Red Dead Redemption 2: Discussion & Speculation (Part 2)

[Catskill]

 

 

Talking about members of the forum is off topic?

Well seeing as people were given warnings on the previous pages to stop talking about the physics of RDR, its pretty off topic if you ask me.

Thats because we already have a physics thread. Discussing the sh*tty behavior of a member of the forum is fine for general chat

 

 

So talking about features of RDR in a topic about RDR discussion is more off topic than talking about about why someone was banned and speculating what other accounts they were using?

 

Yeah great logic.

[paddymcg]

Probably RDR2 will only be mentioned in E3. Something about DLCs at the Sony conference.

That's the only way I see it happening.

 

I highly doubt Rockstar will be at E3, I'd put good money on it but I think it's highly likely RDR2 will show up briefly in Sony's conference to tease some timed exclusive stuff.

[Frantz Fuchs]

Probably RDR2 will only be mentioned in E3. Something about DLCs at the Sony conference.

 

I agree, Sony will most likely announce some exclusive online stuff/special editions. We won't see another trailer or gameplay.

[TheOriginalGunslinger]

Hold up (haven't been on in a few days) but Dee got banned again?

 

Edited May 14, 2018 by TheOriginalGunslinger

[DirtCheap]

Can't wait to battle bears, pumas, snakes, wolves, foxes, gators, lynxes, birds, foxes, dogs, boars, coyotes, lawmen, bounty hunters, agents and outlaws in RDR2.

[~INDIO~]

 

 

 

Talking about members of the forum is off topic?

Well seeing as people were given warnings on the previous pages to stop talking about the physics of RDR, its pretty off topic if you ask me.

Thats because we already have a physics thread. Discussing the sh*tty behavior of a member of the forum is fine for general chat

 

So talking about features of RDR in a topic about RDR discussion is more off topic than talking about about why someone was banned and speculating what other accounts they were using?

 

Yeah great logic.

Agree 100%. Get warned for discussing the game but people can talk sh*t about Dee all day long and that's fine. It's laughable

[Keith_The_Triangle]

Its because we already have a dedicated thread to bitching about physics.

Edited May 14, 2018 by Keith_The_Triangle

[~INDIO~]

Its because we already have a dedicated thread to bitching about physics.

At least we were talking about the game and not some forum member that keeps getting banned. It's called Red Dead Discussion not Dee Discussion.

[Cutter De Blanc]

We already have a dedicated forum for bitching about other forum members

[DirtCheap]

Imagine if in RDR2, there's a Pinkerton agent who promises you money if you do tasks for him until the end where he admits he was lying all along.

[Keith_The_Triangle]

We already have a dedicated forum for bitching about other forum members

Do we?

And btw INDIO I agree with you. I think its very stupid how discussions keep getting moved to other threads. I was just trying to explain what I think the logic was. I am 100% with you

[Jason]

The reason why things like physics and graphics discussion have their own threads and have discussions about them pushed towards those threads is because they are topics that tend to completely take over the general chat topic. The Dee thing is pretty much over after a page but physics and graphics discussions can and have lasted for pages and pages and generally kill all other discussion and chatter in the topic, or dissuade people from posting as they tend to get a bit heated.

 

I swear, everytime one of those topics gets told to keep it in their relevant thread the next topic in this thread gets moaned about for being off topic and it being stupid that the last topic was told to keep it to the relevant threads, lol.

[Cutter De Blanc]

 

We already have a dedicated forum for bitching about other forum members

Do we?

I was under the impression that that's what "The Pit" is for

[greenrock]

did the first RDR mention that Dutch was progressive when it came to race and gender

 

 

has a native american, an african american, a mexican in his gang, plus a few women

 

[Spider-Vice]

The reason why things like physics and graphics discussion have their own threads and have discussions about them pushed towards those threads is because they are topics that tend to completely take over the general chat topic. The Dee thing is pretty much over after a page but physics and graphics discussions can and have lasted for pages and pages and generally kill all other discussion and chatter in the topic, or dissuade people from posting as they tend to get a bit heated.

 

I swear, everytime one of those topics gets told to keep it in their relevant thread the next topic in this thread gets moaned about for being off topic and it being stupid that the last topic was told to keep it to the relevant threads, lol.

