What do you think is the best game in the HD era?

[caseclosedjk]

Now that the (Possibly) final HD era game is released, what do you think was the best released this gen?

[l911]

I think this list should include RDR.

[Tycek]

Jeez, one is better than another: one is comparing full games, add-ons and one portable game and the second one wants to include different game just for the sake of it.

There are two games to compare in HD era. Did you really feel like topic about this is necessary?

[Pooyan Cyrus]

Can you compare Chinatown Wars with V really?

However, Ballad of Gay Tony was the best until V came out.

I think HD era isn't finished yet. We should wait at least two years to start Next-Gen era.

[GtaIvFanboy]

Honest Opinion

 

1.IV

2.Tlad

3.V

4.Tbogt

 

 

 

5.Chinatown Wars - its just not in the same league as the other 4 which is Understandable though.

[caseclosedjk]

I think this list should include RDR.

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

[Flesh-n-Bone]

Haven't played Episodes from Liberty City but between the others, I'd easily pick GTA V. Highly enjoyable with lots of new features.

[Vorpax]

LOL there shouldn't be anything more than just GTAIV and GTAV (if you aren't going to put non-GTA series games made by R* as well!...), because technically and factually all the other stuff is just DLC content and not standalone game (no matter how big and different it is...) It is still GTAIV regardless! GTAV improved a bit since GTAIV and all of its addons, but only for HD era! Any other game (well except maybe for GTAIII and for someone Vice City, not for me imho!...) beats GTAV in almost anything else outside of graphics, animations, textures and realism!...

[Algonquin Assassin]

_{Can CTW even be considered a HD GTA? I agree with Vorpax that the only two should be GTA IV and GTA V as TLAD and TBOGT aren't stand alone games so in that case I feel GTA V definitely improved in areas over GTA IV, but regressed in others. Peds seem more static and not as lively, the exclusion of many of GTA IV's side missions, not as many interiors etc.}

 

_{I still hold GTA IV in slightly higher regard even if GTA V has more features. Both are fantastic though.}

[caseclosedjk]

_{Can CTW even be considered a HD GTA? I agree with Vorpax that the only two should be GTA IV and GTA V as TLAD and TBOGT aren't stand alone games so in that case I feel GTA V definitely improved in areas over GTA IV, but regressed in others. Peds seem more static and not as lively, the exclusion of many of GTA IV's side missions, not as many interiors etc.}

 

_{I still hold GTA IV in slightly higher regard even if GTA V has more features. Both are fantastic though.}

Yes. We all consider the IV era as the HD era, right? Well chinatown wars is set in the same canon, thus, its HD era.

[l911]

For me RDR was just like GTA but set in wild west era just like GTA VC was in 80's SA was in 90's .

[TheGodDamnMaster]

GTA IV will always have a special place in my heart, but I have to say I'm having much more fun in GTA V.

[universetwisters]

My vote goes for GTA 5. I haven't found anything wrong with it yet

[redx165]

 

I think this list should include RDR.

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

 

You said best HD era and that includes RDR, Midnight Club, MP3, Table Tennis.

 

Anyways it goes from

 

RDR

GTA V

GTA IV/TBOGT

MP3

GTA TLAD

Midnight Club

GTA CW ( Isn't even HD )

[caseclosedjk]

 

 

I think this list should include RDR.

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

 

You said best HD era and that includes RDR, Midnight Club, MP3, Table Tennis.

 

Anyways it goes from

 

RDR

GTA V

GTA IV/TBOGT

MP3

GTA TLAD

Midnight Club

GTA CW ( Isn't even HD )

 

Take a look where it is posted. GTA General. Are those games GTA? No.

[redx165]

 

 

 

I think this list should include RDR.

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

 

You said best HD era and that includes RDR, Midnight Club, MP3, Table Tennis.

 

Anyways it goes from

 

RDR

GTA V

GTA IV/TBOGT

MP3

GTA TLAD

Midnight Club

GTA CW ( Isn't even HD )

 

Take a look where it is posted. GTA General. Are those games GTA? No.

 

Why do you have DLC and a SD game into the mix? It should only be GTA IV vs GTA V. You really need to work on making threads cause this one makes NO sense.

[universetwisters]

 

 

 

 

I think this list should include RDR.

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

 

You said best HD era and that includes RDR, Midnight Club, MP3, Table Tennis.

 

Anyways it goes from

 

RDR

GTA V

GTA IV/TBOGT

MP3

GTA TLAD

Midnight Club

GTA CW ( Isn't even HD )

 

Take a look where it is posted. GTA General. Are those games GTA? No.

 

Why do you have DLC and a SD game into the mix? It should only be GTA IV vs GTA V. You really need to work on making threads cause this one makes NO sense.

 

You yell at him for not posting non-GTA games, and then you yell at him for including GTA DLC. What's going on?

[Algonquin Assassin]

 

 

 

 

I think this list should include RDR.

 

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

 

You said best HD era and that includes RDR, Midnight Club, MP3, Table Tennis.

 

Anyways it goes from

RDR

GTA V

GTA IV/TBOGT

MP3

GTA TLAD

Midnight Club

GTA CW ( Isn't even HD )

 

Take a look where it is posted. GTA General. Are those games GTA? No.

 

Why do you have DLC and a SD game into the mix? It should only be GTA IV vs GTA V. You really need to work on making threads cause this one makes NO sense. It doesn't make any sense to include games from other franchises too.

[GtaIvFanboy]

 

 

I think this list should include RDR.

Why? I was talking GTA. Not R* in general.

 

You said best HD era and that includes RDR, Midnight Club, MP3, Table Tennis.

 

Anyways it goes from

 

RDR

GTA V

GTA IV/TBOGT

MP3

GTA TLAD

Midnight Club

GTA CW ( Isn't even HD )

 

What are you talking about lol he was quite Clearly talking about The Gta Games in the HD Universe.