Who will be the best melee fighter

[greenrock]

out of the trio

[trevors685]

Probably Trevor. You can smash stuff with a lot of power when on a psychotic rage. I'm so honored to share the same name.

[Remi749]

My guess would be Trevor, because he's a psycho, so he will go all out on someone. and after him I think Franklin, I'm not sure, it's just because he's a lot younger than Michael, but I don't know enough to really decide about those two.

[Red XIII]

I say franklin, psychopaths tend go on rampages with weapons rather than their fists.

[Cosmic Gypsy]

My guess is they will all be absolutely awful at melee fighting, much to my displeasure... (R* haven't had a decent melee system since the PS2 era..)

 

But if i had to choose, i'd either say they'll all be good in their own way, or Franklin.

[AJayG]

do they all have like specific skills? like 1 might be really athletic 1 might be good at fighting and 1 good with weapons? sorry if this has been said ive jsut been hiding under a rock until lately getting hyped for this game.

[Red XIII]

My guess is they will all be absolutely awful at melee fighting, much to my displeasure... (R* haven't had a decent melee system since the PS2 era..)

 

But if i had to choose, i'd either say they'll all be good in their own way, or Franklin.

I thought the cage fighting in tbogt was excellent, yea it could do with some polishing but was good for its time and had a fair bit of depth to it.

[98 in 1]

 

My guess is they will all be absolutely awful at melee fighting, much to my displeasure... (R* haven't had a decent melee system since the PS2 era..)

 

But if i had to choose, i'd either say they'll all be good in their own way, or Franklin.

The melee systems on the PS2 era GTA's were just as bad. SA was a slight improvement, but fights were just too easy with enough muscle and CJ's unbeatable foot stomp. IV was a step in the right direction, but it was very clunky.

 

OT: Trevor, seeing as he has a military background.

[Prometheus]

I would say Micheal would be the best fighter, yet the most fragile. You would be able to throw a knockout punch at anyone with grandpa, but it may just cost you a hip. Same applies for shotguns and rocket launchers; you wouldn't want to play through the game with a hernia.

[omer19992010]

Trevor since he was in the military.

[Frantz Fuchs]

Franklin, because he's black.

[evoluon--720]

Franklin looks like he has some muscle on him so im going assume he's going to be throwing hay makers and one hitter quitters on niggas..trevor is a brawler ofcourse and Michael is gonna get his Bruce Willis on

[InfernoV]

Michael.

People are under estimating him, i picture him as the type of fighter who you try punching he blocks your punch, breaks your arm and throwns you on the floor, experienced fighter. Most effective technique

Trevor will be wild punching, smashing there face into the wall, stomping on there face and other brutal stuff.

Franklin more of a brawler, close range punching, grappling with take downs , elbows and knees.

[wendtcod]

My guess is they will all be absolutely awful at melee fighting, much to my displeasure... (R* haven't had a decent melee system since the PS2 era..)

 

But if i had to choose, i'd either say they'll all be good in their own way, or Franklin.

La noire's fighting was fairly decent

[wendtcod]

Michael.

People are under estimating him, i picture him as the type of fighter who you try punching he blocks your punch, breaks your arm and throwns you on the floor, experienced fighter. Most effective technique

Trevor will be wild punching, smashing there face into the wall, stomping on there face and other brutal stuff.

Franklin more of a brawler, close range punching, grappling with take downs , elbows and knees.

Franklin is black...chances are he will pull a gun.... Im not racist LOL

[Johan]

It was hard to choose between Franklin and Trevor but considering from what we've seen so far Trevor looks much more brutal

 

[Vanzant]

I fixed the topic title. I have a hard job here.

 

I think as far as fighting skills goes, the most exp you have with either one should be.

[Seenyour31]

Franklin is black...chances are he will pull a gun.... Im not racist LOL

There's always one.

[hinti21]

Franklin, he's a professional goon?!

[Ben73]

Anyone but Trevor.

I don't understand everyone's obsession with him.

[Geweelt]

I guess everyone will have their own fighting abilities.

Trevor will be strong, Franklin (as he's younger) will be faster, Michael won't fight at all (because he's an oldman)

[SlappyPwnsAss]

I heard somewhere that Trevor is the best at melee fighting because hes been in the army

[AtomicPunk]

Trevor.

You ever see a redneck hand out an a$$-whoopin'? It's usually a pretty bad one.