Both games are just great, unforgetable. No matter how improved graphics and the texture resolutions will be available in the next GTA VI, VC and VCS will always be something special.
And only hardcore fans of VC&VCS like myself will agree with me on this one.
Both games come very closely but if i had to choose i would say VCS but just for 1 point better than VC.
Altough some things are better in VC, like unique 80s athmosfere, peds clothing and radio stations.
But VCS wins with its gorgeous orange sunsets during 20:30 ang 23:00 in game time, graphic, vehicles and fun meter. IMO..
Also in VCS is Vic a killing machine who can snap necks, strangle, knee kicks in the back and throwing peds like a bags of chips
Now who can beat that?
Altough Tommy fights good too (especially head bangs) but Vic is like a killer seal.
Personaly i find a good hand combating protagonist quite important because i like to defend myself with fists only from a cop without pulling a gun and earn 2 stars.
I mean look at Toni Cipriani in LCS he`s got to have the lousiest fighting skills among all protags. Even Claude is better at that.
When cop comes after Toni with a nightstick he cant do sh*it without a weapon. Just falls down and gets busted.
That suck so this is an important aspect of a game, at least for me.