GTA 4 or Read Dead Redemption

[deli2000]

So here the deal. I have 4200 microsoft points, and I can either buy gta 4 with both it's expansion packs, or RDR.

which one should I pick, and why?

 

also if I get gta 4 should i get it on 360 or pc? if I get it on pc, I can mod it but I cant get the expansion packs.

[Tommy Dickfingers]

Both great, but GTA IV + the DLC's just edges it for me.

[LittleBlueTroll]

Can you buy a game for the PC with microsoft points?

[d0mm2k8]

if I get it on pc, I can mod it but I cant get the expansion packs.

Why not? Only get GTA IV for PC if your specs are good enough.

[deli2000]

 

Can you buy a game for the PC with microsoft points? 

Using Games For Windows Live

 

 

if I get it on pc, I can mod it but I cant get the expansion packs.

Why not? Only get GTA IV for PC if your specs are good enough.

I believe that the individual expansion packs aren't on games for windows

Edited June 16, 2011 by deli2000

[OnlineGamer]

What are your PC specs?

 

For me, it's a no brainer: PC GTA IV.

 

But, if your PC is really bad for the needs of GTA IV, it might be best to pick from the choices on a console instead, cause GTA IV is really demanding because it simulates a lot in real time that no other games do (rdr does, but it doesn't do nearly as much at once)

[BGModder]

Personally, I would get Red Dead Redemption. It was close with the TLAD/TBoGT, but I just enjoyed the story and overall game better in RDR.

[AceRay]

Red Dead Redemption, the world seems more alive and its just an amazing game in general.

[Finn 7 five 11]

If your a GTA Fan its GTA IV hands down.

I would go the pc version if your specs are very good, otherwise go for xbox,.

[ChossenOne]

Red Dead Redemption. But you should get both, as they're both hugely enjoyable. I don't see how you won't love either.

[Sunrise Driver]

GTA 4 + EFLC or GTA 4 on PC. Much superior game.