Red Dead Redemption 2: Discussion & Speculation (Part 2)

[Juan marstoon]

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

 

Could you make it a gif ? What is the mission called ?

Edited May 22, 2018 by Juan marstoon

[SeniorDerp]

At 0:14s that kick looks like gameplay. Press X to antagonize and collect de muneh

 

 

Besides, why would this particular scene be a cutscene ?

It has already been noted being able to interact with a lot of things. You go up, target Mr Muneh "Press X to antagonize" then walk over to the fire, target his soup "Press B to eat". The way interaction is being described makes this scene seem like its being created in-game by the user

Edited May 22, 2018 by SeniorDerp

[YouAreWrong]

Those physics man!

 

Rockstar definetly put the time and effort into them after hearing the dissapointed opinion of the physics in V!

 

Love R*!

[Spitta_Vercetti]

 

 

 

 

Maybe this was discussed before, but looking back at that trailer, dont you think the action shown from 0:14 s and 0:30 s may actually be an example of the npc interaction we've heard so much about ?

 

At 0:14s that kick looks like gameplay. Press X to antagonize and collect de muneh

 

 

Besides, why would this particular scene be a cutscene ?

And when he threatens the kids mother in the 2nd trailer?

I cant remember who it was but some channel that saw the demo uploaded a video showing all gameplay in the trailers IGN already confirmed that was gameplay when Arthur kicked the NPC

[~INDIO~]

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

Could you make it a gif ? What is the mission called ?

Sorry I'm not good with that kinda thing, but it's the 2nd mission you do with Seth on the way to Tumbleweed

[Juan marstoon]

 

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

Could you make it a gif ? What is the mission called ?

Sorry I'm not good with that kinda thing, but it's the 2nd mission you do with Seth on the way to Tumbleweed

 

 

Alright, np

[~INDIO~]

 

 

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

Could you make it a gif ? What is the mission called ?

Sorry I'm not good with that kinda thing, but it's the 2nd mission you do with Seth on the way to Tumbleweed

 

Alright, np

The mission is called A Gentle Drive With Friends

[paddymcg]

 

 

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

Could you make it a gif ? What is the mission called ?

Sorry I'm not good with that kinda thing, but it's the 2nd mission you do with Seth on the way to Tumbleweed

 

 

Alright, np

 

The mission is called 'A Gentle Drive With Friends'

 

[vKing]

If Arthur is fully customisable. How would you customise him?

I'm gonna double denim him up with a bowler hat and some lamb chop sideburns.

I'm going for a full short beard with an elegant moustache, either a top hat or bowler hat, tight pants and some type of classy shoes because i hate cowboy boots that almost reaches your knees and are bent at the tip. If there are hairstyles in the game then i think shaved sides with the remainder hair on top slicked either back or to one of the sides will look good.

Overall attire i'm going for something like what Javier is wearing:

(Javier you sexy c*nt you)

Also this blue wool jacket doesn't look too bad, might even make Arthur wear it in sunny weather lol.

Edited May 22, 2018 by vKing

[pjw]

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

 

Exactly my thoughts as well. I stumbled upon this video on YT and it shows the physics side by side.

 

It's weird because Rockstar has said that RDR2 is running on an upgraded version of the RAGE engine but the physics still looks very rough....

 

 

We're gonna write off the physics as being "very rough" based on a less than 1/2 second clip of a guy sliding along the ground? Healthy scepticism is warranted, but I thing we're overreacting here. The clip isn't long enough to ascertain much of anything. That said, when watching the clip in slow motion I noticed (contrary to what some say) the guy does actually move a little: his left leg buckles slightly as he slides along the ground, and his sliding body kicks up a bit of dust. Not much, but something positive to take from that clip at least. Although to reiterate, it's difficult to take anything meaningful away from a split second clip like that.

Edited May 22, 2018 by pjw

[HandSoap2811]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Maybe this was discussed before, but looking back at that trailer, dont you think the action shown from 0:14 s and 0:30 s may actually be an example of the npc interaction we've heard so much about ?

