The Offical Origanal VS. Cover Versions Debate

[Crazyeighties]

In this thread I would like to hear everyone's thoughts on Origanal, VS. Cover versions of songs.

 

Rules for this thread

Post a video of the original version of the song.

Post a video of a cover version of the same song

The next person to post will rate both versions and tell why they think it is better, worse or about the same.

 

After rating and telling us why you rated the cover the way you did you post an original version and a cover. So on and so on

 

Feel free to comment on your own posts as we'll tell us your thoughts I why you think the cover or the original is the best version

 

I will start off with Bad Company: By Bad Company (the first video is the original)

http://youtu.be/bydVh0m6330

 

The cover is by Five Finger Death Punch

 

Edited November 9, 2013 by Crazyeighties

[B Dawg]

Bad Company, reminds me of the Battlefield game, really beautiful song 10/10 for both, prefer the original, but the cover is also very good. Can I comment on the videos I post tho?

 

Original:

 

 

 

Cover:

 

 

 

Edit: The original lacks the anger which the Metallica cover gave it. You can't make a hate song and sound like a pussy. Cover >>> Original

Edited November 9, 2013 by B Dawg

[Crazyeighties]

Bad Company, reminds me of the Battlefield game, really beautiful song 10/10 for both, prefer the original, but the cover is also very good. Can I comment on the videos I post tho?

 

Original:

 

 

 

Cover:

 

 

why not it will make the topic even better

[W3BB13]

*official, *original

Edited November 10, 2013 by W3BB13