What are the chances that Jack is actually Dutch's kid?

[Mirror Park Resident 8,001]

Nah, if ever Uncle had Abigail, it was paying for it. John is more annoyed about Uncle's laziness than the possibility of Uncle banging his wife. With Abigail retired from that life, that's a no go. 

 

She still has a soft spot for Uncle, Uncle brought her to the gang and she brought Uncle to the rancher life. But Uncle is called Uncle and not "daddy" for a reason, like @Arthur Bell said.

 

As for Jack's real father, who cares. He looks after John enough to not make a big drama about who's the real father. Although John did that once, lol 

Edited December 5, 2018 by Fluffy Sock

[jje1000 852]

I also find it interesting how flustered John seems to get when Abigail or Uncle talk about Arthur at Beecher's Hope.

 

It looks like John feels some sort of inadequacy as a father figure compared to Arthur, especially considering that he and Jack never really do get close to one another.

 

 

Edited December 5, 2018 by jje1000

[Smokewood 2,135]

zero chance.

The game tells you in Arthur's journal that Jack is in fact John's kid.