Who is Arthur Morgan talking to in the first trailer? What do you think?

[tsycho]

“Listen to me... When the time comes, you gotta run and don’t look back... This is over...”

 

We are now sure that the voice belongs to Arthur. Who is he talking to? Dutch? Marston? Someone else? Maybe someone who isn't a member of the gang? Let me know what you think about this.

[alex3]

I think he's talking to Marston at the end of the game.

[1898]

Definitely not Dutch, I don't think he likes him. The "Listen to me" is something he would say to someone that he has some authority over so Marston is my guess.

Edited November 8, 2017 by 1898

[PapasHota]

Hes talking to that blonde woman

Edited November 8, 2017 by PapasHota

[B Dawg]

Probably to his horse. Gotta take care of your steed. A man's best friend in the wild west is his horse.

Edited November 8, 2017 by B Dawg

[Cutter De Blanc]

He's talking to the gamer about Take-Two's business practices

[MojoGamer]

I dunno, maybe we need Morgan Freeman's help

[GTAFanClub]

He could be talking to his dog but my guess is Marston.

[DexMacLeod]

I think Arthur and a bunch of others have had enough of Dutch and are about to turn on him/leave the gang. This line is him telling them all that the days of the Dutch van der Linde gang are numbered and it's gonna get ugly.

[Pedinhuh]

Either Marston or Abigail, telling them to f*ck off the gang when the time comes.

 

This could mean that Arthur knew about the gang's intention of ditching Marston...

 

...Maybe the botched robbery(was it a train robbery?) was a setup to kill Marston???

 

sh*t, I guess I stumbled upon a spoiler here.

[Hunter S. Compton]

Either Marston or Abigail, telling them to f*ck off the gang when the time comes.

 

This could mean that Arthur knew about the gang's intention of ditching Marston...

 

...Maybe the botched robbery(was it a train robbery?) was a setup to kill Marston???

 

sh*t, I guess I stumbled upon a spoiler here.

Don't get ahead of yourself. Basically all of that is conjecture.

 

And no, the botched Robbery that wounded John was on a Ferry (possibly the wrecked Serendipity from the first game).

[Rucke]

I hope he is talking to Marston. That would be really epic.

[Star-Lord]

I hope he is talking to Marston. That would be really epic.

I second that motion.

[Rucke]

 

I hope he is talking to Marston. That would be really epic.

I second that motion.

 

Hopefully near the end of the game when the gang is starting to fall apart and Dutch is becoming more and more crazy.

[eyman]

At the end of Red dead Redemption, John Marston tells Abigail and Jack "Keep riding and don't look back".

Full circle. Maybe it's the same fate but through the eyes of another man.

Edited November 13, 2017 by eyman

[Dee-account-with-1kbans]

John. Or that Blonde girl

[DexMacLeod]

 

 

I hope he is talking to Marston. That would be really epic.

I second that motion.

 

Hopefully near the end of the game when the gang is starting to fall apart and Dutch is becoming more and more crazy.

 

I'd be pretty surprised if the first line we ever heard from the game comes from near the end of the story.

[Femme Fatale]

It could be someone we'd least suspect. Just look at Niko's life is complicated speech from IV's first trailer, he said it to Ileyna Faustin, a rather minor character in the game's story.

[J.Dillinger Blackheart]

could be anyone, doesn't sound like arthur to me tho, or dutch.

[Piggsy pls]

Michael's narration from the first GTA V trailer wasn't even in the game. Anything's possible.

[DIEXEL]

A young John Marston.

[Corndawg93]

I think he's talking to John Marston right before the ferry heist

[Yelda]

Maybe it´s Marston and his young family ... or the girl from the trailer? It can be anyone ...

If Arthur said that to Marston, he ignored his words and had to learned it on the hard way.
Besides I wonder, how did John get off the fairy when he got wounded? Someone must have helped him ...

[HandSoap2811]

John at the river boat