Top 5 Punk bands

[ISd3d 0]

1. Bad Brains

2. Black Flag

3. Minor Threat

4. Misfits

5. Screeching Weasel

[-Flatliner- 0]

Sex Pistols are always hailed as the greatest punk band. Personally, I think that's a whole lot down to Sid Vicious's suicide. As a band, they had so littke musical talent that they were left to rely of shock tactics.

Admittedly, that gained them commercial success, but the ability to play their instruments was more or less non-existant.

Yea, they defnitely weren't the most talented musicians around. But I still think they deserve all the recognition they receive because they basically created the genre of punk rock.

I don't think they were the greatest punk band, but I think they were the first.

[Moonshield 9,935]

Except for the fact that they went against "punk" mentality what with being commercial puppets and basically sh*t on the entire DIY scene itself?

[-Flatliner- 0]

The Pistols were a popular band, but that didn't make them commercial puppets. They invented the "punk" mentality as far as I'm concerned. What did they do to sh*t on the DIY scene?

[Mullen 3]

1. Nucleo Terco

2. Kortatu

3. Decibelios

4. Non Servium

5. Piperrak

 

Oi! Oi! Oi!

[Moonshield 9,935]

The Pistols were a popular band, but that didn't make them commercial puppets. They invented the "punk" mentality as far as I'm concerned. What did they do to sh*t on the DIY scene?

Being signed to a major record label? Yeah, really punk.

[Kained But Able 0]

The Pistols were a popular band, but that didn't make them commercial puppets. They invented the "punk" mentality as far as I'm concerned. What did they do to sh*t on the DIY scene?

Being signed to a major record label? Yeah, really punk.

Haha, yeah, never been into those corporate whores.

 

Anyway... a list of 5 bands I like in no particular order

 

1. F-Minus

2. Choking Victim / Leftover Crack

3. Capdown

4. Sonic Boom Six

5. Five Knuckle

 

 

[Moonshield 9,935]

I need to get some Leftover Crack, but I don't know where to start.

[lesfleanut 4]

I need to get some Leftover Crack, but I don't know where to start.

I'm sure reemah can help you there.

[ToyMachine 1]

The Pistols were a popular band, but that didn't make them commercial puppets. They invented the "punk" mentality as far as I'm concerned.

Stop talking, please.

[-slash 2]

The Clash

Cancerslug

The Powder Monkeys

Dead Kennedys

The Ramones

[ISd3d 0]

 

Crossover is better.

Check out IRON AGE

[Twang of Cauliflower 0]

Refused

Stormtroopers of Death

Misfits

Bad Religion

Bad Brains

The Germs

 

 

On the Sex Pistols: They took the mentality of "you don't have to be the greatest musician ever to make music" to an extreme. If you know what I mean.

Edited December 10, 2006 by Twang of Cauliflower

[8ballsoffire 0]

1. The Clash

2. The Clash

3. The Clash

4. The Clash

5. The Clash

 

can't be bettered in my opinion, nothing before or since has ever come close. here's a proper list:

 

1. The Clash

2. Gang of Four

3. The Fall

4. Elle Milano

5. The Slits

[darthYENIK 8,766]

 

I totally agree.  And the sex pistols didn't deserve half the success or regard that they have.

How so?

The Sex Pistols were the cause of the 77 revolution. They laid the foundation for all punk rock. I think they're deserving of every ounce of recognition they've ever gotten.

They sucked, period.

 

I don't give a flying f*ck about what they did with their image, or whatever bullsh*t foundation you think they laid.

 

The sex pistols sucked musically, not to mention they had a prepubecent boy for a screamer singer. And they (as I said, and still stick to) did not deserve sh*t.

 

And sorry to burst your imaginary bubble, but a little band called the Ramones beat the sex pistols in being the first punk rock band. But I don't really give a f*ck who was first.

[Alternative Child 0]

For f*cks sake, I know for a fact if any of you were given the chance to be signed up to a major record label, you WOULD, no questions asked.

 

For me...

