Most Psychopathic Protagonist

[jaylen pizarro]

tommy vercetti

[Ahmedmfroezspeed]

i don't get why people vote for Trevor and Tommy

both their crimes combined together are paper white compared to Toni...

Edited May 30, 2020 by Ahmedmfroezspeed

[Limefong]

Niko.

 

[Fusky89]

Trevor Philips 

[JetNormalGuy]

I just noticed that all the psychopathic lunatics in the series commited their crimes in Liberty City (Claude,Tommy,Toni,Niko,Johnny)

 

No wonder its labelled as the worst place in america...

 

 

[KingD19]

Claude the Michael Myers of protagonist silent assassin 

 

[VenusianDream]

Tied between Tommy and Toni. They're both always pissed off, and they have no qualms about killing others to progress further in life. Tommy hates authority, and doesn't show any respect or regard towards anyone unless they've proven to be a useful asset to him. Toni is probably the worst, he has a very high kill count and often kills people brutally. He leveled a whole block of buildings without a care in the world. The only thing that matters to him is the Leone family (or rather his status as a capo) and his mother, and even that's questionable because his mother is a complete bitch and is likely the cause of his mental trauma.

 

Claude and the GTAO Protagonist(s) also seem psychopathic, not just because they're mutes but because they work for multiple people and have no loyalty to anyone. They'll do anything regardless of the risk (even killing one of their employers) so long as the pay is good, and they live very chaotic lives with no real direction or purpose.

Edited June 26, 2020 by VenusianDream

[Mr Philips The Gey]

On Wednesday, December 05, 2012 at 4:43 AM, Irrational said:

 

Althoug I totally agree with you, and also think that Claude DID shoot Maria at the end of the game, it's not good to state it as a fact, because there are alot of people who think that Claude didn't shoot her. Cockstar never cleared that up either, even when it was directly asked to them, all they said was "We dunno, problem?".

wait what? Cockstar?

[Guest]

Toni. He's a f*cking terrorist. That's one of the reasons why he's my least favorite protagonist of the series. 

Claude is also cold AF but his crimes are not as bad as Toni.

Tommy also is cold and psychotic. He probably comes second. They don't call him "The Harwood Butcher" for nothing.

Carl is less violent, but he somehow buried a man in concrete for the most dumbest reason.

Vic is the least psychotic out of the protagonists. He is the only one who hates crime so yeah.

Niko can sometimes be aggressive but he does have some qualities.

Same as Johnny.

Luis is the least psychopathic out of the IV triology.

Don't really give a f*ck about the V protagonists.

[Dr Busta]

Toni Cipriani 

He has no brain he's everybody's killing machine and can do the worst sh*t thinkable if you just told him to 

[Guest]

On 1/24/2021 at 9:38 PM, DR:BUSTA said:

He has no brain he's everybody's killing machine and can do the worst sh*t thinkable if you just told him to 

Exactly. At least Tommy and Niko definitely knew what they were doing.

Edit: @H-G bruh don't tell me you're gonna spam-react to my old posts mate  jk

Edited May 10 by DR Cherry Bomb

[Homicidal Hipster]

Considering the word psychopath is used to describe Trevor on several occasions I'm going to say him..

[Lexiture]

5 minutes ago, Thelema93 said:

Considering the word psychopath is used to describe Trevor on several occasions I'm going to say him..

 

[Homicidal Hipster]

8 minutes ago, Lexiture said:

 

You picked the wrong thread fool 

[MoodyBastard78]

On 6/23/2020 at 9:24 AM, Limefong said:

Niko.

 

Bro, Niko is the  closest thing to a normal person in the entire saga.

[AmigaMix]

It probably would have been a good idea to establish a common frame of reference when this thread was made.

People use the "psychopath" - label as liberal as they use the words "fascist" and "communist"...

 

 

[atay26]

I think that people don't understand that us, ourselves are projected into Claude. You can't really call him a psychopath (unless you are one and that's how you see yourself on claude) also just because someone doesn't talk doesn't mean or prove anything. There is many reasons that could contribute to that matter and people seem to forget this was there first 3d protagonist, hell people expect Claude to show emotions when he doesn't even have facial rigging. Just shows the level of stupidity that people don't take in mind.

[Jeansowaty]

15 hours ago, atay26 said:

I think that people don't understand that us, ourselves are projected into Claude. You can't really call him a psychopath (unless you are one and that's how you see yourself on claude) also just because someone doesn't talk doesn't mean or prove anything. There is many reasons that could contribute to that matter and people seem to forget this was there first 3d protagonist, hell people expect Claude to show emotions when he doesn't even have facial rigging. Just shows the level of stupidity that people don't take in mind.

See, that's a thing I just can't associate myself with. I don't feel like I'm projected onto Claude, solely because of the reason that after all, HE is the one doing decisions. He chose to betray Kenji and the Yakuza, perhaps I wouldn't do that? That's why after all he is a twisted person, he doesn't have respect for anyone whatsoever, no matter how right they treat him.

