Rate The Song Above You

[Sorkenlol 1]

Not sure if there's a thread, if there is, please direct me to it and lock this one.

 

Basically, just rate the song above you, and post your own song after you've given your rating, don't double post please.

 

Here's one of my favourites.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JWCFRwUzQA

 

Jethro Tull - The Witch's Promise

 

REVISED RULE (July 2018) - I've noticed for a long time people just leave their scores and post another track, which is technically the purpose, but it doesn't tell anybody anything about what you actually thought. Why have you rated it the score given? Did you like it, what was it missing, was it too long? Not only does this contribute more to the topic rather than just a numbers game, but it adds a little bit more depth and meaning to the songs being shared. I'd appreciate it if people could share a little bit about what they thought about the song along with their scores. Thank you.

[Stephan90 822]

not bad 7/!0

 

here is mine

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=palJlPXEy00

Edited January 1, 2009 by Stephan123

[Canofceleri 58]

4/10. Pathetic song. You should have been sucked out your mother's twat onto the f*cking tray for that, mate.

 

The following is a selection from 1969's Captain Beefheart avant-blues masterpiece, Trout Mask Replica. The song is "When Big Joan Sets Up." It is amazing. If you don't give it at least a 10 you must have profound mental retardation.

 

 

[Sorkenlol 1]

Hehe, odd choice, not sure what I should rate that. I didn't like it, I like blues, but that wasn't it. I'm sure some can appreciate that kind of music though, 3/10.

 

 

 

Cream - Crossroads

[TonyZimmzy 31]

1/10. Hate old-old music.

 

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=LlOOn8kHN54

[Mark 478]

Edit: I'd say about 8/10. Never really listened to Finch, but I could get to like it.

 

And now, my attempt to try and get the lowest score. Sad thing is, I like it.

 

 

[Scarface187 222]

I'm giving that 5/10. Horrible or not it automatically gets 5 from me for being insane.

 

I give you Metropolis by Dream Theater.

 

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=kKAkreYSns4

 

 

4:30 to 4:43 is one of my favorite parts of any song ever.

 

 

And what the f*ck is wrong with you people? Cream and Captain Beefheart are awesome. I understand people have their own opinions and I can understand why people wouldn't like Captain Beefheart really but Cream?

Edited January 1, 2009 by Scarface187

[Sorkenlol 1]

 

Edit - I'm giving that 5/10. Horrible or not it automatically gets 5 from me for being insane.

 

I give you Metropolis by Dream Theater.

 

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=kKAkreYSns4

 

Awesome, I used to listen to Dream Theater a few years ago, then I just kind of forgot about them, time to dig up the old cd's.

 

8/10

 

Here's mine

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UddURb0alQc

 

Sorry, the quality ain't good.

[Don Garcia aka NjNakedSnake 0]

Hm, I give it a 7/10. Very mellow, and it did right by Bob's version.

 

Mine: http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=zzaClXAt3aY

[Scarface187 222]

Hm, I give it a 7/10. Very mellow, and it did right by Bob's version.

 

Mine: http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=zzaClXAt3aY

8/10. The vocals were alright but the guitar playing was awesome. The playing reminded me of Joey Eppard, which brings me to.....

 

Joey Eppard - Amaze Disgrace

 

 

I could only find a non live version on last.fm.

[Stephan90 822]

cool song 7/10

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNYTkTTHywc&feature=related

[jimmy. 3]

7/10. I'd elaborate but I know sh*t about metal/lyrics are in German.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7fMI5NYwyTQ

Edited January 2, 2009 by jimmy.

[Gutslab 1,986]

10/10

Love the genre, and era. Great lyrics, and awesome vibe.

 

 

[JimBobby 0]

8/10 reminds me of SA

 

takes a while to get into the song

 

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-mzD9bwzUyo&feature=related

Edited January 2, 2009 by JimBobby

[Mullen 3]

1/10 i can't stand Incubus

 

 

[Guglielminpietro 1]

1/10 i can't stand Incubus

 

 

Well I hope you still listened to the song before rating it. Or else this topic would be a complete waste of time. And we wouldn't want that.

 

Anyway, your song was alright, if you like low-budget punky stuff. Could probably use a melody though, it's not what you'd call catchy. 4/10.

 

 

Next - maybe the best song ever written, you decide.

 

 

 

 

(Biffy Clyro - 57)

 

[Canofceleri 58]

Maybe I could see the appeal, but not for me. Nothing impressive at all, respectfully. This song however, is brilliant. Prolly my favorite overall Zappa at the moment, Rdnzl.

 

 

[Esperanto_Boy 4]

Maybe I could see the appeal, but not for me. Nothing impressive at all, respectfully. This song however, is brilliant. Prolly my favorite overall Zappa at the moment, Rdnzl.

