Most of the magazines give a 10/10 at the moment. I guess they haven't played the game that long. What is the fanbase's rating?
Quite the opposite, they give it 10/10 because they HAVE played the game.
I have too and so have most of the people (beside the trolls) that say it's far from perfect. But if it's a 10/10 for you, that's cool.
Essentially there is no perfect game, and there is never going to be one. But my experience is way too positive to give it anything less than a 10 at this point.
Many people complain about things that are already in the game, they just have not played enough to unlock it, or their have never even touched it.
Also, they have to realize that GTA V is GTA V, not SA 2.0. And probably there is never going to be a SA 2.0, enjoy the game for what it does best.