Red Dead Redemption 2 Gameplay Series Discussion

[tsycho]

7 minutes ago, TDWPMark said:

Yeah, exactly. This would break the immersion af.

[Catfish Pie]

LOL! Godmode hacking child NPC noobs!

 

[Red Dead Rebel]

6 minutes ago, tsycho said:

Yeah, exactly. This would break the immersion af.

Making Arthur throw dynamite at kids in the first place is immersion breaking AF.

Edited August 16, 2018 by Red Dead Rebel

[Ajax-D]

1 hour ago, LeonVegaSuarez said:

not sure if serious, but weather changes won't go as far as changing the type of landscape of a region. Deserts won't turn into grasslands and vice versa.

Erosion

[Yelda]

I could definitely live better with the solution in the shown video than with dead children ... f * ck sry but realism goes too far imo. I have nothing against gore and bloodbaths in games, but that would be the worst thing for me. THAT would break my immersion! I hope R* will make them immortal or will find a other solution here ...

Edited August 16, 2018 by Yelda

[tsycho]

Just now, Red Dead Rebel said:

Making Arthur throw dynamite at kids in the first place is immersion breaking AF.

You're right. Didn't even think about that tbh...

Don't get me wrong, guys. I DON'T want to kill children

[Horrid_Saiyam]

So are we expecting any sort of info today from R* since it’s a Thursday  

[Zello]

This is how R* handles the children problem. Arthur can only use a belt to whip children if their parents tell him that they're misbehaving instead of disciplining them they call Arthur instead to do it for them.

[MrHarlow]

10 minutes ago, Horrid_Saiyam said:

So are we expecting any sort of info today from R* since it’s a Thursday  

Merch maybe. Artwork? Art book? 

[AdlersHand]

5 minutes ago, Zello said:

This is how R* handles the children problem. Arthur can only use a belt to whip children if their parents tell him that they're misbehaving instead of disciplining them they call Arthur instead to do it for them.

 

 

[Spadeflush]

48 minutes ago, Red Hardbro said:

I keep saying in September is when we may get the next one but I hope its sooner. I hope we don't go back to the long waits again!!!

We've been spoiled enough this spring/summer, there will be another 7 month wait until the next gameplay trailer. 

 

29 minutes ago, Yelda said:

This is a interesting article about gambling in the old west: Gambling in the Old West
I think it would be cool to see other card games than the usual ones like Texas Hold´em or BlackJack  ... 

Personally I loved liar´s dice and horseshoes more than the card games ^^

Eh, some people are card games guys while others are dice games guys. Actually I think thats what RDR2 needs: dice games other than liar's dice. 

 

38 minutes ago, tsycho said:

I know this discussion has been here before but: How do you think R* will handle the children we saw? They won't let us kill them pretty sure, but i don't think children will only be seen in cutscenes, that would be kinda weird. In some games your character pulls his gun up or you simply can't shoot when you aim at a companion, so you don't even have a chance to shoot them. Maybe that's a solution... But what about explosions (dynamite)? You throw dynamite into a crowd of people and the only one who survies is a child? Can't imagine that...

Arthur will just refuse to throw the dynamite if its gonna land on kids. Even if the dynamite has already been lit. He might say something like "I can't do this" similar to how Geralt sometimes talks to the player. 

[Xerukal]

They could also make the children immortal.

[Reno_]

You should get something like a wasted screen for killing a child.

[Feather]

I hope fire bottles return, those were really cool in RDR.

[philley]

6 minutes ago, Feather said:

I hope fire bottles return, those were really cool in RDR.

You mean molotows?

 

Because THIS is a fire bottle and THIS is a bottle on fire

Edited August 16, 2018 by philley

[The Jungz]

I hope children are killable, makes you think twice before going into a town with your guns drawn. You can murder cats and dogs in GTA V but I never did it because I think it's sick, but it's nice to know that the option is there. Same with kids.

 

In short, if it's in the game, it should be killable. If kids are immortal then get them the f*ck out of the game.

Edited August 16, 2018 by ThroatSlasher2

[Emmi]

Maybe you are restricted to use any kind of weapon at the gangs' camp? Outside the camp they could make NPC kids anticipate stuff like Arthur throwing dynamite near their area so they run away in advance and won't get hurt? Either way I'm sure R* found a good solution to this matter.

[AdlersHand]

Just now, ThroatSlasher2 said:

I hope children are killable.... You can murder cats and dogs in GTA V....  it's nice to know that the option is there. 

 

 

Not aimed at you but

[Reno_]

7 minutes ago, ThroatSlasher2 said:

I hope children are killable, makes you think twice before going into a town with your guns drawn. You can murder cats and dogs in GTA V but I never did it because I think it's sick, but it's nice to know that the option is there. Same with kids.

 

In short, if it's in the game, it should be killable. If kids are immortal then get them the f*ck out of the game.

That's not that bad. It would make you feel bad if you were going into towns guns blazing and kill a child by accident. Would make some people think twice before throwing dynamites and molotovs from your horse. It's still immersion breaking for Arthur to do so though.

[Red Dead Rebel]

21 minutes ago, philley said:

You mean molotows?

 

Because THIS is a fire bottle and THIS is a bottle on fire

 

This is a fire bottle.

[Spadeflush]

Kids were gonna be in GTA III, but then Rockstar took them out because they thought of the backlash that would arise. And that was in 2001, the world wasn't even as "pussified" as it is today. 

[philley]

13 minutes ago, Red Dead Rebel said:

 

This is a fire bottle.

HA! Really? Funny!

[Feather]

1 minute ago, philley said:

HA! Really? Funny!

Thats what you get for being a smartass lmao

[eighthdoctor]

9 hours ago, Aborted_Fetus said:

Of all the beautiful moments shown in the video, this is one of my favorite shots. I just love everything about it. The lighting (dusk or dawn?), the way the collar of the jacket flaps, that badass walk like he's untouchable, and the grimace on his face - or whatever you'd call that expression.

That expression says "I haven't had my coffee yet, don't f*k with me."  

[TwistedMedia]

I think Arthur will refuse to shoot children (similar to how some games don't let you fire at Friendly AI) and as for explosions, I can see them just being able to outrun the blast radius. Or possibly when the shooting starts the kids all immediately run away and "disappear" into buildings that we have no access to.

[NightWalker14]

Is this a cat?

 

[LeonVegaSuarez]

Bros...the wait is getting worse and worse. This game cannot come soon enough.

[ThereIsNoBathroom]

17 minutes ago, NightWalker14 said:

Is this a cat?

Yep i see two cats

 

Edited August 16, 2018 by ThereIsNoBathroom

[Auditore]

6 hours ago, DGSimo said:

He got banned once for having a alt account, now it seems like he's back with another being his usual annoying self. That or its a Dee alt which also wouldn't surprise me given the number of infamous alt accounts he had here. lol

Nah Dee is in there as Dee,he called out GreenRock for using a alt-account recently.

[Haggis Basher]

27 minutes ago, ThereIsNoBathroom said:

Yep i see two cats

 

I wonder how many different types of animals there will be in the game.