Rate the Profile Above You

[Queen]

Lots of us put a great deal of effort into our profile pages (specifically their About Me section), so I thought it'd be helpful to have a rating topic for them as well. If this has been done before, and crashed and burned, feel free to delete the topic. I just thought it'd be interesting. And it'd be great if people didn't just rate, but also left feedback on what they liked and/or didn't like.

 

So let's get started...rate mine, I guess.

Edited February 15, 2016 by Queen

[Flachbau]

I thought about starting something similar but I never got to it. Thanks for making this I don't think this violates any rules since most of us have a lot of graphic related work on our About Me sections.

 

For your About Me section, I rate it a 9/10. Very neat and organized, but I personally liked how you had it before (with the NOTW tid-bits).

[The Dedito Gae]

I'll bite.

 

 

I'll give you a 9/10, you have links to your accounts on other sites, a song of the week that you update, a respect list that gets shorter every month, a bunch of medals and a post of me!

[[...]]

6/10

[Nico]

It's well organized. 9/10

[Pavle]

I like the picture where it shows how great I am at rekting people. Also dat Facade logo.

 

Solid 10/10.

[Queen]

You've got the Facade logo, which is awesome (though perhaps a bit too small) and takes you to their page. It's also great that you have a link to your Steam page, and the Newbie guide. Extra point is awarded for a quote from American Pyscho. and an extra two points awarded for the Shania Twain song. I reward you with [9/10].

[The Dedito Gae]

6/10

This isn't fair m8, i been trying to keep it simple and following the same template for months, sad MH is sad MH.

 

Ignore this salty post and rate Mr. Queen's profile.

[Flachbau]

I already rated Queen's profile.. so

 

I rate yours a 7/10. It made me chortle.

[PhillBellic]

8/10. Simple and Clean.

 

Deducted One Point because the 'Current Gangs' Icons could have been set up to redirect/link to the Page for that Group. Kind of like what you have done with your 'Social Media' Section.

 

[Nico]

lol, endless profile filled with police cars and mispelled names of places

 

5/10

[Queen]

I enjoyed browsing your About Me page. It's cool that we can click on your name and find out more about you. I admire anyone who has an artistic nature to their personality. So hat's off to you, sir. I also appreciate the bright and vibrant colors you use, and the fact that the colors found in the Facade logo match the colors going through your name. And of course, what a great song to post on your page -- I've never listened to Mayer Hawthorne, but may have to change that. Funny conversation in the spoiler as well.

 

[10/10]

Edited February 17, 2016 by Queen

[The Dedito Gae]

Queen's discography, is cool and all, but you seem like a decent fella and i'd rather know more about you, i don't even believe you are 69.

8/10

 

Edit: Please don't drop just the rating, would be cool if you would elaborate.

Edited February 18, 2016 by Midnight Hitman

[Payne Killer]

9/10

 

I like how you have it match your forum personas.

[Queen]

Simple, clean, and straight to the point. Glad to know you're a music guy as well. Also, nice extensive list of members you respect. [8/10]

 

Recently updated my profile page. Let me know what you think.

[Flachbau]

Very organized! I enjoyed reading your little bio about yourself, what your interests are, etc. Queen Song of the Week sounds very interesting 10/10

 

While I agree on the terms of being elaborate and such, dropping the rating part of your post gives this topic no meaning, and it would be silly to have it here.

Edited February 18, 2016 by Android

[The Dedito Gae]

While I agree on the terms of being elaborate and such, dropping the rating part of your post gives this topic no meaning, and it would be silly to have it here.

I wasn't saying that Rick, just don't post your rating and nothing else, some feedback or suggestions about profiles would be good.

 

@ Queen

 

*Ignore me and rate Android's profile*

[Flachbau]

That makes sense, sorry for the confusion I absolutely agree, though. Seems like everybody so far has been very constructive in their own ways.

[unbid]

9.5/10. It's cluttered, but well organized.

[Nico]

Simple but good.

I miss when you had that pager i made for you

 

9/10

[Flachbau]

Heroes is a great song of choice, very nice of you to showcase it, along with representing Facade The quote was funny, but I don't think I was online when it happened.

 

9/10, you could benefit from adding a small bio about yourself. Which is something I'm gonna be doing shortly.

[Nico]

...you could benefit from adding a small bio about yourself.

I've been thinking about doing that.

 

Ignore this post and rate Android's profile.

[TheOneLibertonian]

Very nice and very clean. Also a fan of David Bowie myself too. Lovely overall.

 

9.5/10

[[...]]

Too many photos. 9/10

[Queen]

I loved reading about your favorite and least favorite GTAs. You provide excellent reasons for both, but I wonder how you've calculated your scores. Or do you just pick what you 'feel'? Regardless, I'm honored to be on your respect list. Would be nice to know a little more about 'you'. But otherwise, your profile page looks clean, and your passion for the GTA series is highly evident. Loved your remark about the GTA Online section.

 

I shall rate you [9/10].

[Femme Fatale]

10/10...

Damn you love Queen, are you really 69?!

[Queen]

No, I'm not 69. I put in Freddie Mercury's birthday instead of mine. I'm only 27.

 

Please rate Cranium's profile page.

[Pavle]

Bad song, everything made me feel weird and I got scared at one point.

 

I give you a 4/10 for effort.

[Flachbau]

Simplistic presentation, can't believe you have that horribly made license plate that I gave you a while back All in all, very nice. Not a fan of Scania Twain though 8/10

 

I've just updated my About Me section; it now includes a short bio of myself, including hobbies and forum history, clickable gang logos (they redirect you to their separate topics), and just a bunch of refreshed headers and such.

[PhillBellic]

Nice. I see you have taken my Advice on board.

 

10/10.