What is the most evil/sadistic thing you've done?

[Rykjeklut 790]

With this game being so open, you can do a whole lot of cool things, and a whole lot of sinister things, if you so choose... who can forget their first time hogtieing a woman and tossing her on the traintracks in RDR1?

 

A random guy in a camp pissed me off, so i beat him to the ground, hogtied him, and carried him to the waters edge. I then antagonized him for a bit, before picking him up and tossing him into a few inches of water. Then I stood and watched him swallow mouthful after mouthful of water while struggling to get to the surface, so tantalizingly close.

 

A different gentleman gave me some choice words while riding past me up in Ambarino, so i killed his horse, shot out his legs, tied him up, and put down some predator bait. Unfortunatly I had to get out of there because of the supercops, but I can only imagine.

 

What evil stuff have you been up to?

[Libertad 417]

I've not done anything particularly sadistic, although I felt bad for pistol-whipping the elderly gold prospector and stealing his gold nugget. Just think about it, you've finally found some gold and you're jumping for joy. Someone with a pistol walks towards you, tackles you to the ground, and violently breaks your nose, knocking you out and taking your gold. He was an old man, and yet I knocked him out without a moment's hesitation. He might be dead. All for 25 dollars...

[Sonny_Black 3,125]

8 minutes ago, Libertad said:

I've not done anything particularly sadistic, although I felt bad for pistol-whipping the elderly gold prospector and stealing his gold nugget. Just think about it, you've finally found some gold and you're jumping for joy. Someone with a pistol walks towards you, tackles you to the ground, and violently breaks your nose, knocking you out and taking your gold. He was an old man, and yet I knocked him out without a moment's hesitation. He might be dead. All for 25 dollars...

Same situation here..except that I killed him and I felt bad..

[theEwing1979 980]

Random encounter with a woman walking away from her dead horse. She asked me for a ride to Emerald Ranch and I initially agreed so she hopped on my horse. I then remembered I had business to attend to in the Strawberry area which is the other direction so I made her get off. She cussed me out so I tackled her to the ground and cut her throat. 

 

I executed an innocent woman who was in distress. I actually felt kind of bad for a few moments afterwards. 

[septimoose 2,743]

Riding into Saint Denis there was a guy asking for help. I went to speak to him but accidentally pulled out the ol' pistol instead of asking what was up. He took offense and started mouthing off at me. I figured he might like a trip somewhere nice and quiet. I trussed him up like a Christmas roast, took him out to the bayou, looted him of 63¢, threw him in the mud and left him for the gators.

Edited November 1, 2018 by septimoose

[Nah Tso Gud 296]

Probably in the mission where  Charles gets really upset. In late chapter 2, or chapter 3?

 

Where you locate 2 guys. 

 

I disposed of the one, somewhat fittingly by putting an arrow in his forehead. Then, I took my double barrel shot gun and removed the head, arms and feet. Leaving an unidentifiable bloody lump on the ground.

Edited November 1, 2018 by Nah Tso Gud

[RyuNova 17,575]

I...I...

...I DIDN'T STROKE A DOG THAT WAS WHINING FOR ATTENTION!

[Dangerous and sad 1,655]

Stole money off a blind beggar 

[The Algerian 1,416]

This is how "evil" I try to be.

 

 

It's not easy though, since the mechanics aren't very consistent.

 

I did however try to antagonize a dog to see if I'd lose honor points like when killing a horse.

Edited November 1, 2018 by The Algerian

[White Shark 7,792]

Some Lemoyne Raider gave me guff. So I lassoed him, hogtied him, dumped him on my horse, road to the swampy river area and fed him alive to a gator. Good fun.

 

Again, raiders who had stolen some poor guy's wagon, so I killed 4 of them and tied the other 2 up on the pier. I proceeded to dump each body in the river as the two watched. I then dumped both of them into the river alive and watched them squirm and drown at the bottom like worms. 

 

Criminals face full brutal justice from me.

[RyuNova 17,575]

5 minutes ago, White Shark said:

Some Lemoyne Raider gave me guff. So I lassoed him, hogtied him, dumped him on my horse, road to the swampy river area and fed him alive to a gator. Good fun.

 

Again, raiders who had stolen some poor guy's wagon, so I killed 4 of them and tied the other 2 up on the pier. I proceeded to dump each body in the river as the two watched. I then dumped both of them into the river alive and watched them squirm and drown at the bottom like worms. 

 

Criminals face full brutal justice from me.

 

Something fun to do as well is Hogtie someone, put them on the back of their own Horse, walk behind the Horse and press B/Circle to slap its haunches and have it gallop away with them on the back.

[Nutduster 13,400]

I haven't done anything truly evil on purpose, though I did recount in another thread the story of murdering 5 people near Emerald Ranch to cover up one crime (damn witnesses kept popping up!).  The worst thing I've done on accident though was in Valentine.  There's a dog that hangs out across the street from the saloon with the "LENNY!" mission, and I had made fast friends with it.  On my third visit to town I went to pet the dog, and accidentally pressed the right trigger, instantly shooting him right in the face as he was wagging his tail at me.  I felt bad enough about it to reload my game. 