 

At 0:14s that kick looks like gameplay. Press X to antagonize and collect de muneh

 

 

Besides, why would this particular scene be a cutscene ?

And when he threatens the kids mother in the 2nd trailer?

I cant remember who it was but some channel that saw the demo uploaded a video showing all gameplay in the trailers

IGN already confirmed that was gameplay when Arthur kicked the NPC

 

Link?

[~INDIO~]

 

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

Exactly my thoughts as well. I stumbled upon this video on YT and it shows the physics side by side.

 

It's weird because Rockstar has said that RDR2 is running on an upgraded version of the RAGE engine but the physics still looks very rough....

 

We're gonna write off the physics as being "very rough" based on a less than 1/2 second clip of a guy sliding along the ground? Healthy scepticism is warranted, but I thing we're overreacting here. The clip isn't long enough to ascertain much of anything. That said, when watching the clip in slow motion I noticed (contrary to what some say) the guy does actually move a little: his left leg buckles slightly as he slides along the ground, and his sliding body kicks up a bit of dust. Not much, but something positive to take from that clip at least. Although to reiterate, it's difficult to take anything meaningful away from a split second clip like that.

Oh wow, his left leg buckled ever so slightly guiz!?

[luke73tnt]

This drought may be the shortest, but its the hardest

[Spitta_Vercetti]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Maybe this was discussed before, but looking back at that trailer, dont you think the action shown from 0:14 s and 0:30 s may actually be an example of the npc interaction we've heard so much about ?

 

At 0:14s that kick looks like gameplay. Press X to antagonize and collect de muneh

 

 

Besides, why would this particular scene be a cutscene ?

And when he threatens the kids mother in the 2nd trailer?

I cant remember who it was but some channel that saw the demo uploaded a video showing all gameplay in the trailers

IGN already confirmed that was gameplay when Arthur kicked the NPC

 

Link? Im not good with posting links just YouTube : IGN - RDR 2 Gameplay....they also stated the campfire scene in the third trailer was gameplay as well and not a cutscene

 

[Hugoat]

I do not know about you guys but I'm not feeling the drought (It must be because I know I'm going to see RDR2 again next month) anyway I always look at the screenshots several times and it calms me down.

* On this day last year RDR2 was delayed until "Spring 2018" ...

[Spitta_Vercetti]

I do not know about you guys but I'm not feeling the drought (It must be because I know I'm going to see RDR2 again next month) anyway I always look at the screenshots several times and it calms me down.

* On this day last year RDR2 was delayed until "Spring 2018" ...

https://goo.gl/images/6h3abL yep and this was one of the first screenshots which now Arthur, Javier , Bill & Micah Bell.....

[joshua969]

I do not know about you guys but I'm not feeling the drought (It must be because I know I'm going to see RDR2 again next month) anyway I always look at the screenshots several times and it calms me down.

* On this day last year RDR2 was delayed until "Spring 2018" ...

Once mid-late August comes, I think I'll start feeling the drought more. If we're lucky, maybe we'll see something new every month until release, even if it's just screenshots.

 

I'm wondering when they're going to officially announce the artbook that was leaked before the blowout.

[Hugoat]

Probably next month with the special editions

[Guest Guest176525326]

 

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

 

Exactly my thoughts as well. I stumbled upon this video on YT and it shows the physics side by side.

 

It's weird because Rockstar has said that RDR2 is running on an upgraded version of the RAGE engine but the physics still looks very rough....

 

 

We're gonna write off the physics as being "very rough" based on a less than 1/2 second clip of a guy sliding along the ground? Healthy scepticism is warranted, but I thing we're overreacting here. The clip isn't long enough to ascertain much of anything. That said, when watching the clip in slow motion I noticed (contrary to what some say) the guy does actually move a little: his left leg buckles slightly as he slides along the ground, and his sliding body kicks up a bit of dust. Not much, but something positive to take from that clip at least. Although to reiterate, it's difficult to take anything meaningful away from a split second clip like that.

