Most Psychopathic Protagonist

[Anywhere USA]

1 hour ago, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

the online protagonist is custom

it depends on you, your mind, and your personality

you want him a psychopath ?, no problem

you want him a sociopath ??,  no big deal

the point is, the online protagonist depends on you and your personality

We do know some of things he does in general, the heists, the doomsday stuff, the casino stuff

1 hour ago, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

the online protagonist is custom

it depends on you, your mind, and your personality

you want him a psychopath ?, no problem

you want him a sociopath ??,  no big deal

the point is, the online protagonist depends on you and your personality

We do know some of things he does in general, the heists, the doomsday stuff, the casino stuff

[KingAJ032304]

On 12/2/2012 at 11:57 AM, Lock n' Stock said:

Johnny Klebitz for me. He came across as a really crazy and psychopathic biker dude who seemed to enjoy killing cops and AOD members. His rough voice gave him a psychopathic personality.

There is nothing psychopathic about anyone in the Lost...

[billiejoearmstrong8]

4 hours ago, KingAJ032304 said:

There is nothing psychopathic about anyone in the Lost...

Nothing at all...

 

 

[Lock n' Stock]

20 hours ago, KingAJ032304 said:

There is nothing psychopathic about anyone in the Lost...

Lol, you quoted a post from 2012. I'd never write anything like that today.

[KingAJ032304]

5 minutes ago, Lock n' Stock said:

Lol, you quoted a post from 2012. I'd never write anything like that today.

Only in GTAForums will people will always reply back no matter how old the original post is lol

[Americana]

I'm sorry, but what exactly makes Tommy Vercetti a psychopath? 

 

---

[Mr. Galloway]

Claude.

[billiejoearmstrong8]

8 hours ago, Ronald Reagan said:

I'm sorry, but what exactly makes Tommy Vercetti a psychopath? 

 

 

---

He commits mass murder with no remorse or emotion

[Sunglasses]

11 hours ago, Ronald Reagan said:

I'm sorry, but what exactly makes Tommy Vercetti a psychopath? 

 

 

---

"I'm a convicted psychotic killer and drug dealer." - Tommy Vercetti.

[Americana]

That's what he said.

 

Wait...did you all base your opinion on this quote? 

 

---

[billiejoearmstrong8]

No, based it on that throughout the game he commits huge amounts of murder and violence and never shows any emotion, remorse or struggle over it. None of the stuff he sees and does affects him emotionally at all, he's completely ruthless in his quest for money and power. That quote in the ending scene is just the icing on the cake.

Edited February 9, 2020 by billiejoearmstrong8

[Sunglasses]

Anyway, to answer the question, Toni probably takes the cake for me.

[Tao Cheng]

-

Edited August 28, 2020 by Tao Cheng

[Jeansowaty]

About Tommy, you have to notice that there is a difference between psychopath and sociopath. Psychopaths are cunning and manipulative, they tend to stay away from heavy criminal actions and prefer quiet acts of mischief. Sociopaths on the other hand are more loud and brash, prone to their emotions and unable to live a stable life. Both don't feel remorse or guilt. I think it's likely that Tommy is a bit of both, or neither.

[Ahmedmfroezspeed]

On 2/9/2020 at 6:52 PM, billiejoearmstrong8 said:

No, based it on that throughout the game he commits huge amounts of murder and violence and never shows any emotion, remorse or struggle over it. None of the stuff he sees and does affects him emotionally at all, he's completely ruthless in his quest for money and power. That quote in the ending scene is just the icing on the cake.

Bruh you haven't played liberty city stories yet...

Toni is the protagonist with the highest kill count of the series

Where in the portland chainsaw masquerade mission 15 people were killed in it, and that attack on fort staunton in the mission bringing the house down mission where it killed over a hundred

And probably over a thousand

And it didn't faze him

And he never felt remorse about it

So yeah no matter how psychopathic the new protagonist will be,  he will never ever be as psychopathic as Toni Cipriani. ..

