Who would win in a fight? Michael, Trevor or Franklin

[HoleInTheSky]

Trevor, with his psychotic/violent streak.

[Vorpax]

Seriously people! Do they really have to fight? Why not make friends? Who so hostile?!

[Pregnantplatypus]

Has anyone seen the gif where franklin knocks that one guy out

[Von_Von]

I have allready seen Franklin beating a guy up... Not bad. New rage engine?

[RetardOfTheYear]

Niko Bellic would win

[InfernoV]

Franklins a good fighter, the way he knocked one guy out was awsome.

 

I wanna see trevor fight

[ThaMuscle]

*************Spoiler************** I don't understand how Trevor takes on the whole of the lost mc and mayweather pretty much by himself but yet at the end runs away from an amateur bank robber. Think having to write for two other protagonists somehow led to narrative inconsistencies...

[Grand Theft Savage]

Terrible scenario. And Trevor would body both of them in a shootout or in melee. You can't stop his rage mode.

[GoldenBlade]

Trevor. There's no telling what he will do.

[Vellocet]

Trevor would waste them, Trevor is nuts he will do whatever he can do to win, in Hand-to-hand mostly, however Michael shooting could certainly be a trouble for Franklin and Trevor, if it is between Franklin and Michael on Hand-to-Hand Franklin would KO Michael,.

[Sussus Amongus]

Claude and Tommy V win!

[DeafMetal]

Still say Trevor.

[Tlaneloli]

What kinda fight, Franklin would win a fistfight

All out fight Trevor can handle that sh*t better cuz he's crazy, but he don't really wanna hurt his friends, Michael could hurt Trevor, Franklin could hurt 'em both, he would've no matter what option you choose killing one of them was an option.

[El Zodape]

No fight is fair with Trevor in it.

[Official General]

Franklin would win a physical fight one on one with both Trevor or Michael. From looking at his muscular frame, and the fact that he spent him in prison probably lifting weights and getting into fights, it's a clear choice for me to choose Franklin.

 

Lol at those choosing Trevor. In a physical comparison, Franklin clearly has the upper hand. Just because Trevor is a psychopath it don't necessarily make him physically strong or invincible.

 

Franklin kills Trevor anyway, so a part of this already answered ;-)

Edited December 9, 2013 by Official General

[Wolfhuman]

lmao, this topic.

[am30]

Trevor. No contest.

[HeatedHeavy]

Trevor. However, for some reason or another I can see Lamar kicking ALL their asses. He just seems like he'd have the most heart to stomp them dudes out if he had to.

[carmelo3]

Franklin would lick off Michaels head back

[IDredMan]

Well that's the point of the 3 different characters.

Trevor can take on a tank in hand-to-hand combat (Metaphore ...A tank doesn't have any hands)

Michael can shoot you from across the city.

Franklin can run you over in a blink of an eye.

[CainCigano]

Sorry for bringing back an old thread, I found it on google and decided to comment.

 

A lot of people are picking Franklin to win because of his muscular build alone. Having that body type doesn't mean much during a fight unless you're fighting someone who you have clear physical advantages over, or if it's someone who has no idea what they're doing.

 

In a combat sport like MMA, the tall and lanky guys are some of the most successful. Look at Anderson Silva, he's not really skinny, but he's not incredibly muscular or compact, and he's arguably the best fighter of all time and has beaten many guys who are more muscular and probably stronger than he is (Forrest Griffin, Stephan Bonnar, James Irvin, and Yushin Okami for example).

 

My point is that Franklin's build won't necessarily help him very much. Trevor has a longer and leaner build, and probably a longer reach.

 

Strength is definitely an important factor in a fight (not the only factor, but still an important one), and Trevor has the advantage there as well. Look at the stats in the game, Trevor is considerably stronger than both Michael and Franklin.

 

When it comes to hand-to-hand combat, none of them are particularly skilled and their defensive strategies are limited to ducking down and to the left while dropping both of their hands to avoid getting hit, so it would pretty much be decided on physical advantages, aggression, and mentality.

 

I would say Trevor is most likely the more durable than the other two. He is the least afraid of getting hit and being ready for the impact will drastically increase your ability to take punches. His willingness to get hit also means he'd be more aggressive because he won't be afraid to take a punch in order to give one. I'd also say that he most likely has the most punching power.

 

Trevor also has meth and rage mode working in his favor. No way he'd lose to Michael or Franklin in a fist fight.

Edited July 3, 2014 by CainCigano

[L0SS4NT0SK1LL3RV]

Rules

 

• Fight to death
• ​Empty city (No pedestrians)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

My Scenario:

 

The fight starts and all three of them are looking for each other. Franklin starts speeding to a near by parking lot with his Bugatti Veyron that was parked in his garage. He speeds past the security gate while drifting the car strongly as he stops. He has a serious look on his face as he grabs his 9 mm pistol.

