GTA V Forum Reviews: Your Reviews of GTA V

[Davidbc]

I like the idea

[BMW Sterling]

It sucks

[DryBomber5]

I doubt I'll be returning to these forums after the game gets released but if I do, I'll definitely consider reviewing it. Speaking of reviews, anyone know if GTA 5 will be reviewed this week or are we gonna have to wait until the 16th?

[TimeLordDoctor]

You go Deffpony!

[Audiophile]

Might I suggest locking it on the 16th since Australians are getting it while the rest of us are on the 16th and some people will get early copies.

 

Just a suggestion if the idea is to PM you the review.

[Deffpony]

I cant wait to see what everyone comes up with, and I look forward to reading them.

 

The voting categories will probably be some fun ones.

 

• Most oblivious review
• Funniest Review
• Worst review

@Audiophile: Yea I intended on locking this on the weekend before release.

Edited September 8, 2013 by Deffpony

[Kirsty]

Great idea, can't wait to read some of these over the release period as it's interesting to get another person's insight into the game, hopefully people put lots of effort in

[TECHN9CiAN]

i doubt i'll be returning after the game comes out unless i discover something that i feel nobody else has discovered and is worth sharing.

 

i have full faith in that this game sill earn nothing less than a near perfect score on all aspects of the game. but i will review anyway, good idea deffponer

[epicluca]

Great Idea Deffpony, I think you should lock the thread until the 17th to stop spam/troll posts

[Deffpony]

Great Idea Deffpony, I think you should lock the thread until the 17th to stop spam/troll posts

I figured I would let people discuss the idea a bit for a few days before locking and clearing it out

[Capricornus]

Great idea man.I typically don't care about reviews but its good in this case because its coming from actual consumers as opposed to people who are being paid to write a review for the game.

 

I guess this can also serve as an official "who's got GTA V" thread.

Edited September 8, 2013 by Capricornus

[IveGotNoValues]

This could be interesting, great idea

Edited September 8, 2013 by COASTERPUNK

[kj2022]

I'll probably type up a review. Brilliant idea Deffpony!

[Stop hating IV]

Why must PM to Deffpony? You can leave both the discussions and the reviews topics pinned and leave them open for everyone to post .

Edited September 8, 2013 by Stop hating IV

[yaninufc]

i feel like i have to do this

alot like homework lol

[Spider-Vice]

It'll be a clusterf*ck if it's all posted in a topic. Deffpony can organise himself much better if it's sent by PM.

 

This is an awesome idea! I won't be reviewing it as I'm gonna wait for the PC version but I can't wait to see how this goes.

[DrProfessor]

Sounds good, rather read some reviews on GTAF than the shoddy stuff you usually get on IGN.

[Kirsty]

I'm sure it'll be a good way for Rockstar to see some organised fan feedback too

[Reaper Madness]

Great topic. I'll be sure to post my review and read others.

[XNaifX]

I expect that sales of the game in the first week more than billion dollars

[carnage.]

Why is good, fine, bad, and horrible even on there?

[Josh410]

11/10 stars

[GUCCI_MANE_PIZZA_PARTY]

So let me get this right. Instead if adding a poll, you are going to lock this thread, make everyone go out of their way to PM you a review, relay the results to the other admins, and then passive aggressively take credit for the little census? Good luck with that.

Edited September 8, 2013 by GUCCI_MANE_PIZZA_PARTY

[GUCCI_MANE_PIZZA_PARTY]

Just add a poll instead of making everyone type of full out review.

[Murad96]

So let me get this right. Instead if adding a poll, you are going to lock this thread, make everyone go out of their way to PM you a review, relay the results to the other admins, and then passive aggressively take credit for the little census? Good luck with that.+

 

+1

 

With this, more people will review, and it will be easier to do it. And then this, or another thread could be the discussion thread.

 

Edit: It might be better to just lock this thread and allow people to post proper reviews via PMing the mods, while still allowing people to 'vote' reviews in a poll if they can't be bothered to PM the mods. That way you can either write one, or use the poll.

Edited September 8, 2013 by Murad96

[Deffpony]

Every review that gets sent to me will be posted in this thread. Having it as just a poll would be stupid because filling out a poll isn't a review. Its just a score.

 

There's no passive aggressiveness. I might even keep the thread open and bin any post that isn't a review. This way there aren't 20 pages made up of 3 reviews and posts discussing them.

[Durden]

Nice idea, I'll try and write a review.

 

Can we edit our review at a later date? I want to make a GTAV review next week, but I want to edit it later, accounting for GTA Online.

[EseAdsDRIV3]

Every review that gets sent to me will be posted in this thread. Having it as just a poll would be stupid because filling out a poll isn't a review. Its just a score.

There's no passive aggressiveness. I might even keep the thread open and bin any post that isn't a review. This way there aren't 20 pages made up of 3 reviews and posts discussing them.

Thank Gawd, would of hated to see them! Btw how do you add images now and a polls bad, mmkay.

[Deffpony]

Nice idea, I'll try and write a review.

 

Can we edit our review at a later date? I want to make a GTAV review next week, but I want to edit it later, accounting for GTA Online.

Well, I would prefer it if you didnt make any changes to the review after submission but I might be able to work it in case by case. However, GTAOnline will most likely have a review thread of its own, since it is pretty extensive. So this review should not include GTAOnline. Im going to add that to the OP.

 

Also, I might add a multi poll to this thread for those who dont feel the need to write a full fledged review. the problem with that is too many people dont take polls seriously.

[Skorge]

Sounds fun, count me in Mr pony man.