[billiejoearmstrong8]

On 2/22/2020 at 4:18 PM, Ahmedmfroezspeed said:

Bruh you haven't played liberty city stories yet...

Toni is the protagonist with the highest kill count of the series

Where in the portland chainsaw masquerade mission 15 people were killed in it, and that attack on fort staunton in the mission bringing the house down mission where it killed over a hundred

And probably over a thousand

And it didn't faze him

And he never felt remorse about it

So yeah no matter how psychopathic the new protagonist will be,  he will never ever be as psychopathic as Toni Cipriani. ..

Oh yeah I agree Toni is the worst! Only explaining why I also consider Tommy "The Harwood Butcher" Vercetti to be in the psychopath category. Toni, Tommy and Claude all make the cut imo. Maybe Trevor, but he's a lot more emotionally affected by stuff so not sure. The rest are sociopaths.

Edited February 24, 2020 by billiejoearmstrong8

[Gettin up]

Trevor.

[Niobium]

tommy is the biggest psychopath of them all. toni may have done "more" violent things, but he is too submissive to salvatore to be more psychopathic than tommy. niko obviously struggled with doing bad things throughout the game, and while johnny had no problem grinding pretty boy's face to the wheel, he thought that billy went too far by smashing pretty boy's face with a hammer after they got the info they needed. CJ will flip flop from psycho to submissive throughout the game. trevor is just a bitch.

 

tommy wins here.

Edited February 24, 2020 by Niobium

[Shadowfennekin]

CJ assaulted a construction site and buried a guy alive solely because he called his sister a whore.

One word....

 

At least Trevor has the speed making him do most the sh*t he does. CJ just acts out on his own

[DK06282000]

Trevor Philips gets my vote. He has done so many things that even Tommy "The Harwood Butcher" Vercetti himself would want no part of doing.

[NewGuybj]

Offcourse it's Trevor. Why many people think it's Tommy?

[billiejoearmstrong8]

17 minutes ago, NewGuybj said:

Offcourse it's Trevor. Why many people think it's Tommy?

Because when he murders people and causes mayhem etc it doesn't seem to affect him at all. Doesn't make him feel sad or troubled or guilty whatsoever even for a moment, it's nothing to him. As long as he gains more money and power there's no problem. Trevor is at least emotionally affected by what he does. 

Edited March 10, 2020 by billiejoearmstrong8

[Ahmedmfroezspeed]

On 2/25/2020 at 12:12 AM, Niobium said:

tommy is the biggest psychopath of them all. toni may have done "more" violent things, but he is too submissive to salvatore to be more psychopathic than tommy. niko obviously struggled with doing bad things throughout the game, and while johnny had no problem grinding pretty boy's face to the wheel, he thought that billy went too far by smashing pretty boy's face with a hammer after they got the info they needed. CJ will flip flop from psycho to submissive throughout the game. trevor is just a bitch.

 

tommy wins here.

Well Toni wins my vote because...

Well , he's sadistic

And come to think of it,  whenever he slaughters anybody he always chooses the most painful. cruel, sadistic,  and yet brutal way to do it

Look at giovanni casa for example

That dude was killed by cipriani by a fire axe, his corpse got chopped up, the chops were put in the grinder, and the corpse meat was delivered to casa's deli

Now Tom may haveslaughterred a person with a chainsaw, but at least he showed some respect to the corpse, unlike cipriani,  who showed no respect for the corpse

You say that he feels remorse but I say no he didn't,  I say it was fake to manipulate the father and be forgiven for his sins, even if he DID feel remorse,  it just seemed shallow and short lived...

[Ahmedmfroezspeed]

On 2/25/2020 at 8:38 AM, Shadowfennekin said:

CJ assaulted a construction site and buried a guy alive solely because he called his sister a whore.

One word....