 

 

Good sh*t! Zappa's the man.

 

I'll see that and raise you this irritating ditty, sung by his daughter Moon Unit (wha?) no less.

 

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=5M9aY7hXjGU

[Mullen 3]

 

Well I hope you still listened to the song before rating it. Or else this topic would be a complete waste of time. And we wouldn't want that.

sorry if my post came off blunt. even though i don't like Incubus at all i will still recognize them as great at what they do. i just don't like things too polished, "low budget-punky stuff" as you put it is pretty much all i listen to.

 

@Esperanto boy: 9/10 i love Frank Zappa and everything associated with him

 

 

 

[Slamman 127]

I was reading in Nick Mason's Pink Floyd book about how the UK music scene was exposed to US artists like Velvet Underground and The Mothers of Invention.

 

I had thought to make a thread on that.... but not yet, he gets mentioned here a lot. I was not a fan but was exposed to MUCH of his music...again, by Mr. Earl Root. Earl's favorite artist was probably Zappa. Zappa was clearly not a metal artist, but Earl dedicated whole radio shows to his music and always was interested in collecting ANY recordings he could find, in mint condition, etc...as a record collector and fan

 

I still wouldn't call myself a fan, but I grew to respect him and give his music a chance versus writing it off as too much jazz and not enough rock and roll.

Didn't hurt that Steve Vai cut his chops performing with Zappa live! He is an amazing guitarist who also reveres Zappa...with first hand experience, so some bias there.

Bears repeating...from me, Incubus is again a stolen name from a much HARDER band that will NEVER be called 'polished', or punk. They were TRUE METAL.

 

If I am to rate Suicidal Tendencies...in keeping with the theme, I of course, am a long time fan!

Picking up the box set of Miami Vice was a given with me, but Suicidal perform on the show and it's awesome, as always.

Edited January 2, 2009 by Slamman

[Lt. Dan 1]

7/10

 

I really enjoy Suicidal Tendencies. Their music really conveys a "f*ck you" mood.

 

 

[fox09 0]

10/10

 

 

It's Zeppelin, I mean, come on.

 

 

 

[Slamman 127]

I neglected a song but I was actively looking for a video I saw on MTV, but it's not on YouTube, sadly. At least I haven't dug it up with a search.

SO, from the same band.... Rolling Stones.

 

This is a demo outtake of Let It Loose, from Exiles on Main Street...review;

 

I'll further edit with an opinion on above video <G>

EDITing; OK, Richie Kotzen was most notable for his playing in Poison for a time, it was not at the height of their career...however, he was kicked from the band for sleeping with someone else's girl. A similar situation happened with a local band at the time I knew them well.

 

I haven't followed Poison's career too closely. I'm a casual enjoyer of their music. Can't say I'd heard that one before. For a first timer, sometimes the studio track is a better representation. For me, the live sound loses some of the song tightness that the studio captures. Most often a live performance is very loose, and more fluid of course.

Edited January 2, 2009 by Slamman

[Drag_Drift 4]

8/10. Dreamy. Reminds me of cough syrup and broken guitar strings. Bravo.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwHZyVkreNc

 

Too old for my age, but what the heck. I love it.

[Slamman 127]

One should hear the vocal version of Let It Loose as well, I have a box set with all the outtakes stuff, I got it on at the moment, it's a nice Stones collective.

I'll let someone comment on the song you picked, but for the record, I wanted to interject that Eric Clapton's other band had a hit with Bell Bottom Blues... One I still love to hear.

Though he covered Cocaine (John Cale <?> track) in the 1970s but he, himself struggled with it, glad he was able to get off the drug.

[Juice By Kayla Marie 3]

0 because slamman didn't post a song and wrote a lot.

 

 

 

listen to the whole songgg

haha, it grows on you. love the beat and the lyrics.

[fox09 0]

I was just waiting for those kids on the skateboards to smack into each other.

 

Oh, right. 7/10, I suppose. Mellow, kinda catchy.

 

 

 

Indie band from Vancouver. Not their best song, and a really, really crappy video.

[outcest 5]

yes!!! Lotus Child is pretty dope man....i just have a hard on for most of our local acts...you live in the city?

 

nonetheless: catchy, poppy, and decent lyrics.

 

6 and one half/10

 

 

 

i'm f*cking in love with this song/album/band. perverse lounge tunes. kinda like the muzak they'd play in hell's waiting room...y'know, before the eternal damnation...

[Juice By Kayla Marie 3]

Not my style, 4.5.

 

 

 

[nabo45 12]

Not my style of music, but it's ok. 7/10

 

Van Halen - Ice Cream Man (Live)