For me, The Last Of Us was a disappointment, with awkward shooting, awkward swimming, etc. Just generally not as good as i was expecting/what other people lead me to believe. I prefer Uncharted.
My favourite PS3 exclusives are Uncharted, Motorstorm, Metal Gear Solid 4 and The Last Of Us nonetheless. I'm sure Beyond is also a really good game, I've just never played it. Same with God Of War, i have friends who love that game, i've just never played it myself.
Gran Turismo 4 sucked, i'm sure Forza is much better. (I would hope so for the sake of Xbox owners...) The Infamous was also terrible with awful, cheap graphics/psychics/animations/voice acting/level design and so on. Wasn't even worth downloading Infamous for free when Sony got hacked.
The Resistance was also f*cking terrible, i remember that was one of the first games i got for my PS3, i gave it a good day or 2 to grow on me but after a while i just had to admit to myself that it was terrible in every way.
Heavy Rain was pretty cool i guess, although i didn't like the way you couldn't actually control/play most of it, and i certainly hated the story line in some places, like at the beginning when he's "chasing" his son through the shopping mall. If it was me i would have pushed right through the crowd and got to my son in no time, but of course the game makes you walk at the slowest pace ever, makes it so you can't push through crowds etc, in a totally unrealistic way. To be fair though, if i was the kid, i wouldn't walk out into traffic like a total retard either, that is the reason why Heavy Rain wasn't that great. Because of the overly forced/scripted/unrealistic and limited scenarios.