 

1: Sex Pistols

2: Germs

3: Tattooed Mother f*ckers

4: Crass

5: G.B.H

[-Flatliner- 0]

You guys are the only "punks" I've known to discredit the Sex Pistols.

[Alternative Child 0]

You guys are the only "punks" I've known to discredit the Sex Pistols.

Yeah, a lot of "Punks" hate the band because they switched over to a major record label, or because they went against the "DIY" scene. First off, NO band just gets together for the fun of it, thats complete bullsh*t, all of them are in it for the money.

 

The "DIY" scene had already been whored out by 77' anyways.

[Phalanxe 0]

 

First off, NO band just gets together for the fun of it, thats complete bullsh*t, all of them are in it for the money.

 

Ha.

[Moonshield 9,935]

You guys are the only "punks" I've known to discredit the Sex Pistols.

Yeah, a lot of "Punks" hate the band because they switched over to a major record label, or because they went against the "DIY" scene. First off, NO band just gets together for the fun of it, thats complete bullsh*t, all of them are in it for the money.

 

The "DIY" scene had already been whored out by 77' anyways.

You're right, every single band/composer/musician makes music solely for monetary gain, just how every painter, sculptor, author, poet, comic artist, and whathaveyou creates art just for money, and not to spread a message or a express their beliefs. You're completely right.

[WalkerBoh 0]

Im not good with genre's, I keep it all as "music" and "crap that hurts my earries".

 

bad religon

nofx

dead kennedys

misfits

" "

 

[boardwalk4est 0]

misfits

dead kennedys

crass

the exploited

midnight creeps

epileptics

 

no order, except for the the first 5.

[Alternative Child 0]

You're right, every single band/composer/musician makes music solely for monetary gain, just how every painter, sculptor, author, poet, comic artist, and whathaveyou creates art just for money, and not to spread a message or a express their beliefs. You're completely right.

This is about music, not art. If you have and idea, you make money off of it.

[*MURDOC* 4,799]

You're right, every single band/composer/musician makes music solely for monetary gain, just how every painter, sculptor, author, poet, comic artist, and whathaveyou creates art just for money, and not to spread a message or a express their beliefs. You're completely right.

This is about music, not art. If you have and idea, you make money off of it.

Yeah dude, music is definitely not considered art, its more of a job, totally not something you do for fun.

 

 

give me a f*cking break.

 

 

[Moonshield 9,935]

 

You're right, every single band/composer/musician makes music solely for monetary gain, just how every painter, sculptor, author, poet, comic artist, and whathaveyou creates art just for money, and not to spread a message or a express their beliefs. You're completely right.

This is about music, not art. If you have and idea, you make money off of it.

Hahaha, oh wow. If you're being serious, I'm very sorry for you. It must hurt to be so wrong.

[Paco 2]

 

You guys are the only "punks" I've known to discredit the Sex Pistols.

Yeah, a lot of "Punks" hate the band because they switched over to a major record label, or because they went against the "DIY" scene. First off, NO band just gets together for the fun of it, thats complete bullsh*t, all of them are in it for the money.

 

The "DIY" scene had already been whored out by 77' anyways.

Do you have at least a slight idea as to why people dislike signing to major record labels?

 

It's called art for arts sake, dipsh*t.

[Mr.Robot 0]

1. AFI

2. Greenday

3. ???

 

 

 

 

1. Dead Kennedys

2. The Clash

3. New York Dolls

4. The Casualties

5.The Libertines

 

 

[inthegarage 59]

1. Germs

2.GBH

3.Cockney Rejects

4.The unseen

5.Anti Flag

6.Bad Brains

7.The buzzcocks

8.The vandals

9.The exploited

10.Dead Kennedys

[axdamn16 0]

MY Favorites:

1. Against Me!

2. Defiance, Ohio

3. This Bike is a Pipe Bomb

4. Dead Kennedys

5. The Vandals

6. NOFX

7. The Clash

8. The Ramones

9. Anti-Flag

10. Rancid

 

HAHAHAHA you guys arguing about punk are all gay!!!!

[Moonshield 9,935]

Hey, you're the one that likes NOFX.