Well in general I think Gta 5 is a better game, but this is the city. Anyways in Los santos it's very sunny with great detail and countryside. While Liberty city is gray and depressing with ok detail. I think Los santos looks more beautiful at night then Liberty city does. I also like how Los santos has palm trees. Liberty city is awesome and all, but I don't feel at home there though. In Los santos I feel at home, because we have houses in vinewood hills and mirror park. Los santos feels more of a laid back city then Liberty city tbh with you. Los santos feels more luxury then Liberty city, because of all the nice houses. Los santos feels like a rich city that doesn't feel depressing like Liberty city. Liberty city doesn't feel like it has those type of nice houses it feels like they put too much skyscrapers and not enough ghettos.
Liberty city feels like a depressing city with not much luxury. Los santos feels sunny with a bunch of luxury houses in vinewood. While I'm kind of mad at rockstar for putting useless mountains in east Los santos and should done ghettos there instead it's still a nice city. I like Liberty city it feels like Gta 3 all over again with Gta San Andreas features and better graphics. Liberty city motto "worst place in America" it gives you that feel. I'm kind of disappointed that rockstar didn't put Staten Island in Liberty city, but I'm sure when they do Liberty city in a future HD era Gta they will do Liberty state and expand Liberty city. Same goes for Los santos it's only part of southern San Andreas not the whole San Andreas state. It's really a tough decision in terms of which city you like most. You can be in a city with luxury houses and with more detail put into it, or you could be in a depressing city with lots of crime. Tbh honest with you my complaint with Los santos is that the map should be bigger do they can add more ghettos. Liberty city I wish it had countryside and Staten Island. Guys I have to say it's really a tie. Los santos feels like a laid back city with a luxury and sunny feeling(sometimes it feels like vice city to me for some strange reason lol) or Liberty city a depressing city with some type of weather. They both have crime in the city, but it would be cool if we could go to Los santos in 1992 in Gta 5 and see the Los santos riots.
Liberty city has that Gta 3 feeling you know (btw Gta Liberty city stories isn't dark so that Liberty city in that game sucks.) , now Liberty city doesn't have countryside which is an issue for me. Los santos has countryside and I'm glad it does it feels good to get out of the city.
I agree it was cool in Gta 4 that you could watch the history of Liberty city tv show. Los santos doesn't feels like a movie set probably, because of vinewood. Your right Liberty city had the Mafia, Russians and Jamaican gangs etc.., this is why I think Las Vegas should be in Gta 6. Well I think it's strange that rockstar yet to set a gta in the Midwest. But seriously though it's not rockstar' fault that Los santos feels like a movie set to you. That's just the way Los Angeles is setup. This might sound creepy to you, but I have seen your post on Los santos vs Liberty city topics back in 2013. The Liberty city atmosphere feels alive while Los santos atmosphere is just odd. Well this is exactly why we need Gta to be set in vice city again.