According to gamer's choice, it's TLOU. Even though it was PS3 exclusive, it gained a lot of positive feedbacks.
Rockstar brought trouble to their shoes by themselves. They were the one who flaunted a lot. They thought of going into a new light but they forgot the true reason why GTA series got popular. Speaking to themselves, they made a complete unique game and it resulted a lot of old fans to lose their interest in the series.
TLOU on the other hand, was amazing in all aspect; except the part of not having versions for all consoles and PC. Perhaps, people are only concerned about selling off unfinished work than making the game flawless.
I just wish Rockstar makes GTA V better in PC than it's console versions. THEN, it will be a revenge from the PC community.