Both look great. I voted for the new layout, but whichever happens, i'm sure most members will be cool with it.
If the new layout were to be chosen, where would the potential flag/member log link/post count go if added?
Also, is there any way to display post date like it used to be (option in settings, or as default) (right now it says eg. posted 34 minutes ago, posted 2 days ago, posted a week ago...and before we had posted 13 Aug 2012 14:23, posted 5th November 2009, 17:29. It feels a bit more convenient and precise
Edit: is there any way to switch the edit/quote/multi quote buttons to top right corner of post? Could be a bit more convenient for editing long posts in some pinned topics rather then scrolling down. Just a very small suggestion, i'm fine as it is, just fell to my mind.