Jimbatron 8,124 Posted December 23, 2018 This stuff about Trelawney and the Stange Man (totally spurious - the latter being unambiguously a supernatural entity that bullets pass through and has a totally different demeanour, only sharing taste in clothes and facial hair that were basically smart business dress for the era) is dragging this off topic. Karen is the gang member with the biggest question mark over what happens to her. What triggers this reported letter from Tilly? I’ve found Tilly in Saint Denis after the story, but not had any such letter. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
GroveStGTAV 741 Posted December 23, 2018 (edited) 5 hours ago, Nutduster said: That doesn't happen No its happened Edited December 23, 2018 by GroveStGTAV Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Nutduster 12,694 Posted December 23, 2018 3 minutes ago, GroveStGTAV said: No its happened Video or nah. I looked up a video of it myself because I didn't remember that happening, and it simply doesn't. Sorry. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Darealbandicoot 1,849 Posted January 2 On 12/23/2018 at 4:50 PM, Jimbatron said: This stuff about Trelawney and the Stange Man (totally spurious - the latter being unambiguously a supernatural entity that bullets pass through and has a totally different demeanour, only sharing taste in clothes and facial hair that were basically smart business dress for the era) is dragging this off topic. Karen is the gang member with the biggest question mark over what happens to her. What triggers this reported letter from Tilly? I’ve found Tilly in Saint Denis after the story, but not had any such letter. The letter from Tilly appears on the dinner table in Beachers Hope after a while. I found it completely by accident. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DEALUX 2,164 Posted January 2 lol but the strange man is a supernatural being. He appears as a ghost in that house in the Bayou. Some of you need to play RDR 1. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
McAgent 47 Posted January 7 Karen has to be dead, like super dead Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Gunboat138 111 Posted January 11 On 11/18/2018 at 12:47 PM, Rockstar Vienna said: About Trelawny... Never understood why people think that Trelawny could be the strange man (or has a connection to him). Just because of his looks? Then many strange men run around in Saint Denis fe. ! This outfit (in combination with that moustache) was nothing special back then. I see Trelawny more as a younger version of West Dickens (who wears almost the same outfit and the same moustache btw) , just with more class. A lot of people hopelessly want connections to old games. I had an argument with somebody who was "1000% convinced" some random npc in one of the gameplay trailers was Landon Ricketts. It's a phenomenon I don't understand, yet I'm sure theres an explination for. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Cutter De Blanc 12,288 Posted January 11 I have a save after completing My Last Boy, but before the final mission, and Karen is nowhere to be found in camp already Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
tbrown 1 Posted January 15 I think I may have found Karen in the Bastille saloon in St. Denis. A woman sitting just to the right of the bar, on a sofa in the corner. When I entered she asked "What does a girl have to do to get a drink round here?!" She then goes on about how boring her life is now and how exciting it used to be before everyone went off and settled down. You can hear her talking no matter where you go in the saloon. I talked to her and got similar responses to the ones I received interacting with Karen later in the game. Her build and her voice are similar to Karen's. I think this might be Karen but I'm not sure. But, what better place to find a drunk than in a saloon. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Shinola Gamer 319 Posted January 15 tbrown I think that's Lillian Powell. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
UncleTacitus 65 Posted January 16 Yeah, she's there way before Karen (alledgedly) disappears. I think I first met her in Chapter 3 or something. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RJX74 297 Posted January 17 It's a small detail, but Arthur mentions in guys final journal entry to tell Tilly not to give up on Karen. Arthur didn't give up on her in the end. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
GoodSense129 25 Posted January 19 My personal theory : she was heavily drunk , ran astray from camp and was kidnapped by the murphee brood Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
FreeMaxB585 161 Posted January 19 Its said she drank herself to death when you read that letter as john Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Uncletahiti 0 Posted January 25 I found her dead on the ground near Rhodes https://youtu.be/eN4T9uQZCdg Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
tbrown 1 Posted February 5 your right it is Lillian Powell. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
UndeadPotat0 158 Posted February 9 On 1/19/2019 at 3:21 AM, FreeMaxB585 said: Its said she drank herself to death when you read that letter as john What letter? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DrDetroit 167 Posted February 9 On 12/23/2018 at 8:39 AM, Nutduster said: This whole theory is dumb. It's based on nothing more than them looking somewhat alike in how they style themselves, and even if it was true it would add nothing to the game. I wouldn't say it's 'dumb' at all. It's totally plausible, however, highly unlikely in my opinion. Trelawney is a bit of an enigma, disappears most of the time (hardly ever at the camps), and looks ALOT like the Strange Man. This is why the theory is absolutely plausible. Anyhow, I do agree with your sentiment regarding Trelawney and the Strange Man - not the same entities (I didn't say person, cause the Strange Man is not a person, nor from this world). Great discussion none-the-less. I'm really baffled by the myriads of mysteries in this game...I just can't put it down and I want to, but I can't - it's that good imo. I think my ARMA 3 platoon have given up on me for now. Good day! DrDetroit Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
