my vote: #1 Bully (Canis Canem Edit)
Note: I'll make a list of the games mentioned as #1 here - the one which gets mentioned the most is the ultimate #1 Rockstar game yet.
RED DEAD REDEMPTION [18 votes]
GRAND THEFT AUTO V [17 votes]
GRAND THEFT AUTO IV [13 votes]
GRAND THEFT AUTO SAN ANDREAS [7 votes]
BULLY [4 votes]
GRAND THEFT AUTO VICE CITY [4 votes]
MAX PAYNE 3 [3 votes]
GRAND THEFT AUTO III [2 votes]
ROCKSTAR TABLE TENNIS [2 votes]
THE WARRIORS [1 vote]
STATE OF EMERGENCY [1 vote]
MIDNIGHT CLUB III [1 vote]
Edited by Emmi, 4 weeks ago.