Jump to content

A life with Kate? or Roman?


eHeadache

Recommended Posts

*first post*

 

Well i know im so behind the times and i only got my xbox 360 for christmas after about 6 years away from owning a console and I have been playing this fine game thats GTA4.

 

Last night i got to the end of the missions, and have it saved into two separate saves after completing the last but one mission, so now when i load either file its wedding time.

 

What I cant decide on is which way is right? I dont know if I like either Kate or Roman enough to decide, cant they both die?

 

To be fair, Roman is quite possibly the most annoying character in the game, but he is my cousin, what Im wondering is if I live happily ever after with Kate is there any benefit? or do we just carry on going out on dates.

 

Because I can get dates for cheaper than that and still keep my quarter mill with roman dead and kate hating me. Does she ever come round or is the end of it?

 

Do girlfriends add to the 100% completion?

 

Thank you for reading, any answers would be most awesome

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if i let kate die, and keep roman (loosing my 250k) do you get the money when you settle wth the mafia (pegrinno what ever his name is) or is that it, skint?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As has been stated by girishb whether you choose deal or revenge you still get the money and if you choose Roman to die Kate doesn't want to date you no more and you loose Roman's free cab rides.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bobby_Williams

Deal = Dimitri will still turn on you,and then kate isnt your friend anymore after

 

Revenge = Pegorino turns on you,then roman gets shot.

user posted image
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Deal = Dimitri will still turn on you,and then kate isnt your friend anymore after

 

Revenge = Pegorino turns on you,then roman gets shot.

Wrong.

 

Deal - Roman die

Revenge - Kate die

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You have it saved in 2 slots right? Open one of them and do the deal, and then open the other and go for revenge, THEN see which one you prefer. And you can at least say you have played through both possible endings.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think roman is better. I find him funny and he actually has a benefit (cabs).

 

Just keep 2 saves, one complete and one after "that special someone"

Banned, now stay the f*ck out
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Dimitri and Pegorini dies either way,and, Kate is out of your hair either way (except for the odd glitch of a ghost call from her). therefore, I like to kill of Roman. (who is NOT the most annoying character. that distinction must go to Dwayne)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...
Mr.Superman1

 

As has been stated by girishb whether you choose deal or revenge you still get the money and if you choose Roman to die Kate doesn't want to date you no more and you loose Roman's free cab rides.

 

Edited by Mr.Superman1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kill Kate, she is pretty much useless... Even if she stays alive, you will not be able to date her again after the story is complete.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Detective Phelps

Do the revenge ending, if you do the deal ending, Roman dies and Kate will refuse to talk to you. If you to the revenge ending, you still get the same amount of money as in the deal ending. Not only that, you also get to use Roman's taxi service, since he survives the revenge ending.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FearTheLiving

Revenge vs Deal

 

Revenge

+Kill Dimitri & Pegorino

+Roman Lives

-Money Later

-Kate Dies

 

Deal

+Kill Dimitri

+Money Sooner

-Roman Dies

 

 

Personally I prefer Revenge not only do you kill Dimitri, you kill him where it all started (Platypus). Niko loses Kate which is sad (I thought she was the best girl for Niko), but I think the loss of Roman would probably break Niko, add in the fact it's a little unclear if Kate is gonna stand by Niko after the Deal ending (She shuns him, then says she'll be there after Roman's death.) Towards the end you get to jump on a helicopter on a bike vs a boat which I feel is a much cooler scene. Then you have your new antagonist (Pegorino) that I feel it should have been (you follow his goons after all) bleeding on happiness Island with Little Jacob, Roman, and Niko all the while Niko is telling him that the Comission thought he was a joke. Overall I really satisfying ending if you ask me.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

AuSsIeThUnDeR36

I choose Revenge, it seems the more likely of the two endings. I can fully see Niko wanting revenge after what Dimitri did to Roman.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Revenge vs Deal

 

Revenge

+Kill Dimitri & Pegorino

+Roman Lives + free taxi service stays

-Money Later

-Kate Dies

 

Deal

+Kill Dimitri

+Money Sooner

-Roman Dies - free taxi service goes

+Kate lives - you break contact with her anyway

 

 

Personally I prefer Revenge not only do you kill Dimitri, you kill him where it all started (Platypus). Niko loses Kate which is sad (I thought she was the best girl for Niko), but I think the loss of Roman would probably break Niko, add in the fact it's a little unclear if Kate is gonna stand by Niko after the Deal ending (She shuns him, then says she'll be there after Roman's death.) Towards the end you get to jump on a helicopter on a bike vs a boat which I feel is a much cooler scene. Then you have your new antagonist (Pegorino) that I feel it should have been (you follow his goons after all) bleeding on happiness Island with Little Jacob, Roman, and Niko all the while Niko is telling him that the Comission thought he was a joke. Overall I really satisfying ending if you ask me.

 

yea.

Niko cares for both Roman and Kate, however Niko cares for Roman more than Kate. you can hear it in Niko's voice he can recover from losing Kate but not from losing Roman.

Edited by Caliber7
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • 1 User Currently Viewing
    0 members, 0 Anonymous, 1 Guest

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.