 

At least Trevor has the speed making him do most the sh*t he does. CJ just acts out on his own

Trust me

Getting buried in concrete is WAY better than getting your meat sold in a meat deli

[NewGuybj]

On 3/10/2020 at 6:55 PM, billiejoearmstrong8 said:

Because when he murders people and causes mayhem etc it doesn't seem to affect him at all. Doesn't make him feel sad or troubled or guilty whatsoever even for a moment, it's nothing to him. As long as he gains more money and power there's no problem. Trevor is at least emotionally affected by what he does. 

 old gen gta, all protogonists in 3d era were like that, even Victor Vance. Also I don't think Trevor was affected in any way when he killed Johnny.

Edited March 12, 2020 by NewGuybj

[billiejoearmstrong8]

56 minutes ago, NewGuybj said:

 old gen gta, all protogonists in 3d era were like that, even Victor Vance. Also I don't think Trevor was affected in any way when he killed Johnny.

Trevor is very emotional and is negatively affected by a lot of the stuff he does. Even though he still does terrible things and doesn't always feel bad he still contemplates morality (think of some of his talks with Michael), is traumatised by the stuff he sees/does (for example we see how troubled he is after killing Debra and Floyd even though it was likely in self defense) does have a moral code of sorts and has moments of compassion (eg letting the guy go after he tortured him). I don't know exactly what he is, still a very bad person obviously, but he isn't an ice cold psychopath.

 

I get what you're saying about 3D era protagonists being like that, part of it is they just weren't as developed as characters. But Tommy seems particularly cool and ruthless. He can be killing someone with a chainsaw one minute and cracking jokes the next, and unlike say Vic or CJ none of it is really about helping his family and friends or getting out of a bad situation, it's pretty much all just a personal quest for money and power. I'd class Toni (the worst of all, cold and sadistic), Claude (also extremely cold) and Tommy as psychopaths. 

 

Edited March 12, 2020 by billiejoearmstrong8

[Nappy]

This is an easy vote for Trevor.

[Ahmedmfroezspeed]

On 12/2/2012 at 12:39 PM, HOW'S ANNIE? said:

Which one of the protagonists did you feel was the most psychopathic, who got a real kick out of killing and bringing harm to people?

 

(Doesn't include any of the V or pre-GTA III protagonists.

How about you, Annie ?

Who do you think is the most psychopathic GTA Protagonist in the series ?

[Ahmedmfroezspeed]

On 12/4/2012 at 10:20 AM, lil weasel said:

Carl Johnson:

Burns people alive.

Buries a man alive in concrete.

Drowns a man and woman.

Abandons an aircraft in flight without regard as to where it crashes.

Blows up an Aircraft in flight.

Pimps.

Smuggles.

Murder for 'Hire'.

Vandilism.

Burglary.

Hit & Run.

Espionage.

Terrorism.

At least his crimes were "less evil" than Cipriani,  I mean CJ did bury an engineer alive in concrete for calling his sister a hooker , but cipriani killed a butcher with a fire axe, chopped up the corpse and put it in the grinder, and then he sold the butcher's corpse ine the butcher's own deli -damn toni that's messed up-

For what ? Not paying the protection money,at least Johnson did it for a word ,while cipriani did it, for 1 action, the butcher ended up being the sausage,

Not to mention that he blew up a rival gang prostitution building, at least Johnson burned it, but cipriani blew it up, not to mention decapitating 20 forellis with a katana, plus, CJ has no rampages,  not even in a storyline mission, but Cipriani kills Pedestrians in his rampages,  at least vercetti targeted gang members and had 40 kills, but Cipriani targeted peds with a chainsaw and had 55 kills, damn man, when it comes to Terrorism,  Johnson is way more merciful than Cipriani,  I mean he did blow up a drug factory, but he didn't blow up a neighbourhood filled witb Innocent peds killing over a hundred for 5000$

Damit , compared to Cipriani, HE'S NOTHING. ..

Edited March 15, 2020 by Ahmedmfroezspeed

[lil weasel]

Stretching it.  Mixing REAL LIFE with a fantasy game is going a bit far. 

Sure the game is Broadly based on Watts, but it is Not. It is still fiction.