Bug Reports and Feedback

[Spider-Vice]

In a game of this magnitude, there's bound to be some issues that could be minor or could be major. But there's not a more vocal QA tester than the overall player base of a game.

 

If you've found any bug, glitch, or something else that isn't supposed to happen and you think people (or Rockstar) need to know, post it here! 

 

If you have a problem with your game and are looking for a solution instead of just letting people know about it, use the quick questions thread or create a thread for your issue!

[blakef249]

My legendary elk pelt can't be turned in or lost so it automatically turns in. The game has a bug and says I didn't skin the elk. In the Compendium it says, tracked 1/1. killed 1/1. skinned 0/1. Now I'll never be able to get my elk outfit. This needs to be fixed!

[Highlyfunctional]

I just had a similar problem where my Legenday Moose died in the river and I can’t skin or drag it out.

[Pocket Fox]

Issue 1: I have 2 permanent bullet holes in my hat. Any hat I change to also gets the same 2 holes, as well as any mask. Including hats I continue to buy.

 

Issue 2: Sound has been reversed. Things happening behind me are loud, in front of me are quiet. People talking, shooting, playing guitar to my left come through the right speaker and vice versa.

[Xshallprevail]

I'm having the same issue with the legendary wolf

[theLich]

Aside from PS4 pro/4k checkerboarding issue which I hope will be addressed sometime (after seeing Xbox One X version and other PS4 games on Pro I cannot help but think that game could look just a tad more sharp) there's one weird thing happening several times (not game-breaking): sometimes when attempting to lead horse it starts slowly moving away (up on cliffs, into walls etc) and Arthur can only move closer to it by weird circling movement. Eventually after a little 'dance' you can whistle the horse to saddle it and movement gets back to normal.

[DirtyDan0311]

We NEED the option to remove the hitmarkers! Come on Rockstar!

[DanByDefault]

I have been waiting for 3 days to hand the harmonica to Sadie and the Penny Dreadful comic to Jack Marston. But they have both disappeared from camp... have managed to hand Hosea his crime novel. 

 

Any one know what's going on please?

[GTA_ForeveR20]

Feature that they should had:

- Stach your weapons at camp or sell them, i need to scrool between 10+ weapons just to find my favourites

Bugs, i just started chapter 3 if i find more i will report this too:

- Sound cuts off in a split second when im rinding around the world, happend a lot of times

- On side missions with your companions you talk to them but you dont hear what they are saying because arthur then gives a response

- Kid with the newspaper sometimes appears on the map but when i get there he just heasnt there, so im losing lore of the game

- Legendary bear appeard on the mission and one time afterwards, after that he just doesnt appear anymore, i dont know if this happends with other legendary animals

- Some doors dont close when you open them

- Every time i open the map the index section automatically opens itself, its annoying

- Happend two times that after a mission the gang gets 300 dollars but when i arrive at the camp there isnt 300 dollars stash 

- With random events if the npcs touch you or your horse they just flee and the mission stops and your losing funny, good, lore missions

- I dont if the game is so design or is a bug but i already had two or three the same random events

- At camp ducht was reading a book sitting next to a tree and in a split second hes body moved randomly and he just changed pose

- Log challenges the bar to select the challenges is glitched out, it appears outside of the collum

- I already did the home robberys that are in the log but they just stay there

- The father and sons next to Velantine one time where in cover and the father was shooting in the air, there werent any enemies around and i already had that mission done, just happend one time

- You get a foto of wolves but theres a golden circle like a ring in the middle of the foto, and now when i open the journal theres the golden circle in de midlle of the pages

[the_grizzly_man]

Can anyone confirm the missing gang members 'bug' is a real problem? See reddit link for details: https://www.reddit.com/r/reddeadredemption/comments/9svl1a/huge_game_breaking_bug_read_before_playing_game/

 

To summarise, the claim is that in Chapter Two if the first mission you do is go into Valentine with Uncle then several gang members disappear and remain unavailable.

 

 

[Shadowfennekin]

Honor won't go up no more.

Hope it's enough for the missable chapter 6 mission. I'm gonna drop a save just in case before that's supposed to trigger.

The honor bug is real; been doing everything I can but it won't budge past 8/10ish? of the way to the top...... when's the bug update gonna happen already?

[gattopersiano]

I can't complete the mission Artificial Intelligence. I did the second mission but didn't get the trophy. Now it says that i have to go back to Dragic but he is nowhere to be found.

[wagszilla]

Minor mission spoiler

 

...

