Niko vs Johnny vs Luis

[MyDog]

I've asked a question about Tommy, Claude and CJ, but who do you think is the toughest between these three? Me, I dunno really, as I haven't played neither TLaD nor TBoGT. Maybe Niko.

[Kmeto 2]

Niko Bellic. He is killer, Luis and Jhonny haven't got chance.

[kudoboi]

Niko Bellic. He is killer, Luis and Jhonny haven't got chance.

luis. he has the auto rifle

[Tyla]

If all three were placed in a cage and let loose on each other, I'd have to say Johnny K. He just looks like he'd bite Luis' ear off.

[Algonquin Assassin]

Honestly I reckon if all 3 were placed in a room Niko would probably let Johnny, and Luis beat eachother senseless, and take out whoever's left standing.

 

Niko seems very intelligent, and would probably use it to his advantange. Plus he has alot of military experience.

[IMarwanI]

Niko Bellic got this "Red Army sh*t" lol

 

so I say Niko can beat the crap outta Luis and Johny

 

Luis can beat them with the Explosive Shotgun

 

but in fist fighting

 

Niko all the way

[WF the Hobgoblin]

Tough, but i'd go with Niko.

[IMarwanI]

Not so tough eh' Luis?

LOL if there was a TBOGT after finishing GTA IV you wouldn't be able to continue xD cause I killed Luis XD

 

[WF the Hobgoblin]

You can kill niko in TBOGT.

[IMarwanI]

You can kill niko in TBOGT.

also in TLAD lol

[na89340qv0n34b09q340]

LUIS cuz of his cage fighting skills and he has the explosive shotgun.

[Prasdana]

Niko>Luis>Johnny

[Vercetti27]

If it is a case of toughness, Johnny would win hands down.

[Sanjeem]

 

Niko Bellic. He is killer, Luis and Jhonny haven't got chance.

luis. he has the auto rifle

Niko has red Army skills, and an AK 47 will do just an nicley as an auto-rifle.

 

Oh and you can kill Luis in the bank with one shot, and even though you can kill Niko in TBOGT at the industrial shootout, thats after the bank robbery so...Niko lives

[NickRad]

Niko was the best protagonist in Gta history. I hope he returns in the next Gta

[MrcTOtheJ]

I am going with Niko, more skill than both Johnny and Luis, and when he's angry watch out. Not only that Johnny even said that he was deranged in the museum mission in TLAD when you reach the down stairs area, that an I think Niko is less afraid of death than both Luis and Johnny.

[IMarwanI]

I am going with Niko, more skill than both Johnny and Luis, and when he's angry watch out. Not only that Johnny even said that he was deranged in the museum mission in TLAD when you reach the down stairs area, that an I think Niko is less afraid of death than both Luis and Johnny.

damn right cause he says "Don't care if I live" lol

 

 

and also the mission where you had to save Roman from the russians he did all he could to save Roman which prooves he is the best

[Algonquin Assassin]

 

Oh and you can kill Luis in the bank with one shot, and even though you can kill Niko in TBOGT at the industrial shootout, thats after the bank robbery so...Niko lives

Niko is like The Terminator in TBOGT. I remember trying to kill him, and he wouldn't. Even from a rocket launcher blast he still got up. It took sh*tload of bullets from the auto shotgun to finally take him down.

 

Johnny, and Luis are more vunerable in their appearances in GTA IV.

[Johnny gat from sr]

If were talking about strength johnny easily but in a hand to hand fight johnny would still win ik niko was in a war and sh*t but johnny is a bikers are the toughest mfers in the the world they can be shot five time then get up luis is (racist warning) a black elvis Presley a no body and idiot but i think niko has a chance but in the end johnny is just way tougher and stronger

[Jack Lupino]

Luis is the strongest .He can steal a helicopter from heavily guarded ship, survived two huge gunfights with police/SWAT team,hop on top of running subway train and shoot oncoming helicopters,chase enemies on top of the tallest tower  etc. 

He also killed a bunch of Lost MC bikers and police at the same time all by himself while in a car.

 

Niko doesn't look as strong as much as Luis to me.

The only mission where Niko appeared as strong and tough was in three leaf clover and then also he needed two sidekicks to finish the job.

 

Johnny was the weakest of the three , always fight in gangs but never alone and got killed like a pussy with boot to the head.

 

 

Edited March 30, 2019 by Jack Lupino

[Algonquin Assassin]

2 hours ago, Jack Lupino said:

Luis is the strongest .He can steal a helicopter from heavily guarded ship, survived two huge gunfights with police/SWAT team,hop on top of running subway train and shoot oncoming helicopters,chase enemies on top of the tallest tower  etc. 

He also killed a bunch of Lost MC bikers and police at the same time all by himself while in a car

Good for him.

 

2 hours ago, Jack Lupino said:

 

Niko doesn't look as strong as much as Luis to me.

The only mission where Niko appeared as strong and tough was in three leaf clover and then also he needed two sidekicks to finish the job.

 

 

 

 

See what makes your above post so biased is you can't even give Niko the same benefit. Since he's a hitman/hired gun he kills a lot of people and does it the majority of the time on his own, but the little dig that he has two sidekicks wiih him for Three Leaf Clover is just silly. Name a heist in any GTA game where the protagonists just does the whole thing by themselves? 

 

2 hours ago, Jack Lupino said:

Johnny was the weakest of the three , always fight in gangs but never alone and got killed like a pussy with boot to the head.