 

"where the f**** are these ni**as," he says

 

He gets out the car and starts to slowly crouch walk to the top floor of the parking lot. While approaching the top floor, he hears sounds of a helicopter landing on a near by roof-top and the first thing that comes to his mind is Trevor.

Franklin pulls out his rocket launcher and and runs to the top floor. He sees a helicopter landed on a roof right across from the parking lot and he shoots the helicopter with his rocket launcher and the air fills with smoke.

 

Franklin jumps the roof to reach the helicopter after the explosion and he realizes there are no signs of a dead body from the explosion.

 

"WHATS THE MATTER FRANKY!!!"

 

Trevor hits Franklin in the back of the head with a pipe

 

"You LOOKIN FOR SOMETHING FRANKY?!!"

 

Trevor gives him another blow

 

"HUH? ANSWER ME FRANKY, ANSWEERR MEE!!!!"

 

Franklin's is not moving and his face is bloody. Trevor pushes Franklin's body off the roof and waits to hear Franklin's body hit the ground.

 

"wheeeeerres MIKEY?" Trevor chants

 

Trevor goes back down and takes Franklin's car. He turns on the engine but then bullets start flying into the car but none hit him. It was Michael.

 

"I've always hated you Trevor," Michael yells

 

Trevor goes to the trunk of the car to find a taser. He shoots it and it hits Michael and Michael falls to the ground and Trevor starts to laugh.

 

Trevor picks up the pipe and heads to Michael. Right when Trevor is going to end it, a car comes around the corner and hits Trevor and he dies.

 

Franklin falls out the car exhausted. He has a broken left arm and shoulder because of Trevor and his face is bloody.

 

Franklin is struggling to crawl and Michael who is now out of shock from being tased gets up grabs Franklin pistol from and turns him around.

 

"I never wanted to do this to you Franklin," Michael says while pointing the gun to Franklin's head

 

Franklin looks at him, "What?.. I get no last words homiee?"

 

Michael looks at him with concern, "This is not a movie son, nothing can save you"

 

Franklin puts his fingers to his mouth a whistles as loud as possible, "Go gettem' boy"

 

Chop comes from around the corner and jumps on Micahel and rips him limb from limb

 

Franklin struggles back up, he pets Chop and looks back at Michael, "Now I see why you decided to retire from the "game" in the first place old man."

 

THE END, Franklin FTW!

 

 

 

haha i didn't even remember about Chop

[AzelfandQuilava]

This would actually of been a nice 100% reward as a bonus level, imagine it. You'd get to choose one character and try to kill the other two, all of you can use your ability, all of you have extended health and the other two would be controlled by AI on level with the Police (Robocop AI).

[GTA-Biker]

I think Trevor would win.When his special ability is activated,his attacks become stronger and he takes little to no damage.

[wiizardii]

Alright this is my scenario:

 

 

SO Michael is bored, he is in the mood of trolling. So he calls trevor to hang out, and Trevor says yes. After that, Michael calls Franklin and ask HIM if he can hang out, and Franklin also says yes... So this is where the issue comes: Trevor blew up Franklin's house so both trevor and franklin hate each other by this time.

 

 

So 20 minutes has passed. Michael did not show up to anyone one of them. So Trevor gets pissed, so does Franklin. So both of them have the same idea: go home to Michael and beat him up.

 

So trevor drives to Michael's house. Obviously he does not go to the front door, so he tries the back door. Because there is no one on sight in the kitchen, Trevor opens the back door. and sneaks into Michaels house. By this time Franklin has walked into the De Santa house, and he sneaks into Michaels house the same way he did a long time ago (he jumped onto the Bath room door, and luckly the window was open like before) So in Franklins view, Jimmy was in the toilet taking a sh*t, so Franklin quickly knocked Jimmy out so he would not scream. By this time trevor was already few upstairs, and heard alot of moaning sound from Tracey's room (She was masturbating) And then, as Franklin opened the bathroom door, Trevor looking, and Michael opening his room's door, all the trio saw each other. Here is a dialouge:

 

Trevor: Franklin !??!!??! What the f*ck?????

Franklin: Yeah I am here to kick Michael's ass because he trolled me, nigga

Trevor: Oh, you motherf*cker!