 

 

Because half a second clip is plenty to figure out how things might turn up. Remember that famous GTAV trailer where the cars had adapted that look of the Midnight Club arcade feel, and everybody were wondering and worried that the cars had no weight, suspension etc, well guess how that turned out? GTAV's driving got watered down from the realistic physics of GTAIV. That is how.

[Jason]

You're absolutely mad if you think a half second clip is enough to judge a major pillar of the game, especially one as varied as physics. Wait for the gameplay trailer and other trailers, find other examples of the physics looking off than just the one. The fact that people are writing off physics over one example is mad.

 

We have more signs pointing to RDR1 style physics than not, especially with features like slow-mo kill cams.

[Potter145]

I also don't feel the drought at all lol

 

I'm still going through all the information released 20 days ago and still can't comprehend everything.

[Ray_Velcoro]

 

I know they did this last time and nothing happened but I hope we will see something

[Synthetic_Soul]

Once the gameplay trailer comes out is when the REAL drought starts.

 

Binge watching that f*cker 20+ times a day...hours will seem like days!

 

And don't even get me started on those first 25 days of October.

Edited May 22, 2018 by Synthetic_Soul

[pjw]

 

 

 

Just been playing the mission where Seth is throwing dead bodies off the back of the stagecoach.. looks like the guy being thrown off that one in the 3rd trailer when he lands and doesn't move

 

Exactly my thoughts as well. I stumbled upon this video on YT and it shows the physics side by side.

 

It's weird because Rockstar has said that RDR2 is running on an upgraded version of the RAGE engine but the physics still looks very rough....

 

 

We're gonna write off the physics as being "very rough" based on a less than 1/2 second clip of a guy sliding along the ground? Healthy scepticism is warranted, but I thing we're overreacting here. The clip isn't long enough to ascertain much of anything. That said, when watching the clip in slow motion I noticed (contrary to what some say) the guy does actually move a little: his left leg buckles slightly as he slides along the ground, and his sliding body kicks up a bit of dust. Not much, but something positive to take from that clip at least. Although to reiterate, it's difficult to take anything meaningful away from a split second clip like that.

 

 

Because half a second clip is plenty to figure out how things might turn up. Remember that famous GTAV trailer where the cars had adapted that look of the Midnight Club arcade feel, and everybody were wondering and worried that the cars had no weight, suspension etc, well guess how that turned out? GTAV's driving got watered down from the realistic physics of GTAIV. That is how.

 

I disagree. A half second clip provides us with fuel for speculation, and those speculations may turn out to be true. But, the clip in question doesn't provide enough information for us to determine how the physics will turn out with any degree of certainty. Speculation is fun, though we should avoid being cocksure.

 

When we get our first look at gameplay, once we have more examples of the physics in action, is I think when we'll be able to work out the nature of the in game physics.

[SuperKitsune]

Once the gameplay trailer comes out is when the REAL drought starts.

 

Binge watching that f*cker 20+ times a day...hours will seem like days!

 

And don't even get me started on those first 25 days of October.

Bruh, we survived the great droughts of 2016-2017 and 2017-2018. We're drought veterans by now. We've seen everything from Rockstar.

[Keith_The_Triangle]

I will take GTA Vs driving over IVs any day of the week. sh*t was like driving a boat on ice, almost ruined the game for me

Edited May 22, 2018 by Keith_The_Triangle

[Trenzalore616]

[joshua969]

Once the gameplay trailer comes out is when the REAL drought starts.

 

Binge watching that f*cker 20+ times a day...hours will seem like days!

 

And don't even get me started on those first 25 days of October.

October 2018 will be the longest month in this forums history.

[Zello]

 

 

ARGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHH

YOU ARE A WEAKLNG IF YOU CANT DRIVE IN IV!!!!!!!!!!

DRIVING IN IV IS FOR REAL MEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ZELLO SMASH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[VigMarston]

This'll be us when October rolls around