Well that should be obvious since he's a BIKER and yeah you're wrong. In Politics, Off Route, Coming Down, Buyer's Market and Collector's Item he does them without needing help from other members of The Lost. Might be a good idea to play the game again or atleast do some research before shooting your mouth off. 

[TheSantader25]

-Guns:Luis, his missions were insanely more difficult than Niko. Well, it's TBOGT. 

 

-Melee:Niko, No explanation needed. Luis is definitely up there as well though because of his LC cage fighting experience. 

 

[Rumblebud]

1 hour ago, Jack Lupino said:

Johnny was the weakest of the three , always fight in gangs but never alone and got killed like a pussy with boot to the head.

Keep in mind that he had gotten dragged into a meth addiction through Ashley which very likely threw him off of his fighting capability.

 

The ice got him good. Trevor did too.

[Algonquin Assassin]

To Johhny's credit he also goes throughout game with a f*cked leg which hinders his mobility. He's a tough son of a bitch seeing he's past his physical prime, but still manges to push himself as much as he can.

[Jack Lupino]

2 hours ago, American Venom said:

Good for him.

 

See what makes your above post so biased is you can't even give Niko the same benefit. Since he's a hitman/hired gun he kills a lot of people and does it the majority of the time on his own, but the little dig that he has two sidekicks wiih him for Three Leaf Clover is just silly. Name a heist in any GTA game where the protagonists just does the whole thing by themselves? 

 

Well that should be obvious since he's a BIKER and yeah you're wrong. In Politics, Off Route, Coming Down, Buyer's Market and Collector's Item he does them without needing help from other members of The Lost. Might be a good idea to play the game again or atleast do some research before shooting your mouth off. 

My point was most of nikos missions were basic driving and shooting people but luis missions were far more difficult and challenging (like surviving on top of train or even escaping a locked building roof surrounded by Bulgarins men) that's why he appeared tougher and stronger to me. He faced more life risking situations and faced bigger obstacles than niko.

If GTA 4 had more challenging missions like tbogt than probably he would appear more stronger to me.

[Algonquin Assassin]

56 minutes ago, Jack Lupino said:

My point was most of nikos missions were basic driving and shooting people but luis missions were far more difficult and challenging (like surviving on top of train or even escaping a locked building roof surrounded by Bulgarins men) that's why he appeared tougher and stronger to me. He faced more life risking situations and faced bigger obstacles than niko.

If GTA 4 had more challenging missions like tbogt than probably he would appear more stronger to me.

That has nothing to do with the characters themselves. R* could've made GTA IV's missions more over the top and silly like TBOGT, but that doesn't mean what Niko faced was a walk through the park throughout the story. I'm not interested in mission difficulty as quite frankly I never found TBOGT's missions very challenging. Just really over the top and immersion breaking.

 

[santosvagos]

8 hours ago, CanadianMuscle said:

Keep in mind that he had gotten dragged into a meth addiction through Ashley which very likely threw him off of his fighting capability.

 

The ice got him good. Trevor did too.

That 's just Rockstar bullsh*t reason to get rid of johnny since they can't find any other ways  . The LOST MC in GTA V just stands there to look pretty in the game and AOD is wiped out , WTF Rockstar ???

[Rumblebud]

^ R* definitely could've thought out Johnny's death in a better scenario. At least where he could die fighting; although not being quite as personal as it was in Trevor's introduction, it'd be more interesting to see Trevor's seemingly uncontrollable rage put in control by the player.

 

Maybe with a IV-style objective:

 

Choose Johnny's Fate.

 

I'm not so sure about how it would affect The Lost's operation throughout GTA Online if he was alive and still president of the chapter, either being passively in the shadows of the gang while the others are put forward to face the player, since they appear in countless scenarios and missions. None of us could say his death was canon if he was still involved with the gang and key members included, during shootouts or any "story" scenario if they were still to appear outside of these areas in other elements of the game.

[Algonquin Assassin]

2 hours ago, CanadianMuscle said:

^ R* definitely could've thought out Johnny's death in a better scenario. At least where he could die fighting; although not being quite as personal as it was in Trevor's introduction, it'd be more interesting to see Trevor's seemingly uncontrollable rage put in control by the player.

 

Maybe with a IV-style objective:

 

Choose Johnny's Fate.

 

I'm not so sure about how it would affect The Lost's operation throughout GTA Online if he was alive and still president of the chapter, either being passively in the shadows of the gang while the others are put forward to face the player, since they appear in countless scenarios and missions. None of us could say his death was canon if he was still involved with the gang and key members included, during shootouts or any "story" scenario if they were still to appear outside of these areas in other elements of the game.

But in the end it was all for something for anti-GTAIV/TLAD fanboys to drool over so Trevor could have his 5 minutes of fame (Since the majority of GTA fans see him as a terribly written character).

 

We all know it could've been better thought out and sadly it's one of those "what if?" type of scenarios R* failed to capitalise on.

[Rumblebud]

15 minutes ago, American Venom said:

But in the end it was all for something for anti-GTAIV/TLAD fanboys to drool over so Trevor could have his 5 minutes of fame (Since the majority of GTA fans see him as a terribly written character).

 

We all know it could've been better thought out and sadly it's one of those "what if?" type of scenarios R* failed to capitalise on.

It all technically ended when the Alderney clubhouse was burned down in Liberty City. It would have been too much work for R* to find a role for him anywhere else in GTA V.