[ThatBenGuy1998]

A four way tie between Claude, Toni, Trevor, and Tommy.

[Ondr4H]

Tonny because he is total wacko, he dont slightly care. Blow up part of city for 5000 dollars without double thinking? Yeah thats great example of his mind.

 

His Mama get angry so Tonny just chop some dude and sell his meat... Because mama says so.

 

This was out of touch for regular GTA protagonist. There were all kinda likable assholes, but he is just creepy murderer 

 

[atay26]

On 4/25/2022 at 6:38 PM, Jeansowaty said:

See, that's a thing I just can't associate myself with. I don't feel like I'm projected onto Claude, solely because of the reason that after all, HE is the one doing decisions. He chose to betray Kenji and the Yakuza, perhaps I wouldn't do that? That's why after all he is a twisted person, he doesn't have respect for anyone whatsoever, no matter how right they treat him.

I think your pushing it, it was simply just not a game mechanic at the time and even so it doesn't stop you feeling like your Claude, take the online protagonist for example he/she behaves the same way Claude does and they can't make a decision to backstrap or join other gangs. Uh Right they treat him? Sure they gave Claude a hideout and employed him but how about the Leones? They did the exact same thing and look where that got him, every gang was using him for personal gain. Not one to judge but the Yakuza are not the most trusted allies as we know in GTA advance they had no issue betraying mike. If you can't feel projected into Claude then it removes the total freedom that rockstar were going for, Afterall the key concept for GTA 3 was freedom, to have the ability to do whatever you wanted. Sam Houser gave an interview describing Claude as having no personality but rather having the player's personality.

Edited October 19 by atay26

[Eugene H. Krabs]

Glad to see the Toni rep in here. Guy literally blew up a neighborhood for a measly $5,000 and sold someone's organs to their own deli store by passing it off as sausages.

 

Not only that, but he helped feed a cannibal, he killed the mayor, and he's the only one who targets innocents in rampages (keep in mind that in all the other 3D era games, rampages only target gang members). Hell, one of the rampages require you to kill 25 Leones.

[Badman_]

Guys. It's Trevor. The most psychopathic and most handsome protagonist in GTA.

[H-G]

Most psychopathic protagonist? Man, it's gotta be Toni Cipriani, hands down. He's a total freakazoid (yet still boring AF to me).

 

1. He's so hell-bent on gaining favor of Salvatore or his mother that he'd kill just about anyone, even if it doesn't earn him any money

2. He cuts up Giovanni Casa alive in a sawmill and sells his meat back to Casa's own deli as "special sausage meat"

3. He blows up a whole neighborhood full of Italians (despite clearly being Italian himself) clean off the map (so what if the Forellis live in Fort Staunton? Like WTF dude, there must've been innocent people in there too)

4. He can optionally go on a rampage that involves killing 25 fellow Leone mobsters

5. He killed two higher-ranking Leone mobsters and never said a word about it (a Leone made-man before the game's storyline according to rare promotional pre-release info, and Vincenzo Cilli during the actual storyline, the latter of whom was presumably of caporegime status)

6. He does absurd tasks for a local reverend like stealing an FBI dossier, breaking up a diamond deal to fetch the cargo, causing mayhem around the city with a firetruck and assassinating popular movie stars in an attempt to "clear out (his) sins", only to find out that the reverend was fake and was a crappy journalist looking for insane news stories to make a name for himself

7. The dude can run around in a chicken suit and underwear no problemo

 

IDK what the hell R* were thinking when they wrote up LCS' storyline...

Edited May 10 by H-G

[Jezus Holy Christ]

I know his character was underwritten but for me it's definitely Claude. Not a hint of emotion in this guy. Not even rage or anger.

He strikes me as inhumane, beyond psychopathic.

[Journey_95]

On 5/30/2020 at 8:18 PM, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

i don't get why people vote for Trevor and Tommy

both their crimes combined together are paper white compared to Toni...

Tony was basically a terrorist who bombed civilians for Donald Love...he was not a fun or interesting character like Tommy and Trevor

[DR Cherry Bomb]

I mean it's none other than Toni Cipriani from Liberty City Stories. At least all of the other protagonists had their own charm and merit, meanwhile this guy has nothing to him and he's unlikable.

Order him to blow up an entire apartment, he'll do it. Order him to kill an innocent old man, he'll do it. Order him to literally do anything absolutely insane and unthinkable, he'll freaking do it!

And they say CJ is poorly written, man...

Edited June 2 by DR Cherry Bomb

[atay26]

On 5/11/2022 at 9:41 PM, Jezus Holy Christ said:

I know his character was underwritten but for me it's definitely Claude. Not a hint of emotion in this guy. Not even rage or anger.

He strikes me as inhumane, beyond psychopathic.

That's because your his emotions. He was designed like that which makes him different.

[ChubbyB0b]

Why people vote Tommy over Claude or Toni, the latter being a special nutcase.

[Vice City Bikini Girl]

Trevor