These are a must!! If we can think of good sh*t like this imagine what R* are thinking or thought of.
A few of my wishes (I don't want to expect too much neither)
-better trade system: you could harvest pelts, skins, meeat or bones and sell them via a micro management, or even exchanging those against rare weapons or ammunition. I'd love to see a ranch, which the player owwns and could updgrade. You could sell various things, or even sending chariots or carriages to towns for benefits (though it soounds aa bit too much for a R* game).
-better interactions between animals and general IA (humans). Animals should be able to drink, hunt, or interact between eachother. Like, bucks fighting for females, much like Assassin's Creed 3.
-dual wielding for revolvers and handguns. Why not, unlocking this ability after completing some challenges would be great.
-better dual system. I loved Call of Juarez' duals. They were more "natural".
-better IA in overall.
- less automatic weapons, more carbines, lever action rifles, bolt action rifles, breach loading rifles, revolvers.
-more mini games, such as shooting targets, and poker-style games.
-property owning : ranch, farms, warehouses or even brothels. If we play as a younger John Marston, it would make sense. It wouldd help getting funds and money for the gang.
-territory and landgrabs against rival gangs, both in single and multiplayer?
-heists (banks, or even gold mines).
-more horses breeds.
-more treasure hunting, made harder, implying you have to kill people looking for it, or even siding with them if you want to multiply your chances of finding it.
-swim (?). Though I don't know if people at the end of the XIXth century knew how to swim, it could be fun.
deadline, exclusives to mp and cashcards