SPOILERS SPOILER:The Blind Man

[Guest Guest176525326]

1 hour ago, Cutter De Blanc said:

Encountered him again just now. This time he tells me, "You... are not who you think you are.... which is lucky!"

 

What the f*ck, man!

He has more lives than a cat as well, I must have killed him like 10 times

[3Prcntr 174]

I just don't understand why u can antagonize him. It forces you to pay a dollar to hear these so called 'fortunes'. It would be much more interesting to just antagonize him like the monk on the mountain. I'm sure he would still talk if you did too. Especially if you are low honor.

Edited December 19, 2018 by 3Prcntr

[LeftTurnus 40]

On 11/18/2018 at 4:40 AM, The FoolYT said:

Most likely as the depiction of death is generally the grim reaper which is a hooded skeleton and skeletons have no nose.

 

Also I still see this guy as John Marston and he still tells me things like "You're one of the lucky ones" and other stuff like that.

Last night I saw him (as John) and he was a little different. To start he had a nasty cough, his voice was hoarser, and he said something I had not heard before. Something along the lines of "Two people are looking for you. One is full of hatred. The other their intentions are unclear. I do not think he is of this world..."

 

The one full of hatred I can see as probably Milton. The other? Not of this world?

 

[The FoolYT 1,037]

23 minutes ago, LeftTurnus said:

Last night I saw him (as John) and he was a little different. To start he had a nasty cough, his voice was hoarser, and he said something I had not heard before. Something along the lines of "Two people are looking for you. One is full of hatred. The other their intentions are unclear. I do not think he is of this world..."

 

The one full of hatred I can see as probably Milton. The other? Not of this world?

 

Maybe the strange man could be the one not of this world

[Deadman2112 1,197]

@LeftTurnus

 

RDR1 spoilers...

 

He tells John...

One is from this world, the other is from another. One is full of hate. As for the other, he's not sure what plans he has for John.
He even says the words I Know You during this conversation.

The two people he is referring to are...

Edgar Ross.


The government man who set John on the path of hunting down his old gang, and also kills John at the end of RedDead Redemption.

Throughout the story of RedDead Redemption he repeatedly refers to John and anyone like him as "scum" and "filth".

In his eye's, they are a cancer that the world could do without...

...and he see's himself as the cure.

http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Edgar_Ross

The other he is referring to (the one not of this world) is simply known as...
"The Mysterious Black Hat Man"

He even sets John on a side mission called

"I Know You"

in RedDead Redemption.

http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Strange_Man

 

 

 

...

Edited December 26, 2018 by Deadman2112

[LeftTurnus 40]

^^^ Thanks.

 

I have not played RDR1 so did not know the references.

Looking to play it now though...

 

 

[Cutter De Blanc 13,834]

He says to me this time, "Thank you sir... Thank you... Keep moving... but don't move too fast."

[Cutter De Blanc 13,834]

"Run from the seeker, sir. Run and keep running. Or help others to run."

[kannibaljones 7]

edgar looks a lot like dutch

[Pressure Drop 956]

Thought I would mention that the Strange Man does have a cabin in RDR2, just in case any of you didn't know. Won't say any more but you can look it up if you wish

[DEALUX 2,400]

1 hour ago, Pressure Drop said:

Thought I would mention that the Strange Man does have a cabin in RDR2, just in case any of you didn't know. Won't say any more but you can look it up if you wish

He's in the game alright. Both games imply that he's the devil or his messenger or something. It's kind of ambiguous. Perhaps there is no devil. Just someone god sends to deal with evil people.

 

 

[Pressure Drop 956]

3 hours ago, Dealux said:

He's in the game alright. Both games imply that he's the devil or his messenger or something. It's kind of ambiguous. Perhaps there is no devil. Just someone god sends to deal with evil people.

This video was pretty interesting...

 

[Boozey St John 1,668]

5 hours ago, Dealux said:

He's in the game alright. Both games imply that he's the devil or his messenger or something. It's kind of ambiguous. Perhaps there is no devil. Just someone god sends to deal with evil people.

 

 

I always assumed he was Lucifer; he gave off a lot of hints. His ominous appearance, stoic voice, cold yet calm demeanor. 

 

- "Why would you remember me? You've forgotten far more important people..." 

 

John has continuely stared death in the face many times and survived without realizing it.

 

- "I hope my son turns out like you." The anti-Christ- blah, blah, blah. 

 

-"Funniest thing, I can't remember."

The devil has many names;

Satan

Lucifer

The Devil

Beezelbub

 

Etc.

 

Just my opinion, but I wish they did add the strange man mission/side quest to the main game after the epilogue.

Edited January 1 by Boozey St James
Edit.

[Bengaldog14 0]

During the epilogue I ran into the blind prophet and he said something along the lines of “2 will come for you one is full of hate the other not of this world”. I’m hoping it’s a tease of future dlc but can’t find any one else hearing this

 

[Guest Guest176525326]

3 hours ago, Bengaldog14 said:

During the epilogue I ran into the blind prophet and he said something along the lines of “2 will come for you one is full of hate the other not of this world”. I’m hoping it’s a tease of future dlc but can’t find any one else hearing this

 

Future DLC? You must be having a laugh... 

[RyuNova 10,816]

Is he immortal?

I have been tempted to lasso him as I rode past.

[happygrowls 10,540]

35 minutes ago, RyuNova said:

Is he immortal?

I have been tempted to lasso him as I rode past.

You can shoot him, but he just respawns.

 

100% he's a demigod of some kind

[RyuNova 10,816]

6 minutes ago, happygrowls said:

You can shoot him, but he just respawns.

 

100% he's a demigod of some kind

 

He's the opposite to The Strange Man.

[Domac 409]

To John he says something like

"Remembering the past will cost you your future"

 

- John goes after and kills Micah, who betrayed him in the past. Because of that, he pays with his future, aka he gets killed because killing Micah is how Ross found him and then the story of RDR1 played out.

Edited February 28 by Domac