 

In the last mission with the hunter  general dude where you kill the Legendary Boar, the boar fell near his dead body.

 

I went to skin the boar but the game glitched out on me.

 

Arthur fell through the game world / ground into a gray dead zone where he was falling like he’d jumped out of an airplane. I didn’t die but landed back in the game world ground like 20 feet nearby. The guy’s dead body was there but the boar was not.

 

 

So I am going to be missing that boar skin.

[The Algerian]

Killer clue mission is bugged.

Found the first trail and the piece of the map, no problem. Part 1 obtained.

Found the second, no problem, part 2 obtained.

Then the third, I pick up the map and it says I obtained part 1 again.

 

Now there's nothing I can do, all the map and bodies/head  have vanished.

[SMiT2710]

Just tried to restart the mission American distillation so I could race Dutch again. Mission restarted but my horse was no longer with me and all of my items (tonics and food) for myself and the horse had disappeared. I was given a base level horse, 2 stamina 2 health, my normal horse and all my items werent returned to me until it reloaded to my normal game after I got back to camp.

[Jimbatron]

Not sure if this should be classified as a bug or just an annoying oversight by R* but you need to be careful with your internet and social club connection and your pre-order or special edition bonus items.

 

I think I got the thoroughbred horse as a pre-order bonus. Maxed out the bonding. Made a cup of tea whilst the game was loading and didn’t see my internet connection had dropped. It then replaced the thoroughbred with a more bogstandard horse (less stats but still the same name and bonding) unfortunately the game auto saved before I realised what had happened.

 

When I reconnected I could get another thoroughbred for free, and effectively I’d now got an extra horse I could sell for $12 as some sort of weird karma compensation, but had to rebond again from scratch. One to watch out for.

[Bfortmforn]

Early on I bought a lot of clothes and saved and deleted outfits, I'm not sure what caused the issue but I can only assume because of my previous saved and deleted outfits, when I bought the upgraded saddlebag and my slots increased, my outfits deleted and now I can only save outfits 1, 3 and 4.  2 and 5 are not saveable, and occassionally on a reload or restart, what I have saved and on my horse get deleted.  Super frustrating.

[SanderRijn01]

In Valentine, when you enter from the northeast side, you can see two chimney's disappear when you come closer. The smoke is still coming out, but there are no chimney's anymore. Maybe it's a easy to fix

[carpetbacon]

Okay so I found the Lanchester repeater or whatever it is called in the basement of the gun store in Rhodes. Then I went to Strawberry and was using it, died and now it’s gone. It’s not it the saddlebags or anything can someone tell me why??

[Possebility]

(story spoiler ahead)

Spoiler

When playing with John

- ...once you change his holsters/belt, the gun in his main holster is visually bugged. It's a shame that you can't get dressed all in black without it.

- ...the "pomade-glitch" gets you a haircut!

 

A big one:

(kinda like in GTA5) it's possible to "fall through the map" when leading your horse across the streets of St. Denis. The outcome is a respawn near camp without dying.

Edited November 6, 2018 by Possebility

[Guest]

On 11/3/2018 at 9:13 AM, Bfortmforn said:

Early on I bought a lot of clothes and saved and deleted outfits, I'm not sure what caused the issue but I can only assume because of my previous saved and deleted outfits, when I bought the upgraded saddlebag and my slots increased, my outfits deleted and now I can only save outfits 1, 3 and 4.  2 and 5 are not saveable, and occassionally on a reload or restart, what I have saved and on my horse get deleted.  Super frustrating.

There is something wrong with storing outfits on the horse. For example if I have outfit 1, 2 and 3 on my horse and equip the bandana/mask while wearing outfit 1, the game creates another custom outfit and deletes either outfit 2 or 3. What ends up happening is you get 2 identical outfits with the only difference being that one has a bandana.

I've also bought the upgraded saddlebags but I can only store 3 outfits.

Another issue I have is that Arthur has gone completely invisible. Switching to default outfits seem to trigger this bug. When using custom outfits on the other hand he turns bald, eyes disappear as well as his satchels and gun holsters.

Also the weather changes rapidly from rain to sunny to a thunderstorm in a matter or minutes; it would be nice if they lasted a lot longer.

[DentureDynamite]

On 11/6/2018 at 7:24 AM, Possebility said:

(story spoiler ahead)

  Reveal hidden contents

When playing with John

- ...once you change his holsters/belt, the gun in his main holster is visually bugged. It's a shame that you can't get dressed all in black without it.