Edited November 1, 2018 by Nutduster

[septimoose 2,743]

7 minutes ago, Nutduster said:

I haven't done anything truly evil on purpose, though I did recount in another thread the story of murdering 5 people near Emerald Ranch to cover up one crime (damn witnesses kept popping up!).  The worst thing I've done on accident though was in Valentine.  There's a dog that hangs out across the street from the saloon with the "LENNY!" mission, and I had made fast friends with it.  On my third visit to town I went to pet the dog, and accidentally pressed the right trigger, instantly shooting him right in the face as he was wagging his tail at me.  I felt bad enough about it to reload my game. 

 

Yo.

 

That ain't cool.

 

I hope you got all the negative karma you can get. Accident or not.

[RyuNova 17,575]

8 minutes ago, Nutduster said:

I haven't done anything truly evil on purpose, though I did recount in another thread the story of murdering 5 people near Emerald Ranch to cover up one crime (damn witnesses kept popping up!).  The worst thing I've done on accident though was in Valentine.  There's a dog that hangs out across the street from the saloon with the "LENNY!" mission, and I had made fast friends with it.  On my third visit to town I went to pet the dog, and accidentally pressed the right trigger, instantly shooting him right in the face as he was wagging his tail at me.  I felt bad enough about it to reload my game. 

 

[CosmicBuffalo 1,700]

I dynamited the photo guy and then his horse.  

Edited November 1, 2018 by GenericGTAO

[Nutduster 13,400]

4 minutes ago, septimoose said:

 

Yo.

 

That ain't cool.

 

I hope you got all the negative karma you can get. Accident or not.

 

Uh, OK.

[TheSantader25 7,312]

The Strauss Side missions. 

[Rykjeklut 790]

1 minute ago, TheSantader25 said:

The Strauss Side missions. 

They knew what they were getting in to.

[septimoose 2,743]

25 minutes ago, Rykjeklut said:

They knew what they were getting in to.

 

Yeah. Giving you tuberculosis.

[HockeyMike24 936]

I like to occasionally lasso people and ride around dragging them behind my horse.

[unicornace 289]

3 hours ago, Libertad said:

I've not done anything particularly sadistic, although I felt bad for pistol-whipping the elderly gold prospector and stealing his gold nugget. Just think about it, you've finally found some gold and you're jumping for joy. Someone with a pistol walks towards you, tackles you to the ground, and violently breaks your nose, knocking you out and taking your gold. He was an old man, and yet I knocked him out without a moment's hesitation. He might be dead. All for 25 dollars...

Dude I watched him find that nugget then let him run off with the gold. I had $700 or so at that point.  I broke into a house with a son and his drunk father. shot the father while the son hid under the bed and cried. That hit me right in the feelers

[White Shark 7,792]

1 hour ago, septimoose said:

 

Yo.

 

That ain't cool.

 

I hope you got all the negative karma you can get. Accident or not.

Lol. So serious.

[Mikeol1987 1,850]

tip: don't leave someone hogtied in a foot of water its gruesome.

[HockeyMike24 936]

4 minutes ago, Mike R.L. said:

tip: don't leave someone hogtied in a foot of water its gruesome.

Damn. That's it. When I get home I'm gonna hogtie someone and throw them off a bridge into water.... Perhaps a fast flowing stream.

[GTA-Biker 6,337]

3 hours ago, septimoose said:

Riding into Saint Denis there was a guy asking for help. I went to speak to him but accidentally pulled out the ol' pistol instead of asking what was up. He took offense and started mouthing off at me. I figured he might like a trip somewhere nice and quiet. I trussed him up like a Christmas roast, took him out to the bayou, looted him of 63¢, threw him in the mud and left him for the gators.

If he was offering to tell you about something you'll wanna hear and said something about a quick way to make money,you did the right thing.There's a guy in Saint Denis who lures you into a back alley,and then his friend jumps you and mugs you.It happened to a Youtuber CaRtOoNz:

Spoiler

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLQQc3ix0q0

At 19:55

 

Edited November 1, 2018 by GTA-Biker

[SirWillC 690]

I lassoed some bloke off his horse as he was getting by because I didn’t wanna walk back to Valentine after drinking with Lenny.

Edited November 1, 2018 by SirWillC
Grammar Correction

[Hyperlith 27]

2 hours ago, HockeyMike24 said:

I like to occasionally lasso people and ride around dragging them behind my horse.

...through a river, or campfire, or forest. Thump, thump, thump.

I think I haven't done the most sadistic thing yet; barely started playing

 

[septimoose 2,743]

1 hour ago, White Shark said:

Lol. So serious.

 

Didn't mean it seriously lol... I mean, he shot a fictional dog accidentally. We've all been there! I was just turning on him as quickly at the whole of whatever state you're in will turn on you. Pull the wrong trigger at the wrong time and the whole town will treat you like you butchered every child in the state.

[Lock n' Stock 2,925]

Shot all the limbs off of some bandit who tried attacking me then put him on the back of my horse and rode around with it.

[CrimsonFolo 1,075]

Got a bounty guy and i let him talk to his wife and child before taking him. After a while, he falls off the horse and i get ambushed by 4 guys. Kill them and head back to the wife and child. I blast the wife in the face with the shotgun and the kid didn't even flinch.