What is the most evil/sadistic thing you've done?

[Slam_Jones 708]

One time Uncle said "hello" to me in camp AND I JUST WALKED AWAY WITHOUT SAYING ANYTHING.

 

I know, I know, I can be cruel beyond words sometimes.

[Satanta 207]

Got tired of listening to the old woman in the cabin cussing and screaming so hog-tied her.  She wouldn't shut up so I pitched her into the basement.  She STILL wouldn't shut up so I pitched her face-first into a wall.  Solved that issue.

[Cutter De Blanc 14,032]

Went into a pigpen where some guy appeared to be enjoying feeding and cleaning the pigs, he says "Hey there hope you're having a good morning" to which Arthur responds "Shut up, you don't know me." I then lasso a pig in front of the guy, kill it and ride off with it. The guy screamed and ran away. It looked like the pig I killed was pregnant. I felt really bad about the whole interaction, and to make matters worse the pig ended up decomposing and was rendered useless

 

I don't know why I did it in the first place, just to be a mean f*cking bastard I suppose

Edited November 20, 2018 by Cutter De Blanc

[Satanta 207]

Oh I forgot.  Spanish Treasure Hunter wanted to sell me a Map.  Went ahead and paid him for it to be sure I got it then, once he mounted his horse [[A Nokoma or whatever of the Race variety]] I shotgunned him in the back and took his horse.  Me and that horse are still together Best Buds.

[Rykjeklut 785]

2 hours ago, Satanta said:

Oh I forgot.  Spanish Treasure Hunter wanted to sell me a Map.  Went ahead and paid him for it to be sure I got it then, once he mounted his horse [[A Nokoma or whatever of the Race variety]] I shotgunned him in the back and took his horse.  Me and that horse are still together Best Buds.

These mares aint loyal

[Satanta 207]

3 hours ago, Rykjeklut said:

These mares aint loyal

Mine has yet to toss me and run in a gunfight tho.  She don't always litsten too well when I tell her to follow and once had to hike back to the oil fields from some creek after a Mission to get her back as she was napping.

[Qbert 215]

A drunk guy stumbling through van horn asked me where the train station was I lied and told him it was by the fence and he just walked off the pier falling in the water. As I went to look at him in the water he was lifeless and arthur said well I hope he can swim

[Thorson87 0]

Nothing too bad, did the side mission where you help an old homeless guy get stuff back from his house (ledger, gun and a watch iirc). Didn't like what he had in his ledger so when I returned it to him I lasso him and drag him through his camp fire then shot his horse in the head because the bastard kicked me. 

[tonko 1,665]

2 hours ago, Qbert said:

A drunk guy stumbling through van horn asked me where the train station was I lied and told him it was by the fence and he just walked off the pier falling in the water. As I went to look at him in the water he was lifeless and arthur said well I hope he can swim

Hahahahahaha classic. 

[ViciousSpirit 41]

I found a chinese monk meditating on a cliff. Kicked him off ..

[woggleman 3,971]

On 11/21/2018 at 12:27 AM, Thorson87 said:

Nothing too bad, did the side mission where you help an old homeless guy get stuff back from his house (ledger, gun and a watch iirc). Didn't like what he had in his ledger so when I returned it to him I lasso him and drag him through his camp fire then shot his horse in the head because the bastard kicked me. 

Nothing bad about that when you find out about what he did. I shot him in the leg and left him there to suffer.

[Haha365 903]

13 minutes ago, ViciousSpirit said:

I found a chinese monk meditating on a cliff. Kicked him off ..

Confucius say " What goes around,  comes around" That means a goat will most likely knock you off a mountain. 

[SAS_Intruder 791]

You guys are pretty sick. Maybe I am too boring but I didn't do anything bad unless it was part of the mission or self defense. 

[Rykjeklut 785]

On 11/24/2018 at 5:16 PM, ViciousSpirit said:

I found a chinese monk meditating on a cliff. Kicked him off ..

I set him on fire, and he ran off the edge. Felt kinda bad.