- ...the "pomade-glitch" gets you a haircut!

 

A big one:

(kinda like in GTA5) it's possible to "fall through the map" when leading your horse across the streets of St. Denis. The outcome is a respawn near camp without dying.

I kind of hope R* doesn't fix this one--a poor man's fast travel back to camp..!

 

Some bugs I've noticed:

 

• I've had a feeling stage coach disappear into thin air (can't remember the exact location or if it was an O'Driscoll one or not).
• Some crimes in Valentine don't get reported even if multiple NPCs see it happen; but upon returning to Valentine the next day, a bounty is suddenly there, and townspeople start shooting at you.
• Freeing the man held in the basement of the Rhodes' gunsmith (and taking what you want, as he gives permission for you to do) may result in an instant bounty when you step outside the store, even if no-one saw you, and you had no gun drawn when exiting.

Edited November 9, 2018 by DentureDynamite

[schnowzer08]

First post here so hopefully I don't screw things up. 

 

I noticed while playing last night on the Xbox one X that the the camera appears to extinguish player made fires when you equip it. 

 

I created a house fire using the Fire Bottle inside of a house and as soon as I switched to the camera the spreading fire extinguished.

I was streaming on mixer and managed to catch a clip of this https://video-1.neatclip.com/video/5be613540364d.mp4

 

The second time it happend was in the same house and when I looked in the view finder the fire extinguished.

I also have a clip of this. https://video-1.neatclip.com/video/5be6101850a1d.mp4. 

 

Has anybody else experience this weirdness when using a fire bottle to create a fire and then take a picture or is it just my game?

 

[Shadowfennekin]

Small game arrows aren't working in dead eye for me -.-

Only way I can get a woodpecker and it's impossible to get precise aim at such a tiny creature, especially one that ONLY flies and never lands! Little bugger

I do the lock thing and the arrow acts like I manually aimed it and f*cks off 

Edited November 11, 2018 by Shadowfennekin

[Dioltas]

Horse + Cart - can't reverse. So I accidentally drove my horse and cart in between 3 trees right beside the quest objective for the train heist where I'm asked to steal the cart with kerosene in it. I can't move left or right to get out and there is no reverse.. Mission is now broken and I guess I'll have to try find a way to start it again. Very annoying but could be avoided by letting us be able to reverse when driving the horse and cart.

[Nicko5382]

There is a massive chunk of the map missing next to the trapper North East of emerald ranch which you can fall through and probably die, it is very noticeable and game world breaking. Its to do with that dynamic event when there are rail tracks being built, instead of the tracks, there is just this big hole through the map. It looks pretty disgusting lol

Oh and it goes around the mountain, it's really big. 

[invisiblegnome]

10 hours ago, Nicko5382 said:

There is a massive chunk of the map missing next to the trapper North East of emerald ranch which you can fall through and probably die, it is very noticeable and game world breaking. Its to do with that dynamic event when there are rail tracks being built, instead of the tracks, there is just this big hole through the map. It looks pretty disgusting lol

Oh and it goes around the mountain, it's really big. 

i have the same problem, currently getting the run around at rockstar support about the issue. as far as i can tell, the railroad camp where they are working on laying tracks, which you can visit playing as arthur, the whole section of terrain is missing, where the completed track which joins up the 2 points which are located, one just north of the letters O and V and the other just south of the letter E of New Hanover. i have a feeling the devs forgot to replace the camp texture with the updated one when you play on as john several years later

 

[Stannard96]

Anyone else experiencing extreme lag outside the general store in Valentine at night?

[ravynwolvf]

I can't sell wagons to the fence in Emerald Station. Did the quest, am almost done with chapter 2. I've tried three times now with different wagons, and the doors open and I drive in, then I talk to him quickly, but I never get any money. Worse yet, my menus get messed up. If I try to open my satchel, it flashes twice and closes again. I also lose my compass. The only way I can get it to work again is to exit the game entirely. It feels like the cutscene isn't entirely ending or something, though it doesn't stay in cinematic mode.

[Faber222]

 

 

Mission of dinosaur bones:
I sent the position of several bones at the same time.
Having sent the location of two bone locations at the same time I received more (two) pieces of quartz at the same time.
But if I withdraw the second piece of quartz, it does not appear as a new object received and only one remains in the inventory, and in practice it is lost.
then I sent two other positions but in mail there is still only 1 piece of quartz to recover (2 more lost) and anyway if the recovery does not appear in the bag