 

FIGHTTTTTTTT

 

Trevor engages franklin with a double leg take down, sending jabs to franklin's left cheek. as he also sends alot of jabs, he sends out elbow shots to Franklin's face. By this time, franklin was crying like always. Michael was angry, so he stopped Trevor, and stumped on Trevors head. Alot of noises was going on (Franklin crying, Trevor screaming, and Michael also screaming) so Tracey ran out of the house naked, and Amanda also ran out naked (Michael finished having sex with her earlier)

 

So now the fight went downstairs, all the trio were at each other, blood was everywhere. Franklin took a vas, and broke it into Michaels head, by this time Michael got angry as f*ck. He gave a straight out punch to Franklin's nose, And Franklin's nose was seperated. Trevor took Michael on a choke hold, and tried to make Michael go to sleep with it. Michael countered, and threw trevor at Franklin. The trio went into the Kitchen, and the bloody fight was still going on. Trevor saw a bottle of Pisswasser beer, and he took it. As Franklin punched Michael, Michael went down to the ground. And with a surprise attack, Trevor took Franklin by his throat, took him down, and made the JohnnyKlebitzMove, in wich he threw Franklin down, and threw the bottle on Franklin's face and screamed c*nt c*nt c*nt, c*ntTTT!

 

By this time, Franklin was dead. Michael saw a pipe, so he took it, but was not shocked that franklin was laying dead. He smashed the pipe onto the left side of Trevor's face. By this time, trevor entered rage mode and went all out on Michael. Michael was still strong, so he took Trevor's leg and tried to snap it. As he was snapping it, Trevor saw a Whiskey bottle. He smashed it broken onto Michael's face. There was alot of broken glass pieces. So Trevor had full control in this fight, he took the biggest glass piece, and tried to cut it into Michael's eye, but Michael was quick to counter, so Michael took the glass piece, and tried to shove it into Trevor's eye, but failed miserably. Trevor quickly took another smaller broken glass piece, and was quick to thrust it into Michael's left eye. Michael took the kitchen knife, and took it inside of Trevor's stumach, but fell instantly afterwards. Franklin was dead, and Michael was soon to die too.. Trevor was throwing up blood, because of the knife attack. He saw that Michael tried to crawl and take the golf club, but trevor instantly pulled the knife out of his own stumach, and threw it at Michael's neck. It went straight through Michael's neck, Michael was spitting out ALOT of blood. And died a painful death. Trevor, succumbing to his wound, did his last action. By taking the kitchen knife and cutting Fanklin's head off, and playing football with it for about 30 seconds. Afterwards, Trevor fell down, and died.

 

WINNNNNNEEEERRRRR: Trevor (but died afterwards sadly)

Edited July 14, 2014 by Phoenix_Shit

[Zackyoung1]

Melee-either mike for experience or Franklin cause he's stronger and seems like a brawler.

Guns-Mike

 

Just cause Trevor is nuts doesn't make him a badass killer, give anyone a heavy machine gun and PcP and boom, real life Trevor

[wiizardii]

Melee-either mike for experience or Franklin cause he's stronger and seems like a brawler.

Guns-Mike

 

Just cause Trevor is nuts doesn't make him a badass killer, give anyone a heavy machine gun and PcP and boom, real life Trevor

Hmm... Not really. Would that person be happy to kill innocent people? Would that person enjoy seeing people getting their guts drilled? Would that person enjoy killing as a hobby? Would that person enjoy smashing a beer bottle onto a meth head's head and stump on the head while screaming c*nt? I don't think so. Trevor is a straight out psychopathic maniac, who is an antagonistic protagonist. He is also good at hand to hand combat, he was in the canadian military, and he enjoys killing in many ways (Wether its combat, melee, or with guns) Although Michael and franklin kill people, they don't directly enjoy it like its a hobby.

Edited July 14, 2014 by Phoenix_Shit

[The Byzantine Empire]

Trevor has advantage because he is an aggresive psychopath,he will become a monster after a little gun fight against other two.

 

But in my opinion John Marston would kick all their asses with his dead-eye revolver

[Jenia]

Trevor, but because he is a f*cking headless psycho with abandonment issues and a had a difficult childhood.

No, Chuck Norris would kill them. Farting.

And LS would turn into a nuclear wasteland. And then R* releases a DLC called Wasteland Adventures with 2323623768923658 pieces of clothes to your Online character, all new 1235678 handmade from sh*t vehicles, and over 9000 new weapons with a new tint! RAINBOW!!

Oh! Don't forget the new camouflage vehicle paintjob, new parts to your wreckage and rusty wheels only in Rusty Ol' Wrecked Los Santos Customs!

True Story.

 

 

[wiizardii]

Trevor, but because he is a f*cking headless psycho with abandonment issues and a had a difficult childhood.

No, Chuck Norris would kill them. Farting.

And LS would turn into a nuclear wasteland. And then R* releases a DLC called Wasteland Adventures with 2323623768923658 pieces of clothes to your Online character, all new 1235678 handmade from sh*t vehicles, and over 9000 new weapons with a new tint! RAINBOW!!

Oh! Don't forget the new camouflage vehicle paintjob, new parts to your wreckage and rusty wheels only in Rusty Ol' Wrecked Los Santos Customs!

True Story.

 

 

Post of the month!