Split thread

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

[J.Dillinger Blackheart]

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

Sadie isnt some uppity looking woman like this. She is part of a outlaw gang, Why would she look anything like this.

[Idro_Novenalen]

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

 

Clearly, this woman here ain't an outlaw. Jeeeeesus

 

 

 

to be clear, this is Pearl Hart

Edited May 7, 2018 by Idro_Novenalen

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

 

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

 

Clearly, this woman here ain't an outlaw. Jeeeeesus

 

 

 

to be clear, this is Pearl Hart

 

 

She looks nothing like Sadler tho'. It's okay this forum is blinded by critisism on Rockstar, but facts are facts. Also, it's not the clothes I'm talking about, it's the face. She has a face nobody back then had.

[JordanDFC17]

 

 

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

Clearly, this woman here ain't an outlaw. Jeeeeesus

 

 

 

to be clear, this is Pearl Hart

 

She looks nothing like Sadler tho'. It's okay this forum is blinded by critisism on Rockstar, but facts are facts. Also, it's not the clothes I'm talking about, it's the face. She has a face nobody back then had.

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

[J.Dillinger Blackheart]

 

 

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

Clearly, this woman here ain't an outlaw. Jeeeeesus

 

 

 

to be clear, this is Pearl Hart

 

She looks nothing like Sadler tho'. It's okay this forum is blinded by critisism on Rockstar, but facts are facts. Also, it's not the clothes I'm talking about, it's the face. She has a face nobody back then had.

LML wait Whut!? Nevermind smh lol. Its too early lol

[DisCrafted]

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

Edited May 7, 2018 by DisCrafted

[JordanDFC17]

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890'sSorry I didn't see how clear it was, but I realise now he's a time travelling game critic

[DisCrafted]

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's

Sorry I didn't see how clear it was, but I realise now he's a time travelling game critic

 

Yep, we totally have those now...

[SuperKing573]

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

Im going to be honest, Id rather see her fighting along side the gang rather than Sadie.

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

[J.Dillinger Blackheart]

Next somebody is going to be pissed at fingernails not growing or arthur not being able take a sh*t.

[DisCrafted]

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

Right, cause we have a picture of every single woman that lived back then...

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

Next somebody is going to be pissed at fingernails not growing or arthur not being able take a sh*t.

 

The new AI Rockstar have worked on is gonna do it's job on those details Not on women's face in the game. It's dissapointing that a billionare company can't set an realistic approach to their games.

[Red Dead Rebel]

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

 

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

 

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

Right, cause we have a picture of every single woman that lived back then...

 

 

Just Google "Women 1800's" bro. Then there's hundreds of pics you can go through and find me some proof on.

[JordanDFC17]

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

Again how do you know? You've seen some pictures of ugly women from the late 1800s and assumed they all looked like that

[J.Dillinger Blackheart]

 

Next somebody is going to be pissed at fingernails not growing or arthur not being able take a sh*t.

The new AI Rockstar have worked on is gonna do it's job on those details Not on women's face in the game. It's dissapointing that a billionare company can't set an realistic approach to their games.

Your the only one who gives a f*ck, because i sure don't find it disappointing. I could give a flying f*cktard how "realistic" people look. As long as the characters capture that western vibe IDGAF how historically accurate it is.

[DisCrafted]

 

 

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

Right, cause we have a picture of every single woman that lived back then...

 

 

Just Google "Women 1800's" bro. Then there's hundreds of pics you can go through and find me some proof on.

 

You missed the point, yet again.

[Matrelith]

We all know beauty was invented in 1930 by Johnathan Beauty when he looked at a woman one day and thought to himself ''I would''.

Edited May 7, 2018 by Matrelith

[Lexiture]

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

Do you think they were monkeys? Your messages have nothing to apport here, also do you think every women had the social status to wear like her?

 

Look at this one, from the same era.

 

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

 

 

Next somebody is going to be pissed at fingernails not growing or arthur not being able take a sh*t.

The new AI Rockstar have worked on is gonna do it's job on those details Not on women's face in the game. It's dissapointing that a billionare company can't set an realistic approach to their games.

Your the only one who gives a f*ck, because i sure don't find it disappointing. I could give a flying f*cktard how "realistic" people look. As long as the characters capture that western vibe IDGAF how historically accurate it is.

 

 

Calm down. Only a little kid uses "only you care" btw. Just because I have a different opinion on how a game should be made makes me wrong? I suppose what you want in the game is facts, not an opinion. Also incoming Mr Morgan like on your post.

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

 

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

Do you think they were monkeys? Your messages have nothing to apport here, also do you think every women had the social status to wear like her?

 

Look at this one, from the same era.

 

 

 

You missed me the point. Try to explain how the girl in the pic you posted looks anything close to Saddie's face. Yes, outlaws looked like that back then with their apperance, but they did not look like a victoria secret model.