[BoulderFaceplant 270]

One time in Tall Trees I came across a campsite with a few gangsters trying to murder a man and his wife. Well, they executed the man before I could do anything, so I shot all the gangsters. I rode up to the woman and stood beside her. She was absolutely broken, sobbing over her dead husband. I asked if she was alright, and she replied, “Just go away...” Ungrateful pos, I saved you, didn’t I? So, I let her cry for a little bit, then I took out a shotgun and blasted her head off. 

[sleepwalk1980 2,031]

Hogtied a guy then threw him in the river and watched him drown.
It took ages for him to die.

[3Prcntr 178]

Burn someone tied to a tree who thought I was going to free them. Why TF would I do that? The hard work was already done for me.

Plus, stabbing people... That's pretty brutal especially if they are hog tied.

But could you imagine being burned? You wouldn't even be able to scream after it hits your throat.

I've pretty much done it all in this game. Drowning would suck too. Or being dragged by a horse until you die. Would be crazy if people could bleed to death... I'd crotch shot with an arrow much more often.

Your pain, is my pleasure

17 hours ago, Rykjeklut said:

I set him on fire, and he ran off the edge.

That is awesome. Where is he? I haven't burned anyone in a day...

On 11/24/2018 at 1:02 PM, SAS_Intruder said:

You guys are pretty sick. Maybe I am too boring but I didn't do anything bad unless it was part of the mission or self defense. 

I played the story as a good guy. Now I'm done and it's time to be a bad guy. Plus, they kinda set you up for it... And it's just a game

On 11/20/2018 at 9:54 PM, Qbert said:

A drunk guy stumbling through van horn asked me where the train station was I lied and told him it was by the fence and he just walked off the pier falling in the water. As I went to look at him in the water he was lifeless and arthur said well I hope he can swim

What about the hunter in the snow that lost his friend and you discover he has been mauled by a bear? I went and told him the truth and his dumbass went looking for him, and the bear got him too. I shot the bear like 100 times but the game wouldn't let me save him. I wonder what would have happened if I lied to the guy? Would he still be alive?

Anyone do this?

On 11/20/2018 at 3:20 PM, Cutter De Blanc said:

Went into a pigpen where some guy appeared to be enjoying feeding and cleaning the pigs, he says "Hey there hope you're having a good morning" to which Arthur responds "Shut up, you don't know me." I then lasso a pig in front of the guy, kill it and ride off with it. The guy screamed and ran away. It looked like the pig I killed was pregnant. I felt really bad about the whole interaction, and to make matters worse the pig ended up decomposing and was rendered useless

 

I don't know why I did it in the first place, just to be a mean f*cking bastard I suppose

There is a trinket that stops the decomposition of animals while they are on horseback. f*ck his pig.

Edited December 3, 2018 by 3Prcntr

[Guest Guest176525326]

Helped a guy out of a bear trap and then blew his face off with a shotgun,  I couldn’t stop laughing... 

[Rykjeklut 785]

6 hours ago, 3Prcntr said:

That is awesome. Where is he? I haven't burned anyone in a day...

 

Up in Ambarino somewhere. That mountain you're riding over with Rains Fall

[rooob 0]

Still on my first play through so still playing the honour thing.

As already mentioned I often ignore good mornings from camp members, too busy lugging hay to be fair.

 

Just on the corner by the tailors in St Denis, horse parked up on the post. I start running (fast walk in town please R*) down the road from the tailors alongside the high wall and mash triangle just as I'm heading around the corner to jump on and go only to find I have some innocent woman up against the wall by her throat! Just about got out before it turned into a fest! 😂

 

Much like pulling a gun on someone you just wanted to say hello to...

[Big Molio 9,184]

Not sadistic, but bloody violent (in an awesome way)

 

I was in the saloon in Rhodes, and two dudes at the end of the bar slammed a guy's head down on it. As I walked over to intervene, they started on me and in the melee that followed I somehow drew my revolver and blew these two guys away at close quarters. I was button mashing to be honest and don't really know how it happened, but it was pretty intense. Everybody ran out screaming.