunting challenge. I'm doing this playthrough at a snails pace.

 

I want the fishing rod, but I think I have to advance the story for that.

[Sonny_Black]

I'm not sure if I'm going to do that..the way it ended, I don't know if I can take it to see Arthur and the gang again..even tho he is one of my favorite protagonist ever, in any case it feel so sad.

 

Edited November 11, 2018 by anthony

[Audiophile]

Yes. I'm on my second playthrough; chapter 2. 

 

I feel more free to take my time and do whatever I please. My first playthrough I was always good to keep my honour high. I took my time until chapter 4. Then I started focusing on the story because I wanted to see how it ends and did not want it spoiled further. 

[lndex]

I've made a new save start strictly for more exploration, hunting and so on..but i'm currently pushing for 100% on my main save (after the epilogue and all that).

[ajheadshot777]

I'm on epilogue 1 still, and once I'm finished, I do plan on doing another playthrough. With knowing what I know now, I feel like I can play the game more thoroughly in the next playthrough and really tie actions and decisions into Arthur's story.

 

My first run, I had Arthur's honor right in the middle through most of the game, then maxed it out towards the end, and did a little hunting and no fishing. Next time I'll probably start off being a complete douche bag for the few first few chapters, along with lots of hunting, fishing, side missions, treasure hunting, etc., then focus on the story missions and increase my honor towards the end. 

[SeniorDerp]

After I finished Epilogue 2 I started a new one. It’s pretty nice because the story has been told and now I can just take my sweet time exploring. There was still a ton of map that I never explored during my first play through 

[Oldsport]

yes after i first finished the game which i rushed through, i started a second play through. ive been on chapter 2 for about a week and a half now. i did all the missions every now and again, the only mission i got left is the leopold strauss mission where arthur contracts the TB. idk when ill feel like doing that one, maybe when i fully upgrade the camp and arthur satchels from pearson.

[Cutter De Blanc]

I haven't killed Micah, and I reloaded from chapter 4

[wut]

No way,

I got like 2 hours sleep a night for a week straight finishing the game(I played slow all side missions ect)

 

I loved every second but to do that again, hell to the no

 

I would die

 

[LittleJesus]

Yes.

First playtrough took me a week to finish.

Second playtrough I spend a week in chapter 1 and 2.

Currently in chapter 3, probably I'll spend another week in it 

[BZXC32]

 I dont think  you have to be further in story for that. When you see someone fishing, you just shoot/ kill him instant, like in the back, the rod falls on the ground where you can pick it up. When he gets the chance to put the rod away and pulls his own gun you cant retrieve the rod anymore. 

8 hours ago, HockeyMike24 said:

I'm on my second playthrough at the start of chapter 2. I have only done up to Hosea's hunting mission so I unlock the stables. I already found some treasure, unlocked second holster (Not Micah's), a double action revolver, the Lancaster repeater and completed level 10 of hunting challenge. I'm doing this playthrough at a snails pace.

 

I want the fishing rod, but I think I have to advance the story for that.

 I dont think  you have to be further in story for that. When you see someone fishing, you just shoot/ kill him instant, like in the back, the rod falls on the ground where you can pick it up. When he gets the chance to put the rod away and pulls his own gun you cant retrieve the rod anymore. 

[*Lola]

12 hours ago, vadimukr22 said:

After Arthur died and all , and you kill Micah at the end , did you restart the story to play as Arthur again or nah ? 

Made it to chapter two in second time playing and got bored.

Still a Rockstar fan. May just need more time before starting over.

Waiting for RDO. I prefer co-op over single player games.

[E•MO•TION]

No. As much as I want to go back to “happier times”, I’m focused on achieving 100% completion and completing all story mode achievements.

[MVP]

I plan to start my second playthrough this week. 

[silly_nate]

I haven’t even finished chapter 4 and I’ve already created a new save at the beginning of chapter 2. Mostly just to exploit the gold bar glitch and have some extra munay. I already took the gold bar in my “main” save, but that save was downgraded to a quick play through save on account of the God forsaken red dead wikia not being updated yet with useful info. 

[Chrismads]

Yes i restarted the game and found that I'd missed alot of sidemissions. Like going killing bison poachers with Charles and robbing with Javier. 

Everyone aiming to get 100%: I don't think you can get 100% if you didn't take your time and study all the exotic animals in Guarma.