|QUOTE (Lightning Strike @ Saturday, May 11 2013, 15:10)|
Right where do I start, firstly I never, ever argued that Red Dead was perfect. What I wanted was for him to tell me what these flaws that he apparently found in the game were, that was it. To say that I said Red Dead was perfect and has no discernible flaws is just as idiotic as arguing such a thing in the first place.
Secondly, I asked him for proof of why he believes that Red Dead Redemption is a technically worse game then Grand Theft Auto IV, when as we all know that's simply not the case. So if you're going to go ahead and insist that I'm displaying blatant fanboyism in favour of Red Dead you've clearly not bothered to read the entire conversation.
Therefore, he does need proof as what he's said is extremely hypocritical. He says that no-one notices the flaws that Red Dead Redemption has, but fails to mention any of them, then though he proceeds to say that everyone seems to pick on Grand Theft Auto IV for its flaws yet it's a much, much better game.
The fact is that if he personally prefers Grand Theft Auto IV over Red Dead Redemption I've no issue with that, but arguing that the game was over hyped and nowhere near as good as Grand Theft Auto IV technically without providing a bit of proof as to how Red Dead Redemption is a technically inferior game? That's deserving of a response.
Oh and if you think that I've been bitchy you do realise that he went into an entirely separate section of the forums to go to a thread and then insult both my appearance and stroke his own ego saying that he's quite possibly the best looking member on the forums. I'm sorry but he's acted rather childishly throughout this entire thing and you getting involved and moaning at me for the way I've talked to him isn't really helping.
I never said that you said it was perfect. But the way you were bumming it like it was the only thing in the world that matters, I felt like I needed to let you know. Although if you knew it wasn't perfect, then why did he need to list everything wrong with it? He didn't post to point out the flaws, he was only saying the hype makes people blind to them. Then you snapped around "FLAWS?! WHAT FLAWS?! WHO SAID THAT? YOU THERE BOY! TELL ME THESE FLAWS NOW".
| Firstly you say that the game runs entirely off of its own hype and that's simply not the case, the game runs off of its own awesomeness and that's pretty much the only reason people flocked to the stores in hoards to buy the game |
I thought you were big on proof? Where's your proof? It's okay we'll drop it, probably an accident.
| You call Grand Theft Auto IV a fantastic game that people "bash" for its flaws, yet the fact remains Grand Theft Auto IV has a large number of flaws, flaws that were addressed in Red Dead Redemption and from where I'm standing it almost seems like you're arguing that Grand Theft Auto IV is the better game (technically of course) out of the two when it's simply not the case. |
Whoops, looks like you fell into the apparently unforgivable hole of mentioning flaws but not listing them.
| regardless of what you think drove Red Dead Redemption to be popular I can tell you for a fact that it wasn't false hype that made the game out to be something more then it was/is. |
Woahhhhh this is freaky, there isn't any proof here either...? Surely you just forgot again.
| Oh and please, please try to structure your posts so that in future people of English decent can actually understand the point that you're trying to convey. |
You mean descent? Or maybe even decency? No wonder you were having trouble understanding him.
| try harder next time before attempt to criticise a game of this scale and scope. |
...? I don't like being that guy, it's just that you're doing a sloppy job of correcting someone.
| A great example of this is the fact that Red Dead Redemption is technically a better game then Grand Theft Auto IV, not to say that you can't prefer Grand Theft Auto IV over Red Dead, but you gave no reason to support the claims that you were making so again I ask you to present proof that Grand Theft Auto IV is a better game then Red Dead. |
But... where is your proof that Red Dead is technically better? I thought you were leading somewhere with this -
| in every respect it out does Grand Theft Auto IV, in case you're wondering what I mean by this I mean to say that every game mechanic from graphical fidelity, to the soundtrack (the first Rockstar open world game with a dynamic soundtrack in the background) to the game's vast array of activities and multiplayer modes. |
But alas, I was misled. Just a load of hot air. You haven't explained or proven anything. I was going to give you the whole 'first Rockstar open world game with a dynamic soundtrack' bit, but as someone else pointed out Bully already done it. And I prefer the radio anyway.
You say Red Dead is technically the better game. Technically. You said technically like seven times. Please indulge us with these technicalities if you are going to f*cking ramble on about them so much.
Obviously I didn't originally reply because you are a hypocritical little c*nt, I did it because you were berating somebody with your faux eloquence (which is transparent as f*ck, btw. Give it up.) when all they wanted to do was come in here and give a friendly opinion. Read his posts again, he was more than amicable.
Even in the member photos topic the worst he called you was butthurt. If that annoyed you then well... I guess he wasn't wrong.