[JordanDFC17]

Plus sadies character model was probably based on her voice actor who *breaking news* isn't from the 1890s

[Nutduster]

 

 

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

 

Clearly, this woman here ain't an outlaw. Jeeeeesus

 

 

 

to be clear, this is Pearl Hart

 

 

She looks nothing like Sadler tho'. It's okay this forum is blinded by critisism on Rockstar, but facts are facts. Also, it's not the clothes I'm talking about, it's the face. She has a face nobody back then had.

 

 

I'm dumber for having read this post. How fast do you think evolution works that women apparently have completely different faces in the span of a handful of generations?

 

Also, this just in: Red Dead Redemption (original or part II) is not focused on realism. It is based mainly on Westerns, which were themselves the building up of a largely fictitious myth of what the old frontier was actually like. Westerns in the 50s and 60s had men and women who looked very much like men and women of the 50s and 60s, not of the late 1800s (and I mean their hair and makeup, not their actual faces). They also, like this game, featured wall-to-wall shootouts and excitement when those events were actually quite rare even in the wildest parts of the Old West. This game never purported to be realistic. Wanting it to be is like wanting GTA to be more realistic and less like a Scorsese movie.

Edited May 7, 2018 by Nutduster

[Lexiture]

 

 

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

Do you think they were monkeys? Your messages have nothing to apport here, also do you think every women had the social status to wear like her?

 

Look at this one, from the same era.

 

 

 

You missed me the point. Try to explain how the girl in the pic you posted looks anything close to Saddie's face. Yes, outlaws looked like that back then with their apperance, but they did not look like a victoria secret model.

 

A Victoria Secret model doesn't have scratches on her face. Or stab someone on the hand during an argument.

But why are you worried about that? Can't you enjoy life?

 

Are you going to play the game going full neck-beard stating to your mum how this game is not historically-accurate?

Edited May 7, 2018 by Lexiture

[GeorgeWashingtonxx77]

 

 

 

It's a weird thing to point out, but it pisses me off how Rockstar makes characters like Sadie Alder when women back in those days looked completely different. People's appereance evolve by time. Sadie is some hot chick you could find in a bar nowadays, not in the late 1800's. This is how a typical caucasian woman looked like in 1899:

 

 

Clearly, this woman here ain't an outlaw. Jeeeeesus

 

 

 

to be clear, this is Pearl Hart

 

 

She looks nothing like Sadler tho'. It's okay this forum is blinded by critisism on Rockstar, but facts are facts. Also, it's not the clothes I'm talking about, it's the face. She has a face nobody back then had.

 

 

I'm dumber for having read this post. How fast do you think evolution works that women apparently have completely different faces in the span of a handful of generations?

 

Also, this just in: Red Dead Redemption (original or part II) is not focused on realism. It is based mainly on Westerns, which were themselves the building up of a largely fictitious myth of what the old frontier was actually like. Westerns in the 50s and 60s had men and women who looked very much like men and women of the 50s and 60s, not of the late 1800s (and I mean their hair and makeup, not their actual faces). They also, like this game, featured wall-to-wall shootouts and excitement when those events were actually quite rare even in the wildest parts of the Old West. This game never purported to be realistic. Wanting it to be is like wanting GTA to be more realistic and less like a Scorsese movie.

 

 

I give up, everything you just wrote is something I agree with, but you still have the nerve to post that long ass text without context. I never said that it HAS to set an realistic approach, It's just something I would like. What's wrong with me wanting something in the game?

[1898]

 

 

 

Westerns in the 50s and 60s had men and women who looked very much like men and women of the 50s and 60s, not of the late 1800s (and I mean their hair and makeup, not their actual faces).

 

 

Ah yes, who can forget the 50s westerns stars sporting rockabilly haircuts then the 60s when taken over by long haired hippies and beatniks.

[Idro_Novenalen]

 

 

How do you know? Who's to say there wasn't women walking around who looked like sadie?

 

He CLEARLY lived in the 1890's! That's the only explanation. /s

 

 

If you are going to insult me, atleast do it while backing up with some proof on this matter. Women was not attractive back then. They became hot in the mid 1900's.

 

 

[Nutduster]

 

 

 

 

Westerns in the 50s and 60s had men and women who looked very much like men and women of the 50s and 60s, not of the late 1800s (and I mean their hair and makeup, not their actual faces).

 

 

Ah yes, who can forget the 50s westerns stars sporting rockabilly haircuts then the 60s when taken over by long haired hippies and beatniks.

 

 

I guess what you know of history comes entirely from half hour documentaries, huh? Most people in both of those decades were neither greasers nor hippies. The fact is that Hollywood (and its foreign competitors) have always bent in the direction of current fashion. It's less noticeable in Westerns but definitely present, in the hair, the clothes and the makeup. It's their way to try to make their movie less dated (when it comes out), though it also ends up making the movie seem MORE dated later on. It's even more obvious in sci fi movies, often set in the future or on other planets/galaxies, but somehow still reflecting the fashions of the day as if through a prism. e.g. Han Solo and Luke Skywalker's feathered 70s hairdos in A New Hope.