This man knows the drill!

[Keith_The_Triangle]

did the first RDR mention that Dutch was progressive when it came to race and gender

 

 

has a native american, an african american, a mexican in his gang, plus a few women

 

His entire gang in RDR was made up of disaffected Native Americans

[Big_Smiley]

 

 

We already have a dedicated forum for bitching about other forum members

Do we?

I was under the impression that that's what "The Pit" is for Indeed it is. Massive sh*tfest, but i f*cking love it.

[eyman]

did the first RDR mention that Dutch was progressive when it came to race and gender

 

has a native american, an african american, a mexican in his gang, plus a few women

Well he is often regarded as a very Robin Hood esque figure (Heroic Outlaw), fighting for those who were considered outcast by society at the time, even if it meant he had to steal and kill. Dutch stood by that until his death, as can be seen in RDR when he decided to live with natives.

 

There really is more to Dutch, it just depends on what angle you see him from and I think RDR II will showcase all those angles.

Edited May 14, 2018 by eyman

[SuperKitsune]

 

 

 

 

Dee was Pinkerton spy?

Yeah lol

Like this place couldnt get any weirder

On a different note...has Damien been around lately ?

Dee was pinkerton spy?! Well..he did live up to his alias. You can say that much...

 

And I was just going to ask the same. Where is Damien at?

 

Apparently his phone got stolen, idk if that's the reason for his recent absence though.

 

Also Dee seems like the kinda person that would claim responsibility for another troll(Pinkerton) if he was already on the way out, so idk if I buy that - unless of course they found ties between the two accounts.

How do you know his phone got stolen?

 

Yeah..maybe Dee is just hungry for any kind of attention. Who really knows.

[Spider-Vice]

There were ties between the two accounts. Now please let's let this subject die, it's not the place for it.

[luke73tnt]

Just watched the 3rd trailer again, I realize now the person giving the fire speech doesnt actually sound like Dutch all that much

Edited May 14, 2018 by Spider-Vice
edited ref to deleted post

[Reno_]

Before we get any new info, this whole thread is pretty much done. We're more ghosts than users

[Mr. Jabe]

Imagine if in RDR2, there's a Pinkerton agent who promises you money if you do tasks for him until the end where he admits he was lying all along.

 

That pretty much sounds like the plot of every GTA V Strangers & Freaks mission!!

Edited May 14, 2018 by Mr. Jabe

[B_E_N_1992]

So is Red dead Redemption 3 confirmed with seeing Dutch at a younger age about 30 ?. Hopefully we'll know about his earlier life & the premise will be set for what the story will be.

 

​I can imagine Indians being more present in RDR3

​

​It will come obviously in about 2026

Edited May 14, 2018 by B_E_N_1992

[Jason]

I think it's a decade too soon to be talking about RDR3 lol

[Mr. Jabe]

Just watched the 3rd trailer again, I realize now the person giving the fire speech doesnt actually sound like Dutch all that much

 

I've made a topic where everyone can comment "Dutch" or "Not Dutch" depending on who they believe speaks those lines. It'll be interesting to keep a record so we can see who was right (and who was wrong) come the moment of truth.

 

Comment if you want..........or don't, if you don't give a f**k!!

Edited May 14, 2018 by Mr. Jabe

[phenetole]

So is Red dead Redemption 3 confirmed with seeing Dutch at a younger age about 30 ?. Hopefully we'll know about his earlier life & the premise will be set for what the story will be.

 

​I can imagine Indians being more present in RDR3

​

​It will come obviously in about 2026

 

For RDR3 I'd love to play as a prospector during the gold rush. Or a native american with the atmosphere of the The Revenant.

[B_E_N_1992]

Yes but first we need bully 2, agent and gta VI. Then rdr3

[SuperKitsune]

So is Red dead Redemption 3 confirmed with seeing Dutch at a younger age about 30 ?. Hopefully we'll know about his earlier life & the premise will be set for what the story will be.

 

âI can imagine Indians being more present in RDR3

â

âIt will come obviously in about 2026

You got a deathwish, boy? The thought alone of the drought and pointless speculation for that game can kill a man. Edited May 14, 2018 by SuperKitsune

[Cutter De Blanc]

Confirmed does not mean "Evidence points to but we have no definitive proof"